Windows XP Downgrade Lawsuit Dismissed

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
The antitrust lawsuit filed against Microsoft last year over Windows XP downgrades has been dismissed. The courts said Microsoft in no way benefited from the fee to downgrade to XP from Vista. The judge in the case stated that the plaintiff should have filed suit against Lenovo, the company that charged her for the downgrade, not Microsoft.

In the lawsuit, Alvarado claimed that she was being taken advantage of by Microsoft by having to pay additional money to downgrade. The problem with that assertion is that Microsoft did not charge, nor profit from, that fee. Alvarado should have filed her suit against Lenovo.
 
Sounds like the plaintiff was high on MS hate and Vista FUD. She should clear her head before crafting any other frivolous lawsits.

No, wait, she should just get a Mac. I'm sure she'd love it.
 
Just nice to see that there are other greedy corporations out there besides Microsoft! Folks its all about money, even when doing no evil.
 
plaintiff should have filed suit against Lenovo, the company that charged her for the downgrade, not Microsoft.
She has even less of a case with lenovo, if thats possible.:p

Levono isn't a monopoly

They can charge whatever they want for any service they want. She is free to buy from another company if she doesn't like levono.

But I get the feeling this case was less about justice and more about how much money she can extort from MS:mad:
 
Why does she think she is entitled to a free downgrade anyways? The license still cost money. Yeah this seems like a case where the woman thought she was gonna get some extra money out of the deal.
 
Finally, a judge with some common sense.

That Vista capable lawsuit should have gotten tossed too.
 
She wouldn't win against Lenovo anyways. They'll just claim that all systems are preloaded with Vista on it and that they lose X amount of money by having a technician reload XP onto the new system.
 
She wouldn't win against Lenovo anyways. They'll just claim that all systems are preloaded with Vista on it and that they lose X amount of money by having a technician reload XP onto the new system.

The whole basis of this class action is with dubious merit at best. I'm not saying that OEMs aren't milking this because they are, but OEMs can legitimately say that there is a cost to downgrading a machine as miniscule as it might be.
 
Ya, I went back to see what kind of lawsuit this even was. Antitrust. Ya, lawyers would laugh at her ass if she went up to Lenovo with such a lawsuit.
 
Vista shouldn't have been tossed. It should have been free, since it was nothing more than a public alpha of Windows 7.
 
The whole issue with this case is that while Microsoft didn't profit they also let OEM's have free reign of the cost of the OS. Microsoft is pretty strict on OS prices for OEM's. If you've ever taken a look they all charge almost to the dollar of what Microsoft says they should charge.

When they released Vista they wanted everyone to move to it and allowed the OEM's to charge extra for an OS license, which really had no extra value associated to it. I've purchased many machines from Dell, HP, etc, and was charged extra for Windows XP. It didn't bother us because quite frankly stability mattered a whole lot more.
 
How the hell did the Lawyer not catch this... Oh, wait. Now he gets to sue twice !
 
Back
Top