Windows 8 App To Bring Back Start Menu

Picture this scenario - something I'd like to try for our office's conference room:

Windows 8 from a projector. Kinect for virtual touchscreen. I'm thinking this would be a great presentation operating system.

Would certainly make Powerpoint presentation more interesting when the presenter must do jumping jacks to forward to the next slide...come to think of it. This *is* a brilliant idea...
 
You know that as far as Microsoft executive management is concerned, Gates is just as missing as Jobs is for Apple, right? Steve Ballmer has been Microsoft CEO for over 12 years now.

haha I always laugh when I see idiots post stuff like that. When is the last time you saw bill gates do anything at microsoft at the CEO level in the last 10+ years.

That guy needs to change the clocks on his time machine its not 1995.
 
Sissies...

Just learn the new Interface.. it takes about a day to get used to it.

Been playing with Windows 8 for a couple weeks, and hate the new interface.
I spent way to much time on simple things such as just trying to find the "off" button or how to close an app. I especially dislike the corner menus, as they make no sense when used with a mouse/desktop, and are dificult to use in a VM.

Unless Windows 8 can be defaulted into something similar to the Windows 7 desktop, I'll be using Windows 7 for a long time.
 
People like those on this board probably represent 1% of the people that use PCs. Most don't care what OS they have as long as they can get to Facebook and YouTube.

The users I support at the office range from developers to users that barely know how to use a mouse.

On th high end, these people get paid to much to waste time trying to figure out a new user interface.
On the low end, it would likely take weeks of training just so they could fine the off button. :)
 
again, why are people in the metro interface for anything but apps or trying to shut down or control panel?
 
It's not just me, it's the media, don't be stupid, please. Let's not pretend Bill Gates is not Microsoft. Same difference. I could care less if he hasn't had a thing to do with anything for years. That's not the point and you two know it. You want to know what's really funny, when two tweeners totally miss the point and go off and giggle over a little fact and make a big deal about something that no one else really cares about. lol
 
again, why are people in the metro interface for anything but apps or trying to shut down or control panel?

I think you'll see a lot average people use Metro apps on the desktop as there there's just going to be tons of them easy download, cheap and even free and work well with mice and keyboards. There should be a lot of games and content apps that fall into this category.
 
...and remind me again of the compelling business case that creates a need to upgrade from Win 7 to Win 8 on my desktop system?

I don't believe they care. Businesses upgrade on a cycle. Be it 7 or 8, they sold you a new license, and only 1/3 of businesses have upgraded from XP to 7. and they likely are going to upgrade to something before 2014, so they are good. Now if to say that everyone decides to keep XP even after it's not supported then there's a big problem.
 
this, jesus everyone is making such a big deal out of this

The big deal here is that everyone just got bitchslapped on visual department. I'm sure a majority out there who uses PCs wouldn't mind AT ALL. But for some, who are so attuned to a specific visual perception of their working condition that they would be kicking and screaming before they accept the change that is Metro.

Here's what I think though: by 2014, most would be laughing to themselves, thinking " How the hell did we survived XP and 7 without Metro? Lol."

People adapt to changes, and since most arent really INTO the desktop scene, the world isn't gonna crash and burn because of Metro.
 
People adapt to changes, and since most arent really INTO the desktop scene, the world isn't gonna crash and burn because of Metro.

People don't seem to understand it, but Microsoft is in a way extending the life of the desktop with Windows 8 and Metro. One the eve of the iPad 3 everyone is going nuts. The world just isn't that interested in the desktop anymore. The desktop isn't going away but in a way we are in the post-PC world in terms of the devices that have passion about.
 
People don't seem to understand it, but Microsoft is in a way extending the life of the desktop with Windows 8 and Metro. One the eve of the iPad 3 everyone is going nuts. The world just isn't that interested in the desktop anymore. The desktop isn't going away but in a way we are in the post-PC world in terms of the devices that have passion about.

I think you're misunderstanding. We get that tablets are the next best thing since sliced bread, but what most of the guys here don't understands is why Microsoft won't make Metro UI a tablet-only feature, or make it capable of being opted out on desktop computers.

Don't get me wrong, I like Metro UI, even on the desktop computer. It's not detracting my computer experience in any way since I spend less than 1% of my time in the Start menu (or Metro UI, if you will), but others want the ability to opt out.

Perhaps Microsoft learned from Office 2007 that when a user is forced to learn something new, they'll adapt quickly, and that's what they're aiming for with Windows 8.

We're living in a generation of complacency, I've discovered over the years. Nobody seems to likes changes anymore, and when they happen, they sing the all to common tune: "we reject change just for the sake of change". I dunno about the rest of you, but why not change for the sake of change? Must we be victims of tradition? Stay with Windows 7 if you must. I want to continue to see what else can be brought to the table in my lifetime.
 
I think you're misunderstanding. We get that tablets are the next best thing since sliced bread, but what most of the guys here don't understands is why Microsoft won't make Metro UI a tablet-only feature, or make it capable of being opted out on desktop computers.

In time everyone with Windows 8 will run Metro apps even on desktops and laptops and even people pooping on Metro now, there will simply be too many of them and some will be great even on desktops.


Perhaps Microsoft learned from Office 2007 that when a user is forced to learn something new, they'll adapt quickly, and that's what they're aiming for with Windows 8.

And this is a point have made quite a lot. Sinofsky was responsible for the Ribbon in Office 2007. I think it kind of borders on ludicrous that Microsoft just makes a change like Metro in a vacuum and no usability testing and no idea that Metro is a big change and they just changing the UI to just to change it. Clearly that assessment is completely wrong, Microsoft has said a lot publicly about Metro and it's effort to make it keyboard and mouse friendly even though it is touch first and the whole tag line of Windows 8 is "no compromise". The UI changes are ones that Microsoft must have some confidence in being easy to pick up and not being horrific to use with a keyboard and mouse.


We're living in a generation of complacency, I've discovered over the years. Nobody seems to likes changes anymore, and when they happen, they sing the all to common tune: "we reject change just for the sake of change". I dunno about the rest of you, but why not change for the sake of change? Must we be victims of tradition? Stay with Windows 7 if you must. I want to continue to see what else can be brought to the table in my lifetime.

I don't know, I think a lot people like fresh and new gadgets which is why iPads sand smart phones have done so well and to a lesser degree Android tablets. I think it tends to be technical people like us that often have the most consternation over changes as we have the most invested in the status quo.
 
The issue I have with Metro over the old menu style UI is that I don't see any visual cues or breadcrumbs as to where or how to do something.

So far I'm amazed that the only way I've found to shut down the tablet laptop I installed 8 on is to press Alt-F4 and then select Shutdown from the menu that appears.

What was two mouse clicks is now two key presses and a mouse click. Most things do not appear slicker or quicker so as a desktop/PC user whats the benefit of Metro for me?

Other things like right clicking My Computer to select properties now involves whizzing left and right across the screen for no benefit.

It's like using a motorway with all the road signs removed. Maybe Metro will be nice for the 145 folks that buy a MS tablet but for the rest of us using real computers, I don't think so.
 
Personally I'm skipping Windows 8

No doubt this will be a learning experience for Microsoft, and hopefully, they'll see what works and what doesn't, and come up with a better UI in Windows 9
 
I've been trying the CP for the last couple of days and I'm still not feeling it. Outside metro its fine, but in metro it feels like I get stuff done despite it, not because of it.

For example, I needed an elevated command prompt, once I found it in the metro search, right clicking brought up options down at the bottom of the screen, not on a menu conveniently next to my mouse, extra work all for the sake of an asthetic.


Say what? First of all, Metro UI is *nothing* like iOS. I'm a 3-year iPhone user and a Windows 8 Consumer Preview user since last weekend and I see no similarities between the two. Clicking icons to launch programs have been around since the invention of the Mouse.

The only reason why one might say it copies iOS is because it's now touted to be a touchscreen-friendly operating system. At the end of the day, it's still just clicking an icon to launch a program.

I've not used an iPhone, but I've used smartphones, and the way ALL the bundled 'apps' are full screen is just like a phone OS. Perhaps 3rd party apps will be available in windowed mode but I doubt it, doesn't seem to fit with the theme.

I have a single 24" screen, plenty of space for multiple programs, sure some things like games are best full screen, but anything else works just as well resized to a part of the screen, I don't need all 24 inches to run a single program with 3/4 inch text.

I wonder why they're even calling it 'Windows 8'. Right now, using it they way they seem to want me to (rather than using the desktop like a savage) it feels like they should call it 'Screens 1'
 
The only issue I have so far is that it is unstable. (Beta, I get it.) Mostly, I just think it is the beta amd drivers causing the issue even though I am grateful they did create some. The stability issues occur both on my desktop and laptop.

One thing I like is that Win8 works really well with multiple monitors.
 
I never realized how many people clicked the Start button to get the Menu to pop up until now because there wouldn't be so many people freaking out. I've always been a taskbar/desktop shortcut/Quick Launch person for a long time.

The more I fiddle with Win8 the more I like it for the small things. I can alt tab programs with just the mouse including closing programs (Mouse in the top left corner, the tabbed program boxes pop up, right click on what you want to close) and you can 'window' a Metro app alongside your desktop (it squishes it to either side of the screen)

I have a dumb question... we're [H] so why are we all worried about the newb stuff? We're all living in the desktop 99% of the time because our x86 based programs run like they have for years with traditional windows and Xs in the right corner to close them. Win8 boots up (very damn quickly), we log in, goto the desktop and get down to it, I don't see the problem. We have the same crap we've been doing with some subtle upgrades and changes, almost as if the Win8 desktop is Win7 SP2. Try copying a few large files at the same time and see what the file transfer window does. I love seeing the graph and exactly where it's slowing down. Then we get the new foofoo stuff that most of us will never use, although the weather app is nice.

As much as I want to hate the tablet UI I can't because it never gets in my way, at all. It's like a got a hybrid but I only do long highway driving but the engine is still as good as the last one.
 
The start menu needs to die a quick and painless death. If you want a start menu stick to windows 7 and when you're ready to get rid of the mullet and billy ray cd along with your 2 decade old application menu you can upgrade to windows 8.

Let's keep the progress in the right direction and force people to break old bad habits.

This joke has been used before and wasn't funny the first time. You aren't a comedian sorry, find better material.

It simply boils down to simple facts. Metro is great on touch devices and complete crap on non. It should be defaulted off on a normal desktop and laptop and defaulted on for touch devices. This would end the debate completely. Give people choice and don't force bad design decisions on them. Defend it all you want, call us old, call us whatever it doesn't change the fact that metro and the new start screen are absolutely TERRIBLE on a desktop. It is not going to be received well by the average users at all. People freaked out and couldn't find things moving from XP to win 7, if you think that giving them an interface that removes ALL sense of familiarity is going to be received with open arms, you are delusional.
 
Yeah, all it needs is a selector to allow you to switch between Aero7 mode and Metro8 mode.

Then its debate and worries over.

I have a feeling the final RC will have this.
 
I know what you are talking about. You probably think that all rectangular tablet is a ripoff of Apple too. :rolleyes:

Microsofts early tablets were horrific. Do you really want to bring those up, or should we continue to politelypretend they dont exist?
 
Say what? First of all, Metro UI is *nothing* like iOS. I'm a 3-year iPhone user and a Windows 8 Consumer Preview user since last weekend and I see no similarities between the two. Clicking icons to launch programs have been around since the invention of the Mouse.

The only reason why one might say it copies iOS is because it's now touted to be a touchscreen-friendly operating system. At the end of the day, it's still just clicking an icon to launch a program.


I'm writing this on an iPad and the desktop layout feels identical. Multiple pages of icons that can themselves be updated with limited information without opening the full "app".

The reason I say it's just a bad clone is because it mimics the stripped down functionality of iOS without adding anything new. Well, except for the gestures, but they're clunky and certainly not flawless on the touchpad.

Win 8 just feels like an attempt to catch up with iOS, to the detriment of traditional mouse users. Why did Microsoft insist on trying to shove tablet functionality onto their mouse-friendly OS? They obviously dont care about liiting the number of different Windows versions they release, so why not continue with a separate tablet edition?
 
It's not just me, it's the media, don't be stupid, please. Let's not pretend Bill Gates is not Microsoft. Same difference. I could care less if he hasn't had a thing to do with anything for years. That's not the point and you two know it. You want to know what's really funny, when two tweeners totally miss the point and go off and giggle over a little fact and make a big deal about something that no one else really cares about. lol

lmao you need to take your own advice about not being stupid. That is like me complaining about bill clinton for america's current trouble. Its not the same difference, and it doesn't matter if you could care less. Bill Gates doesn't run microsoft and hasn't for quite a long time. If you are too clueless to see this it doesn't change the fact. If you cannot use facts that are accurate why would anyone take your post serious so it is a big deal.

And tweeners?

i'm 31 if anyone sounds like a child here its you.
 
I'm writing this on an iPad and the desktop layout feels identical. Multiple pages of icons that can themselves be updated with limited information without opening the full "app".

The reason I say it's just a bad clone is because it mimics the stripped down functionality of iOS without adding anything new. Well, except for the gestures, but they're clunky and certainly not flawless on the touchpad.

Win 8 just feels like an attempt to catch up with iOS, to the detriment of traditional mouse users. Why did Microsoft insist on trying to shove tablet functionality onto their mouse-friendly OS? They obviously dont care about liiting the number of different Windows versions they release, so why not continue with a separate tablet edition?

Perhaps they're listening to everyone's original complaint that's been around since Windows 2000. The complaint that there are too many versions of Windows. So Microsoft says fine, we'll make one for everything.
 
The market is pushing for the dumming down of interfaces for clients. This is a fact. Some of use still want traditional desktops and cli, and we will get it...stop going crazy thinking that Win8 is some sort of red-headed step child that will tank. Metro is a great step forward for touch devices and it bridges the divide between smart phones, tablets, and desktops.

I look forward to it and in my mind, i believe the desktop will get the complete Metro look for Windows 9, meaning that the Metro touch and desktop will pair both ascetically and technically much more seamlessly.
 
Windows 8 commercials should go a little something like:

"It wasn't your idea, but we figured we'd shove it down your throat anyways... If your a PC stick with Windows 7, cause it is what you wanted."

+1 for Start8
 
The start menu needs to die a quick and painless death. If you want a start menu stick to windows 7 and when you're ready to get rid of the mullet and billy ray cd along with your 2 decade old application menu you can upgrade to windows 8.

Let's keep the progress in the right direction and force people to break old bad habits.

So what you're saying is that you can't come up with any logical reasons why a keyboard mouse interface should backtrack and downgrade to a touch/phone interface. And so because you have no argument you will just resort to stupid personal attacks on anyone who DOES have a logical argument (ie: productivity, training, intuitive interfaces, number of clicks to accomplish a given task, etc).
 
Back
Top