Worth Upgrading Ti4200 128mb?

Stinn

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Jul 13, 2001
Messages
1,796
Is it worth it to upgrade my Ti4200 card to, say, a 9600XT? I've read a couple comments here and there that it just wouldn't be worth the upgrade.
What do you guys think?
 
Not worth it for the small performance gain. 9800 Pro's are close to the same price now and perform much better.
 
I've got a Ti4200 and i'll be upgrading to a X800XT/6800U, I hear its worth it
 
Upgrading to a X800Pro or X800XT is absolutely worth it. A 9600XT is noticably faster than a Ti4200, but not worth $200 IMO. Rather spend the $200 on a 9800Pro and get an upgrade that is really significant. Or spend $400 and get an X800Pro which is about double the performance of the 9800Pro if you can afford it.
 
i have a 4200
i might be upgrading to a 9800pro soon. it's about 172$ at newegg
i think it might be worth it, or else i might wait till the pci express cards come out or something, then the price might drop even more

edit
well not to mention the DX 9 and pixel shader 2.0 support. that alone is worth 172$ price...drool

right now i'm really sad with the gaming i'm having with the 4200, it sucks on theif 3, with a 2800+ and 512 megs of ram on a nforce 2, just barley playable. same with splinter cell and any other DX9 game
 
Personally, I would save my cash and get either an X800 or a 6800. But if you feel you must upgrade now, I'd definitely get a 9800 Pro.
 
i would look in to volt moding right now its not really worth all the money for the small performance increas. but when i up graded from my ti4400 i got a 9700pro it was so much better... to bad she died but now im off to get the x800.
 
Ti4200 is a very good card. Man, this card has had a shitload of lasting power. When was it launched anyways, 2001? Excellent card, it's been value/budget all it's life practically as the Ti4600 was always ahead of it from the get go. But it's stayed in some enthusiast's machines for over 2 years now, and it's still a damn good card.

Unfortunately, I think this card is in it's sunset quarters now. The 9500Pro, 9600XT, 5700U, they all tried to give you something better performance wise for a good price. But in reality the advantages really aren't there. Maybe a bit in the way of FSAA and anisotropic filtering, but other than that the raw speed increases were relatively small. I don't think many people who have a 9500Pro (like myself) or 9600XT use very much FSAA anyways, maybe a tad but not much.

I think the next round of "mainstream" cards, i.e.: <$200 USD, will decimate the 9600XT, 9500Pro, and Ti4200. Sort of a new revolution of chips, that are far superior.

If I was you, I would hold off and see what the X600 has to offer. After you see some benchmarks for that, then decide whether you still want the 9800, or move to a X600.In short, keep the Ti4200 for at least another month or two.
 
6800 U or the new X800 -> Yes.

9800 Pro / XT -> Maybe.

Anything less -> No.
 
It totally depends on what you play!

I would say, if you are still playing only Direct X 8 games, such as any of the Unreal Tournament 2003/2004 games, then the upgrade probably isn't worth it. Same for Call of Duty, Splinter Cell, etc...

Now, if you are looking to play games like Painkiller, or FarCry, forget it...buy the most monstrous card you can afford...

My TI4400 is holding up throughout my frag fests online, I agree with what was said about the series staying power...I have had this beauty for years and I still don't think an upgrade is worth it.
 
I am likewise on the fence. Ti4600 128 Mb -- I want some more performance but without spending a lot of money since pci express is coming out eventually and I'll do a full overhaul.

Can't decide if I should spend $150 or so and upgrade the vid card. . .or the proc. . . or just suck it up and wait.
 
With an X800, the rest of your computer will most likely be the bottleneck. The most logical course of action seems to be to get a 9800Pro for about $200. It will offer considerable performance gains.
 
Fahim said:
i have a 4200
i might be upgrading to a 9800pro soon. it's about 172$ at newegg
i think it might be worth it, or else i might wait till the pci express cards come out or something, then the price might drop even more

edit
well not to mention the DX 9 and pixel shader 2.0 support. that alone is worth 172$ price...drool

right now i'm really sad with the gaming i'm having with the 4200, it sucks on theif 3, with a 2800+ and 512 megs of ram on a nforce 2, just barley playable. same with splinter cell and any other DX9 game
i wouldnt get the 170 dollar 9800 pro from newegg b/c that is the 128 bit one, make sure u get the 256 bit one for better performance
 
MOJO, i have to disagree with you on the 9500pro vs the 4200, my 4200 had bad caps so i replaced it with the 9500pro over a year ago and i saw huge performance gains all the way around. I do use FSAA too and love it. I think that the 4200 was a good card, but the 9500pro was much better.
 
I noticed a substantial jump in framerates when I replaced my 4200/128 with a 9700Pro.. but as always YMMV
 
Depends 100% on what you use it for and what games you play.
 
I replaced my 8500LE with a 9700PRO and it has been the best move I have made. My frame rates are incredible. A 9800PRO is a great card and should handle all games currently out, but then again future proofing is always a good idea if you can afford it. Think about it.... $200 for a 9800Pro now and $200 for a X800Pro in 2 years or $400 for an X800Pro now.
 
4200 is about the same as a 9600 or 5700/5600 granted the Ultra or XT versions do a little better in some cases. But raw horse power its right there with them. Now if you turn up the eye candy the 4200 takes a bigger hit, and its only a DX8 part vs. DX9 parts. But in general the ti4200 still is a great buy.

Currently you can find ti4200's from $80 up.... and $80 they are still well worth the cash. And if you have one, I'd wait a little longer for the 6800's to hit the street. That should help drop the price of some other cards like the 9800pro/xt 5900U/5950 etc.. (current high end cards) So you MIGHT want to upgrade to one of those.

Personally I would wait until the 6800GT or 6800 vanilla come out and should become the new ti4200's Plus it will make the X800 series probably come down a little bit from their launch premium.

Plus the new nV drivers are coming out this week that will put a whipping on ATI's cards. (supposedly up to 30% increases like the Detonators of old)
 
Fahim said:
i have a 4200
i might be upgrading to a 9800pro soon. it's about 172$ at newegg
i think it might be worth it, or else i might wait till the pci express cards come out or something, then the price might drop even more

edit
well not to mention the DX 9 and pixel shader 2.0 support. that alone is worth 172$ price...drool

right now i'm really sad with the gaming i'm having with the 4200, it sucks on theif 3, with a 2800+ and 512 megs of ram on a nforce 2, just barley playable. same with splinter cell and any other DX9 game

Get the 206$ one, its the 256 bit version of the 9800 pro, the 172$ one is 128bit which is relative to half the performence you'd expect from a 9800 pro.
 
thecheat said:
Get the 206$ one, its the 256 bit version of the 9800 pro, the 172$ one is 128bit which is relative to half the performence you'd expect from a 9800 pro.

YES, VERY GOOD POINT many noobs arent noticing that those are the 128-bit memory interfaces (HALF the BANDWIDTH!!) DON'T get one of those! (128bit versions) They shouldnt call them 9800 Pro's!!!

BTW, a ti4200 normally defaults to a DX8 render path which usually gives equal or better performance (fps) than the 5600/5700/9600 on a DX9 render path with only a minor quality loss. For games like Halo, SplinterCell, etc.
 
chrisf6969 said:
YES, VERY GOOD POINT many noobs arent noticing that those are the 128-bit memory interfaces (HALF the BANDWIDTH!!) DON'T get one of those! (128bit versions) They shouldnt call them 9800 Pro's!!!

BTW, a ti4200 normally defaults to a DX8 render path which usually gives equal or better performance (fps) than the 5600/5700/9600 on a DX9 render path with only a minor quality loss. For games like Halo, SplinterCell, etc.

ok i was wondering what the differnce was ;)

i've played splinter cell on my 4200 and i think it looks like terrible and runs terrible on the lowest settings. it just can't render it the way dx9 demands. it's slow and blocky. it feels like i'm playing half life on a riva 128.
 
Back
Top