X-Box 2, PS3, or Nintendo Revolution?

adamadekat

Gawd
Joined
Aug 12, 2004
Messages
527
Having owned a PS2 and an X-Box, I would definitely say X-Box 2. There was almost nothing the PS2 had that the X-Box didn't have. And speaking on the GameCube, I would much rather have it than the PS2. PS2 was just a 'hype' console (oh, man! gotta have a PS2!) :confused: in my opinion. Besides, who could ever pass up the next Halos and the awesome multiplayer games you have with friends? Forget GTA, I can buy that for PC 6 months after it's released on PS3 and have it look better.

Post your opinions on what you will get!!!
 
There was almost nothing the PS2 had that the X-Box didn't have

you mean besides the ps2 only titles like GT3(4) and FF10, ect?

personally, i'll get PS3 and GC2
 
all 3, probably spread out over a 6 month period
but again, it all comes down to the games
PS3 for sure and new Nintendo definitely
xbox 2 probably last, unless they can really offer some top notch games that aren't halo
not that i don't like halo, i love it, but i'd like to see more quality games first
 
All of them but Nintendo Rev if I had to choose just one.
 
Probably all three, but I have to admit it's pointless deciding on which one to get when neither of them have even made it to the manufacturing process yet.
 
I have the highest hopes for PS3. I am a reformed Xbox !!!!!!. The Xbox will have a few things though the others will not match. Halo, Xbox Live and MS published games. I will probably get an X2 and a PS3.
 
adamadekat said:
I said almost nothing...besides those games are a waste of time.

I can name over 20 titles that are awsome and the Xbox doesn't have.

Remember everyone has thier own opinion, because you don't like RPGs doesnt mean they are crap.
 
|MaguS| said:
I can name over 20 titles that are awsome and the Xbox doesn't have.

Remember everyone has thier own opinion, because you don't like RPGs doesnt mean they are crap.

OK. But, that's why I said "Post your opinions" which means I'm entitled to my opinion as well, so don't freak out.
 
NR ... waiting to see what the new metriod and zeldas gonna look like ;)
 
Any and all that have games that I wish to play. I currently have my PC, a Cube and an XBox. The only reason I dont have a PS2 is because there just are not many/any games that I really want to play to be honest. Although Ace Combat 5 and GT4 are giving me the spending itch. But then, I am a bit adverse to buying a console this late into its' life-cycle. But things being the way they are at the moment, I think I will probably get an XBox2 (Xenon or whatever its called), the new Nintendo (Revolution/21) and when my PC becomes a real slouch I will give that a top to bottom rebuild too. If Sony start pumping out games that I want to play then a PS3 will also be on the cards.
 
What the heck is this? The consoles aren't even officially announced. This thread is what we like to call "preemptive at best."
 
|MaguS| said:
because you don't like RPGs doesnt mean they are crap.

Wha!? I thought that was exactly what it meant! ;)

I am getting the X2 and maybe a PS3 (especially if they make an updated ICO), the Nintendo thing has nothing that I want to play.

I agree though...RPG's are dumb....IMO. ;)
 
Terpfen said:
What the heck is this? The consoles aren't even officially announced. This thread is what we like to call "preemptive at best."

Uh, yeah they have been officially announced. The only not-official thing is the final name for each console. And again, that's why I said "Post your opinions on which one you will get."
 
adamadekat said:
Uh, yeah they have been officially announced. The only not-official thing is the final name for each console. And again, that's why I said "Post your opinions on which one you will get."

No, they have not been. Microsoft continues to deny that it's working on a next generation console at all. Sony has yet to officially acknowledge the PS3--they will do so only at their pre-E3 event, which is what the buzz last week was all about. Nintendo isn't saying a damn word.

Could you link me to the press releases from Microsoft, Sony, and Nintendo announcing their next-generation consoles, complete with specs, projected release dates, and pricing? I didn't think so.
 
It's nice to see that we can speculate.

why does it have to be such a big deal if they are official or not. There will be new consoles and there's a good chance something will be out from someone before christmas 2005, so why can't we have some fun and talk about it? is there any harm in it? if you don't like the thread, fine, bon't start taking it off into a different tangent.

and good RPG's rule. :cool:
 
For me, the only reason why I would play a PS2 is FFX. That's not a good enough reason to buy one, so I just toss my mem card in other people's PS2s when I wanna play. I have an Xbox and a Gamecube. I bought the Gamecube for Mario, Metroid and Zelda. I will prolly be doing the same thing with the next one, but prolly a couple years after launch. Will most likely get the Xbox within a month of launch or so.
 
Terpfen said:
No, they have not been. Microsoft continues to deny that it's working on a next generation console at all. Sony has yet to officially acknowledge the PS3--they will do so only at their pre-E3 event, which is what the buzz last week was all about. Nintendo isn't saying a damn word.

Could you link me to the press releases from Microsoft, Sony, and Nintendo announcing their next-generation consoles, complete with specs, projected release dates, and pricing? I didn't think so.

Dude, you are so ignorant.
 
Microsoft and Sony are going to fight tooth-and-nail and neither is going to gain a real advantage. Their machines are going to be roughly equal in power (Sony has a better CPU, Microsoft will have better tools, I expect the GPUs to be fairly similar) and game developers know MS is in the fight for real this time (last time, no one knew for the first year whether MS would drop their unprofitable console venture).

Unless one side makes a massive screwup (like not including a hard drive or backwards compatibility) I don't see a clear winner emerging.
 
i would say xbox 2
xbox 2 launch games will be
i am geting an xbox 2. i might get a ps3. but sony is the king of hype.
they bran wash all the gamers


QUAKE 4
CALL OF DUTY 2
HALIF LIFE 2

AND A FEW OTHERS
 
At least the PlayStation3 (I think the step-up in technology will give the PS3 a better reputation than the flailing PS2). Maybe the Xbox2 and unless it is uber-revolutionary, I don't think I will touch the next Nintendo console.

Even though the Xbox is gaining marketshare on the PS2, Sony's library of games has always been known to trump whatever their competitors offer, and I think this trend will continue into the next gen, even though I do expect MS to eat into Sony's lead. That, in itself, should help a lot of gamers make their decision.
 
adamadekat said:
Dude, you are so ignorant.

Still waiting on those press releases.


Tofu Drift said:
Even though the Xbox is gaining marketshare on the PS2...

Well, the Xbox has outsold the PS2 since August, but that's not quite "gaining marketshare," since Microsoft is nowhere near trumping Sony's installed base of 80 million PS2s. It takes more than Halo 2 to trump that.
 
Every console has great games the others dont... its just what you like.
I am going with X-box 2 :D
 
Terpfen said:
Well, the Xbox has outsold the PS2 since August, but that's not quite "gaining marketshare," since Microsoft is nowhere near trumping Sony's installed base of 80 million PS2s. It takes more than Halo 2 to trump that.

Xbox sales performance 2004 (Canada):
Based on ACNielsen data for November 2004, Xbox captured the number one market position with 39 per cent share of unit sales. In addition, Xbox grew its year-over-year console sales by 53 per cent, driving market share to 37 per cent (based on ACNielsen data from January-November 2004). At the same time, total console sales in the industry grew by only 19 per cent.

http://www.bytesector.com/data/news_item.asp?newsID=3025

Xbox sales performance 2004 (US):
The Xbox may have sold fewer units during 2004 than the PlayStation 2, but it was Microsoft's console that gained market share consecutively for 14 months. Sales of the Xbox were up 27 percent in 2004 while PlayStation 2 sales were down 28 percent.

http://biz.gamedaily.com/features.asp?article_id=8766&section=feature

Now I must agree there are fewer Xboxes in homes than PS2s (there is no denying that), but Xbox's piece of the console market pie is slowly (but steadily) growing unless you can show me numbers otherwise. Gaining marketshare and trumping Sony's install base are two different things.
 
That's the thing--I'm talking about overall marketshare. Xbox is gaining, and I'm not disputing that--I acknowledged in my previous post that Xbox has been outselling PS2 for a few months now.

The only point I was making is that this is a case of too little, too late. It's great that Microsoft has finally made a profit off the Xbox--$80 million, on revenue of $1.37 billion, IIRC--but this ist he last year of the current generation, and unless Microsoft sees exponential growth over the next few weeks, this generation is still Sony's.
 
Terpfen said:
unless Microsoft sees exponential growth over the next few weeks, this generation is still Sony's.

I'm not denying that this generation has been dominated by PS2. First and foremost, I don't want to be mistaken as a nonsensical PS2-bashing Xbox fan-boy. I have a PS2 and I love it.

I'm just saying more and more people are buying Xboxs rather than PS2s these days and my point is that MS is gaining marketshare even though Sony has the lion's share of it (although it is slipping gradually). My intention of citing statistics is not to prove that PS2 lost their lead in marketshare; it was to prove that Xbox is nibbling away at it. That's all.

I'm sure MS knew their current gen console was a risky venture to begin with, having to do battle with two giants (Sony and Nintendo), but I also know they will take what they learned with Xbox and apply it to the Xenon/Xbox 2/Xbox Next. Nevertheless, my faith is with the PS3, although I'd like to see how the Xenon pans out as well.
 
Glad to clear that up, then.

Personally, I'm hoping Nintendo puts up a better fight. If the DS is the best they can do now... well, say hello to a new third party developer/publisher.
 
I'll probably just get the PS3. Sony has done an excellent job with the PS, PS2, and PSP, so I don't see any reason to worry about the PS3 being a failure or not worth it. The PS2 had a majority of the single console specific games I wanted to play, and I predict I will see something similar on the PS3.

As for the X-Box 2, it really depends what kind of games come out for it. If a majority of the good X-Box 2 titles are multiplatform or PC games (as is the case with the X-Box now, for the most part) then I probably won't get it. If they add support for a keyboard and mouse so FPSs can be played with a non-gimp control scheme it might make the system more tempting, but it will still depend on the games.

The next Nintendo system is definitely a wait and see thing. Considering the rather pathetic launch of the DS with very few games and even fewer good games, I wonder if it will even be worth getting the Revolution/GC2 in the first 6-12 months after release. However, if this console ends up being as revolutionary as it's claimed to be, then we might see a lot of good games for it.
 
Terpfen said:
Still waiting on those press releases.

While there have been no 'press releases' , they have been talking quit a lot. Just as an example: X2, PS3, NR (Nintendo Revolution) [side note= I hardly think gryroscopes in the controllers is revolutionary]

Terpfen said:
Well, the Xbox has outsold the PS2 since August, but that's not quite "gaining marketshare," since Microsoft is nowhere near trumping Sony's installed base of 80 million PS2s. It takes more than Halo 2 to trump that.

True, but PS2 came out a year before both of those, no?

Anyway....as of Dec31st, 2004:
PS2 81.39M
Xbox 19.09M
GC 18.02M
Those are world-wide sales numbers and include sales figures from GC's price slash in the UK.

And just for kicks:

Games library numbers for each:CURRENT STATS:
PS2: Total Games = 1410 [Coming Soon: 147, Exclusive: 90, Online: 54]
XBOX: Total Games = 771 [Coming Soon: 92, Exclusive: 76, Online: 95]
GC: Total Games = 445 [Coming Soon: 31, Exclusive: 50, Online: 4

While the overall number is given to Sony, the lead in exclusives in not so great. Like many have said....whom ever 'wins' the next great console race.....is the one who buyers think has the best exclusive games. Which is subjective and cannot be predicted.

And as another side note...EA's CEO stated in a earning briefing that he expects selected games for the next gen of consoles will be initially priced higher than the 50-55 we see now. And when asked about who he thinks will have the largest market share....he simple said that you won't see a gap as you do today between the top two....he didn't comment on Nintendo's offering at all. Interesting.
 
The way I see Nintendo is that they've always come up with quirky ideas (Anyone remember the Virtual Boy?) that may not necessarily sell. For Nintendo and competition's sake, I hope that the Revolution doesn't take the same path as the Virtual Boy and be revolutionary in that sense.

It would be a sad, sad day for console gaming if Nintendo pulled a Sega...
 
Tiny said:
True, but PS2 came out a year before both of those, no?

Anyway....as of Dec31st, 2004:
PS2 81.39M
Xbox 19.09M
GC 18.02M
Those are world-wide sales numbers and include sales figures from GC's price slash in the UK.

My point exactly. And a year can't explain a difference of 60 million units (40 million if you add Xbox and GC market share together.)


And as another side note...EA's CEO stated in a earning briefing that he expects selected games for the next gen of consoles will be initially priced higher than the 50-55 we see now. And when asked about who he thinks will have the largest market share....he simple said that you won't see a gap as you do today between the top two....he didn't comment on Nintendo's offering at all. Interesting.

Of course, Larry Probst also said "It might turn out that [the] PlayStation 3 is launched earlier in Japan than it is in North America and Europe." That's not quite the mark of a gifted analyst.


Tofu Drift said:
It would be a sad, sad day for console gaming if Nintendo pulled a Sega...

I see Nintendo on that course. They'll get out of consoles and focus on their handhelds... but if the PSP and its successor trump the DS and the Game Boy Evolution, Nintendo won't have much choice. They'll probably become Microsoft-exclusive just to spite Sony.

All this because of the SNES-CD.
 
Terpfen said:
Still waiting on those press releases.

Terpfen is right that there have been no official announcements of the PS3 and Xbox2.

On the other hand there has been so many companies announcing they were working on hardware or software for these projects that his primary point, that this thread is "preemptive at best", is wrong..... Just because they aren't officially announced does not mean they aren't happening and aren't worthy of discussion.

Of course it you do want semi-official proof there is always this:

xboxnext.com

Registrant:
Microsoft Corporation
Domain Administrator
One Microsoft Way .
Redmond, WA 98052
US
Email: domains@microsoft.com

Registrar Name....: REGISTER.COM, INC.
Registrar Whois...: whois.register.com
Registrar Homepage: www.register.com

Domain Name: xboxnext.com

Created on..............: Fri, Jul 27, 2001
Expires on..............: Fri, Jul 27, 2007
Record last updated on..: Fri, Nov 19, 2004

Administrative Contact:
Microsoft Corporation
Domain Administrator
One Microsoft Way .
Redmond, WA 98052
US
Phone: 001-425-8828080
Email: domains@microsoft.com

Technical Contact:
Microsoft Corporation
MSN Hostmaster
One Microsoft Way .
Redmond, WA 98052
US
Phone: 001-425-8828080
Email: msnhst@microsoft.com

DNS Servers:

ns3.msft.net
ns4.msft.net
ns1.msft.net
ns2.msft.net
ns5.msft.net
 
If it helps, I'm in regular contact with the Public Relations representatives of Microsoft Canada's Xbox Team, and their official stance on the Xenon is that "Microsoft does not comment on rumour or speculation" :D
Couldn't get a drop of information out of them.

Of course, a little beer didn't help the prying either.
 
My psychic abilities aren't as well as some of yours, so I will say that I will wait until the consoles are out before making a decision about what I am getting.

Granted I haven't seen the next machines, but I feel Sony is a little late with their next console - while they have great games I think the hardware is a little dated. The PS2's graphics made me sell my PS2. I also feel MS is rushing out their console, the X Box should have at least a year or two of life left in it, while the graphics aren't the best I think it would be wise to wait a little to get even better hardware in their next machine so they have enough horsepower to have games that run in 720p or even better 1080i :D. As schedules go the GameCube seems to be on a good schedule, but I'm worried about their ability to produce a really powerful console and because they can't they are trying to do something revolutionary instead of just improving graphics... I love nintendo and their franchises, and I wonder what trick they have up their sleeve and I wonder if it will work.
 
I find it amusing that there's a GPU wars within the next generation of console wars. Sony is aligned with NVIDIA and MS/Nintendo are aligned with ATi.

Those guys chose to ignore S3! :rolleyes:
 
Back
Top