The battery in my M1710 died... it basically won't ever hold a charge. I've seen these things go for $80 on CraigsList and $50 on eBay so your offer should be significantly cheaper than that. Ideally, you have the higher capacity 7200mAh version.
you should really just buy it from ebay. Nobody is gonna be "significantly" cheaper than what you ask, and your chances of getting a heavily used / crappy battery are increased.