windows ugly and mac pretty ?!?

Stardocks looks incredibly tacky, so I'm sure Apple will over look it for a while longer, but with "custom" icons and add on you can improve how it looks. I find the same to be true for Vista or XP, you can change the way anything looks. I'm actually not a Mac fan, but I love the dock and I miss the old task bar at the top from Win 3.11, never liked it at the bottom (so I moved it and got the dock app). Also plenty of places to get custom Icons from any OS for Windows, plenty of sites dedicated to cool backgrounds and if your still not happy you can get WinBlinds (just for fun I made my old notebook look like a Mac). If your still note happy, just install OSX on your PC and have it done with.

EDIT I'm one of the folks that still consider Pluto a planet.
 
I'd say I'm a little strange in this regard.

I'm a big OS X fan. I appreciate the visual aesthetic and the "fun" presentation, but it doesn't go so far as to look too childish when I'm doing serious work in Pro Tools, Peak or whatever. I suppose I like all of the little GPU-accelerated gimmickry except for Time Machine, which is just plain over-the-top. If I had the option to roll back to an OS 9-like GUI, which I did actually like, there's no way in hell I'd actually do it.

When using Vista (which isn't often), I prefer the classic Windows theme. I really don't find the visual aspect of Aero Glass all that engaging, and in fact, it's something of a turn-off for me. The stylization is almost completely unappealing, not unlike like XP's skinned themes which I disable in XP as well (I also use nLite now to remove the themes completely). The icons in Vista have improved over those used in XP, if you ask me, so that's one little plus Vista does have over XP for me, but it's understandably minor.

I don't know if it's a question of whether or not the graphic designers at Microsoft aren't as "good" as those at Apple, because I'd guess they're every bit as good, but what sort of leash they're on when they're developing various aspects of Windows. I think Apple's designers are probably on a shorter leash and are able to hit closer to the mark.
 
I don't think it has anything to do with leashes. It is purely subjective. Let's say you have two ice cream companies. One makes vanilla, and the other makes chocolate. Each person you ask will have a preference between the two, so they'd naturally favor that brand. Does that mean vanilla is better than chocolate, or vice versa? Not at all. I'm not quite sure why this is being over analyzed, or why the topic was even brought up in the first place. Each person has their preference, and that's simply it. This isn't about which company makes a better OS, as there's no way to ever objectively prove that.
 
Vanilla is clearly the superior choice.

Chocolate should only be served at room temperature (thereby excluding the possibility of iced cream), or possibly in a fudgesicle if that's truly your only source of chocolate.
 
All proven to be fixed by a huge range of websites as well. As someone already mentioned to you, you can downgrade to XP. If you'd stop looking for an argument for a few minutes, you'd see that by purchasing a license for Vista, you are legally entitled to downgrade. How to go about doing that, I don't know, never had a reason to.

fixed? no. improved from what they were, but not at the performance level of xp.
as seen here:
http://blogs.zdnet.com/hardware/?p=1332
 
Windows XP was ugly, and I'm going to guess that's what you are referring to. It used office-themed icons from the 90s, and everything was raster-based GDI graphics which scaled to today's monitor resolutions very poorly. It's not that Windows is ugly, it's that XP/2k were designed in an era when space was still a consideration and sacrifices had to be made.

Mac OS X, as well as Windows Vista, do not have the "ugly" problems you speak of because they are a new generation of operating systems. They were designed with home users in mind and geared less directly towards professional office use. All their graphics are vector-based rendering on 3D accelerated technologies. Their prettiness easily accounts for their size, in an era when visual appeal is expected of computers, and storage space is literally not even a consideration. Everything is built around using a mouse instead of the old keyboard shortcutting system, allowing new users to catch on quickly (but aggrivating old guys who are still used to keeping both hands on the keyboard).

Vista and OS X redistribute the balance of productivity and speed. Some people like it, and some people (most of the ones you see on this board) hate it, and cling to Windows XP, insisting that Vista and OS X are nothing more than "eye candy with a performance reduction."
 
Windows XP was ugly, and I'm going to guess that's what you are referring to. It used office-themed icons from the 90s, and everything was raster-based GDI graphics which scaled to today's monitor resolutions very poorly. It's not that Windows is ugly, it's that XP/2k were designed in an era when space was still a consideration and sacrifices had to be made.

Mac OS X, as well as Windows Vista, do not have the "ugly" problems you speak of because they are a new generation of operating systems. They were designed with home users in mind and geared less directly towards professional office use. All their graphics are vector-based rendering on 3D accelerated technologies. Their prettiness easily accounts for their size, in an era when visual appeal is expected of computers, and storage space is literally not even a consideration. Everything is built around using a mouse instead of the old keyboard shortcutting system, allowing new users to catch on quickly (but aggrivating old guys who are still used to keeping both hands on the keyboard).

Vista and OS X redistribute the balance of productivity and speed. Some people like it, and some people (most of the ones you see on this board) hate it, and cling to Windows XP, insisting that Vista and OS X are nothing more than "eye candy with a performance reduction."

as long as XP has been around tho, MS could have easily dropped ui pretty in there tho. New icons, etc. It wouldnt have been difficult to do.
 
as long as XP has been around tho, MS could have easily dropped ui pretty in there tho. New icons, etc. It wouldnt have been difficult to do.

As a manual download you have to go to the Download Center for, sure.

Otherwise you'd have tons of people bitching about "Why the hell is this update getting applied? It's BLOAT!"
 
As a manual download you have to go to the Download Center for, sure.

Otherwise you'd have tons of people bitching about "Why the hell is this update getting applied? It's BLOAT!"

uncheck it from the list. people who are dumb enough to have auto downloading and updating deserve whatever they get.
 
as long as XP has been around tho, MS could have easily dropped ui pretty in there tho. New icons, etc. It wouldnt have been difficult to do.
Why, so we can all rehash (even more so than is already happening) the same arguments from before? The XP bashers were very quick to ask, why they needed all the eye candy when Windows 2000 worked fine for them. To them, XP was nothing more than a cute front end to Windows 2000. Had Microsoft done the very same thing with Vista, people like you would have been all over them for charging us so much money for a visual upgrade, and nothing more.

With a little thought mixed in, one would realize that Microsoft is damned if they do, and damned if they don't. No matter what they choose to do...someone is there ready to bitch, regardless of how weak their platform is for the argument. "You can't make all the people happy, all the time" as the saying goes. I would rather have a new and improved OS that takes some time to fix some small issues, than see the same thing over and over again with a fresh coat of paint.
 
What motivation would Microsoft have for porting Aero to XP? Vista's delays have meant that XP got a number of features originally planned to be Vista-only where a larger installed base would be beneficial for other reasons, but for Microsoft to release all of Vista's features for XP for free would make no business sense. They're trying to phase XP out, not encourage people to keep using it for as long as possible.

If you want to use XP but have it look like Vista, then WindowBlinds can pretty much arrange that, as mentioned.
 
I use Rocket Dock and Object Dock, and like them both.

I don't like OSX, and I think Windows personally looks better.
 
I find it amazing the amount of detail that is NOT THERE that DeaconFrost and Mithent manage to read into a simple "they could update some icons" post.

Who said anything about porting the window manager to xp? who said anything about all the eyecandy? some simple updated icons, maybe a new official color theme or two. A few SIMPLE things. I didn't ask for the world. How long has XP been on the market now? Shouldnt MS have done something simple like this as a minor bonus tossed in among the myriad of security fixes?
 
What motivation would Microsoft have for porting Aero to XP?
Well, I'm sure they could port the SKIN at least. How it actually works with the GPU and all that has changed, I believe (have no desire to be any sort of programmer guru... so I couldn't tell you).


Microsoft to release all of Vista's features for XP for free would make no business sense. They're trying to phase XP out, not encourage people to keep using it for as long as possible.
QFT.
I think some people UTTERLY FAIL to realize Microsoft is still a company, and needs to make money. Which is another reason I tire of DX10. Even if they wanted to put in the vast amounts of time to port DX10, it's one less reason to go to Vista. Just stupid business sense.
 
as long as XP has been around tho, MS could have easily dropped ui pretty in there tho. New icons, etc. It wouldnt have been difficult to do.

I'm not sure on the specifics of XP's old GDI system, but I don't think it allowed for scalable vector graphics and hardware-accelerated effects like the new Aero engine does.
 
ahah. After the Vista disaster you say this? OSX isnt perfect either, but lets face it, MS shipped something broken with intent to fix it later. It quite pisses me off, having bought this broken crap. If I could switch for another copy of XP, I would in a heartbeat.

What vista disaster? the fact it sold 60million copies in it's first month? (XP did 30mill) and continued after that to outsell XP exponentially...


Vista wasnt broken for me... but of course every blames something not work in vista on vista, not the crappy drivers, or software written by 3rd parties.
 
Vista wasnt broken for me... but of course every blames something not work in vista on vista, not the crappy drivers, or software written by 3rd parties.

Someone just rear-ended me on the highway today... I probably need to sue Honda for not making cars that can avoid accidents, huh?
 
What vista disaster? the fact it sold 60million copies in it's first month? (XP did 30mill) and continued after that to outsell XP exponentially...


Vista wasnt broken for me... but of course every blames something not work in vista on vista, not the crappy drivers, or software written by 3rd parties.

only like a lot of other people in this thread you didn't read before you lipped off.
I didn't have ANY technical problems with vista, I used it from release until a few weeks ago, but it was torture. Its slow as shit doing ANYTHING related to copying/moving/deleting files.

Anyone who doesn't admit this is quite simply lying. Any number of benches (as I've already pointed out) prove that XP is dramatically faster at the same tasks.
 
With Vista x64 I did have some slow file copying but it seemed to be more the pre-copy setup causing the slowness. "Preparing to copy.... .... ......" I haven't tinkered with SP1 enough yet to see if this is better overall, but when I was copying drivers an stuff it didn't seem slow at all. I should try copying really big files or something I guess.

I'm not sure which is worse, Vista slow file copying or OS X splattering .DS_Store files all over everything it has write access on, and also making little shadow files of everything it manipulates. I remember in my 10.2-10.3 days I brought my G4 tower to work to use and there was never any question about what servers I was connecting to since I left those damn hidden files everywhere.
 
Back
Top