Would like your comparison input

GJSNeptune

[H]F Junkie
Joined
Mar 31, 2004
Messages
12,372
My brother has a fairly recent Apple G5 that he uses in his studio. He says it has a little over 2GB of RAM and I think a processor around 2GHz, maybe a little more. He says he paid about $1800 for it and another $500 for the extra RAM. I didn't ask about hard disk space. He said it has the newest OS.

He said the same system is going for about $1000 on eBay, and that he'd sell it to me for $800.

I'm interesting in buying it for video editing (instead of the audio he uses it for). I was wondering how this would fare against maybe a dual-core PC system I could build for the same $800 (or more if I know which route to take).

I'd want at least 2GB of RAM. I know that most video editing is hungry for both RAM and CPU speed. What do you guys think? I certainly can't afford a new Mac Pro, so it's either his G5 or a dual-core PC.
 
The dual core machine you're thinking about building will eat that G5 for breakfast, lunch, dinner, and a late night snack, period.

The real question is: do you want a Mac or a PC?

A 17" Core 2 Duo iMac can be hand for what, $1100 these days, under $1000 for a refurb from Apple, and that too will eat the G5 for the aforementioned meals AND you'd be able to run a Windows-based OS on the machine with Boot Camp or with Parallels.

I'd say the most important factor in this is: what's the video editing software you intend to use; is it Mac or PC based; etc.

Need a bit more info to be able to provide better suggestions and comparisons...
 
Apple owns/bought the major video software companies. Video editing is made for Apple computers.

I've never owned a Mac, so it'd be quite an experience. I've used them at schools and such, but nothing extensive.

I'd like to use Final Cut if I can afford it, but since this isn't the best of technology, a cheaper editing app would still be good to learn with.
 
Adobe Premiere Pro would be the Final Cut Pro equivalent PC software.

Sorry, not at home, so no nice linkage, lol:

$185 - E6300
$135 - GA-965P-DS3
$210 - 2GB DDR2-800 G.Skill 2GBNQ
$110 - HD400LJ Samsung HDD sata300 400GB
$50 - CM Centurion 5 ATX case
$50 - 500W XClio psu
$35 - Lite-On sata DVD burner
$37 - GeForce 6200LE 128MB onboard
=======
$812 + tax and shipping

I just wanted to show you what's possible with your budget.
 
Back
Top