Windows 8 Release Preview Review

I also believe that they should allow users to easily revert to the original start menu since a lot of you seem to hate it.

Windows 8 may be a flop but the point of Windows 8 is to make touch core to the OS. I think putting in switch that disables perhaps the most critical part of the touch design based on anonymous feedback from people that mostly have never used touch or any of the new Windows 8 hardware when the vast majority of Windows 8 will come with this hardware doesn't serve much of a purpose at this time.

Maybe the outcry will be so hard to overcome that Microsoft may have to put a UI switch, in but then at that point Windows 8 was just a huge waste of time and nothing would have been accomplished. Putting in the switch now significantly reduces the chances of Metro and touch apps being written if developers have no confidence that their apps will be available on ALL Windows 8 and RT machines from desktops to tablets and everything in between.

The switch sounds good in theory but it would simply slow the progression of touch in Windows 8 which in that case Microsoft would have been better of leaving Metro out of Windows 8 and just have developed a separate touch OS.
 
The switch sounds good in theory but it would simply slow the progression of touch in Windows 8 which in that case Microsoft would have been better of leaving Metro out of Windows 8 and just have developed a separate touch OS.

This should have happened.
 
The dumbest decision in my opinion is making the way to get to metro with the mouse a hot corner. I have seen several videos of people sitting there relatives down and tell them to use it without helping them. They could have atleast left the start button and simply had it bring up the metro ui sort of like office 2010's menu button.
 
Look at all the money Apple is making with their offerings; everybody wants a piece of that marketing magic dough. The consumers have made Apple super duper rich and MS wants to get into catering to people's "eccentricity" too.

I am interested in Windows 8, and it is interesting how MS is pushing Metro, and what effect it will have. Maybe I can get for cheap as a student... and then hoard it and never use it. Next laptop will probably have it.

Personally, I don't think I would enjoy using a small screen, otherwise I would hook up a keyboard to a cell phone :)
 
The dumbest decision in my opinion is making the way to get to metro with the mouse a hot corner. I have seen several videos of people sitting there relatives down and tell them to use it without helping them. They could have atleast left the start button and simply had it bring up the metro ui sort of like office 2010's menu button.

^This. Even though I'm in the camp that likes the Metro UI (or am at worst indifferent to it when it doesn't work as intuitively as I think it should), the lack of a static Start button on the desktop screen where it's been since forever just seems asinine to me. I had a teenaged cousin over this past weekend and had him try out the release preview, and he was cool with the Start screen and live tiles and all, but when I ran over the couple of [stock] methods to get to it (via the physical Windows key and from the hot corner), his gut response was exactly, "What the-- why?? That sucks. This isn't going to sell." Yeah, it's just one off-the-cuff reaction from one guy, but enough such reactions and you can potentially get another Vista as far as public perception goes, something Microsoft seemingly just countered with 7.

As for myself, that is the one thing that still throws me off even though I've been exclusively using 8 on my primary since the developer preview. I'm cool with Metro (probably thanks to having used a Windows Phone for nearly a year now), I'm fine with not having a Start menu (since I can configure the Start screen to serve the same purpose for me anyway and then some), but the lack of a static Start button on the desktop still sometimes causes me to go, "Click St-- oh wait, it's not there anymore. Uhh... uhh... reach for the physical key or go for the hot corner. Hot corner's faster, so hot corner. Crap, overshot the hot corner. Uhh... physical key, then. Okay." Yeah, this lasts all but a second or so, and I can probably get over it eventually, but why must they remove such an iconic part of the OS?? :confused:
 
Windows 8 may be a flop but the point of Windows 8 is to make touch core to the OS. I think putting in switch that disables perhaps the most critical part of the touch design based on anonymous feedback from people that mostly have never used touch or any of the new Windows 8 hardware when the vast majority of Windows 8 will come with this hardware doesn't serve much of a purpose at this time.

Maybe the outcry will be so hard to overcome that Microsoft may have to put a UI switch, in but then at that point Windows 8 was just a huge waste of time and nothing would have been accomplished. Putting in the switch now significantly reduces the chances of Metro and touch apps being written if developers have no confidence that their apps will be available on ALL Windows 8 and RT machines from desktops to tablets and everything in between.

The switch sounds good in theory but it would simply slow the progression of touch in Windows 8 which in that case Microsoft would have been better of leaving Metro out of Windows 8 and just have developed a separate touch OS.

It's fine to want to move toward touch and all, but forcing it on people that don't have touch devices probably isn't the way to do it, you know? Make MetroUI the default but don't make it a giant hassle to make it look like Windows 7 for those people who do not have touch devices.

It honestly doesn't make any difference to me since the way I used the start menu was: Press windows button, start typing the name of the program/file I wanted. This is the way I've been launching programs since XP (using launchy), and I'm glad MS built this into Vista/7.

As for the hot corner, I actually much prefer this. Either you use the windows key or you flick your mouse very quickly to the bottom left to get to the start menu, I honestly don't see the difference here. You aren't changing your motion, you are just freeing up a tiny bit more real estate for something useful. I think it would be nice if you could change the justification of the icons in the taskbar now, though, such as having them be in the middle of it.

Once you know that it is how you access the Metro/State it's no different than it was before and no one should ever forget that. I will give you an example of this. The first time I used OSX I had no idea how to log off (it was on a school computer). That little logo up in the upper left? I had no idea it was an actual button until I googled how to log off (it seriously had no indications of being a button, it just looked like a logo). I haven't forgotten that since.
 
The purpose of this post is to present an observation and opinion. I am not pro any side, to declare up-front. Personally, I bought Office 2010, hoping to get a laptop this year, use Windows XP/Vista/7 at works, use stable-series Linux for long-term familiarity. Use Fedora to understand latest trends.

It is hope that this will help some

1. Generally, you have two scenario
1.1 You believe classic desktop should be an option, and you advocate and want Microsoft to present that option
1.2 You believe classic desktop should be an option. You argue for correctness, practicality, reasonable circumstances. However, you understand change is inevitable, hence from here you understand Life is a cycle. A lot of things are seasonal, you learn to engage and disengage, where sensible, with amicable cause, permissible.
1.2.1 Indirectly, you also understand sometimes common thought/logic/sense have other factors that will come in when circumstances is ripe and all elements converge. You learn to read the text books but analyze with real data.

2. Based on the scenario
2.1 Point 1.1 you want and you feel strongly about that option for Microsoft to provide. You have a "seek, and the dependance is created". You are not wrong, many valid views. However, since you "depend", based on principle, you are dependent. As a result, it is.
2.2 Generally, Microsoft tries to provide help as well. Microsoft needs your purchase, so there is a "seek, and dependence is created"
2.2.1 Desktop functions are still there, though the theme and presentation is modified.
2.2.2 Windows 7 will be supported until some time in year 2020. You can purchase one copy and wait till year 2020 to figure out your next option.
2.2.3 based on heatless, MS has presented reasonable package and path
2.2.4 Not sure petition will help based on heatless feedback on this forum. Worth a try.

2.3 As for Point 1.2
2.3.1 Because you eventually understand things come and go, the option is to suggest, but accept that either you stay with Windows 7, or else purchase a new copy if you feel strongly about having classic desktop for years to come.
2.3.2 Alternatively, if crowd belonging to point 1.1 succeeded in pursuing classic desktop revival, you obviously can enjoy it as well.

Cheers.
 
30 years ago plenty of people were questioning mice and saying that hindered productivity because most people only understood and used computers with keyboards. Most of Metro opponents haven't used touch on ANY version of Windows for any period of time.

Metro is a disruptive change that integrates touch into Windows well for the first time and people that haven't used touch or see no need for touch want to make it go away. Sure I get that, but I don't see the long term benefit in the growth of Windows holding onto a 20 year old UI and allowing the the main point of Windows 8 to disappear. Windows 8 is not about desktops and keyboards and mice OR tablets and touch and pens, it's about desktops and keyboards and mice AND tablets and touch and pens and in the future even other possibilities.

Always on Metro is not about force in the proper sense of the word, it's about a design philosophy that says it's not a keyboard and mouse only world anymore.
 
I'm excited for the speed increase, the new things to learn, and the fun of installing a new OS. Bring on Windows 8!!!
 
There's just a fact that a lot of people are going to hate Metro, no matter what Microsoft did to the UI there were going to be haters and to be fair lovers as well.

But boy there are some really nice machines showing up at Computex. Sure Metro and touch aren't revolutionary but this new hardware is stuff people haven't seen before and for the first time since Windows 95 Windows has a cool wow factor in that it is new gear that's touch enabled and runs apps that are much better looking than the standard battleship gray stuff of the last 20 years.
 
There's just a fact that a lot of people are going to hate Metro, no matter what Microsoft did to the UI there were going to be haters and to be fair lovers as well.

But boy there are some really nice machines showing up at Computex. Sure Metro and touch aren't revolutionary but this new hardware is stuff people haven't seen before and for the first time since Windows 95 Windows has a cool wow factor in that it is new gear that's touch enabled and runs apps that are much better looking than the standard battleship gray stuff of the last 20 years.

"fair lovers". Yes, because those of us who hate it aren't being "fair" right? There's a reason Apple didn't do this : It Sucks.
Stop being such a microsoft apologist because you're so in love with tablets.
 
"fair lovers". Yes, because those of us who hate it aren't being "fair" right? There's a reason Apple didn't do this : It Sucks.
Stop being such a microsoft apologist because you're so in love with tablets.

I think you're reading it wrong. I guess a comma between"fair" and "lovers" would have been the correct way to write it.

And really, Microsoft apologist? At least when I talk about Metro I actually have an I idea of what using Windows XP, Vista, 7 and 8 with these various form factors and input methods is actually like instead of just bashing something I've not tried.
 
And really, Microsoft apologist? At least when I talk about Metro I actually have an I idea of what using Windows XP, Vista, 7 and 8 with these various form factors and input methods is actually like instead of just bashing something I've not tried.

Because you keep a tablet on your desk for input? are you kidding me? Do you realize how absurd that is for normal people? Your world view is very slim because you consistently consider only yourself. Until we all have large touchscreens built into our desks, touch is useless at the desktop level.
 
30 years ago plenty of people were questioning mice and saying that hindered productivity because most people only understood and used computers with keyboards. Most of Metro opponents haven't used touch on ANY version of Windows for any period of time.

Metro is a disruptive change that integrates touch into Windows well for the first time and people that haven't used touch or see no need for touch want to make it go away. Sure I get that, but I don't see the long term benefit in the growth of Windows holding onto a 20 year old UI and allowing the the main point of Windows 8 to disappear. Windows 8 is not about desktops and keyboards and mice OR tablets and touch and pens, it's about desktops and keyboards and mice AND tablets and touch and pens and in the future even other possibilities.

Always on Metro is not about force in the proper sense of the word, it's about a design philosophy that says it's not a keyboard and mouse only world anymore.

I disagree completely. Windows 8 is about nothing more than touch devices and this absurd notion that they are going to replace a standard productivity machine. It is about force, design philosophy has nothing to do with it. MS knows that if they don't force it, then everyone will turn it off. So they are taking the gamble that people can't live without windows instead.

There's just a fact that a lot of people are going to hate Metro, no matter what Microsoft did to the UI there were going to be haters and to be fair lovers as well.

But boy there are some really nice machines showing up at Computex. Sure Metro and touch aren't revolutionary but this new hardware is stuff people haven't seen before and for the first time since Windows 95 Windows has a cool wow factor in that it is new gear that's touch enabled and runs apps that are much better looking than the standard battleship gray stuff of the last 20 years.

Hardware that all would of shown up without Win 8. I don't know where you get this absurd idea that Win 8 as new as it is spawned all that new hardware. Hardware like that takes years to develop and Win 8 hasn't been available to hardware developers for years. Android or iOS could have just as easily done everything being done. There has been absolutely nothing revolutionary so far.
 
Stupid lack of edit button. If you think that this is the first time Windows has had a "cool wow" factor, you clearly missed Vista and Win 7.
 
Because you keep a tablet on your desk for input? are you kidding me? Do you realize how absurd that is for normal people? Your world view is very slim because you consistently consider only yourself. Until we all have large touchscreens built into our desks, touch is useless at the desktop level.

Really? No one has an iPad on their desk? No will just pick on something like an iPad when they move away from their desk and take it to a meeting? And if you look at the hardware being announced at Computex, the hybrid and convertible designs can go from desktop connected to external monitors and keyboards to laptop to tablet instantly.

You keep thinking of tablets in the mobile OS context. Windows 8 tablets can work like any Windows machine has in the past and work as well as tablets.
 
I disagree completely. Windows 8 is about nothing more than touch devices and this absurd notion that they are going to replace a standard productivity machine. It is about force, design philosophy has nothing to do with it. MS knows that if they don't force it, then everyone will turn it off. So they are taking the gamble that people can't live without windows instead.

Sure a lot of people would turn it of, a lot of people wouldn't and the problem would be that there's no way to determine who could run Metro apps and who couldn't. A lot of people would turn it off but still want to run Metro apps then wonder why they couldn't. There's plenty of issues with a Metro off switch, it's not a simple and pain-free thing.

Hardware that all would of shown up without Win 8.

Unlikely.

Android or iOS could have just as easily done everything being done. There has been absolutely nothing revolutionary so far.

Yeah, like work with mice and keyboards and work with desktop productivity software. Oh wait, no they can't do that.

I never said this is revolutionary, but these convertible and hybrid certainly do things on the desktop side that iOS and Android can't.
 
Sure a lot of people would turn it of, a lot of people wouldn't and the problem would be that there's no way to determine who could run Metro apps and who couldn't. A lot of people would turn it off but still want to run Metro apps then wonder why they couldn't. There's plenty of issues with a Metro off switch, it's not a simple and pain-free thing.



Unlikely.



Yeah, like work with mice and keyboards and work with desktop productivity software. Oh wait, no they can't do that.

I never said this is revolutionary, but these convertible and hybrid certainly do things on the desktop side that iOS and Android can't.

Really? Ever heard of the Asus Transformer? The prime? you know those two convertible hybrid devices that came out long before Win 8..That oh by the way, work just fine with a USB mouse and keyboard on android. So what is it exactly that Win 8 can do that these cant? Oh it can run office..oh wait on a tablet it still can't do that either as it still requires a special version. Which it is inevitable that Android and iOS both get a version of their own from MS anyhow. So what is it exactly that Win 8 brings to the table that isn't already on the field? Not a whole lot when it comes to hardware. Don't get me wrong, Win 8 from a taking what is out there and polishing it has done amazing work. However to imply that the hardware out at computex is a direct result of it is just laughable. Now in a couple of years this might be a different argument, but for the moment it isn't.

Look, I understand your perspective and we have had some good debates back and forth. Don't go getting all glassy eyed spouting marketing bullshit on me now.
 
Actually there was a least one Windows tablet that came along was before the Transformer in 2003, TC1100 that had a detectable keyboard.

I think you're confusing Windows 8 and Windows RT. Windows 8 is x86 only, therefore it runs traditional desktop software. Windows RT is ARM only and BTW ALL Windows RT have full versions of Word, Excel, PowerPoint and OneNote included in the device.

And I simply don't know where you're saying I'm spouting marketing BS. Windows 8 tablets, convertibles and hybrids are FULL Windows desktop program capable devices. Android devices can't do this natively. That's a fact, not marketing BS.
 
Many people have absolutely NO NEED of a tablet in daily life. Unless they use it for work, for most people it's nothing but a glorified toy.
 
Actually there was a least one Windows tablet that came along was before the Transformer in 2003, TC1100 that had a detectable keyboard.

I think you're confusing Windows 8 and Windows RT. Windows 8 is x86 only, therefore it runs traditional desktop software. Windows RT is ARM only and BTW ALL Windows RT have full versions of Word, Excel, PowerPoint and OneNote included in the device.

And I simply don't know where you're saying I'm spouting marketing BS. Windows 8 tablets, convertibles and hybrids are FULL Windows desktop program capable devices. Android devices can't do this natively. That's a fact, not marketing BS.

Perhaps I should clarify, when I am talking about tablets I am talking about devices that compete directly with the iPad and Asus Transformer. Tablets that are just laptops with a touchscreen laid on them are an entirely different product. Unless I am missing something there is a pretty big size and weight difference between these products, which is why they never really sold well in the first place. I try to compare apples to apples when I can. The laptops that compete in the "iPad space" just aren't going to have the memory capacity to handle a full windows OS, plus full productivity software in its native form. They will all end up getting a specialized version, but again that isn't a shining point for win 8.

Many people have absolutely NO NEED of a tablet in daily life. Unless they use it for work, for most people it's nothing but a glorified toy.

I am going to disagree with this completely. I think it is closer to most people don't actually need a regular desktop/laptop in daily life. Considering a large majority of people only check email, do some web browsing, play some angry birds, post stupid crap on facebook and twitter and do very little productivity work. Tablets are absolutely one of the best devices for them. My parents are a great example of this type of user, the above is all they use a computer for. Me getting them an iPad and eliminating their desktop eliminated tons of tech support frustration for me and frustration in general for them. While I may hate what windows 8 is doing on the desktop, I absolutely love more competition in this market space.
 
In 1987, this is what I think was perdicted by our time: Back to the Future II: Babys toy So well we are getting all hot and bothered by what is happening with Windows, those kids have it right. (This is about all input devices except for voice.
 
Many people have absolutely NO NEED of a tablet in daily life. Unless they use it for work, for most people it's nothing but a glorified toy.

And with the emergence of tablets plenty or people are saying they no longer need PCs and many of those people at least claim that they can be used for productive needs.
 
Many people have absolutely NO NEED of a tablet in daily life. Unless they use it for work, for most people it's nothing but a glorified toy.

I think the main fact you are missing is that most computer users are web surfers. A tablet for most current PC users will suit their needs perfectly. Its easy to lose sight of this as enthusiasts on an enthusiast forum but the reality is tablets are a perfect PC replacement for the vast majority of PC users.
 
Perhaps I should clarify, when I am talking about tablets I am talking about devices that compete directly with the iPad and Asus Transformer. Tablets that are just laptops with a touchscreen laid on them are an entirely different product. Unless I am missing something there is a pretty big size and weight difference between these products, which is why they never really sold well in the first place. I try to compare apples to apples when I can. The laptops that compete in the "iPad space" just aren't going to have the memory capacity to handle a full windows OS, plus full productivity software in its native form. They will all end up getting a specialized version, but again that isn't a shining point for win 8.

As I've said many times, Windows 8 is a much about improved hardware as it is Metro. Until we see what this new hardware looks like and how well Windows 8 performs on it there is no way to draw any conclusions. I would suspect that the Atom Cedar Trail devices will be perfectly capable of running standard productivity and business applications and be far more capable than Android devices in this regard. Also with Metro apps Atom devices will have lots of gaming options that they've never had before.

But again, we need to see the hardware and the prices. I think the options and the power will be great. The big question will be prices.
 
As I've said many times, Windows 8 is a much about improved hardware as it is Metro. Until we see what this new hardware looks like and how well Windows 8 performs on it there is no way to draw any conclusions. I would suspect that the Atom Cedar Trail devices will be perfectly capable of running standard productivity and business applications and be far more capable than Android devices in this regard. Also with Metro apps Atom devices will have lots of gaming options that they've never had before.

But again, we need to see the hardware and the prices. I think the options and the power will be great. The big question will be prices.

I was referring to your statements about Win 8 devices being able to do things that iOS and Android cannot. I called that statement out as false as currently there is nothing that Win 8 and metro can do in the same market space that cannot be currently done on the competition. Apples to apples, right now Metro offers less out of the box then current competition. Microsoft has a huge uphill battle ahead of it. I am not doubting that it cannot become better, but right now it simply isn't there and the idea that any hardware at computex right now was designed because of Win 8 is laughable. We will start seeing the first devices designed around win 8 next year and they won't be worthwhile until the year after. Just like it was with Android and iOS both.

That is why I called you out for quoting marketing Bs, because until there is actual hardware on the shelf and reviewed verifying its capability. It is nothing more than marketing bs of what "could be". I am well aware of the potential the platform has.
 
I was referring to your statements about Win 8 devices being able to do things that iOS and Android cannot.

Again, Windows 8 is x86 only, it CLEARLY does things that iOS and Android can't, even on tablet devices. And while Metro is starting from zero, the library is going to explode. There's simply going to be too many Windows 8/RT devices out there, which from desktop to laptop to tablet to whatever will ALL be able to run Metro apps. No matter who crappy Windows 8 is that's simply too big of a market, an empty market right now, for app developers to ignore. Hell Microsoft has been able to get apps out for Windows Phone faster than Android with a 20th the market share.
 
It's certainly true that Windows devices are potentially more capable of doing things that Android and iOS devices cannot. With respect to Windows 8 x86 tablets specifically, though, it becomes quite a bit more difficult to think of things that they can do which the iPad and Android tablets cannot., to the point where it's just splitting hairs.

I'm referring of course to fundamental acts, not specific software. "Document creation and editing", "gaming", "music production" and so forth, not "Office", "Crysis" and "Pro Tools".
 
Okay, so people are criticizing Windows 8 because it brings a tablet UI to desktops and that's less productive but now iOS and Android devices can do everything that Windows 8 tablet can do?

First of all, that's just true as iOS and Android can't run native x86 programs that clearly have a productivity edge over mobile OS devices. And even though not touch optimized you still have an open desktop on Windows 8 tablets that can run arbitrary code, browsers with plug-ins, IE 10 on the desktop on tablets is touch optimized, in fact nothing stops a desktop program from working with touch, that's possible even in Windows 7.
 
Again, Windows 8 is x86 only, it CLEARLY does things that iOS and Android can't, even on tablet devices. And while Metro is starting from zero, the library is going to explode. There's simply going to be too many Windows 8/RT devices out there, which from desktop to laptop to tablet to whatever will ALL be able to run Metro apps. No matter who crappy Windows 8 is that's simply too big of a market, an empty market right now, for app developers to ignore. Hell Microsoft has been able to get apps out for Windows Phone faster than Android with a 20th the market share.

Referring to the win 8 family in general. The design philosophy is so that metro can compete head to head with the iPad. Which of course begs the question even more of why the hell is it on Win 8 on PC, but I don't wish to get into that argument any further as it is just beating a dead horse.

Okay, so people are criticizing Windows 8 because it brings a tablet UI to desktops and that's less productive but now iOS and Android devices can do everything that Windows 8 tablet can do?

First of all, that's just true as iOS and Android can't run native x86 programs that clearly have a productivity edge over mobile OS devices. And even though not touch optimized you still have an open desktop on Windows 8 tablets that can run arbitrary code, browsers with plug-ins, IE 10 on the desktop on tablets is touch optimized, in fact nothing stops a desktop program from working with touch, that's possible even in Windows 7.

You brought up the comparison by saying that Windows was going to do things that Android and iOS don't. Frankly I see productivity programs as supremely pointless on an iPad/Transformer, but it is going to happen regardless of what I think. So yes I am criticizing Win 8 for bringing a shitty ui to desktops where it doesn't belong.

Back to an earlier comment that I missed..You are 100% correct that price point is going to determine everything. If win 8 on an x86 tablet has any chance of competing, the hardware Must outperform, must be comparable in weight, Must have superior battery life and compete in price. The x86 tablets if they can achieve this and be only slightly more expensive then non x86 platforms, then and only then do they have a chance. Otherwise they will remain a niche product and this whole exercise in UI overhauling will have accomplished nothing except shoot microsoft in the foot.
 
You brought up the comparison by saying that Windows was going to do things that Android and iOS don't. Frankly I see productivity programs as supremely pointless on an iPad/Transformer, but it is going to happen regardless of what I think.
Productivity apps on tablets don't excel, but they do provide a connivence: if you need to edit some sort of document, create a task list or quickly adjust colors on a photo, tablets can perform those tasks. Not admirably, but passably enough to make those apps worthwhile for what they usually cost (nothing compared to a full-blown Office suite like Office).

Windows tablets are capable of the full-blown, heavy-hitting productivity shit, running office suites that will set you back hundreds, but you're going to spend a tremendous amount of time fighting the complexities of touch on a desktop UI to do it, so in both cases you're much better off seeking out a desktop or a laptop to do any kind of real heavy lifting. It just doesn't make sense to bother with serious productivity tasks on any kind of tablet, be it an iOS, Android or Windows tab.
 
I didnt read through all the comments, but did anyone hear him say "desktop mode"

A fully functional desktop and start menu?
 
Referring to the win 8 family in general. The design philosophy is so that metro can compete head to head with the iPad. Which of course begs the question even more of why the hell is it on Win 8 on PC, but I don't wish to get into that argument any further as it is just beating a dead horse.

I agree with the competition with the iPad part. The only thing I'll say about Metro on the desktop is that I've been going through the app store Metro might actually work better in some ways on a bigger screen than it does on tablets. The news readers, the People app, a lot of this stuff works and looks GREAT on desktops and big screens. There will be a lot of desktop users that I think will begin to actually enjoy desktops for the first time in a long time because Metro isn't about trying to cram as much into a tiny space for use with a high precision pointer and battleship gray everywhere. As people can become immersed in apps on a phone or tablet they so will some on the PC beyond games in a long time.


You brought up the comparison by saying that Windows was going to do things that Android and iOS don't. Frankly I see productivity programs as supremely pointless on an iPad/Transformer, but it is going to happen regardless of what I think. So yes I am criticizing Win 8 for bringing a shitty ui to desktops where it doesn't belong.

And this is a point I've made repeatedly. Everyday, more and more people seem to be saying that tablets CAN be used for productive tasks and enjoy the experience. Productivity isn't all about keyboard and mouse efficiency. It can sometimes a simple matter of just enjoying the task at hand and just feeling more productive and happy.

Back to an earlier comment that I missed..You are 100% correct that price point is going to determine everything. If win 8 on an x86 tablet has any chance of competing, the hardware Must outperform, must be comparable in weight, Must have superior battery life and compete in price. The x86 tablets if they can achieve this and be only slightly more expensive then non x86 platforms, then and only then do they have a chance. Otherwise they will remain a niche product and this whole exercise in UI overhauling will have accomplished nothing except shoot microsoft in the foot.

Intel and PC OEMs I think understand this well. I think Cedar Trail devices will be the devices to watch for, sort of Netbook 2.0. These devices should be very close to the iPad is weight, size, battery life and price with $400 to $600 being the sweet spot. We're always talking about Microsoft but if you look at Computex Intel was in full force and ALL about Windows 8 devices. Windows 8's success if very important to Intel.

But the other side of this too are ultrabooks and I have to say that the stuff being shown off at Computex looks like it can go toe to toe with the MacBook Air. One thing I pretty much have to get is the Asus Taichi. Two independent screens in the lid, that's just too cool, even a pen digitizer on back screen.

It looks like Intel and OEMs know that they have to do and it looks like they are trying to cover the price range and capabilities pretty well. Still need to see that HP and Dell have planned, they've been very silent on their Windows 8 plans and it looks like they have their work cut out for them.
 
Windows tablets are capable of the full-blown, heavy-hitting productivity shit, running office suites that will set you back hundreds, but you're going to spend a tremendous amount of time fighting the complexities of touch on a desktop UI to do it, so in both cases you're much better off seeking out a desktop or a laptop to do any kind of real heavy lifting. It just doesn't make sense to bother with serious productivity tasks on any kind of tablet, be it an iOS, Android or Windows tab.

Office 15 is supposed to be fully touch enabled even as a desktop program. A lot of Office 2010 works reasonablely with touch and with a pen (and those things seem to be finding themselves on iPads and Android tablets a lot these days, many people say that pens help with productive tasks even on totally touch devices) it's no contest, Office 2010 is very easy to use with a good level of productivity when touch is combined with a pen on a even a Windows 7 tablet. And believe it or not, even desktop apps work a bit better overall with touch on Windows 8 as there's fuzzy targeting on the desktop with touch.
 
I didnt read through all the comments, but did anyone hear him say "desktop mode"

A fully functional desktop and start menu?

Start Menu or no, the Windows 8 desktop is fully functional, once in a desktop app, there's NO difference between Windows 7 and 8.
 
Start Menu or no, the Windows 8 desktop is fully functional, once in a desktop app, there's NO difference between Windows 7 and 8.

Yes yes, we know you jerk off to the new metro start menu....

The point was, is MS listening to its the majority of its users and releasing a "desktop mode"
 
Office 15 is supposed to be fully touch enabled even as a desktop program. A lot of Office 2010 works reasonablely with touch and with a pen (and those things seem to be finding themselves on iPads and Android tablets a lot these days, many people say that pens help with productive tasks even on totally touch devices) it's no contest, Office 2010 is very easy to use with a good level of productivity when touch is combined with a pen on a even a Windows 7 tablet. And believe it or not, even desktop apps work a bit better overall with touch on Windows 8 as there's fuzzy targeting on the desktop with touch.

One thing I don't get is you and a few others facination with digital pens. Now if you are an artist, sure I get it but there are drawing pads are are magnitudes more accurate than touch screens are going to be in the visible future. Pens on a computer of any type just strike me as completely pointless. I can type many times faster than anything I can write with a pen normally, not to mention a digital one that forces me to slow down even more. Now I suppose if you are just looking for something to toss out rough sketches quickly, then sure but how many people honestly need that and how often would you actually use it? Even though I am not a big fan of software keyboards on tablets and would rather link up a small bluetooth, they are still overwhelmingly faster then a pen. I just don't get that at all.
 
The point was, is MS listening to its the majority of its users and releasing a "desktop mode"

The majority of Windows users haven't even seen Windows 8 or know anything about Metro. Not even 10 million anonymous posts from people how don't like Metro or 20 million videos about the "missing" Start Button comes anywhere near the majority of Windows users.

Sure Microsoft should listen to its customers, it's actually better at that than some people realize. But I don't think that design by a committee that thinks its the majority when it's in reality a pretty small minority is the same as listening to customers.

Since I use Windows daily and have for years across multiple form factors and input devices well duh, I guess I do love it since it's designed to do specially the things that I've been doing for years. And if you think that Start Menu is great you've never used it on a touch device. The touch experience is 100 times worse with the Start Menu then the keyboard and mouse experience is with the Start Screen. If Microsoft produced something that perfectly fit into how you've always done things you'd love it too.
 
Back
Top