Would You Take $10 To Remove Negative Feedback?

"Ed" was a dickhead. He should of contacted the the seller first. I dont think this is a bribe but them trying to solve the problem.
 
actually i have done this.

bought a cheaper knife on ebay i think $15 or so, knife was exactly as described and brand new, but had a small chip on the blade that i was able to fix.

put negative feedback that the blade was damaged etc. got an email saying they would refund my purchase price and shipping to just remove the comment, and well i couldn't argue with that

but had it been a serious issue, i dont think i would have
 
Looked like his negative feedback worked. I see nothing wrong with this. He can change his negative feedback to positive with the comment that states he left a negative feedback for a screw-up, the company compensated him for his inconvenience with $10 in his pocket.

This situation would have been controversial if the seller has explicitly forbidden to comment on how he came to a different conclusion from his original feedback.
 
How about those negative Amazon.com reviews. Often it's not the product, but the shipping or something else, but they leave negative feedback reflection on the product.

If the product is not as advertised, then they certainly should write negative feedback. No one should be buy them off. However, they should be able to leave feedback on the feedback. Also, there may to be sub categories of feedback for situations like having a perfectly good product, but being upset with something else during the transaction.
 
Sure, the item value really negates the true meaning of the feedback, but what the hell do you people think the feedback system is for. Its for keeping vendors honest, regardless of the price.

IMO, the seller has great customer service. He understands that waiting a month for an order to be fulfilled has value to it, understands the feedback system on ebay, essentially is attempting to wipe the slate clean by correcting an error or mistake, and provide compensation for time lost to the customer.

Did any of you even read the article. The guy waited a month, incorrect product was delivered, left negative feedback. Yes, he should have attempted to contact the seller prior to leaving feedback to provide an opportunity to correct it, but either way, thats what the feedback system is for. I'd say neutral feedback would have been justified simply for the wait time if the product delivered was correct.

And as long as negative feedbacks can be reversed by customer service, why not use the system provided. If you don't like the policy, don't sell on ebay.
 
the big Ebay sellers live and die by the 99% positive feedback ratings. They offered the payment because staying high on the positive side pays off with more sales.
 
I've had two experiences with ebay that are relevant to the current discussion. Once I ordered an older used processor for a system I wasn't quite willing to replace yet. For $10 + $8 shipping it seemed like a good way to get a little more mileage out of it. It arrived a week later in a flat rate box. The only packaging was a piece of bent cardboard and some tape, but even that was done so poorly that the processor slipped out and was rattling around the box bare. Some of the pins were bent. I was able to straighten them and use the processor (yes it worked), but I gave the seller neutral feedback for the poor shipping. He wrote me back complaining and I explained my rationale. He wrote me back again telling me what a dickhead I was, etc. and that for only $8 shipping I should be glad I got it at all. He also gave me a sob story about not making any money on a $10 processor that sold new for hundreds, etc. I didn't feel sorry for him and pointed out that $10 was the going price and that from now on I'll just take my business elsewhere. All that aggravation for lack of a few pennies worth of bubble wrap.

The other time I ordered a piece of bodywork for my motorcycle. Again used. This particular piece is a bit delicate when it's not screwed onto the bike, but the seller did a really crappy job of packing it and it arrived broken. I took pictures and sent them to him. He refunded me the entire cost ($50US). I gave him a positive feedback and noted the shipping problem and refund in the comments.

Two different ways of handling a similar situation. In the first case if he had offered me a refund instead of berating me, I would have changed the feedback despite my time having been wasted due to his incompetence.

Now in the case at hand, Ed was unreasonable. He should have contacted the seller first. If he didn't get satisfaction after that, then a neutral feedback would have been in order. Negatives should only be used for complete ripoffs.
 
I was reading an ebay merchant thread related to this. Apparently ebay's rating system is so screwed up, one negative rating can cause ebay to lock your merchant account, depending on how many transactions you have had. For large merchants, they will either automatically refund the cost of the item or they will attempt to bribe you to change your review. Ebay does not arbitrate or look into why you posted a negative review, no matter how crazy you are, so even in situations where the merchant isn't at fault ebay punishes them. Also, their new rating system is based on reviews per month not per year, so if you have a slow month one bad review can take you down.
 
Sounds like the seller is making a serious effort to make the customer happy. I'd take the $10 and change the feedback.

This is what it sounds like to me too, that the seller was trying to make it right. It could have been $10, or the exact price of the item ($2.something) or just shipping out the right item. Whatever it was, seller was trying to make right.

I actually NEVER leave feedback right away if something went wrong with my order, whether on eBay or through Heatware or elsewhere. I ALWAYS give the seller an opportunity to make it right, and I hope that if I screw something up when I sell something, people give ME a chance to make it right before leaving a neg.
 
Back
Top