Windows Home Server Discontinued

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
This week Microsoft announced the discontinuation of the Windows Home Server. The current version, WHS 2011 will be the last version produced and will be available as a standalone copy until the end of 2013 and as a preinstalled OEM until 2025.

So the home server dream is dead, and the nearest direct equivalent—Windows Server 2012 Essentials—costs substantially more ($425, compared to about $50).
 
I have yet to see anyone run windows home server, it's probably a smart move from a wasted support effort aspect.
 
dang and i just bought the deal they had. But it's still going to be installed for 13 years...?
 
:( I love my WHS 2008 and didn't upgrade specifically because of the loss of the disk pooling. I use it to access my files and media stuff when I'm away from home. I was really hoping the next (now non-existant) WHS version would have added in the pooling feature again...I guess MS wants you to move up to Windows Storage Server 2008 R2 Essentials or just use Win8 to do that stuff, but I don't plan on moving to Win8 at all...I guess I'll just keep plugging away with my WHS 2008 as long as I can.
 
I have yet to see anyone run windows home server, it's probably a smart move from a wasted support effort aspect.

I used the original one. It had some pretty cool options. But most of the stuff I can do with Windows 7 on a server, plus I get the functionality of a real operating system without the artificial limitations thats the home server had imposed on it.

Windows 7 offers Home Group, Printer sharing, Remote Desktop Connection, Streaming capability all right out of the box. Plus I can do everything else I would want.
 
I Used WHS v1 for a long while, but then migrated over to Amahi (Fedora). That has since crapped out on me & since it took days of setup instead of hours on WHS I am going back to WHS. I have 2011 sitting here & will be being installed today with stablebit DrivePool.
 
I used the original one. It had some pretty cool options. But most of the stuff I can do with Windows 7 on a server, plus I get the functionality of a real operating system without the artificial limitations thats the home server had imposed on it.

Windows 7 offers Home Group, Printer sharing, Remote Desktop Connection, Streaming capability all right out of the box. Plus I can do everything else I would want.

1) WHS2011 is ~40-50 euros. Windows 7 Pro/Ultimate, which are the only versions which have Remote Desktop are ~150-170 euros. You are comparing completely different price categories.
2) WHS2011 is pretty much Windows Server 2008 R2 (which is based on W7) + few extra functions (backup server, remote dashboard etc). W7 has nothing like that.
3) Compared to Windows 7, WHS2011 has pretty much only limitation - max 8GB RAM, and has few extra features.

Anyway, with this move MS simply cleaned up the whole cheap home server area to the likes of FreeNAS, OpenMediaVault etc.
 
I have always thought I'd build a home server at some point, but based upon the reviews I have read, I didn't find the right answer. It seems WHS 2011 drops support for a few key features that past versions included too.

Now I have friends that are implementing Apple systems and moving away from Microsoft OS products all together (said to require less support, but they are spending more to do so). I hear that we don't need servers anymore and that we should simply "move to the cloud", but I'd rather have my files on site than in the cloud. So, I am debating a build with WHS 2011...

This week Microsoft announced the discontinuation of the Windows Home Server. The current version, WHS 2011 will be the last version produced and will be available as a standalone copy until the end of 2013 and as a preinstalled OEM until 2025.
 
Have had no issues since moving from WHS 2011 to Amahi. And it took me a couple hours to install Amahi. No you don't have to be a Linux guru to use it. No idea what would take days to setup Amahi..
 
We can rebuild it. We have the technology.

It's called CentOS. It can serve many of these functions, and can be built into a virtual appliance. Coupled with VMware's free version of ESXi, it could easily serve as well as any Microsoft product for a home server, and more. I had it doing many of these things not long ago. There was a little snafu, and I had to replace it with a WD router, but I could do it again if I had the time.
 
:( I love my WHS 2008 and didn't upgrade specifically because of the loss of the disk pooling. I use it to access my files and media stuff when I'm away from home. I was really hoping the next (now non-existant) WHS version would have added in the pooling feature again...I guess MS wants you to move up to Windows Storage Server 2008 R2 Essentials or just use Win8 to do that stuff, but I don't plan on moving to Win8 at all...I guess I'll just keep plugging away with my WHS 2008 as long as I can.

take a look at drive bender, it works on basically any Windows OS after xp and i think is more stable/powerful, but don't take my word for it, try it out yourself, they have a 30 day trial (or 15 day, i don't know)
 
I've had a very stable WHSv1 setup for over 6 years now and it's still one of the best additions I've ever added to my home network. MS failed in getting people familiar with the benefits and simplicity of windows home server. Its not just a place to store files and centralized your media, but a great backup routine to have. It backs up all your computers every night while you sleep. Many family's now a days have 3 or more computers (kids home PC, mom & dad's laptops). Having a WHS keeps everyone backed up and safe should anything happen. It catastrophic for family's who stores tons of digital photos to have a hard drive failure. With WHS, all you have to do is replace the dead hard drive, reconnect to the server, then restore your new hard drive with everything that was on the previous hard drive so you computer will be just like it was before the drive ever failed. Its so damn easy!!! This has saved my bacon more then once and it's worth its weight in gold IMO! Its a damn shame more people don't do regular backup or keep putting it off. The heart break I've seen from Mom's bringing to me their dead hard drives begging me to save the photos is just so sad.

R.I.P. WHS... your are and always will be my best digital friend! haha
 
Meh, I doubt it will have a big impact. People don't need in home servers and only a few people will make up reasons to want them. Home servers are the goo-gaw-baubles of a small community of nerds who had to invent reasons to buy them in the first place.
 
People rarely back up at all, so a backup server that could hold multiple hard drives was always a pipe dream. Plus, with online could backup and a decent Internet connection, most of the problem is solved. I used WHSv1 and 2012 for over 2 years but got rid of them when I decided to consolidate storage and recording TV into one box. Much simpler that way.

The premise of WHS good, but the cloud is easier. Doesn't matter what your upload speed is to access files and you don't need to be at home to access them. Plus, its available everywhere.
 
Have had no issues since moving from WHS 2011 to Amahi. And it took me a couple hours to install Amahi. No you don't have to be a Linux guru to use it. No idea what would take days to setup Amahi..

Greyhole's setup required a fair amount of command line work as well as manually editing the config files.. This is beyond what should be required for a basic home setup. Also keep in mind that your setup was likely different then mine as yours was much more recent (basing this on your comment about moving from WHS 2011 to it). So the setup & install process may be better (I know that the folks @ Amahi were actively working on it). Also part of the reason it took days was migrating all of my data onto the pool then adding each drive to the pool one at a time (just like I am having to do now). Several TB's of data being copied & moved multiple times is bound to take a long time.
 
The only reason, IMO, that Server 2011 failed is because Microsoft didn't listen to it's consumers. It's ripped the heart and soul out of Home Server 2008 by taking out drive pooling. Now, thankfully, there are add-ins that do it, I dare say, better than Microsoft did, but it was because of their total lack of connection with the community that I think finally doomed it. I've looked at Amahi and it may be a nice alternative, at some point, but right now I prefer my setup with WHS 2011. Microsoft...you are dooming yourselves. I will not be making the switch to Windows 8 either, and I'm usually one of the guys that ALWAYS ditching the last version of the OS for the new latest and greatest.
 
I bought both WHS v1 and v2. They both are near and dear to my home network's heart. They were easy to use and offered great features (automatic backup, simplified notifications, bare metal restore, lots of wizards, etc..). Chances are I will just break down and buy essentials as the cloud wont be able to meet my needs for a while.
 
most of what home server and small business server did, is covered in the upcoming windows server 2012 essentials.
 
At least it is still available to purchase. WHS 2011 works great for me and was only $30.

So MS won't be selling new versions to people who already have a perfectly fine OS. The thing that really kills an OS is a new version. WHS 2011 will have a long run like XP. :)
 
I run WHS 2011 and like. I think they did this because W8 has the resurrected drive-pool/extender function. I think they're just trying to push people into W8 for Home Server stuff. Maybe they'll just launch a powertoy or something that does the dashboard for the end users.
 
They're simply moving these features into Windows 8... With HomeGroups, Media Streaming, etc... Even Windows 7 can be a respectable server for your home.
Which means HP, etc, whoever is selling these can install Windows 8 and make them "Servers" if they want to. Not a big deal.


While these backups are nice and all, I think it sways people's minds from natural disaster. If your house burns down, it's all gone.


Personally, I use a cloud sync service. I have the original WHS (though honestly, any OS would have done) on an HP MediaServer. I keep all my files on it, and then it syncs them to the cloud for me. If I ever need one, I can get it online. I can care less about the Drive Extender stuff... Because I'm backing up online, I don't care if it'd redundant here. Regardless, I still have enough extra HDDs, I'm utilizing the feature.
It keeps my data fully backed up online from disaster, PLUS I have a local copy of it for speedy access. Pretty much a win-win.


The only reason, IMO, that Server 2011 failed is because Microsoft didn't listen to it's consumers. It's ripped the heart and soul out of Home Server 2008 by taking out drive pooling.
That's the ONLY reason?
It's hard enough to convince people to even spend $20 on a flash drive to backup to much less a few hundred on a server to do it. WHS was doomed from the start. A good idea, but the nerds that knew it was a good idea are a pretty small niche.
 
WHS is a very easy to use product. I bought an HP Mediasmart EX 495 a couple or so years ago, and I just recently blasted it and upgraded to WHS2011 + Stablebit Drivepool (it's way better than DE was, so no big loss). People are always saying "bleh bleh bleh linux bsd bleh bleh" (or something equivalently useless and ironically closed-minded), but with minimal effort I have a headless box that automatically backs up the wife-unit's laptop and serves as a central repository of all our junk... Stuff we need redundant across the disks is handled as such, and the bulk stuff that I can replace just lives out there on one drive - all with 0 effort or management on my part.

In my mind, that's the selling point of WHS; it just works without you having to worry about it. I was on the road back to town and the aforementioned wife-unit asked if we had song X in the library. I connected to our home network via OpenVPN on my phone, logged into the WHS web interface, and browsed through the music real quick. Turns out we had it, a few seconds later it was on the phone, and wife-unit got to listen to her song again with minimal effort on my part.

The box will be happily running for another few years, but I think MS did a shit job of marketing the potential that this product brought to the table. Can't say I'm surprised that they killed it, but someone will eventually pick up on the idea and do it right.
 
most of what home server and small business server did, is covered in the upcoming windows server 2012 essentials.

But at 8 times the price. The most I ever saw WHS 2011 for was $50. Server 2012 Essentials is $400+ dollars. Few people will value a home server that costs that much, never the less JUST the operating system. Though if Microsoft plays their cards right, this really could end up as a well executed reorganization of their server products.

Now as it's been said already, Windows 8 is set to inherit a lot of feature from WHS. Primarily the media storing and sharing functionality that the basic home users are looking for. So things aren't really changing for them, they'll just be using the same OS on their Server as their desktop as their tablet. GREAT.

The big change comes to Prosumers/SOHOs/Small businesses. Now I work for a Managed Services IT company, primarily supporting small and medium businesses. Most of these businesses are using some variety of Windows SBS. I love SBS as do my customers. It's extremely easy to setup and manage, and in a lot of ways it's nearly identical to WHS.

Having used SBS and WHS, I'm left wanting more from my WHS server. I'd LOVE the opportunity to have a domain in my home and the power to manage one as such. But again, I OUTRIGHT REFUSE to pay $750+ for such a product. I realize that I'm losing Exchange and Sharepoint Foundations, but at nearly half the price of SBS, I'm coming closer to stomaching it. Not to mention you can always reinstall Sharepoint Foundations, and no one really NEEDS Exchange at home. I'm happy using GMail or if I really need it, I can pay for Office 365 and use the included domain connector.

So in the end, I'm pretty excited about what this could bring around for myself, other prosumers, and potentially a lot of home users.

Microsoft Flyer said:
such as support for DLNA-compliant devices and media streaming, into Windows Server 2012 Essentials and focusing our efforts into making Windows Server 2012 Essentials the ideal first server operating system for both small business and home use

Q: Will Windows Server 2012 Essentials work with all editions of Windows 7 and Window 8 client software?
A: Yes, you can access Windows Server 2012 Essentials with all versions of Windows 7 and Windows 8. For editions such as Home, which does not have domain join capability, the Launchpad and other attempts to access the network will prompt for a user name and password (whereas this does not happen in Professional and higher editions).

Microsoft Flyer

NOTE: This thread is about WHS.I understand the impact of losing Exchange on SBS, but that's for another thread.
 
i love my whs2011 box. it really is a nice piece of software. what i like best is the way you can setup a website to access your local network remotely. being able to rdp to any pc on my network and access all my files from anywhere is really nice.
 
I've owned both WHS v1 and v2, love them both. Currently have WHS 2011 on a HP N40L with 8TB about of storage for media and backups. Also have a small Acer server at my office with WHS v1 that keeps daily backups of all my PCs there as well which has saved me on multiple occasions.
 
it was nice. but really not worth it for MS.. you want to run a server at home, then get a solid OS either windows or linux.
 
Some of you have obviously never heard of TechNet. Run SBS to your heart's content for 150 bucks
 
Who didn't see this coming.

With the exception of Windows and Office, you can't trust this company to stand behind you for the long haul, particularly in hardware.

Windows 8 is looking a little shaky too.
 
WHS Backup is unique in that it provides bare-metal restorations and single-instance store. That is why I've been using it for years, and until something else comes along with at least those features, I will continue to use it.

The bare-metal restore has saved my ass quite a few times.


People rarely back up at all, so a backup server that could hold multiple hard drives was always a pipe dream. Plus, with online could backup and a decent Internet connection, most of the problem is solved. I used WHSv1 and 2012 for over 2 years but got rid of them when I decided to consolidate storage and recording TV into one box. Much simpler that way.

The premise of WHS good, but the cloud is easier. Doesn't matter what your upload speed is to access files and you don't need to be at home to access them. Plus, its available everywhere.
 
Meh, I doubt it will have a big impact. People don't need in home servers and only a few people will make up reasons to want them. Home servers are the goo-gaw-baubles of a small community of nerds who had to invent reasons to buy them in the first place.

Says the guy that doesn't even use one...
 
Meh, I doubt it will have a big impact. People don't need in home servers and only a few people will make up reasons to want them. Home servers are the goo-gaw-baubles of a small community of nerds who had to invent reasons to buy them in the first place.

uh huh, it's so pointless to have background system backups seemlessly running for my 3 teenagers....:rolleyes:
 
uh huh, it's so pointless to have background system backups seemlessly running for my 3 teenagers....:rolleyes:

You already quoted me, but just to be obtuse and silly, I said that people don't need them and will create reasons to want them. You did create a reason (3 reasons, in fact) to want it and found a way to justify using one. *shrug* So what?
 
for me, WHS died when they took out drive pooling... man it was awesome to have one giant lump of storage along with folder duplication.... it was so easy to manage and didn't require me to learn anything new
 
Back
Top