Windows 9: Microsoft Faces Four Daunting Challenges

You don't have to run modern apps, desktop multitasking on 8.1 is essentially the same as 7 and modern apps can also be split on a screen with up to four modern apps depending on screen resolution including splitting the desktop.

Start Screen is essentially a modern app. It takes you off the standard desktop and into a full screen start menu. You've even mentioned this in that past as being a downside. Desktop usage is the same, but launching applications via the Start button is different. And it can be jarring for many people. Those same people may not want to minimize multiple windows to get to the desktop to click on shortcuts. And, they don't want a row of quick launch icons on their taskbar...
 
Start Screen is essentially a modern app. It takes you off the standard desktop and into a full screen start menu. You've even mentioned this in that past as being a downside. Desktop usage is the same, but launching applications via the Start button is different. And it can be jarring for many people. Those same people may not want to minimize multiple windows to get to the desktop to click on shortcuts. And, they don't want a row of quick launch icons on their taskbar...

But you can't really multitask with either the Start Menu. Yes, you can see other parts of the screen but once you leave the Start Menu it goes away. One advantage of the Start Screen with multiple monitors is that the Start Screen will persist, you can have the Start Screen on one monitor and anything else on other monitors.

I understand that the full screen nature of the modern UI can be problematic for some. I just don't think that functionally it's the impediment that some think that it is for multitasking.
 
I understand that the full screen nature of the modern UI can be problematic for some. I just don't think that functionally it's the impediment that some think that it is for multitasking.

It can be in certain use cases. I know it causes problems with me at times, and I like the start screen. With the start menu, my focus is off the main application while I'm looking at the start menu, but those background applications are still in peripheral vision. With start screen - they are gone. Unless you use multiple monitors, which I like (except on my Helix screen... too small!).

Single monitor with a non-maximized video, for example. Yes, you aren't looking directly at it with the start menu, either, but it's still there. It's an odd thing, and shouldn't matter, but it does. It's not the main focus, but it's better if it's still visible. If the workaround is for people to add shortcuts to the desktop or quick launch, then the start screen isn't needed or wanted. That option for the start menu (some form of it, anyway - non full screen) needs to come back and remain.

I think it comes down to less of a functionality thing for multitasking and more of a psychological.thing. When you click the full screen start screen, you're being detached from your work. When it jumps back, you're back to where you were, but your brain has to redefine your work area and where things are located again. Could take 1/4 second, but it's there.
 
Makes me wonder if DirectX12 will become some sort of a mandatory tie-in which gives people zero choice on the matter of getting windows 9.

I'm sure MS will paywall DX12 and prove they've learned nothing. As for zero choice, Steam Machines and SteamOS will have launched before Win9 or DX12 and they'll be a choice, and based on OpenGL which means no ultimatums to get the latest/greatest renderer.
 
One advantage of the Start Screen with multiple monitors is that the Start Screen will persist, you can have the Start Screen on one monitor and anything else on other monitors.

Who cares? Irrelevant, since most Windows desktop users and 99% of laptop users don't have multiple monitors. If they can't build an OS to work well on a single monitor without headaches, they failed. Not sure why you're still trying to argue the same old nonsense when even Microsoft has long conceded they screwed the pooch.

The war is over, the leader was executed, go home.
 
I'm sure MS will paywall DX12 and prove they've learned nothing. As for zero choice, Steam Machines and SteamOS will have launched before Win9 or DX12 and they'll be a choice, and based on OpenGL which means no ultimatums to get the latest/greatest renderer.

Sure steam Machines give choice, if you want nothing but a shitty wannabe PC to hook up to a TV :rolleyes:
 
I think it comes down to less of a functionality thing for multitasking and more of a psychological.thing. When you click the full screen start screen, you're being detached from your work. When it jumps back, you're back to where you were, but your brain has to redefine your work area and where things are located again. Could take 1/4 second, but it's there.

I agree that for some these kinds of things exist but I do think it gets overstated. There have been many studies about human cognition and there is a very small number of things that the average people can focus on simultaneously. Even the Start Menu will take the average persons attention away from what they were doing and then they have to go back to where they were. And one big difference is that the Start Screen can display a great deal of information if one uses modern apps, that inherently is distracts one away from what there are doing by design.
 
I've made my point very clear, as has most of the world.
MS didnt make it clear what Windows 8 would be, otherwise it would have got the same glowing reviews as the pre release versions.
 
Who cares? Irrelevant, since most Windows desktop users and 99% of laptop users don't have multiple monitors. If they can't build an OS to work well on a single monitor without headaches, they failed. Not sure why you're still trying to argue the same old nonsense when even Microsoft has long conceded they screwed the pooch.

Some people have made either made more out the issues of Windows 8 or inaccurately describe what's there. Plus much is made of enhancing desktop productivity. Multiple monitors are part of enhancing desktop productivity, just as like many look at virtual desktops doing so. Virtual desktops are rumored to be in the Threshold release but I imagine a very small percentage of people will ever use the feature.

The war is over, the leader was executed, go home.

The desktop war was over long ago. Whatever issues Windows 8 has, no other non-Windows desktop OS has been able to capitalize on it in any significant way. The biggest winner from the Windows 8 era was Windows 7.
 
I've made my point very clear, as has most of the world.
MS didnt make it clear what Windows 8 would be, otherwise it would have got the same glowing reviews as the pre release versions.

This just doesn't make any sense. The preview versions really didn't get glowing reviews from what I remember and the Start Menu from day one was not going to be in the RTM release, that was made perfectly clear from the beginning.
 
If you read what I wrote you would see you that isnt what I said.
You cant change what I experienced in the pre release "versions", nor my opinion of the final release, nor the opinions of most of the world.
Even MS admitted they screwed up.

I'm going to stop here because there is no debating with you, its pointless arguments.
Have fun :p
 
And one big difference is that the Start Screen can display a great deal of information if one uses modern apps, that inherently is distracts one away from what there are doing by design.

Yes, if you use modern apps with live tiles, the start screen is nice. But, you're still using it as a notification style screen. Once you click on something, those notifications are hidden again. On the phone, it's GREAT. A quick glance for any updates, missed messages, etc.. On a desktop PC, you're usually too busy working on stuff to go check... I just don't think the Start Screen on the desktop is optimal for the way it's used. Tablets/phone - yes, easily. Desktop, there is some work to be done.
 
If you read what I wrote you would see you that isnt what I said.
You cant change what I experienced in the pre release "versions", nor my opinion of the final release, nor the opinions of most of the world.
Even MS admitted they screwed up.

I'm going to stop here because there is no debating with you, its pointless arguments.
Have fun :p

All am saying is what was different between the first public beta of Windows 8 and the RTM? The Start Menu, which had already been announced as going away and Aero transparency are the only two major things that I can think of.
 
Yes, if you use modern apps with live tiles, the start screen is nice. But, you're still using it as a notification style screen. Once you click on something, those notifications are hidden again. On the phone, it's GREAT. A quick glance for any updates, missed messages, etc.. On a desktop PC, you're usually too busy working on stuff to go check... I just don't think the Start Screen on the desktop is optimal for the way it's used. Tablets/phone - yes, easily. Desktop, there is some work to be done.

Is it really any different compared to desktop gadgets? Those are hidden once an application is maximized or an app covers them up. With the Start Screen they are a key press away and many more can be put on the Start Screen without cluttering up the desktop.
 
I've made my point very clear, as has most of the world.
MS didnt make it clear what Windows 8 would be, otherwise it would have got the same glowing reviews as the pre release versions.

They made it very clear. From day 1, actually way before day 1 they made it clear. They stated Windows 8 would be the largest change to the Windows UI since Windows 95. It will be a complete overhaul of the way that you interact with your computer. This was from the moment they started talking about Windows 8 to the public. Nobody knew what they were changing but we all knew it was going to be big.

They then released the pre release versions and it was 100% the same as the version that we got at RTM. Nothing changed, no new features were added, nothing was removed. The pre release versions were feature complete. So any review you read / heard was based on EXACTLY what we got at release.
 
They made it very clear. From day 1, actually way before day 1 they made it clear.

Nobody knew what they were changing but we all knew it was going to be big.
Not quite clear then.

They then released the pre release versions and it was 100% the same as the version that we got at RTM. Nothing changed, no new features were added, nothing was removed. The pre release versions were feature complete. So any review you read / heard was based on EXACTLY what we got at release.
The final preview looked the same as the RTM.
All the positivity generated by prior versions was sucked out.
I know exactly what I saw and experienced, I was there :p
 
A tech preview is coming this year, and those usually precede the retail release date by a year.
 
The final preview looked the same as the RTM.
All the positivity generated by prior versions was sucked out.
I know exactly what I saw and experienced, I was there :p

You've not mentioned any specifics. Other than the Start Menu which was announced as going away from the beginning and Aero transparency, what else major changed from the first public betas and the RTM? And I don't recall the reviews as overall more glowing of the public betas and the RTM.
 
Who cares? Irrelevant, since most Windows desktop users and 99% of laptop users don't have multiple monitors. If they can't build an OS to work well on a single monitor without headaches, they failed.
Sorry, but as a power user, I REALLY don't care what the single-monitor scrubs have to say on the matter :p
 
You've not mentioned any specifics. Other than the Start Menu which was announced as going away from the beginning and Aero transparency, what else major changed from the first public betas and the RTM? And I don't recall the reviews as overall more glowing of the public betas and the RTM.

Both are those are specific concerns, are you trolling?
Also, the removal of the start menu made it necessary to use Charms, which prior to that were mostly ignored.
The final version looked worse and became annoying to use.
Hence the uproar and my dislike.
 
Both are those are specific concerns, are you trolling?
Also, the removal of the start menu made it necessary to use Charms, which prior to that were mostly ignored.
The final version looked worse and became annoying to use.
Hence the uproar and my dislike.

There were no major surprises and there was no bait and switch as the Start Menu had been announced as going away. As for the removal of the Start Menu making it necessary to use the Charms, that's doesn't really correlate. Most of the functions in the Charms were not in the Start Menu, except local search and but local file searches can be done via File Explorer.
 
It may have been known the start menu was going away, but we werent clear what "exactly" we were going to do instead of it.
Charms were already present but because they were so awkward, they were avoided.
It was hoped that MS had something decent up their sleeve to replace the start menu.
Sadly, our trust was misplaced.

The bait and switch was to get all the positive opinions of Windows 8 without the major changes in place, I really liked it then and was sold on it.
Right at the end they forced us to use charms which are awkward, and made Windows look ugly and archaic.
If you didnt try the preview before release, you could have made a mistake pre-ordering.
Luckily the storm of protest was loud enough for most people to notice.
 
Is it really any different compared to desktop gadgets? Those are hidden once an application is maximized or an app covers them up. With the Start Screen they are a key press away and many more can be put on the Start Screen without cluttering up the desktop.

Yes, it's different. Similar in functionality, but different. It's not a huge difference in the way things work, but it's a change in the way you do things. Not saying it's a good or bad thing (I'm sure you've heard all the bad stuff, anyway - so regardless of how you or I can show the benefits, it's considered bad by the general user). Even for users that are good at using the Start Screen and Windows 8, they have complaints about it. It's not an all-in-one interface. Neither is the Start Menu (tried that on touch devices - phones and tablets). But, one size does not fit all. There isn't one UI that can be the best on all devices (that's been released yet, anyway).
 
It may have been known the start menu was going away, but we werent clear what "exactly" we were going to do instead of it.
Charms were already present but because they were so awkward, they were avoided.
It was hoped that MS had something decent up their sleeve to replace the start menu.
Sadly, our trust was misplaced.

The bait and switch was to get all the positive opinions of Windows 8 without the major changes in place, I really liked it then and was sold on it.
Right at the end they forced us to use charms which are awkward, and made Windows look ugly and archaic.
If you didnt try the preview before release, you could have made a mistake pre-ordering.
Luckily the storm of protest was loud enough for most people to notice.

You keep saying that but we knew before the dev preview what was replacing it. The first preview we got our hands had on no start menu and instead had a start screen. If you thought something else was going to change that is your fault, not Microsoft. if you meet a 50 year old man on the internet, don't be pissed that he doesn't suddenly turn into a 25 year old female just because you thought he would.

There was no bait and switch. You were shown exactly what windows 8 was, you were given time to play with windows 8 just as it was. Charms were there all along from the start and were required. You knew exactly what you were getting if you bothered to look at it and not dream that everything was going to change. As for preorder, who preoders an OS? Anyone that jumps onto a new OS day one normally knows what they are getting into. People don't line up and order windows a year in advance with no idea what they are getting.
 
Yes, it's different. Similar in functionality, but different. It's not a huge difference in the way things work, but it's a change in the way you do things. Not saying it's a good or bad thing (I'm sure you've heard all the bad stuff, anyway - so regardless of how you or I can show the benefits, it's considered bad by the general user). Even for users that are good at using the Start Screen and Windows 8, they have complaints about it. It's not an all-in-one interface. Neither is the Start Menu (tried that on touch devices - phones and tablets). But, one size does not fit all. There isn't one UI that can be the best on all devices (that's been released yet, anyway).

There's no reason why one launcher can't work perfectly fine across devices if it's configurable enough. Most of the debate isn't so much around functionality or productivity but around familiarity. Obviously some think that the Start Menu is critical to Windows, others not so much. One start system that incorporates features of the Start Menu and Start Screen with the ability to configure elements to allow a user to setup what works for them looks to be where this is headed and should work well for most.
 
You keep saying that but we knew before the dev preview what was replacing it. The first preview we got our hands had on no start menu and instead had a start screen. If you thought something else was going to change that is your fault, not Microsoft. if you meet a 50 year old man on the internet, don't be pissed that he doesn't suddenly turn into a 25 year old female just because you thought he would.

There was no bait and switch. You were shown exactly what windows 8 was, you were given time to play with windows 8 just as it was. Charms were there all along from the start and were required. You knew exactly what you were getting if you bothered to look at it and not dream that everything was going to change. As for preorder, who preoders an OS? Anyone that jumps onto a new OS day one normally knows what they are getting into. People don't line up and order windows a year in advance with no idea what they are getting.

I just don't know what he's looking at to come to the statements he's making. Microsoft had a long series of blogs entitled "Building Windows 8" that clearly explained what was going on with the Start Screen and that it would be replacing the Start Menu back in the fall of 2011:

http://blogs.msdn.com/b/b8/archive/2011/10/03/evolving-the-start-menu.aspx
http://blogs.msdn.com/b/b8/archive/2011/10/04/designing-the-start-screen.aspx
http://blogs.msdn.com/b/b8/archive/2011/10/11/reflecting-on-your-comments-on-the-start-screen.aspx

There was absolutely NO baiting a switching here. Whether or not you liked what was going on it was explained and debated online vigorously for almost a year before the RTM.
 
lol @ same old defenses of the failed tablet OS as a desktop OS experiment. Sinofsky is gone, Ballmer is gone and the biggest promises MS makes for Windows 9 is to undo the mistakes in Windows 8.

The consumers market, a shrinking segment below 20%, didn't seem to mind, but >80% of the market totally, completely rejected that mess of an OS called Windows 8 (and 8.1 and 8.1 SR1) because it's just plain terrible for productivity users.
 
lol @ same old defenses of the failed tablet OS as a desktop OS experiment. Sinofsky is gone, Ballmer is gone and the biggest promises MS makes for Windows 9 is to undo the mistakes in Windows 8.

Except the point being made here wasn't a defense of Windows 8 but pointing out, for better or for worse, that it was perfectly clear well before the RTM of Windows 8 that the Start Screen was replacing the Start Menu, even on desktops. There was no question about that, so the idea that there was some sort of "bait and switch" during the public betas simply belies the well document history of it all.

And what's so horrible about fixing what a lot of people don't like?

The consumers market, a shrinking segment below 20%, didn't seem to mind, but >80% of the market totally, completely rejected that mess of an OS called Windows 8 (and 8.1 and 8.1 SR1) because it's just plain terrible for productivity users.

And as terrible for productivity users as many claim 8.1 to be, most of this steams from just one subject area, the Start Screen versus the Start Menu. Whatever the issues are for some with using the Start Screen on a desktop, the subject has been overblown. Not much productive work is done in either the Start Screen or Start Menu. This isn't a defense of Windows 8, just a simple reality check. It mostly boils down to familiarity and that's where Microsoft made it's biggest mistakes with 8, thinking that people would just pick it up and clearly that didn't work out that way for far too many people.
 
You keep saying that but we knew before the dev preview what was replacing it. The first preview we got our hands had on no start menu and instead had a start screen. If you thought something else was going to change that is your fault, not Microsoft.

Bullshit. In that dev preview there was still a regkey that let you enable the real Start Menu and bypass/suppress Metro. Most people had a reasonable assumption at that point that the Start Menu would therefore still be an option even if just for power users.

Of course once people got wind of the tweak and it made the news rounds and everyone started re-enabling the start menu, Sinofsky ordered it removed immediately. And in a fitting twist of irony, when Windows 8 launched it was Sinofsky that was ordered removed immediately.
 
Bullshit. In that dev preview there was still a regkey that let you enable the real Start Menu and bypass/suppress Metro. Most people had a reasonable assumption at that point that the Start Menu would therefore still be an option even if just for power users.

Of course once people got wind of the tweak and it made the news rounds and everyone started re-enabling the start menu, Sinofsky ordered it removed immediately. And in a fitting twist of irony, when Windows 8 launched it was Sinofsky that was ordered removed immediately.

So a piece of code from a previous version of windows was still hiding in there so that was a reasonable reason to believe they would add it back in even though they said it wasn't going to be there?

I recall in windows 9x (2000 also I think) you could find the old windows 3.1 program manager hiding on your system and replace the normal windows UI with the old 3.1 UI. Is that reason enough to think that they were going drop the start menu an go back to the old program manager back then?

All anyone did was fine a piece of code left over from the jump from 7 to 8. Once found Microsoft removed it to keep people from using it since it was never intended in the first place. However there was still always whatever tools that you guys use to add that worthless start menu back into your system.
 
Back
Top