Windows Upgrade Options for Businesses

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
CIO.com spoke with a Microsoft Windows senior director and she outlined five points IT managers should consider when evaluating their Windows upgrade strategy. Even end users can benefit from this information so check it out if you or your business is undecided on the Windows upgrade path.

If you're an XP user who has no concrete upgrade plans, Schuster warns of the risks of skipping Windows Vista. For instance, you may find yourself with applications that are no longer supported on XP and not yet supported on Windows 7.
 
not yet supported in 7? i though it was using vista core coding...
 
heheh, "you better run out and buy Vista, play with that for a good 6 months, then upgrade to Windows7"

senior director must mean publicity manager.
 
I already know the software that I wanted to work in Vista still will not work in windows 7. I have to find something besides bloated up roxio and nero programs.
 
I already know the software that I wanted to work in Vista still will not work in windows 7. I have to find something besides bloated up roxio and nero programs.

I've have any problems with Nero 9 in Vista or 7. There is a very nice freeware recording app that I use as well that also works in Vista and 7, InfraRecorder: http://infrarecorder.org/
 
I remember when Nero 6 was about 15-20MB. When Nero 7 hit, it became about 250MB. It is a bit nice to have the video conversion, but come on. All I use is nero burning rom, and I was forced to upgrade when I went to Vista.

I ended up selling my desktop, with my Vista disc since my school provided me a laptop, with XP. I plan to just skip thru Vista and go straight to W7. Why bother?
 
Rings completely hollow. "Please buy our product, don't wait for our next one."
 
Got to love marketing. With Xp having such a large market share and windows 7 being largely based on Vista who really believes that crap. Give bigness a large price break on Vista. I know that's the only way I could convince the company I work for to get it.
 
The most recent Windows Weekly podcast touched on alot of this and was a very interesting listen. I highly recommend it.
 
As much as people hate on Vista, I have to say that I really enjoy it (it's very fast!) and will never go back to XP.
 
OH GOOD GRIEF. For the most part businesses have software assurance, and the move between versions of windows doesn't cost anything as a benefit. Companies that have skipped Vista to move straight to 7 are going to find that sticking with XP is what really works and that is going to be a conundrum when Microsoft kills the XP support. Most of the problems with Vista aren't really real its all perception. Not that there are not problems, but where I work half the IT guys dislike it without ever even trying it. I "read this or that" or I "heard this or that", and so it goes nowhere. The senior guys all huddle up and push their FUD down everyone's throat. Windows to me hasn't changed as drastically as Windows Vista changed things since the move from 3.1 to windows 95, and in some ways I'd call it more drastic. This puts a lot of people in the catagory of needing to LEARN, and they resist it like the plague.
 
Windows to me hasn't changed as drastically as Windows Vista changed things since the move from 3.1 to windows 95, and in some ways I'd call it more drastic. This puts a lot of people in the catagory of needing to LEARN, and they resist it like the plague.

I work on my nieces and nephews laptops all the time and they all use Vista. I find it a major PITA to work on. Maybe there is some way to turn off all that BS so it's easy to get things done.

The bottom line to me and my company is that why bother with Vista when XP works great and everyone is comfortable with it. I remember making the switch to 95 and it was very expensive because none of the progs and utilities worked anymore. :(
 
My next upgrade path is Ubuntu. (IT Admin for 700 Workststions)

Did I want to learn Ubuntu?
No:
Microsoft left me no choice with their bloated crapware, ridiculous pricing and specially designed to be utterly confusing licensing schemes, not to mention the goons they will send round as soon as think it might be profitable.
 
Yup thats right!!!

You better buy their POS OS each time so that you don't totally get screwed all at once.

Getting slightly screwed over each time you can deal with, but taking the whole thing at once might make you want to change your mind.
 
As much as people hate on Vista, I have to say that I really enjoy it (it's very fast!) and will never go back to XP.

Err, It's not really that fast...

Try running vista on your single core P3-1000 that you upgrade to 1Gb of ram a couple years back which had a geforce2 or possibly onboard video.

Your forgetting that your new vista machine is a quadcore or at least dual core. Each core would best a 4000Mhz P3 processor. Not to mention that you have a faster 7200 rpm harddrive with a good size buffer, and at least, AT LEAST 2 Gb of ram.
 
I can see some of the logic for enterprises to go the XP -> Vista -> 7 route but it really is kinda silly.

Why it makes sense: 3rd party app support. Some apps in our enterprise were just certified for vista with in the last year. How long will it take for windows 7? Though apps may still work, good luck getting vendor support. They will just ask you does it work in Vista, we don't support 7?

Why is it silly?

1. Well if 7 ends up being just a "fixed" vista, odds are any apps that work with vista will work with 7. In theory support issues could be supported on Vista test machines and ported to 7, that is IF they really are that close... I would rather jump from XP to 7.

2. Upgrading OS twice inside of 5 years is just a freaking waste of IT resources. Testing all the apps, deployment/installation packages, backups etc is a HUGE project doing it twice is just silly. Especially the jump from XP to Vista/7. The UAC changes alone require twice as much testing time with software and deployment. Granted the transition from vista to 7 should be smoother then XP to Vista, you still have to test everything.


I am the desktop engineer of my company which has 1500+ desktops. I will be suggesting that our OS upgrade be straight to 7. XP is working great for us know and if I am going to create an image and test 300+ apps and deployment I want to do it only once. I have too much to do then roll out back to back OSs. I don't care if we have to run XP for a bit even unsupported, we don't even us MS support. The only thing we will be missing is security updates and honestly our network firewalls and anti-virus take care of 90+% of those concerns.
 
Baaahahahaha, what a shameless display of marketing schlock! Upgrade to vista at full price just as an interim solution before re-upgrading again to Windows7, all just to offset the possibility that maybe your software vendors will no longer support either of the above, assuming you had any problems with your software to begin with.
 
Baaahahahaha, what a shameless display of marketing schlock! Upgrade to vista at full price just as an interim solution before re-upgrading again to Windows7, all just to offset the possibility that maybe your software vendors will no longer support either of the above, assuming you had any problems with your software to begin with.

As mentioned previously.... Most enterprises that really have to worry about upgrade paths pay for MS licensing by the year/head. We have had Vista licensing for 2 years now, and when 7 is released will be fully licensed for that as well. It costs us nothing extra to run the suggested upgrade path...

If you don't have the assurance licensing, then chances are you are small enough to run multiple OSs and upgrade any way you want.

So though you think its marketing schlock, it really isn't. This article wasn't meant for users or small business'. It was meant for enterprise size environments.
 
Being a Administrator for a SMB , I do not recommend vista today,and at this point, you are better off waiting for the next version of Windows that going to Vista.
 
Why go to either OS when XP runs everything we need to run, perfectly? Thanks, but I won't be upgrading any of the ~150 PCs at my site in the foreseeable future.
 
Why go to either OS when XP runs everything we need to run, perfectly? Thanks, but I won't be upgrading any of the ~150 PCs at my site in the foreseeable future.

True, until XP no longer receives security updates and/or applications stop dropping support for XP.

I am guessing this will be some time in the future.

You do want to plan ahead though... you never know when your users will demand an application that will only support vista (usually an upgrade or something).

Its ALWAYS the small crappy app vendors out there that cause the largest changes to your environment. We have a few apps that I swear are developed in the basement of someone's home. Support emails are hilarious where the support staff are CC'ing in other employees with "Mom can you answer this question..." lol I am not kidding.
 
True, until XP no longer receives security updates and/or applications stop dropping support for XP.

Funny, most of my small businesses use apps that are older than the OS. Two of my places use DOS apps still! :eek:
 
Back
Top