Worth ditching the 780i?

Kr1z

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Nov 1, 2007
Messages
1,305
For a P45 chipset motherboard? I tried out SLI with two 8800GTs, didn't really think it was worth the price or performance to keep two. Sold both 8800GT and went single card solution, to a GTX 260. I have a eVGA 780i board, now and the biggest problem is the northbridge runs incredibly hot, and I can't find any aftermarket cooling that fits on the northbridge.

I would like to get a nice overclocking board, and compatible with some hr-05s on both the north and south bridge.

Q6600@3.15ghz
DDR2-800 @1002Mhz
GTX 260
 
I just ditched a 975x board for one of these.
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813128358
Unfortunately they are out of stock there. I haven't received mine yet,it should get here mid week, but the reviews are amazing.

If you check out this thread, you will see people are getting some amazing overclocks on this thing.
http://www.xtremesystems.org/forums/showthread.php?t=205132

Whoops, I see we have our own thread for this:
http://www.hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1352805
 
Given the stability issues and general lower reliability issues of nVidia-based Intel boards, IMO it's worth selling off the 780i and going with a P45 board simply for that reason. The two best deals right now are the ASUS P5Q Pro and the Gigabyte GA-EP45-UD3P that the poster above linked to, which are both on sale for $100 after rebate at Newegg. Both are stable, perform well, and overclock great. Unfortunately the Gigabyte is out of stock at the moment, but you could always wait for it to come back in stock if you're so inclined.
 
Given the stability issues and general lower reliability issues of nVidia-based Intel boards, IMO it's worth selling off the 780i and going with a P45 board simply for that reason.

+1, though I'm partial to the mid-range MSI solutions myself.
 
I have a 750i and the north bridge OEM fan at 30% without issues. Do you have the fan on it? I have 2 brand new 780i fans sitting right here.
 
Would a P45 Neo3-FR or a Biostar Tpower i45 be good? The GA-EP45-UD3P does look nice, but I think I am really paying the for cooling? I plan on replacing anything on the motherboard with aftermarket heatsinks, hr-05s,hr-09, to be exact.
 
Would a P45 Neo3-FR or a Biostar Tpower i45 be good? The GA-EP45-UD3P does look nice, but I think I am really paying the for cooling? I plan on replacing anything on the motherboard with aftermarket heatsinks, hr-05s,hr-09, to be exact.

I wouldn't go with the MSI, but the Biostar is a good board. It's pretty pricey for a P45 board though, so I would recommend the Gigabyte or the ASUS P5Q Pro instead based on price. You won't get substantially better overclocking from the Biostar, so you may as well save $60 and get one of the other two boards.
 
Yeah, I'll say ditch your 780i and go for a P45 board. I did that, and it solved all my problems. I recommend Gigabyte.
 
Would a P45 Neo3-FR or a Biostar Tpower i45 be good? The GA-EP45-UD3P does look nice, but I think I am really paying the for cooling? I plan on replacing anything on the motherboard with aftermarket heatsinks, hr-05s,hr-09, to be exact.

Yeah, I see what you mean, but I think the features are pretty good for a board in that price range. I don't see it being overpriced just for the cooling.
 
I'd say yes.

My 780i got my Q6600 to 3.2 stable.

Then I got an Asus Maximus II Formula P45 and it went to 3.6GHz without a problem. I probably could've squeezed a little more out of it but I'd been just trying to get to 3.6 for so long that I was just satisfied getting there.
 
I have no problems with my 680i SLI board. Been working for about a year and a half.:)

I dont OC so that could be a reason why i am having a good time with it.
 
I wouldn't go with the MSI, but the Biostar is a good board. It's pretty pricey for a P45 board though, so I would recommend the Gigabyte or the ASUS P5Q Pro instead based on price. You won't get substantially better overclocking from the Biostar, so you may as well save $60 and get one of the other two boards.

I have the MSI P45 Neo3-FR and it's gone north of 545FSB without so much as a hiccup. Very easy to OC with IMHO and rock solid.

I also have the Biostar i45 and it is a good board too, just takes a bit more bios fiddling to get it stable, though I think it might push my quad a little farther than the MSI can.
 
I have the MSI P45 Neo3-FR and it's gone north of 545FSB without so much as a hiccup. Very easy to OC with IMHO and rock solid.

I also have the Biostar i45 and it is a good board too, just takes a bit more bios fiddling to get it stable, though I think it might push my quad a little farther than the MSI can.

MSI boards of late have been fairly inconsistent, so I generally shy away from recommending them. If you're having a good experience with one then that's great, but I prefer to go with brands that are more reliable in general.
 
I've been running MSI since the P35 lineup without one issue, they have been great to me so far. I have gone through a few Asus + DFI and they were absolute junk to me, Asus being the better of those two.

Many people tell me similar stories of bad MSI products but I just haven't experienced it.
 
I've been 0-2 with MSI products, so I tend to shy away from them. Both of those were high end boards though.
 
I've had zero stability problems with my 780i. You might check to make sure your NB is correctly seated if your having over heating problems. Around 60C is normal and fine for it though. My only complaint is you can't have a negative GTLVREF adjustment, which is what is currently limiting my overclock. :(
 
I've had zero stability problems with my 780i. You might check to make sure your NB is correctly seated if your having over heating problems. Around 60C is normal and fine for it though. My only complaint is you can't have a negative GTLVREF adjustment, which is what is currently limiting my overclock. :(

Mine idles at 52c but I think that is still way to hot, and this is with a modded 80mm fan on it.
 
Mine idles at 52c but I think that is still way to hot, and this is with a modded 80mm fan on it.

Was it seated correctly? Not sure if it uses clips or some sort of bolt through design.
 
Mine idles at 52c but I think that is still way to hot, and this is with a modded 80mm fan on it.

Forgive me, but unless you've got stablity problems from it, what does it matter? No matter how good a HSF you put on it, it's still putting the same heat load in your case, and even at that, I can't imagine the heatload to be more than 20Watts. And if it is having stability problems at 52C when they are designed for 60C you should just RMA it.
 
Forgive me, but unless you've got stablity problems from it, what does it matter? No matter how good a HSF you put on it, it's still putting the same heat load in your case, and even at that, I can't imagine the heatload to be more than 20Watts. And if it is having stability problems at 52C when they are designed for 60C you should just RMA it.

Heh, normally youd be right but 780i is a beast. Under that huge nb heatsink are 2 high density pieces of silicon, together I'd say they could put out 30-40W.

And yeah, heat goes up, electric noise goes up, signal/noise goes down, max potential OC goes down.

Given the stability issues and general lower reliability issues of nVidia-based Intel boards, IMO it's worth selling off the 780i and going with a P45 board simply for that reason. The two best deals right now are the ASUS P5Q Pro and the Gigabyte GA-EP45-UD3P that the poster above linked to, which are both on sale for $100 after rebate at Newegg. Both are stable, perform well, and overclock great. Unfortunately the Gigabyte is out of stock at the moment, but you could always wait for it to come back in stock if you're so inclined.

hey man, Nforce 2 took me up to 230Mhz "FSB". Dont be raggin on Nforce 2.
(but of course he's right with any modern chipset. Nforce 5 was an alright AMD chipset but for conroe the converted NB silicon was a pos, Nforce 6 and 7 had horrible failure rates and of course 790i had its wierd hdd corruption issues...)
 
I still got the Biostar if you are interested in a trade. ;)
 
hey man, Nforce 2 took me up to 230Mhz "FSB". Dont be raggin on Nforce 2.
(but of course he's right with any modern chipset. Nforce 5 was an alright AMD chipset but for conroe the converted NB silicon was a pos, Nforce 6 and 7 had horrible failure rates and of course 790i had its wierd hdd corruption issues...)

I was referring specifically to nVidia's Intel chipsets. Their nVidia chipsets from nForce 2 onward didn't have any significant issues.
 
I was referring specifically to nVidia's Intel chipsets. Their nVidia chipsets from nForce 2 onward didn't have any significant issues.

Man, I remember my old NF2 DFI board. It was sweet with the mobile Barton.

The IDE SW driver for the NF3/4 was terrible though.
 
any of you guys who had the 780i board and decided to go something else and want to get rid of the 780i board please let me know...either send me a PM or email me at usmc4876@hotmail.com
 
Back
Top