Would a cheap SSD be fine for this?

Blazestorm

Supreme [H]ardness
Joined
Jan 17, 2007
Messages
6,940
I'm running an HTPC... and basically everything is being streamed over the network. I'm thinking to cut down on heat/power/noise I could get a cheap 16GB SSD...

I know people had problems with the jmicron controllers but if I'm never really accessing the SSD except to boot up, load programs, and codecs it should run fine... rioght?
 
I wouldn't bother. The cheapest 16 gig ssd on newegg is about 50 dollars, you can get an indilinx based Supertalent Ultradrive ME, 32 gig for 119. The cheap 16 gig drive is slower than some USB thumbdrives. I think spending 50 bucks on crap is just a waste of money, so either stick with a small magnetic or pay a bit more than double for a drive that's twice the size, and about 10x the speed.
 
Or just get a cheap 2.5" SATA drive. The newer ones are reasonably quick.
 
If you really wanted to build an HTPC on the cheap, then you should consider a notebook hard drive. They're reasonably quiet and generate relatively little heat. I don't think you're going to benefit much from SSDs anyway.

To answer your question, I think it would probably work decently. I use a JMicron-based SSD as a boot drive for a home Hyper-V server and it works fairly well (everything else is on disk). Makes sense since there's nothing running off of it except an OS, hypervisor, and some management tools - and I rarely have to log onto the host OS so stuttering is irrelevent. I didn't care about performance; I just wanted to avoid mechanical failures.

However, that was before reasonably affordable non-JMicrons were available. Nowadays, I wouldn't bother putting a JMicron in any computer if I could spend just a few bucks more for a good Indilinx-based drive.
 
Back
Top