Windows 8 Release Preview Review

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
C|Net has put together a review of the Windows 8 Release Preview that seems to base its conclusions mainly on tablet and laptop use. Still, there is some interesting stuff here, definitely worth the click to check out.

While Windows 8 does get much right, there's too much that hasn't been finalized. The workflow is easy, once you learn it. Does that mean that Microsoft will be including a tutorial for people who haven't read up on it? Ten seconds will do, but that may be 10 seconds too long for many people.
 
You sure as hell need more than 10 seconds to get around working with an ipad... But I guess that's ok because it's apple. :rolleyes:
 
You know, there's a lot of hate towards Windows 8 right now, but honestly I'm looking forward to it. I am extremely lazy and haven't tried any of the previews for it, but a lot of the new features and functions appeal to me. I'm hoping to get to check out a Windows 8 "Launch Party" because I know some people that work for a Gold member company with Microsoft.

Sometimes new can be good. Not always, but still.
 
You sure as hell need more than 10 seconds to get around working with an ipad... But I guess that's ok because it's apple. :rolleyes:

I've never found any Apple product to be easy to use. I've had to support them before and I'm always able to fix them, but they're just unintuitive to be different, it seems.
 
I dont think us gamers are even gonna need Win 8, unless they make DX12 win 8 exclusive......
 
I've never found any Apple product to be easy to use. I've had to support them before and I'm always able to fix them, but they're just unintuitive to be different, it seems.

I'll agree 100% with their "real" OS, but I think the iPhone and iPad are pretty easy to use. I pretty much figured them out based upon what they showed in the commercial. The Mac OS (on the other hand) is pretty, but baffling at times. Especially if you're a PC user.
 
You sure as hell need more than 10 seconds to get around working with an ipad... But I guess that's ok because it's apple. :rolleyes:

Some of these pundits are beginning to sound beyond stupid. The more I look at the debate over Windows 8 and the more I've used it on desktops, laptops and tablets the more I believe that it will do very well. One thing that this article does seem to get is that Windows 8 needs the right hardware. But what they don't seem to understand that it's more than Microsoft's hide on the line. Intel has a much to gain from Windows 8 as Microsoft and with the fortunes of PC OEMs in pretty bad shape these days, PC makers have more to gain than Microsoft.

Windows 8 is massive in terms of the changes to the OS, new hardware and software, everything. Windows 8 might very well fail, and by fail only sell more units than iPads, Macs, Chromebooks and Android tablets combine by only a factor of 1.2 instead of 1.6. Out of everything about Windows 8 this is what is perhaps the most interesting thing.
 
Still not impressed. Will run it in virtualbox and tweak it around a little, but no way I would waste my money on windows 8 for anything other than a tablet. This type of interface really isn't new, and I have never liked it in the past.
 
Windows 8 is massive in terms of the changes to the OS, new hardware and software, everything. Windows 8 might very well fail, and by fail only sell more units than iPads, Macs, Chromebooks and Android tablets combine by only a factor of 1.2 instead of 1.6. Out of everything about Windows 8 this is what is perhaps the most interesting thing.

I too (hypothetically speaking) would wonder why MS could only move 20% more software licenses than the combined Apple/Google/Android hardware. :p
 
Ugh.

Windows 8 is going to be a great tablet OS. But there is absolutely NO WAY that I'm using on my desktop or workstation. Ever. I will seriously switch to a Mac if that's what it takes to keep using a desktop OS on my desktop.
 
Ugh.

Windows 8 is going to be a great tablet OS. But there is absolutely NO WAY that I'm using on my desktop or workstation. Ever. I will seriously switch to a Mac if that's what it takes to keep using a desktop OS on my desktop.

There is always linux too! I have been dual/multibooting for 5+ years now. Doesn't work for some things (ie. gaming), but better than windows 8!
 
Jesus it's fast on an SSD. DAMN! Boot in ~10 seconds. Wow.

I like it. The subtle changes since CP are noticeable, but nothing really major. I'd really like to see more customization on the Start screen (background and such)
 
I too (hypothetically speaking) would wonder why MS could only move 20% more software licenses than the combined Apple/Google/Android hardware. :p

But the iPad is considered a huge overwhelming success and yet Windows 8 in everyone's eye bee a failure if it only sold as many units as the iPad.

However, this much is fairly certain. Metro apps are going to explode over the coming year. Even if Windows 8 is a failure, it will still represent the single biggest app market beyond phones and in probably time a bigger app than all other non-phone app markets combined, including the iPad.

Even if it's a failure. It's just amazing that one can speak realistically of a failed product that outsells successful ones.
 
Win8 on a PAD I would seriously consider if I wanted a PAD. Win8 on a desktop, not so much. Hell, even on a phone I might consider it if I did not already have an Android that I like fairly well.

It will be interesting to see how Win8 does.
 
Big difference between ipad and windows 8. ipad looks more colorful, the 1980s look of metro may keep a lot of buyers away. And maybe only apple can pull off those kinds of sales cause its apple.

I doubt it will make 500mil sales like win7 did though.
 
Big difference between ipad and windows 8. ipad looks more colorful, the 1980s look of metro may keep a lot of buyers away. And maybe only apple can pull off those kinds of sales cause its apple.

I doubt it will make 500mil sales like win7 did though.

Keep trollin, trollin, trollin.
 
Ugh.

Windows 8 is going to be a great tablet OS. But there is absolutely NO WAY that I'm using on my desktop or workstation. Ever. I will seriously switch to a Mac if that's what it takes to keep using a desktop OS on my desktop.

You're not the only one. I've stated this same thing before. I'll simply keep this pc and use it for gaming and move all my desktop activities to a mac.
 
I despise this. With a passion. Microsoft has BILLIONS of dollars to throw around, they should hire some people with taste.

I think people a lot of people don't fully understand just how much history, practice and thought is in Metro. Microsoft talks about it a great deal and the considerations are quite profound. One important element to Metro is power consumption and one thing I think that Windows RT devices will have a petty big edge in over Android tablets is battery life. That tends to be a far bigger consideration for people than an over glorified UI.
 
I think people a lot of people don't fully understand just how much history, practice and thought is in Metro. Microsoft talks about it a great deal and the considerations are quite profound. One important element to Metro is power consumption and one thing I think that Windows RT devices will have a petty big edge in over Android tablets is battery life. That tends to be a far bigger consideration for people than an over glorified UI.

Oh please, this is the same company that brought us the entirely useless and stupid Flip 3d. We're talking about desktops, not phones. I don't care what they do on phones, but stop pushing a tablet or phone OS onto the desktop.
 
Oh please, this is the same company that brought us the entirely useless and stupid Flip 3d. We're talking about desktops, not phones. I don't care what they do on phones, but stop pushing a tablet or phone OS onto the desktop.

Well Flip 3D is gone in Windows 8 as well so at least there's some improvement there.

In any case I've got the RP running on two machines now, the install is very fast and the cloud stuff is pretty sweet.

What is a desktop? What is a phone? Ultimately they are computers of different form factors and default input devices that everyday do more and more of the same things and indeed people are doing more and more on phones and less and less. Computing devices are converging, that's just the reality of it and the artificial divisions that we make between them are blurring everyday.

Sure keyboards and mice are great, not particularly mobile. Touch is very mobile, not the fastest input method. And none of the above do what pens are good at. However it plays out, someone needed to try to push the envelope on convergence to at least see what happens. Maybe most people want separate devices and OSes but if one thing can serve multiple purposes almost was well as two separate ones at lower cost, that will be compelling to some.
 
Big difference between ipad and windows 8. ipad looks more colorful, the 1980s look of metro may keep a lot of buyers away. And maybe only apple can pull off those kinds of sales cause its apple.

I doubt it will make 500mil sales like win7 did though.

Really? So little icons on a fat ass screen is more colorful? Metro is a totally new concept, heck atleast it is something different and more fun to play around with and more graphical interface. I am sorry if you want everything easy in life by all means jump to apple. I love apple products but ipad was the quickest thing I ever got tired of.

Just wait until windows 8 goes on tablets, I bet it's going to put Microsoft right there with top dogs. This is going to be the best tablet OS, I can already feel it, if my monitor was touchscreen I would be playing with this thing all day.
 
There's not enough Metro apps right now that utilize live tiles or stylized art, when that happens the iPads static icons look, well very static by comparison.
 
I have no problems with metro interface on a pc, if apps are well integrated it will be nice to use.
has anyone seen the new facebook integration. Fucking mind blowing. I hated the first time I tried it but this thing is a breeze to use, went to ease of access and clicked on make everything bigger for my 2560x1440 screen and everything is so much easier to read inside metro now.

Facebook integration took about 10 minutes to fully kick in but it is a nice treat from Microsoft.
 
I have no problems with metro interface on a pc, if apps are well integrated it will be nice to use.
has anyone seen the new facebook integration. Fucking mind blowing. I hated the first time I tried it but this thing is a breeze to use, went to ease of access and clicked on make everything bigger for my 2560x1440 screen and everything is so much easier to read inside metro now.

Facebook integration took about 10 minutes to fully kick in but it is a nice treat from Microsoft.

The whole cloud integration is sweet. Email, Facebook, IE favorites, all there, all automatic.
 
Really? So little icons on a fat ass screen is more colorful? Metro is a totally new concept, heck atleast it is something different and more fun to play around with and more graphical interface. I am sorry if you want everything easy in life by all means jump to apple. I love apple products but ipad was the quickest thing I ever got tired of.

Just wait until windows 8 goes on tablets, I bet it's going to put Microsoft right there with top dogs. This is going to be the best tablet OS, I can already feel it, if my monitor was touchscreen I would be playing with this thing all day.

And a lot of people buy what looks pretty. I think this is one of the things that makes apple sell to so many people. A lot of people are complaining about how dull the windows 8 desktop is getting with limited configuration vs windows 7. And from what I seen windows 8 metro is even more dull looking compared to an ipad. I don't own either but just trying to make a point that for a consumer they may get what looks cool and pretty. But we'll see if it fails or not. I'll be skipping windows 8 cause I don't travel or need a tablet.
 
And a lot of people buy what looks pretty. I think this is one of the things that makes apple sell to so many people. A lot of people are complaining about how dull the windows 8 desktop is getting with limited configuration vs windows 7. And from what I seen windows 8 metro is even more dull looking compared to an ipad. I don't own either but just trying to make a point that for a consumer they may get what looks cool and pretty. But we'll see if it fails or not. I'll be skipping windows 8 cause I don't travel or need a tablet.

It really just shows what MS thinks of the consumer. They think the consumer base is filled with absolute idiots and children. They have carried this misconception for quite some time. Would making the same concept look more professional and adult be counter productive in any way? No, it would not, so what's the problem, why not do it?
 
And a lot of people buy what looks pretty. I think this is one of the things that makes apple sell to so many people. A lot of people are complaining about how dull the windows 8 desktop is getting with limited configuration vs windows 7. And from what I seen windows 8 metro is even more dull looking compared to an ipad. I don't own either but just trying to make a point that for a consumer they may get what looks cool and pretty. But we'll see if it fails or not. I'll be skipping windows 8 cause I don't travel or need a tablet.

1. How is the Windows 8 desktop more dull than the Windows 7 desktop?
2. The notion that iOS is less dull than Metro is LAUGHABLE. There is honestly no argument you could possibly make to prove that argument.
 
And a lot of people buy what looks pretty. I think this is one of the things that makes apple sell to so many people. A lot of people are complaining about how dull the windows 8 desktop is getting with limited configuration vs windows 7. And from what I seen windows 8 metro is even more dull looking compared to an ipad. I don't own either but just trying to make a point that for a consumer they may get what looks cool and pretty. But we'll see if it fails or not. I'll be skipping windows 8 cause I don't travel or need a tablet.

Not really sure where you're getting limited configuration from. The Start Screen is more configurable and when it's got live tiles on it, the current iOS UI really isn't more interesting though we can debate beauty all day long. Metro isn't about being beautiful in and of itself, it's about allowing things to be beautiful themselves.

Just got the RP installed on my dual screen desktop and the hot corners are much better. Actually I think the Start Screen works much better on a multi-monitor setup. Three things that I would like to see changed, no way to scroll on the side window navigation, no way to put the notification icons on all the task bars and while it's easy to drag a Metro app around screens it doesn't behave like Windows+PgUP/PgDN. It only moves the app, not the focus of all Metro apps, so moving to another Metro app will moves all the Metro apps including the one just moved back to the other screen.
 
It really just shows what MS thinks of the consumer. They think the consumer base is filled with absolute idiots and children. They have carried this misconception for quite some time. Would making the same concept look more professional and adult be counter productive in any way? No, it would not, so what's the problem, why not do it?

It's interesting that you would say this when people around here routinely dismiss the average person as completely incompetent when it comes to technology.

I think that Microsoft is actually giving users more ability and freedom with Windows 8. It's not tied to a particular form factor or input method. That's not to say that programs themselves will necessarily work well with touch when they were designed for a keyboard and mouse but there are plenty of programs that will be able to work with touch, mice and keyboards interchangeably, even desktop ones like the next version of Office.

With Windows 8 users have the choice to use whatever programs they need or want on whatever form factor they need or want with whatever input method they need or want. That's far from treating customers like idiots. Indeed it's quite a bit more complex than other mainstream OSes because of the device and input neutrality.
 
Just get over it. Metro is the new thing, and its probably not going away. I don't understand why people can't live with change.
 
~@1:10

Guy has to swipe around multiple times on the laptop just to minimize applications. I've been saying for a while that W8 is going to result in decreased efficiency relative to W7...
 
I wish I had a better internet connection so that I could download it in a reasonable amount of time.
 
~@1:10

Guy has to swipe around multiple times on the laptop just to minimize applications. I've been saying for a while that W8 is going to result in decreased efficiency relative to W7...

1. You don't have you use Metro. If you want to use the desktop you get the same efficiency as you do in W7
2. Microsoft is adding gestures to touchpads
3. Metro apps do not run when they are in the background, so they never truly have to be closed, except to keep you Alt+Tab screen clean.
 
~@1:10

Guy has to swipe around multiple times on the laptop just to minimize applications. I've been saying for a while that W8 is going to result in decreased efficiency relative to W7...

The standard mouse gesture is a bit cumbersome.

However since Windows 7 doesn't run Metro apps it's hard to make that case I think. Bottom line is that you really don't need to close Metro apps, they tend to pretty small and don't consume any resources in the background. And Alt-F4 is the fastest way to close a program that's got focus.
 
Just finished installing it on a VM and it seams like a cross between an iPad interface (I dont have a touch screen PC but do own an iPad) and Tabworks (which was my very first GUI OS before Win 95, although it was kind of an overlay of 95 in a sense). You want to know the sad part, Tabworks was a better looking OS. I don't like metro and I will never use any "apps" (Why the hell cant we just call them "applications?" I HATE the term "apps"). I could get used to no start button, but then I would just have shortcuts to everything on the desktop and that would just be a mess. I might spend some more time on it, but right now I will not be getting Windows 8, even though it wont cost me a penny (legally too). That's right Microsoft, I wouldn't install Windows 8 if it were free. Windows 8 might be fine for the tablet and phone market but it is not for the PC.
 
1. You don't have you use Metro. If you want to use the desktop you get the same efficiency as you do in W7.

This is really seems to trip people. It's difficult to understand Metro and Metro apps and their benefit if all one is looking at is keyboard and mouse efficiency. Even in the context of closing a program Alt-F4 can be even more efficient than using the mouse and that works just like it does with a desktop app.

People love to say that Windows 8 is a dumbing down of the OS and it really is a smartening up in that Metro presents another platform for applications that aren't geared towards just keyboards and mice. One has the option of using Metro apps with they want to use touch or even if they want to conserve power on their laptop. But right now I'm in the USA Today app on my dual screen desktop and I've got all the news, nice and laid out add free and it's beautiful and it works just fine with a mouse and keyboard and I don't really need to worry about closing it.
 
Back
Top