Windows 8 Touch PC Demand Strong

I'll never understand where this stuff comes from. Why would anyone constantly hold their arms out to touch a vertically mounted display? There's really no point in that position and why there's still a keyboard and mouse. Now it might be useful to tap the screen to hit a button, maybe pinch zoom in on something. or lay the display down for drawing or inking on a larger surface.

It comes from a company that makes interfaces and interactive displays (it's their profession) based on their testing of real life usability of "Minority Report" style user interfaces.
 
I'll never understand where this stuff comes from. Why would anyone constantly hold their arms out to touch a vertically mounted display? There's really no point in that position and why there's still a keyboard and mouse. Now it might be useful to tap the screen to hit a button, maybe pinch zoom in on something. or lay the display down for drawing or inking on a larger surface.

Windows 8 is hybrid OS, use a mouse and keyboard if you want or need, you touch and pen if you want or need. The idea is to be able to switch between these different forms of input where they are appropriate.

I don't know, vertically mounted touch screens aren't too bad to use. I mean the Smart Board hardware is pretty popular at my workplace and while it's not a touch screen, it's the same concept. Although Windows XP and Windows 7 weren't made for it.
 
Windows 8 is not a hybrid OS, it's a flip-flop OS. :p Ubuntu is an example of a hybrid OS, with seamless multi-touch and web application integration - no separate UI mish-mashing or anything. It's been like this since 2010 or earlier I believe.

You call this seamless touch? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3HHEquvh7KI

This is just a touch enabled desktop which was in Windows 7 three years ago. I've looked around at Ubuntu in the past as something to try out on my tablets but it has exactly the same kinds of flaws as any desktop and keyboard and mouse centric OS would have.

Sure you can touch enable elements of an OS, but you're still working with the same keyboard and mouse centric programs, that's where the big problem is touch enabling a desktop and a reason why Windows on tablets hasn't been successful in the past. You need touch optimized apps.
 
You call this seamless touch? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3HHEquvh7KI

This is just a touch enabled desktop which was in Windows 7 three years ago. I've looked around at Ubuntu in the past as something to try out on my tablets but it has exactly the same kinds of flaws as any desktop and keyboard and mouse centric OS would have.

Sure you can touch enable elements of an OS, but you're still working with the same keyboard and mouse centric programs, that's where the big problem is touch enabling a desktop and a reason why Windows on tablets hasn't been successful in the past. You need touch optimized apps.

Bahhh I really don't feel like explaining the philosophy behind Unity, but I'll bite.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nn3m09zkcbo

On x86 based touch/hybrid devices I don't see how it isn't, and you can't compare Aero and Unity as they're entirely different DEs with huge distinctions in windows management. Having touch optimized applications does aid in touch usability - you're right about that, but it's also in Window management implementation. Since Ubuntu Unity was developed to span across multiple platforms (TVs, Phones, Tablets, Desktops/Laptops), it'll seem less conventional, but that's the hybrid nature of Unity - it's a master of none. All the necessary touch functionality is there for it's designated platform without compromising UI elements and structure for other platforms. So no confusing mish-mashing, etc. The options are there.

The person didn't even utilize multi touch gestures, the short cut gestures, the HUD, and the dock itself for closing applications. Instead of struggling with the log-out manager in the top right, he could've just invoked HUD and typed "shut" or "sh" giving him a list of intentional tasks (including "shut down").

There's a good reason why Ubuntu decided to go way with embedding window context menu options and buttons within a separate panel at top when maximizing a window, as it gives a "one application at a time" experience as seen with conventional table OSs. Also, with virtual desktops this helps with the experience as well. Or why the damn icons in the dash are so fucking fat (which is stupid, imo), it improves touch discover-ability. Gnome 3 shell also has the same implementation. If you want to switch applications, the dock is there. For other tasks that involves using menu options there's the HUD, it just takes some to learn. You should really look into the HUD, it's an awesome feature that highlights Unity. The damn thing literally guesses your intention for anything based on character selection or phrases.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8Vwt11GMc3g Albeit It's on a laptop, but just watch what he does.


Honestly, if you've read into canonicals road-map and try to understand their philosophy with Unity for multi-platform adoption, it makes perfect sense. They've already ported Unity onto the TV (Ubuntu TV), tablet's are next (Ubuntu on Nexus 7), although it's still in development with a huge amount of bugs - it'll get better in time hopefully with Ubuntu 13.04. On desktop/laptops, it already works well so I won't get into that. If you're truly interested, I'd look more into it. :) Keep it mind Ubuntu is still being optimized for mobile devices, so things could change although the concept already works.

But anyways, I still don't like Unity for my own personal reasons... so meh. Some features are quite interesting though.
 
These just don't work in real life. I know from a company that made a whole thing to do exactly this. The users arms would get tired very quickly, even on fitter individuals. Try holding your arms out for an hour or two, it gets difficult after a while, and makes a barried to usage. Which doesn't exactly make it an easier way of doing things. What's left, nothing really, so there's no point doing it. :D

Perhaps I wasn't clear. Gestures, to augment keyboard/mouse. Not replace.

I'm not going to sit at my desk with my hands out Emperor Palpatine style--but if I want to, say, move a window from one screen to another--swish! Also, I'm not constantly inputting anything into my computer unless it's typing. So this idea that such an interface would wear anyone out--I don't get it.

I think we may be discussing two different things.
 
I've mentioned this before, but I think it bears repeating: HUD is the best thing to happen to Linux since the inclusion of repositories and intertwining with software centers.

HUD is magical. It isn't perfect - far from it, actually. But the concept is extremely solid and it allows a whole new way of interacting with applications and your computer that can be much easier and seamless. Eg.: don't want to search through a billion dropdown tabs in a large and complex application for a specific option? Don't know what the keyboard shortcut is? Hit alt and type in what you're looking for.

It's like a flippin' Google search for flippin' everything.
 
Bahhh I really don't feel like explaining the philosophy behind Unity, but I'll bite.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nn3m09zkcbo

On x86 based touch/hybrid devices I don't see how it isn't, and you can't compare Aero and Unity as they're entirely different DEs with huge distinctions in windows management. Having touch optimized applications does aid in touch usability - you're right about that, but it's also in Window management implementation. Since Ubuntu Unity was developed to span across multiple platforms (TVs, Phones, Tablets, Desktops/Laptops), it'll seem less conventional, but that's the hybrid nature of Unity - it's a master of none. All the necessary touch functionality is there for it's designated platform without compromising UI elements and structure for other platforms. So no confusing mish-mashing, etc. The options are there.

The person didn't even utilize multi touch gestures, the short cut gestures, the HUD, and the dock itself for closing applications. Instead of struggling with the log-out manager in the top right, he could've just invoked HUD and typed "shut" or "sh" giving him a list of intentional tasks (including "shut down").

There's a good reason why Ubuntu decided to go way with embedding window context menu options and buttons within a separate panel at top when maximizing a window, as it gives a "one application at a time" experience as seen with conventional table OSs. Also, with virtual desktops this helps with the experience as well. Or why the damn icons in the dash are so fucking fat (which is stupid, imo), it improves touch discover-ability. Gnome 3 shell also has the same implementation. If you want to switch applications, the dock is there. For other tasks that involves using menu options there's the HUD, it just takes some to learn. You should really look into the HUD, it's an awesome feature that highlights Unity. The damn thing literally guesses your intention for anything based on character selection or phrases.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8Vwt11GMc3g Albeit It's on a laptop, but just watch what he does.


Honestly, if you've read into canonicals road-map and try to understand their philosophy with Unity for multi-platform adoption, it makes perfect sense. They've already ported Unity onto the TV (Ubuntu TV), tablet's are next (Ubuntu on Nexus 7), although it's still in development with a huge amount of bugs - it'll get better in time hopefully with Ubuntu 13.04. On desktop/laptops, it already works well so I won't get into that. If you're truly interested, I'd look more into it. :) Keep it mind Ubuntu is still being optimized for mobile devices, so things could change although the concept already works.

But anyways, I still don't like Unity for my own personal reasons... so meh. Some features are quite interesting though.

I've played with Unity before on tablets but has been about year since I last tried it. I'm not saying that it's a bad thing but what it really is at this point is a touch enabled desktop, not a true touch optimized UI with touch apps. It's cool to have all of the touch gestures for window management but the bulk of people's time on a device isn't that, it's using applications and those are still desktop apps. Windows 7 added a good deal of touch ability to the desktop, muti-touch APIs, the task bar, Aero management features and better touch targeting but the problem real problem was tough capable apps.
 
I've played with Unity before on tablets but has been about year since I last tried it. I'm not saying that it's a bad thing but what it really is at this point is a touch enabled desktop, not a true touch optimized UI with touch apps. It's cool to have all of the touch gestures for window management but the bulk of people's time on a device isn't that, it's using applications and those are still desktop apps. Windows 7 added a good deal of touch ability to the desktop, muti-touch APIs, the task bar, Aero management features and better touch targeting but the problem real problem was tough capable apps.

Again, non-comparable. But anyways, I understand. I doubt it'll take on iOS and Android but my point is just that it is a hybrid OS that works well across multiple form factors so far, and it's concept is solid. For what it is and the cloud service it comes with, it's pretty consistent.
 
I was gonna say, "Why isn't heatlesssun posting in this thread yet?" but then I read the second page and saw the "discussion" about how you all are going to have scrambled eggs and like it that way has started. :p
 
Again, non-comparable. But anyways, I understand. I doubt it'll take on iOS and Android but my point is just that it is a hybrid OS that works well across multiple form factors so far, and it's concept is solid. For what it is and the cloud service it comes with, it's pretty consistent.

I don't think it's any more solid than Windows 8's approach (at least not in the typical consumer tablet market) and I just don't see how Unity at this point is a hybrid as it is still a desktop first and only UI with touch added where Windows 8 is a combination of distinct UIs side-by-side. I'm simply saying where's the other part of Unity if it is a hybrid.

There's many things that can be improved in Windows 8 but the foundation of it is much stronger than I think many realize. You can run the same desktop apps as always with Windows and they work just like always. And one can run completely touch optimized apps with no windows or desktop elements. However there are loose ends that need to be improved to get the two elements to work better side-by-side. I do think more desktop touch enablement on the desktop is needed and more desktop like features like multi-monitor support need to be added to Metro.
 
If the kinect used on a PC has the same problems it does on the Xbox 360, it's really not worth it.
Kinect is actually a little beefier on PCs. One crippling attribute with the Xbox is that there's usually so little CPU to spare that driving the Kinect is a constant struggle. PCs tend to have a greater ability to brute force their way through that processing. As a result, Kinect for Windows is lower-latency/higher-precision.
 
The damn thing literally guesses your intention for anything based on character selection or phrases.

Yah! Something I'd turn off, cause everything I've ever used, guesses wrong 100% of the time.

HUD is magical. It isn't perfect - far from it, actually. But the concept is extremely solid and it allows a whole new way of interacting with applications and your computer that can be much easier and seamless. Eg.: don't want to search through a billion dropdown tabs in a large and complex application for a specific option? Don't know what the keyboard shortcut is? Hit alt and type in what you're looking for.

It's like a flippin' Google search for flippin' everything.

It's called F1 in Windows. It brings up Help. Been there for a long time.
 
I have Amazon and Acer on notice about my 27" IPS touchscreen.

If they cancel my order I am suing all the OEMs and their suppliers for collusion - they already told me they can't fulfill my order by Xmas :mad:

Oh and since the OS crew is here, my latest opinions:
Windows 8 > OS X > Windows 7 > Ubuntu > Windows RT > iOS > Android

:cool:
 
It's called F1 in Windows. It brings up Help. Been there for a long time.

Not even close. Nowhere near the same functionality nor does it serve the same purpose.

In browser with HUD: Alt + Ja = Java console launched

In Windows browser: F1, search Java = get nothing.

If you don't know where to look for the Java console or you don't know the hotkey you have the option of launching it via HUD. On Windows you'd have to Google it to get your answer or browse through the tabs at the top. Granted, not exactly a difficult task, but you can picture just how much more difficult this becomes in a program with a whole lot of options and tabs, like GIMP or CAD software. That tiny issue can become exacerbated quickly by the complexity of what you're dealing with.

It's not perfect, though. They need to make it more aware of certain applications and the applications' respective options, as well as block out the pointer from influencing the selections unless it's moved. For example, when I type "sh" the first option is "shut down" but I may be going for "Show full history," and if the mouse is on top of the first bar it'll slightly interfere with the selection. I've shut down my PC rather by mistake more than once :p
 
Not even close. Nowhere near the same functionality nor does it serve the same purpose.

In browser with HUD: Alt + Ja = Java console launched

In Windows browser: F1, search Java = get nothing.

If you don't know where to look for the Java console or you don't know the hotkey you have the option of launching it via HUD. On Windows you'd have to Google it to get your answer or browse through the tabs at the top. Granted, not exactly a difficult task, but you can picture just how much more difficult this becomes in a program with a whole lot of options and tabs, like GIMP or CAD software. That tiny issue can become exacerbated quickly by the complexity of what you're dealing with.

It's not perfect, though. They need to make it more aware of certain applications and the applications' respective options, as well as block out the pointer from influencing the selections unless it's moved. For example, when I type "sh" the first option is "shut down" but I may be going for "Show full history," and if the mouse is on top of the first bar it'll slightly interfere with the selection. I've shut down my PC rather by mistake more than once :p

Type in Java in the Windows search and it brings you to... Java Control Panel.
 
Type in Java in the Windows search and it brings you to... Java Control Panel.

Nono, the F1 help thingie has no functionality within programs but rather pertains to outside of programs. I can launch bookmarks, history, java console within firefox/chromium but if you want to get to the javascript console within the browser in Windows you need to open it via hotkey or clickages.

That's no biggie when the software you're dealing with has limited options and an easy interface, but as soon as its complex and you don't know where to look or the exact name of what you're looking for, you're screwed.

HUD: ALT + so = view source within Chromium
 
Nono, the F1 help thingie has no functionality within programs but rather pertains to outside of programs. I can launch bookmarks, history, java console within firefox/chromium but if you want to get to the javascript console within the browser in Windows you need to open it via hotkey or clickages.

That's no biggie when the software you're dealing with has limited options and an easy interface, but as soon as its complex and you don't know where to look or the exact name of what you're looking for, you're screwed.

HUD: ALT + so = view source within Chromium

I see.
 
Again, non-comparable. But anyways, I understand. I doubt it'll take on iOS and Android but my point is just that it is a hybrid OS that works well across multiple form factors so far, and it's concept is solid. For what it is and the cloud service it comes with, it's pretty consistent.

First, understand this comes from a long time Linux Debian/Ubuntu user. It is currently my main system at home and I love Ubuntu for many reasons. But what you are suggesting here is not one of them.

I have read through this thread and a lot of your misinformation. Unity is NOT a true Hybrid OS. It gives you a variety of options, but a true hybrid OS would have touch enabled applications that interact with or derive their touch commands from the OS. Ubuntu Unity does NOT do this. Also, it is NOT working on multiple platforms. You keep mentioning that, but it lags far behind Microsoft in this area. Microsoft has had their touch enabled solutions working on multiple devices for a long long time. The new Windows Phone is a perfect example how Microsoft truly researches UI and touch interfaces and brings out the best. It is truly a phenomenal device. Its only failing is not being as open as Android. Also the Ubuntu Unity concept is FAR, FAR from solid. Many people, including myself, have severe reservations about it. They have taken some things away in order to provide their new interface. Their HUD launch capability is not very refined. Also you can do similar things in Windows from the command prompt, from the new search bar, get links through the help menu, through voice options, etc. None of these solutions are perfect, and none of them make a real hybrid OS. They simply provide the same OS functionality with some enhanced UI controls.

Now, Windows 8 was a huge step in unifying the multiple platforms, far more so than Unity. Windows 8 is designed with touch enabled apps, window placement, etc in mind for tablets and phones. Ubuntu has yet to truly deliver on anything substantial for those markets.
 
I don't get why you'd want dual video cams on a laptop. If you turn your laptop around, the distant end will see you, but can't see them.
Not on opposite sides, on the same side of the laptop, as I said, so they can use kinect like features. Kinect uses two cameras for stereo vision.

For one, its a very secure passive password protection. Kinect at that distance can very accurately 3D map your face. Then all you have to do is open the screen, it recognizes you, and you're in. To fool it, you would need to produce a reasonably accurate clay model of someone's head.

Kinect can be fun for games, or just added gesture support.

Mainly though, software costs nothing to redistribute really since Microsoft already owns it, and those webcams on laptops are dirt cheap.
 
Nono, the F1 help thingie has no functionality within programs but rather pertains to outside of programs. I can launch bookmarks, history, java console within firefox/chromium but if you want to get to the javascript console within the browser in Windows you need to open it via hotkey or clickages.

That's no biggie when the software you're dealing with has limited options and an easy interface, but as soon as its complex and you don't know where to look or the exact name of what you're looking for, you're screwed.

HUD: ALT + so = view source within Chromium

F1 works on all programs, but only pertains to the program that you were in, when you hit F1. If you want to search for programs, outside of your current working program, you just do a Start Menu and type whatever into search.

If you want to look the source code in IE in Windows, it's right-click, view source. Been like that for the past like 4 IE versions, if not more. There's also F12 for something more complex. There's also F1 and search.
 
Not on opposite sides, on the same side of the laptop, as I said, so they can use kinect like features. Kinect uses two cameras for stereo vision.

For one, its a very secure passive password protection. Kinect at that distance can very accurately 3D map your face. Then all you have to do is open the screen, it recognizes you, and you're in. To fool it, you would need to produce a reasonably accurate clay model of someone's head.

Kinect can be fun for games, or just added gesture support.

Mainly though, software costs nothing to redistribute really since Microsoft already owns it, and those webcams on laptops are dirt cheap.

Okay, that makes a lot more sense. Although face recognition is already available. Although, I'm sure a simple picture of that other person's face is enough to login.
 
Back
Top