x1900gt vs 7900gt?

dagon11985 said:
Wrong. x1900 GT has some disabled shaders.. (Atleast I think it does.)

the x1900 XTX is the fastest ATI card.

x1900 xtx is fastest ati card? wow i didnt kno that!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! <sarcastic>

///////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////

personally i would go for 1900gt over 7900gt
 
NewMonster said:
x1900 xtx is fastest ati card? wow i didnt kno that!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

///////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////

personally i would go for 1900xt over 7900gt
The problem with this is the X1900 XT or XTX are not in the same price range as the 7900 GT.

They will be faster obviously, they will also be more expensive and power hungry.
 
coldpower27 said:
The problem with this is the X1900 XT or XTX are not in the same price range as the 7900 GT.

They will be faster obviously, they will also be more expensive and power hungry.
The x1900XT can be had for 325 after rebates, slightly more than the 7900GT. But otherwise I would get the x1900GT it outperforms the 7900GT in Oblivion and other shader intensive titles, and it will be a better future upgrade because of its 36 pixel shader processors.
 
Flexmaster said:
The x1900XT can be had for 325 after rebates, slightly more than the 7900GT. But otherwise I would get the x1900GT it outperforms the 7900GT in Oblivion and other shader intensive titles, and it will be a better future upgrade because of its 36 pixel shader processors.
325 after rebates is still quite a bit more then the 230US after rebates of the 7900 GT, a 95Us diffference is still quite a bit more then then the 7900 GT, and the X1900 GT seems to be held back by having only 12 TMU's. I perfer the balanced performance of the 7900 GT, X1900 GT doesn't quite beat the 7900 GT as often as the "old" competitor X1800 XT 512 did.

It also remains to be seen if those 36 Pixel Shaders will help in the long run.
 
Go for the 7900GT if you're buying now. Why worry about how Model X of ATI card is faster in some games but slower in others versus Model Y of ATI, when you can just flat out grab something that will be just as fast in both cases, for the most part?

And in terms of power consumption, as an enthusiast, the only time that will ever matter to me is if I don't have enough juice to run whatever needs a massive amount of juice. And in that case, I just add more power and cooling. Simply balance out the equation. Naturally this is for my main rig, and not some SFF gaming box or what have you. For me, being a college computing enthusiast, my rankings are:

Bang for the buck
Performance
Everything else

If I can reasonably (affordably) balance out things like increased power consumption by adding a few cooling components here and there, and still achieve a nice price:performance ratio, then that's all that matters.
 
werd...broke and in college is the way to go. I can't afford shieet... I mean, look at that cheapass thing in my sig.
 
Wait, after reading through this a couple times, i dont know how the x1800xt is being counted out. I might have missed something, but out of the three, i have seen countless times on many different forums, the x1800xt recommended over the other two. Why are you not considering it now?

MH
 
MikeHunt988 said:
Wait, after reading through this a couple times, i dont know how the x1800xt is being counted out. I might have missed something, but out of the three, i have seen countless times on many different forums, the x1800xt recommended over the other two. Why are you not considering it now?

MH
Can you find the X1800 XT 512 anymore for 260US?
 
MikeHunt988 said:
No, but you can find the 256 version for less than that easy.

MH
However, the problem with that is that the 256MB isn't the same performance level as the 512 in the case of R520 cores.
 
nboyshv2.jpg
 
MikeHunt988 said:
How much worse is the performance of the 256 than the 512?

MH

I think the issue is not that there's a decrease in performance... It's that there was a LARGER decrease in the other guy's wallet when he laid down the cash for 512mb of vram and the 256mb version performs exactly the same...

The difference in the two cards is negligible.
 
Tzzird said:
ummm that's a x1900 gt not x1900 xt

Whoops good point. Mind you the guy is asking for help with buying either a 7900GT or a X1900GT!
 
how can you even compare the 7900GT to the X1800/X1900GT

its very overclockable iv been able to get very high core and memory speeds but even without
eVGA sells 7900GT KO 500/1500
7900GT KO 512 560/1580
7900GT KO Superclock 580/1580
7900GT SS 600/1580
any of those are faster then the X1800/X1900GT
and should be compared to a X1900XT
ill give the X1900XT visual with being able to use HDR/AA on some games but for the 250-350$ price point the X1900XT is the one to compare it to.
 
lordurza said:
how can you even compare the 7900GT to the X1800/X1900GT

its very overclockable iv been able to get very high core and memory speeds but even without
eVGA sells 7900GT KO 500/1500
7900GT KO 512 560/1580
7900GT KO Superclock 580/1580
7900GT SS 600/1580
any of those are faster then the X1800/X1900GT
and should be compared to a X1900XT
ill give the X1900XT visual with being able to use HDR/AA on some games but for the 250-350$ price point the X1900XT is the one to compare it to.
Were talking about a stock 7900 GT vs stock X1900 GT/X1800 XT 256,

X1900 XT's are tpyically find about 320-350US range minimum, hecne should probably be compare to the Factory Overclockeed editions of 7900 GT. SInce nvidia doesn't have an "official" competititor for X1900 XT.
 
well within offical specs id go with the X1900XT for 355 the X1900GT imo isnt even worth buying better for the same price better for below the price ;p

but then again who cares about offical spec id still go with either a nice 7900GT for sub 300 and the X1900XT for 350

the X1900GT to me just seems like a waist
 
lordurza said:
well within offical specs id go with the X1900XT for 355 the X1900GT imo isnt even worth buying better for the same price better for below the price ;p

but then again who cares about offical spec id still go with either a nice 7900GT for sub 300 and the X1900XT for 350

the X1900GT to me just seems like a waist
The X1900 GT goes for 250US which is the same price level as stock 7900 GT's. It is defintely not a waste.
 
I paid 260 for a 7900GT KO yesterday and its much faster then the X1800 so imo it is, again its all on perception on whats best for the money but iv used both and I like the 7900GT more

the Nvidia card from eVGA is faster has a better warrenty has a step up programe and is very good with overclocking the X1900GT has nothing to compare with imo to the 7900GT
 
lordurza said:
I paid 260 for a 7900GT KO yesterday and its much faster then the X1800 so imo it is, again its all on perception on whats best for the money but iv used both and I like the 7900GT more

the Nvidia card from eVGA is faster has a better warrenty has a step up programe and is very good with overclocking the X1900GT has nothing to compare with imo to the 7900GT

I don't know what you're smoking, but that 7900GT, even being the KO, isn't much faster than an X1800XT.
 
well my view is that it is faster cheaper and much better warrenty as ATI's only AIB with a good warrenty for more then 3 years is Powercolor they often cost more and HIS everyones fav on newegg has a horrible warrenty imo iv owned both powercolors and HIS cards and have had no actuall problems during the times I owned either of the brands


however the eVGA 7900GT KO is faster on my rig iv used both X1800GT/X1900XT cards among others and the 7900GT KO has no problems overclocking like mad I was unable to get the X1800GT anywhere near the same performance and the 512 isnt even an issue as you can get a 7900GT KO 512 by eVGA as well which also overclocks like mad and is stock at 560/1500

http://www.legitreviews.com/article/322/1/
shows the stock 7900GT by them now I have never used a 450mhz 7900GT but I know I get much much much higher numbers with the 7900GT KO, 7900GT KO 512, 7900GT KO superclock
then any of the X1800GT's iv ever used
so your the one smoking somthing or obviously are an ati !!!!!!!
id use either ATI or Nvidia my fav are the 7900GT/X1900XT
I do not see a point in buying the 7900GTX or the X1900XTX as I can get either to run as fast as the more expensive version ;p

but that is my opionion
but id have to say its a fact that the 7900GT KO as it is, is faster then the X1800XT/X1900GT hands down
kthx
 
lordurza said:
well my view is that it is faster cheaper and much better warrenty as ATI's only AIB with a good warrenty for more then 3 years is Powercolor they often cost more and HIS everyones fav on newegg has a horrible warrenty imo iv owned both powercolors and HIS cards and have had no actuall problems during the times I owned either of the brands


however the eVGA 7900GT KO is faster on my rig iv used both X1800GT/X1900XT cards among others and the 7900GT KO has no problems overclocking like mad I was unable to get the X1800GT anywhere near the same performance and the 512 isnt even an issue as you can get a 7900GT KO 512 by eVGA as well which also overclocks like mad and is stock at 560/1500

http://www.legitreviews.com/article/322/1/
shows the stock 7900GT by them now I have never used a 450mhz 7900GT but I know I get much much much higher numbers with the 7900GT KO, 7900GT KO 512, 7900GT KO superclock
then any of the X1800GT's iv ever used
so your the one smoking somthing or obviously are an ati !!!!!!!
id use either ATI or Nvidia my fav are the 7900GT/X1900XT
I do not see a point in buying the 7900GTX or the X1900XTX as I can get either to run as fast as the more expensive version ;p

but that is my opionion
but id have to say its a fact that the 7900GT KO as it is, is faster then the X1800XT/X1900GT hands down
kthx

Faster than the GT yes, I thought you were talking about the X1800XT.
 
I prob should have specified ;p as I dont even know much about the rest of the X1800 family =X

I just said X1800/X1900XT in my first comment
 
lordurza said:
I paid 260 for a 7900GT KO yesterday and its much faster then the X1800 so imo it is, again its all on perception on whats best for the money but iv used both and I like the 7900GT more

the Nvidia card from eVGA is faster has a better warrenty has a step up programe and is very good with overclocking the X1900GT has nothing to compare with imo to the 7900GT
You simply don't get what I am trying to convey. ATI needed a competitor to the 7900 GT and they didn't have one prior to the X1900 GT, selling off X1800 XT 512 at the same price is not an economic solution. They produced a newer cheaper to make product, though still fairly expensive, but is more forward thinking then the prior product due to being based on R580 technology.Going forward X1800's will be replaced by X1900 line, so they needed to make a new card to take it's place.

I am not saying how competitive in it is in relation to Nvidia's offering I am just saying at that price the option are a X1900 GT/X1800 XT 256 or a 7900 GT. They may or may not be "effective" competition, but they are ATI's offerings in this price range.

I myself would pick a 7900 GT, as both the ATI's offering consume too much energy for my taste, and I don't utlize air conditioning.

From the benchmarks I seen between these cards at this price point I would go with the 7900 GT, if it had been a X1800 XT 512 then it might have been a different story. I personally stick with Nvidia, as I have had good experiences with them.

People are asking about the X1900 GT and 7900 GT in this thread becuase those 2 are what ATI and Nvidia have pitted against each other in this price range of 250US.

In this comparison I would give the nod to the 7900 GT easily.
 
I think some of you need to chill your Ego on what "YOU" think an enthusiast is because so far your wrong.

just because someone prefers say less power vs 1000FPS (over 100) doesnt mean they ARE NOT an an enthusiast, to say so is ridiculous on your part and considerably lessens any credibility you may have.

So before you go judging wheather some is an enthusiast or not, try looking up the meaning first before making yourself(ves) looks like asses.

en·thu·si·ast ( P ) Pronunciation Key (n-thz-st)
n.
One who is filled with enthusiasm; one who is ardently absorbed in an interest or pursuit: a baseball enthusiast.
A zealot; a fanatic.

So someone could own a PCI G4 MX 440 and be an enthusiast, simply because that is what their budget may only allow for, or they have great enthusiasm over what they have done with their product.
 
MrGuvernment said:
I think some of you need to chill your Ego on what "YOU" think an enthusiast is because so far your wrong.

just because someone prefers say less power vs 1000FPS (over 100) doesnt mean they ARE NOT an an enthusiast, to say so is ridiculous on your part and considerably lessens any credibility you may have.

So before you go judging wheather some is an enthusiast or not, try looking up the meaning first before making yourself(ves) looks like asses.



So someone could own a PCI G4 MX 440 and be an enthusiast, simply because that is what their budget may only allow for, or they have great enthusiasm over what they have done with their product.

Well said... I don't think merely having the $$$$ to buy the shit makes you an enthusiast. I've seen some dude on here from time to time schooling Intel noobs with a Penitum 233 listed in his sig. I think that the sheer enjoyment, practice and knowledge of the craft makes you an enthusiast.
 
MrGuvernment said:
I think some of you need to chill your Ego on what "YOU" think an enthusiast is because so far your wrong.

just because someone prefers say less power vs 1000FPS (over 100) doesnt mean they ARE NOT an an enthusiast, to say so is ridiculous on your part and considerably lessens any credibility you may have.

So before you go judging wheather some is an enthusiast or not, try looking up the meaning first before making yourself(ves) looks like asses.



So someone could own a PCI G4 MX 440 and be an enthusiast, simply because that is what their budget may only allow for, or they have great enthusiasm over what they have done with their product.
Here here well said.
biggrin.gif
 
Back
Top