Worth it to go lower end?

Sparrow_69

Gawd
Joined
Jan 20, 2004
Messages
776
I'm considering upgrading from the system in my sig to the following:
A64 4000+ San Diego
Asus A8N-SLI Premium
2x1Gb OCZ Platinum EL
BFG 7800GTX OC
ENERMAX EG495P-VE NOISETAKER 485W PSU
ZALMAN CNPS7000B-ALCU cooler
Dell 2405fpw (already on the way)

Would anyone suggest a replacement for any of the parts? Since I'm cheap, I was debating between the above and swapping for the following

A64 3700+ San Diego (savings of 170$ CAD)
BFG 7800GT OC (savings of 200$ CAD)
DFI LanParty UT NF4 Ultra-D (savings of 75$ CAD)
If that case, I could possibly keep my current Antec 380W PSU
(possible savings of 110$)

Total savings would be: 555$ CAD. Would I see a big boost in performance if I went with the higher end (but obviously more expensive parts?)
 
Simply put, no. The 3700 is almost as fast as the 4000 and has a 1 meg cache, so that's not going to drop performance much at all. I'd definitely drop down to a GT and then overclock it to GTX speed. As far as the mobo goes, are you going to want to go SLI in the future? If yes, than keep your current one, if no, go with the DFI.
 
Sparrow_69 said:
I'm considering upgrading from the system in my sig to the following:
A64 4000+ San Diego
Asus A8N-SLI Premium
2x1Gb OCZ Platinum EL
BFG 7800GTX OC
ENERMAX EG495P-VE NOISETAKER 485W PSU
ZALMAN CNPS7000B-ALCU cooler
Dell 2405fpw (already on the way)

Would anyone suggest a replacement for any of the parts? Since I'm cheap, I was debating between the above and swapping for the following

A64 3700+ San Diego (savings of 170$ CAD)
BFG 7800GT OC (savings of 200$ CAD)
DFI LanParty UT NF4 Ultra-D (savings of 75$ CAD)
If that case, I could possibly keep my current Antec 380W PSU
(possible savings of 110$)

Total savings would be: 555$ CAD. Would I see a big boost in performance if I went with the higher end (but obviously more expensive parts?)

besides the psu and video card, the rest of the cheaper parts are better
:eek:
 
i just ordered my parts today. I almost have the same set up i got the MSI Neo4 Plat SLI and 2g of Corair XMS Ram. I got the 7800 GT to save 150$ and the AMD 64 3700. I will OC the VC and Proc. it worth it to cut the VC and CPU it will save you some nice cash.

I also ordered the Dell 2405fpw
 
Sparrow_69 said:
I'm considering upgrading from the system in my sig to the following:
A64 4000+ San Diego
Asus A8N-SLI Premium
2x1Gb OCZ Platinum EL
BFG 7800GTX OC
ENERMAX EG495P-VE NOISETAKER 485W PSU
ZALMAN CNPS7000B-ALCU cooler
Dell 2405fpw (already on the way)

Would anyone suggest a replacement for any of the parts? Since I'm cheap, I was debating between the above and swapping for the following

A64 3700+ San Diego (savings of 170$ CAD)
BFG 7800GT OC (savings of 200$ CAD)
DFI LanParty UT NF4 Ultra-D (savings of 75$ CAD)
If that case, I could possibly keep my current Antec 380W PSU
(possible savings of 110$)

Total savings would be: 555$ CAD. Would I see a big boost in performance if I went with the higher end (but obviously more expensive parts?)

Definitely get a DFI instead, but I would get teh DFI SLI-D.

Get a 3200+ Venice and OC it a bit too. Will have about the same performance for half the money of either of those.

Keep that PSU you chose.

Stay with the GTX.

Switch the ram to 2x1GB of Crucial Value. Cheaper and will probably OC at least as well. And just about every ram stick available today will perform the same at stock, so don't buy "good" ram if you aren't OCing.

-------------

You definitely wouldn't want a GT. With a 2405 it will be hard to run at native res for long with a GT. It will be easier with a GTX and later you might even want to go SLI GTX's.
 
Unless you are overclocking like crazy, the DFI is not for you. Get an ASUS or Gigabyte for light/moderate overclocking.

Don't waste money on old technology. Get a dual-core.

The difference between the GT and GTX is small (see [H] review). Get the GT and save $$$.

You will need a new PSU eith way, so get the Antec NeoPower or True-550.
 
I was looking at the DFI because its about 65$ CAD cheaper than the asus. For the money, is it a good stable board?
 
From what I do understand about them, the San Diego 4000+ and 3700+ are nearly the same exact cores, meaning you really can't guarantee that one will overclock any more or less than the other with the same cooling. Of course, there are more unique differences among them depending on which particular one you get, but, on the whole it can be said that getting the 3700+ over 4000+ just makes sense really.

Also, for the motherboard, they are right. DFI is for serious overclocking. Mind you, I wouldn't pick an Asus over it. Asus isn't THAT good and, in fact, I've had some of their products that I could only describe as being worse than the equivalent product priced considerably less by everyone else. (Don't get me wrong, they do have some things that are better, but, in general I don't consider them worth the extra cost.) You asked if it's stable, well, it's designed for overclocking, so, yeah, it's stable, it kind of has to be... It's a lot more hassle to set up from what I understand though.

Well, you might try looking at EPoX for motherboards as well I suppose. I don't know about their quality for nForce 4, but, someone recommended this board to me a while back and now that I have it I must say I'm rather impressed. I'd never heard of this EPoX before, but, it's not bad. The only faults I've found so far are that the memory has only a few choices (133, 166, 200 -- it doesn't show the actual ratio, but, either way I have to use a calculator, so no biggie, but, the fact that it doesn't have very many ratios is dissapointing,) and the memory voltage maxes at 2.8V (I plan to get an OCZ memory booster later and crank up my ram to 3.2 or so and see what it can do.) The lack of a large number of memory ratios and the voltage limit don't appear to be terribly uncommon (though many boards do go as high as 2.9, few go higher from what I read.) At first I thought the lack of half-step multipliers was a fault of the board, but, further reading revealed that Athlon 64s officially don't support that (I'm new to A64) so I guess it's a point in their favor that they elected to not put them in when so many boards did since that caused such confusion apparently.
 
How the freak can you call the second option "lower end"? Thats still some high end stuff there!
 
IceDigger said:
How the freak can you call the second option "lower end"? Thats still some high end stuff there!

Oh, wait , nevermind.. missed the point.

To the OP..

"I don't think that the $445 CAD difference is worth it from option A to option B"
 
The specs in your sig look like enough to run anything out there. Why upgrade?
 
Some people like to have better.

Really, people shouldn't ask "why do you want to do that?" when someone asks "which course of action should I take to achieve this purpose?" The why doesn't matter. Everyone has reasons, but, not everyone wants to state them every single time.
 
Sparrow_69 said:
Malogato: why do you say you don't think its worth it?

Because it's just not "faster enough" to justify the expense.. that's my thinking, anyhow.

The performance differences between them are not as great as the COST differences.
 
Well, having looked a bit more into the upgrade, I'm currently looking at getting the A8N-E which is cheaper than the DFI, but still Asus quality. Also, a buddy of mine is selling his 4000+ for just a hair over what it would cost me for a 3700+ (and he has it running above fx55 speed, so that's always good!). Just not sure about the video card yet. Looking for a 7800gtx deal in Canada. Also hoping that i can get away with my 380W antec psu to save me a few more $$. Nvidia's official requirements for the gtx is a 350W PSU, so I'm hoping that I'll be ok!
 
Ack! No! Don't skimp on the PSU. For that setup, even if nVidia says a 350W is fine, you want something higher quality. Get something like this. If anything, drop the video card down to a GT and save yourself $100.
 
*sigh* Everyone these days hears the ancient story that low end PSUs aren't enough anymore so figures just throw the highest wattage you can find at it. You don't have to automatically throw $100+ at the first PSU promising a high number. First of all, this mere 420W PurePower I'm using has been quite sufficient for my overclocks. I seem to recall that nVidia claimed the 7800 series actually has LESS power consumption than the 6800 series, and I'm not exactly running my components at low speeds here.

Anyway, what matters isn't quantity, it's quality. nVidia says "350" because most PSUs promising that can just barely pull off running those things at stock and they can't quantize the quality difference any other way. Of course, you'll be overclocking, so a cheap 350 isn't enough at all, but, the point I'm getting to is that if that antec 380W is a GOOD one (not just a cheap low end model) you're probably ok without burning money. Of course, there's no law against buying a PSU later if your current one isn't good enough. Don't go run and buy the highest wattage you can find just because you need more power these days though.


I do agree on the video card though. Firstly, a 6800 Ultra is STILL ahead of today's games. I imagine a 7800GT will be overclockable to close enough to 7800GTX capabilities (maybe even unlockable, but, I haven't heard of anyone trying that yet) that it will last you a good long time yet. My 6800nu even is only just now finally being tested, and the main problem isn't lack of capabilities, but, simply the fact that it just lacks the advantage of the extra memory that the GT and Ultra both have. I think the 7800GT will show a similar trend and last a pretty good while as well. Besides, if you do get an SLI capable board, you can always grab another a year or so down the road and SLI them.
 
Back
Top