Would I notice a difference, or at least a big difference?

cslogical

Limp Gawd
Joined
May 22, 2005
Messages
298
I have a BFG 7800GTOC 256mb card. If I bought a X1900XT 512mb card is there a big enough difference for price. As in a earlier post I run 1920x1200 for gaming. Thanks
 
my 7900gt's run a lot faster/better than my 7800gt's did. and the x1900xt is supposed to be as good as the 7900gt, or maybe slightly better.
 
vanilla_guerilla said:
my 7900gt's run a lot faster/better than my 7800gt's did. and the x1900xt is supposed to be as good as the 7900gt, or maybe slightly better.

LOL yup....
slightly. They just outperform the 7900gtx in oblivion, but slightly better than the GT :rolleyes:
 
kdog said:
LOL yup....
slightly. They just outperform the 7900gtx in oblivion, but slightly better than the GT :rolleyes:


LOL...Jeez, such typical fan bull*hit...Making such a comment as you did being an owner of an ati card just makes you that much more rediculous...Ya, the x1900xt may perform better in Oblivion in those high shader environments with high grass details, etc. and that is due to it's higher # of pixel shader processors...But dude....were talking what...maybe 5-6 fps's at most....and let's pull out some other games, and we'll see that the 7900 GTX will beat the x1900xt and xtx...

BTW..This site benchmarked both cards x1900xtx, and 7900gtx, and there was a 5fps diff...And that was the xtx not the xt... :rolleyes: review The performance difference is not worth the 400-500$ extra over your current 7800...But it's entirely up 2 u...If u got the money spend it....Also...If u wanna compare 3dmark scores Kdog...by all means I can crank my 7900gtx to 710/1785 and we'll see who outscores who :rolleyes:

EDIT-NM...Looking at your specs...I could beat you stock :eek:
 
Island said:
LOL...Jeez, such typical fan bull*hit...Making such a comment as you did being an owner of an ati card just makes you that much more rediculous...Ya, the x1900xt may perform better in Oblivion in those high shader environments with high grass details, etc. and that is due to it's higher # of pixel shader processors...But dude....were talking what...maybe 5-6 fps's at most....and let's pull out some other games, and we'll see that the 7900 GTX will beat the x1900xt and xtx...

BTW..This site benchmarked both cards x1900xtx, and 7900gtx, and there was a 5fps diff...And that was the xtx not the xt... :rolleyes: review The performance difference is not worth the 400-500$ extra over your current 7800...But it's entirely up 2 u...If u got the money spend it....Also...If u wanna compare 3dmark scores Kdog...by all means I can crank my 7900gtx to 710/1785 and we'll see who outscores who :rolleyes:

EDIT-NM...Looking at your specs...I could beat you stock :eek:

fan.boy ummm yeah, except this is my first ATI card.

You can beat me stock? you must be retarded LOL. The only thing you have that is "faster" is your fx running at 2.9....which has very little impact on games compared to the gfx card. If you read ANY reviews you will see that the x1900 series always have a graphical advantage over the 7900gtx...such as HQ af, etc at the same res. To make the test equal, you'd have to remove all the bells and whistles off the ATI and run it at medium image quality...then it would be equal, and own the gtx in every game. Like you said, its 5fps away from the GTX with MUCH better IQ settings. And trust me, my XTX will RAPE you.

3dmark is all BS. Tell me what your performance is in GAMES.
Tell me what your performance figures in the FEAR timedemo are? 16by12 all settings max except softshadows. 4aa/8af
 
ok lets not get into a war.. the 7900 gtx out performs the x1900 in some games and the x1900 out performs the 7900 gtx in some games... they all have their advatages and disadvantages
 
boomheadshot45 said:
ok lets not get into a war.. the 7900 gtx out performs the x1900 in some games and the x1900 out performs the 7900 gtx in some games... they all have their advatages and disadvantages

agreed, but like I mentioned previously, the x1900 almost always has some graphical advantage turned on which consumes extra FPS.
 
kdog said:
agreed, but like I mentioned previously, the x1900 almost always has some graphical advantage turned on which consumes extra FPS.


terrific. believing that must just fill you with inertia.
 
You guys act as though you personally engineered the cards...
Both cards have their merits, but ATi is definately on top these days.
My guess is they both deliver a great gaming experience, I know I enjoy my 7800gt on all of todays titles, INCLUDING OBLIVION.
So relax and shoot some pixels if you're feeling anxious, nobody's E-Penis really means anything...
 
its no secret that most reviewers leave the Nvidia cards at Quality settings while ATIs default is set to HQ(texture/mipmap?) settings, so ATI cards have a slight IQ advantage from the get go, Nvidia cards take a small hit when u disable the AF ops which would give the ATI cards a bigger lead in whatever games they already win in, and possibly take the lead in other games

while the 7900GTX might be faster in some games, the 7800GT wont touch an X1900XT / XTX 7800GT SLI are about the same performance as the XTX :p specially at higher resolutions
 
The main thing to consider is that nvidia is usually faster with eye candy off, so if you are a fan of FPS no matter the cost then nvidia is probably for you. However, when you start turning eye candy on ati usually takes the lead, so if you like IQ go for ATI.
 
kemist1117 said:
The main thing to consider is that nvidia is usually faster with eye candy off, so if you are a fan of FPS no matter the cost then nvidia is probably for you. However, when you start turning eye candy on ati usually takes the lead, so if you like IQ go for ATI.

Keep in mind that SLI is faster then Crossfire in most cases, my duel 7900GTs get me about the same performance as Radeon 1900XT crossfire, since it cost about 940$, and my 7900GTs costed me 630$ Its pretty clear which ones the price/performance winner.
 
HEY GUYS! Listen up to my words of wisdom:

X1900XTX = 7900GTX

There you go.
 
Back
Top