Windows 8/10 Storage Spaces Questions

ElectroPulse

Limp Gawd
Joined
Aug 19, 2013
Messages
129
Edit for anyone running across this thread in the future: Since there is a performance hit when using Storage Spaces, and I'm trying to avoid partitioning for flexibility's sake (I'll already have the OS installed on a separate drive), I looked around and found a solution for what I'm trying to do: The SUBST command. It allows you to map a drive letter to a folder. So, I'll install programs to drive D, and have a folder called "data" in there as well that is mapped to drive E. To make it persistent, you need to edit the registry as outlined in the original post here: http://answers.microsoft.com/en-us/...-mapping/186c6f52-3d97-49b5-a0fd-b7da20dbf48f


Hello, all!

In preparation for upgrading to Windows 10, I've purchased a new 4TB HDD, and have been trying to decide how to set it up.

I've got a 120GB SSD for boot + few programs, the 4TB HDD for software and files, and a 1TB that will be replaced by the 4TB drive.

My current setup (SSD boot drive + 1TB HDD with a partition for software and a partition for files) isn't as flexible as I'd like (I couldn't adjust partitions to fit actual needs of software installation and file storage), so I've been looking at alternatives.

What I'd been thinking was just running one partition on the 4TB drive, and just dealing with the clutter.

However, I've run across something I was previously unaware of that was introduced in Windows 8: Storage Pools. It sounds like this would offer me the flexibility I would like. You add some drives to the pool, and set up "storage spaces" (which would replace my use of partitions). In my case, I am thinking about adding either 1. Just the 4TB HDD and making the storage spaces I need from that, or 2. Add both the 4TB and 1TB drive to it and mirror my important files on one (will backup files periodically to external drives as well), and software on the other.

However, I have some questions:
1. Performance. Is there any (and if so, how much) performance hit when using a storage space that is only on one drive? I've seen numbers showing a substantial performance hit when mirroring or using parity, but am unsure about with just one drive.
2. Is it possible to even set up a storage pool with a single drive?
3. Are there any alternatives to what I propose? Basically, all data is thrown into a pile on the disk (not physically separated as in positions), but is viewed by the system similarly to partitions (multiple drives in Computer), allowing them to be more flexible in terms of sizing.

Also, anything else to keep in mind?

Thanks!
ElectroPulse

TL;DR:
Is it possible to set up a storage pool with a single drive? And if so, is there any performance downside? Also, any alternatives to partitioning that are more flexible, allowing of the resizing of partitions as-needed (I've run into the issue of not correctly predicting required partitiom sizes for programs and data, and would like to avoid that annoyance in the future).
 
Last edited:
Mirroring is crap for backup. I would work on a better backup strategy, maybe with an external drive, maybe something you can take offsite (in case your house burns down), and maybe something cloud based.
 
Mirroring is crap for backup. I would work on a better backup strategy, maybe with an external drive, maybe something you can take offsite (in case your house burns down), and maybe something cloud based.

Ah, neglected to mention that I intend to do a periodic full backup to external HDDs, as well as backing up essentials to the cloud sometime in the next month or so. The 1TB mirror is just for an always up-to-date copy. Just updated OP.

The mirroring + external backup is hopefully just temporary... In the next 6-12 months I'd like to save up enough to put together a nice FreeNAS ZFS-based box.
 
SS is slow in all way shapes and forms.

SS Mirror is much slower than integrated Intel RAID1, for example. The resiliency of ReFS and it's cost of implementation is the only thing going for it, and is why we use it - but only for archiving old data indefinitely.
 
Thank you for the replies!

Alright then, storage spaces are out.

I've spent a while looking around, and just finally ran across a feature that will allow me to do what I'm imagining, which is to have separate logical disk-type things to organize my information: Mapping a folder to a dive letter using the SUBST command. This will allow me to have another drive set up under Computer, but not have the performance hit of Storage Spaces, nor will I have to deal with resizing partitions later on. (In order to make the "virtual drive" persistent, you need to edit the registry as outlined in the original post here: http://answers.microsoft.com/en-us/...-mapping/186c6f52-3d97-49b5-a0fd-b7da20dbf48f)
 
Last edited:
Back
Top