Work machine: Recommendations anyone? It's YOUR dollars....

RGMBill

Gawd
Joined
Mar 6, 2005
Messages
548
Ok, guys, my boss has okayed me for a replacement to my "legacy" computer, as it's impossible to continue using a 7 year old PC for ever.

So, let's start with this: I do HEAVY software development, and the speed of the machine directly impacts how much work I get done. I'm also a US Government employee... that means you PAY for me to work.

My current antiquated machine has served well, and you've gotten your monies worth out of me using it, but it's time for an upgrade.....


Here are the givens: The machine has to be usable for development for the next 6-7 >YEARS<. That means it needs to be reliable, and it needs to be slightly high end today. I do NOT play games on it, but will eventually want to have some graphic capabilities; a decent (standard) graphic card is fine. I'll be getting a 19" LCD monitor (actually, two) as replacements for the two 21" CRTS... hello, deskspace! I'll eventually have VMWare running on the system with multiple OSes... so I need hefty RAM. And I may not get funding for incremental upgrades for the next three years.

Equipment that can (and will) be reused:
HP SCSI DAT Tape Drive
LS-120 (PIDE) Super Floppy.
IOMega Zip 250 Parallel.
The existing HDs (one SCSI, one PATA) for data continuity.

My thoughts:

I want a dual core system because of the long operational life; I don't want to WASTE your money, though... so I was considering an Athlon X2 4200. Memory is going to be VERY important once I get VMWare and the guest OSes... so I was considering a minimum of 2GB of RAM, but I don't know which brand. For the motherboard, it looks like the ASUS AN8 Deluxe (not the SLI) is one that is highly rated.

So, I need advice: What setup would folks recommend? Specific parts? Which Graphic card (hopefully, <$200). Specific case, HDD, Powersupply, Motherboard, RAM, DVDRW, etc. I'll even take recommendations on which LCD monitors.

Can someone help me spec it out before my boss changes his mind?
 
Bump. Hey guys, this is YOUR tax money I'm spending... and I could use some suggestions for specific pieces of equipment to out.
 
Check with your IT dept for deals you can get through places like Dell... i know we do a crapload of buisness with them, so i'm sure the price is right...
 
For all the multi tasking you'll be doing the dual core chip will be a good choice.

For graphics, look at the Matrox Millenium line of cards. They don't offer much in terms of 3d graphics but they are very good cards for dual display and office type work.

For Ram, just about any name brand will work fine since you won't be overclocking. Or at least you shouldn't be overclocking.

For Lcd's Samsung is my favorite brand but dell's are usually cheaper. For normal development type work pretty much any lcd will be suitable. The only real suggestion I can give you is to go to a store and spend some time with the display models, look at things like the monitors viewing angle, does the screen turn without moving the base, can the screen be raised. The lcd you pick needs to function but it also has to be comfortable for you to use for 8+ hours a day, so pick one you like.

PSU and Mobo's I haven't been following so I can't really help you there.

For all your components make sure you look at warrantys on the parts. All good brands of ram have lifetime warranty's. Retail cpus have 3 year warranty's while the oem parts will have significantly shorter ones.
 
KodiakStar said:
Check with your IT dept for deals you can get through places like Dell... i know we do a crapload of buisness with them, so i'm sure the price is right...

I would (and considering it needs to be highend on the CPU side, I might have gone Alienware) but because of NMCI (the Navy-Marine Corp Internet) I can only UPGRADE existing systems... meaning I can piece out every single part, but I have to put it together (not the best use for the money that I make, but that's the rules... and it beats the time it takes for apps to load while I'm doing software development, since it's a ONE time build cost for my time.... along with upgrades, of course).

So, I need pieces/parts.
 
Why are you not going the OEM route here? You know as well as I that we gov. employees get discounts. Warranty and service is king for gov, enterprise, education, and small buisness settings. I'm sure your org will already have a contract with Dell, IBM, or etc.?

For the power and future performance you are going to need I will reccommend the Dell Optiplex GX620 or the Dell XPS. Both can be fitted with dual core Intels and gobs of memory.
 
Private Citizen said:
Why are you not going the OEM route here? You know as well as I that we gov. employees get discounts. Warranty and service is king for gov, enterprise, education, and small buisness settings. I'm sure your org will already have a contract with Dell, IBM, or etc.?

For the power and future performance you are going to need I will reccommend the Dell Optiplex GX620 or the Dell XPS. Both can be fitted with dual core Intels and gobs of memory.

Because the Navy has directed that all computers be part of the Navy-Marine Corp Intranet (NMCI) and that means that the machines are controlled by Big Brother... without user level administrative rights, and with standard Desktop software. This is a DEVELOPMENT workstation, which CANNOT function properly under NMCI; it's "Legacy" in that the applications that are developed on it are not under the purview of NMCI, cannot be performed under NMCI constraints, etc. However, our illustrious leaders (SecNav, various Admirals) all get an extra gold star or bonus bump in their pay for boondoggling the Navy's IT infrastructure to a private contractor (my command pays out three times as much for 1/10th what we used to have pre-NMCI; for technical commands like mine, this is a major fiasco), so the powers that be decided that we CANNOT purchase new computer systems except through NMCI without paperwork that would triple the cost, half the power, and have me tearing my hair out. UPGRADES to existing systems are fine, however. So, I am going to upgrade the system I have (literally, a 7 year old Gateway, PII-400, that I've had to nurse along for the last 4 of those years... see why I'm not being as productive as I could be anymore?) But upgrades are tricky... the Powersupply of the Gateway won't support a modern Dual Core Processor... and a new to ease maintainence (which now must be performed by ME) would be helpful... etc. Some things are a given... I'll need to DRASTICALLY upgrade the speed of the machine, as it's taking forever when I have to boot up one of the alternate OSes (It's been doing it while I've been writing this...) and some things are "It's going to be ANOTHER 7 years before I can replace it again, so I need to overbuild slightly..." (2GB minimum.... may go with 4 since it will be more difficult to upgrade later, and if I can get a small subnet of virtual machines booted, it might speed things up in development, vice building a subsection on the server for testing while the server is live...) x86-64 support of one form or anther (EMT64 or x86-64, doesn't matter to me...) is one of those "What CPU architecture will be most prevalent 4 years from now, with mainstream OSes?" HDD size isn't CRITICAL as long as I have enough for various Guest OSes, so a 60-120GB drive for the main drive is fine... I have smaller, 10GB drives (one IDE VERY legacy, one SCSI) that will migrate; the IDE could go away, after the data is copied, but the SCSI is "cost free" because of the DAT drive. The LS120 and the Zip250 migrate because I have active data STORED on those media, even though both are obsolete now (BTW, as an aside, LS120 was FAR superior to Zip100, and for ease of use, and reliability, I put it ahead of Zip250, as well, plus it was faster... never could understand why folks went Zip instead).

So, I'd LOVE to go with a BTO from one of the big vendors... but I can't.

Oh, and noise is not CRITICAL, but quieter is nicer... I have enough noise with the laser printers, the baystack switch, and the other various machines in the office that I don't need more noise, but it's not so critical that it's a first concern.

Hey, the machine just finished booting Solaris. Now to work.
 
Not quite related to the topic, but definitely relevant.... make sure your department does not have any standing offers with any resellers, as if they do, buying a PC that does not come from them would be a violation of the standing offer and could get you in some hot water. I work in government (however, in Canada) and any device attached to our network (namely PCs and network printers, however I am sure network equipment falls under this as well) must be purchased in accordance with the national master standing offer (NMSO). Anything NOT purchased through this process is not allowed to touch our network under any circumstance and we are absolutely forbidden to buy outside of the agreement.

As an example, we just recently purchased a number of Dell printers for our region, however there was no NMSO in place to purchase cartridges, so when some of our sites started to run out, it was not possible for us to purchase replacement cartridges.

But of course, the system is perfect and I'm sure you've already considered all this ;) :D
 
WCES Ryan said:
As an example, we just recently purchased a number of Dell printers for our region, however there was no NMSO in place to purchase cartridges, so when some of our sites started to run out, it was not possible for us to purchase replacement cartridges.
So what did you do? Junk the printers?
 
Went through the process of putting a standing offer in place so that we can buy the cartridges. I think we bought around 20-30 of these units so I don't think they want to throw them out. Why they bought them in the first place I don't know... for all intents and purposes they are EXACTLY the same as the Lexmark T630 (which was our previous standard printer). However, go to put a T630 cartridge in there and you get an unsupported cartridge error. Fantastic, yay government!
 
mikeblas said:
What kind of development? For which OS(es)?

Win2K, BSD, Solaris, plus a few >I< don't boot but I crosscompile for (all RTOS machines). I'll probably add WinXP to the list if the system is able good enough :), plus I'll need to have the ability to add any potential OS I may have to support in the future. I'll almost certainly add some Linux (probably not the base OS, though; the VMWare license I'm using now is Win based, unfortunately). I do development for both the front and backend of some Configuration Management software for an ACAT I program (which is what the military classifies as one of >THEIR< big $$$ programs... they call it big money). I'm the SPoF (single point of failure) as I'm the main developer/maintainer/administrator/Customer Rep/face/Customer Support to the system.
 
Dual core, definitely. I might look at the 4400+ for the extra 512kb of cache.

For RAM, I've always stood by trusty Corsair ValueRAM. If you want to run multiple OS's at once, though... yes, 2GB minimum, but maybe 4GB might be worth considering. I can definitely see how a main OS for developing and two or three emulated OS's for testing would eat up 2GB of RAM fairly quick.

I don't know much about workstation graphics cards, but I'd imagine something from Matrox that will more than get the job done can be had for fairly cheaply.

Definitely get a quality motherboard, the A8N would definitely fit the bill.

Larger hard drives can be had fairly cheaply these days, I'd recommend something from Seagate as they have a 5 year warranty whereas most other manufacturers have a 3 year, plus Seagate drives rock.

The case poses an interesting question, because I'll assume that you don't want something very flashy. If it's going to be hidden away this is less of an issue. Maybe a Cooler Master Praetorian, or a Stacker if you don't mind something hugely heavy. An lower-end Antec case might be a cheaper route, but since you have to do maintenance on it yourself you might want to get something nicer and more accessible.

For PSU, check the PSU forum, there is much information there. Anything from PCP&C, something from the Antec Truepower line, etc.

For optical drives, Plextor owns, at least imo.

Hopefully that gets you on your way. :)
 
I'm surprised that you aren't required to get a PC through a company the government has a contract with..
 
How long can you hold off?

The current AMD offerings are nice and all, but they are about to scrap the sockets, meanwhile Intel is about to release Cedar Mill/Presley/Dempsey that will likely be around for a bit longer.

If you can, I'd hold off for a month or two and get a Dempsey based Xeon machine. 3.46Ghz with dual cores and HT = 2 real cores and 2 virtual, so super speedy multitasking, and if you can get a dual socket board, you could pop in a second proc later to really speed things up.

Plus, the Dempsey chips are benchmarking faster than more expensive opterons.
 
As to how long I can hold off, I need to get this through soon (within a month), as the current workstation will become uncertifiable in April, and I need time to get the new workstation up, installed, and supportable before then; considering that I have to build it and test it a bit, while the system it's an upgrade of is still somewhat available, I don't have a lot of time.

So, it sounds like this:

ASUS AN8 Deluxe Motherboard.
Retail Athlon X2 4400+ (Stock Cooling).
Corsair ValueRam (2x1GB DDR2 2x266Mhz (533Mhz)?)
Matrox Millenium
Antec TruePower (550 Watt?)
CoolerMaster (Prateorian Case?)
Plextor DVD R/W drive.
Samsung or Dell 19" LCDs (any model suggestions?)
Seagate HDD (2x200ish, probably, since I can add more capacity later if needed; 200Gb is probably overkill at this point though).
I'll upgrade to a Logitech Optical Mouse, and a new keyboard as well, since those are cheap.
Base OS will PROBABLY go ahead and be WinXP Pro, as it's lifecycle extends further than Win2K right now.. I don't mind maintaining, but I want the base OS to stay stable as long as possible, plus it's more "mainstream". I can reuse the existing PCI SCSI Card for the SCSI drive, the DAT Drive, the IDE controller will support the existing IDE drive and the LS120, and the A8N Deluxe has a printer port for the Parallel Zip 250. I'll reuse existing speakers, etc.

Any other recommendations?
 
For that system, you don't need such a high watt PSU. A True Power 430 from Antec will do fine. If you're not going to do any gaming or 3D rendering, the Matrox Millenium G550 is a dual DVI PCIe x1 video card which would be perfect if the monitors have DVI ports. Any case that'll fit the motherboard and have 1 intake and exhaust will be fine for the system. Go with a Lite-On DVD+/-RW since they're more reliable and commonly used drives.
 
You should get a dual core Opteron based system. Look for a very stable motherboard unless you are buying an OEM. DO NOT buy a Dell if your job is largely depending on the computer (speaking based on experience).
 
i dunno but when i see heavy development i just think of dual cpus.

i would go wtih dual opterons, s940 dualie board, as much ram as you can afford.

videocard really anything will work, go with teh Matrox or really any Nvidia will do u fine. i would go with a single fast sata drive, maybe dual raptors in raid 1, then use ur scsi drive as storage or something.
 
I would go with something like 6600gt just in case you use 3dsmax soild works or auto cad

something that can handle some 3d stuff

also in the future when the new windows comes out i think you will have to have a card that can do some 3d stuff just something to think about
 
Well, the equipment has been purchased and is now coming in (the monitors came in yesterday).

Monitors: Two Dell 2001FP 19" LCD's (1600x1200).
Motherboard: Asus AN8-SLI Deluxe (could not procure the non-SLI version from the vendor).
Processor: AMD Athlon X2-4400+ (Toledo)
Memory: CORSAIR ValueSelect 2GB (2x1GB) PC3200 (*timings weren't that important to me, so I saved a bit to get a better CPU*)
Video: XFX Geforce 6600GT 128MB GDDR3 PCI Express (should be enough to power the monitors easily, but isn't OVERPowered, either).
PowerSupply: Antec TRUEPOWER-II TPII-550w, I have a decent amount of drives (including the tape) going in, so I didn't want to skimp here. If anything, 550w is less than what I would have liked.
Case: CoolerMaster CM Stacker STC-T01-UW (Black and silver, though it doesn't matter).
New HDs: 2x Seagate Barracuda 7200.8 250GB Serial ATA150 8MB Cache (a really nice deal on these, and a long warrenty)
DVD R/W: Asus 16X (Black, but again doesn't matter) IDE. 16x through 40x for the various speeds. Average, but should keep me going for a while.

I'll be assembling the machine in the next week.

Thanks for everyone's input.
 
RGMBill said:
Memory: CORSAIR ValueSelect 2GB (2x1GB) PC3200 (*timings weren't that important to me, so I saved a bit to get a better CPU*)


FWIW Timings are not terribly important with the current AMD64 line. You won't feel the difference between csa2 and cas3 in your day-to-day apps. Check out the memory forum for more info. Ya did pretty good, IMO.
 
Back
Top