x16 PCI Express "Graphics"

UICompE02

SCSI Master
Joined
Jul 16, 2001
Messages
866
I have heard from various (semi-reliable) sources that most motherboards that are sold with a x16 PCI Express slot specifically intended for graphics adapters will not work at full width with other PCI Express devices.

Has anyone heard of this? For example, if I want to build a server-style system where graphics performance is not a concern at all, but storage system throughput is, I would install a PCI graphics card (or use an on-board one) and put a x8 RAID controller in the x16 Express slot. Let's say this board, for example.

I have been told that many boards of this type will negotiate down to a x1 Express link when there is not a graphics adapter in the slot. (and that the write buffers are only implemented in the downstream direction of the Express switch in the MCH) However, I have not seen this documented anywhere on the motherboard manufacturer's site or in Intel's chipset documentation. Also, perusing through the PCI Express 1.0a spec does not specify any method for doing this.

Anyone know anything specific about this, or have a source that will definitively tell me one way or the other?
 
Well cannot say for sure. But specs do say that PCIe is adjustable. This is what Nvidias SLI will also be looking forward to. For example: many mobos will have 1 x16, 1 x8, and remainder to complte the 32 lanes or nothing if the mobo has just 24 lanes. So the SLI card will make the x16 alot come down to x8. But again thats just for graphics. Not heard baout other stuff in there that will make it do so. For a server though you might wanto look at PCI-X too.
 
It looks like from that table the x16 slot is only required to run at x16 or x1, but may run at x2, x4, or x8. I know I will physically be able to insert the card into the slot, but what I'm not sure about is whether it will actually be able to use the full x8 connection width of the adapter. None of the motherboard manufacturers seem to mention which widths each particular slot will run at...

Since this is for testing purposes, it must be a PCI Express slot (PCI-X is not an option), and it must support x8 link width. I have several other servers and boards that have a physical x8 slot that will run at x8 - but also several boards that have a physical x8 slot that only have four lanes connected electrically (Tricky!). But in order to test with the widest range of chipsets, I have been looking into motherboards that have the x16 "graphics" slot (and they usually have a few x1 or possibly x4 slots)
 
Well, I guess I found the answer to my question. According to the datasheets for the 915 and 925 chipsets:

"Note: The PCI Express graphics port will operate in x1 mode if a non-graphics card is plugged in."

So, I guess I'll be staying away from boards based on those and will stick with the E7520 and E7525 chipsets.
 
Back
Top