Windows 8.1 Update Will Hide Tile Interface By Default?

so you agree that the UI is trash? :p


(i kid)


Seriously though... I don't think anyone would argue against the backend changes. They are great. My Ultrabook boots cold in roughly 10 seconds with windows 8 and under a second from the hybrid hibernation/shutdown mode... The updated task manager is also great. It's the hideous start-screen and ribbon UI that most people tend to hate.

Good call on the updated Task Manager. I want to mention the ability to pause and resume file transfer. That feature alone is preventing me from going back to 7 (I miss Aero).
 
x2

imagine having to use traditional desktop UI elements with your finger. It would suck almost as bad as using a touch UI with a mouse lol :D

It's much easier to use a mouse and keyboard with Windows 8 than having only the desktop and desktop apps to use with touch. There are things within many desktop apps that simply don't work at all with touch. And even when things can work with touch with apps, it does take some getting used to, much more so than getting used to the 8 UI with a keyboard and mouse.
 
TeraCopy (from http://codesector.com/teracopy for those running Windows 7/Vista) does that well :)

There's almost always 3rd party options when using Windows, that's one of the things that's so great about. However when those 3rd party options involved using a replacement Start Menu, many here will instantly disqualify those because they are 3rd party options in the box. There's some logic to it I guess but the greatest strength of Windows on the desktop is it's 3rd party support and why so many use it.
 
You sure did! Only... *I did* specify the UI in the post you were responding to. *You* were the one to go off on a tangent into something I never commented on, just to try to draw our gaze away from the man behind the curtain (don't pay any attention to him!).
 
The biggest gripe I have with all this 8 stuff is that it's supposed to make using Windows on a tablet that much better... Only it still sucks on a tablet. The Dell Venue 8, does so many things right, but at the same time it's the OS that holds it back. For 99% of tablet purposes my Nexus 7 does a much better job.

The windows keyboard sucks, the metro browsers suck, Firefox might as well still be alpha, Chrome in metro mode basically assumes you have a keyboard/mouse and is hard to do a bunch of stuff only using touch. IE is the best of the bunch and still feels awful compared to Chrome on Android, especially for text input. I usually end up just using firefox in desktop mode and losing all of the on screen keyboard autocorrect and touch features. Oh yeah there are some pluses, you get Word and the rest of Office. Onenote with a stylus works really cool, much better than the android version. But still the app market for games is really weak, you have to run bluestacks to get any decent games. Google refuses to support the marketplace, a good touch Google Maps would be killer, but it doesn't exist. The Bing apps are very weak, I like the weather and sort of the Bing Finance app, but Bing Maps is just inferior to Google in almost every way. They all just lack polish.

I don't know maybe it will get better if people actually use it and msft opens metro up to devs more... That and I'd like to see them open up the keyboard too, text input is definitely one of the weakest points of the device. Spell check integration is bad, autocorrect doesn't work consistently if at all, lack of auto-replace support, terrible keyboard experience in desktop mode and the list just goes on.
 
Its not Microsofts fault you dont want to learn to use a new UI and use it to its potential. Frankly that is the only reason people have issue with it, they dont want to learn it.

Bullshit. Blaming the negative reaction on “people hate change” "not wanting to learn" is narrow-minded and minimizes the full extent of what’s happening. Maybe people, on the whole, just don’t like Metro on non-tablet devices.

I don’t mind learning. Using OSX (ugh) for a couple important programs not available on Windows required learning. Starting to use Emacs to do some development required learning. The problem isn’t anything to do with learning.

The problem is that we’re being asked to learn something that’s just a worse UX on a standard desktop and mouse setup. This worse UX exists only for corporate strategy reasons, as a trojan horse to artificially make Microsoft’s app store and tablet ecosystem seem more established, not to make a desktop computer user’s life better, which is what it should be doing.

As a side point: if you really think that users should be forced to learn vast amounts about the software they use, you really should return to text-based command line computing. Part of the entire point of having a GUI in the first place is that it massively increases the intuitiveness and discoverability of the UI; all the things Microsoft pissed up the wall in Windows 8.

Cars change in style and technology, but the steering wheel, pedals and seats aren’t having revolutions every two decades. MS is acting like they’ve invented the self-driving car when really they’ve just replaced the controls with something that is impractical for most people.
 
Bullshit. Blaming the negative reaction on “people hate change” "not wanting to learn" is narrow-minded and minimizes the full extent of what’s happening. Maybe people, on the whole, just don’t like Metro on non-tablet devices.

Completely agree. I'll defend Windows 8, and I really love it, but if someone doesn't like it - they don't like it. Not because they don't like change, don't want to learn, etc.. They just don't like it for any other reason. When people start spouting the "You don't like change", I really don't think highly of the rest of their posts. Sure, they defend the same product as I do, but that's the cop out, BS, finger pointing.
 
x2

imagine having to use traditional desktop UI elements with your finger. It would suck almost as bad as using a touch UI with a mouse lol :D

Neither are a problem, so not sure what you're trying to argue here.
 
The biggest gripe I have with all this 8 stuff is that it's supposed to make using Windows on a tablet that much better... Only it still sucks on a tablet. The Dell Venue 8, does so many things right, but at the same time it's the OS that holds it back. For 99% of tablet purposes my Nexus 7 does a much better job.

Your assessment doesn't seem to be the majority view when it comes specifically to the Venue 8 Pro. I think everyone agrees that the Windows Store is well behind iOS and Android currently but it has improved significantly over the 15 months since Windows 8 went general release. The modern version of IE 11 I think compares very well to Chrome and Safari. One very nice advantage is Flash support, there's still tons on the web that's dependent on Flash and a lot of the apps for iOS and Android are often just web site replacements that work in Windows 8 though the apps are more touch friendly. Not really sure what issues you have with Windows 8's keyboard in modern apps, it's pretty good and has real time handwriting to text conversion which works well for me, got a good pen.
 
Completely agree. I'll defend Windows 8, and I really love it, but if someone doesn't like it - they don't like it. Not because they don't like change, don't want to learn, etc.. They just don't like it for any other reason. When people start spouting the "You don't like change", I really don't think highly of the rest of their posts. Sure, they defend the same product as I do, but that's the cop out, BS, finger pointing.

But there are plenty of people who flat out say they don't want any change in Windows. They just want to run the same desktop apps the same way they have for years. I'm not saying that's everyone but resistance to change is part of what's going on here.
 
I would be happier if my ipad had support for a g'damn mouse but wtf do I know I'm just a luddite :D
 
I would be happier if my ipad had support for a g'damn mouse but wtf do I know I'm just a luddite :D

It is interesting that jailbroken support mice and Android supports them and there are now even large screen Android desktops.
 
Microsoft is practically begging desktop and laptop users to move on to another OS (Chrome for Desktop, Linux, whatever).
 
Bullshit. Blaming the negative reaction on “people hate change” "not wanting to learn" is narrow-minded and minimizes the full extent of what’s happening. Maybe people, on the whole, just don’t like Metro on non-tablet devices.

I don’t mind learning. Using OSX (ugh) for a couple important programs not available on Windows required learning. Starting to use Emacs to do some development required learning. The problem isn’t anything to do with learning.

The problem is that we’re being asked to learn something that’s just a worse UX on a standard desktop and mouse setup. This worse UX exists only for corporate strategy reasons, as a trojan horse to artificially make Microsoft’s app store and tablet ecosystem seem more established, not to make a desktop computer user’s life better, which is what it should be doing.

As a side point: if you really think that users should be forced to learn vast amounts about the software they use, you really should return to text-based command line computing. Part of the entire point of having a GUI in the first place is that it massively increases the intuitiveness and discoverability of the UI; all the things Microsoft pissed up the wall in Windows 8.

Cars change in style and technology, but the steering wheel, pedals and seats aren’t having revolutions every two decades. MS is acting like they’ve invented the self-driving car when really they’ve just replaced the controls with something that is impractical for most people.

Very good post.

I don't hate the 8/8.1 UI, but I don't NEED it either. I also happen to like the look of Aero. But, I'm waiting to see how the dust settles with a new CEO. There's going to be a lot of pundits saying a new CEO won't change the course or won't impact change. And, that's bullshit to me. Every CEO wants to blaze their own path stockholders be damned. They want to establish their own identity. They may not last long, but they will have some change in how MS does things. So I'm passing on 8 for now.
 
The problem is that we’re being asked to learn something that’s just a worse UX on a standard desktop and mouse setup. This worse UX exists only for corporate strategy reasons, as a trojan horse to artificially make Microsoft’s app store and tablet ecosystem seem more established, not to make a desktop computer user’s life better, which is what it should be doing.

And what exactly entails making the desktop user's life easier? Could that not be having devices that support everything the desktop does and supporting tablets which more and more desktop users are using and even replacing desktops with depending on what they were using their desktops for? You say the UI is worse, but it pretty much works like Windows 7 on a desktop. There are differences, but they are nearly as dramatic as some make them out to be and they don't effect how desktop applications run.
 
But there are plenty of people who flat out say they don't want any change in Windows. They just want to run the same desktop apps the same way they have for years. I'm not saying that's everyone but resistance to change is part of what's going on here.[/QUOTE]

I swear, "change" was never defined as something unquestionably positive, as the shallow thinkers posting like this seem to think, until the 2008 presidential campaign.

Here's a clue, things can change for the worse. Were you aware of that? The possibility seems to escape you and the rest calling Windows 8 critics luddites. The overwhelmingly negative reaction to the Windows UI, by novices and it pros alike, is not because of some inherent resistance to change. It's because it's a clunky, disjointed, UI for those using a mouse and keyboard.

I have more tech in my home automation systems and server rack than most medium size businesses. I'm an early adopter. I'm no luddite, I just know the difference between a good user experience and a crappy one.
 
I swear, "change" was never defined as something unquestionably positive, as the shallow thinkers posting like this seem to think, until the 2008 presidential campaign.

I didn't say anything about positive or negative change, simply change itself. There are a lot of people that simply don't want ANYTHING to change in the Windows UI and just to want to run the same stuff that they have for years. They want the same old same old forever and always WITHOUT CHANGE. Look at all the people around even a place like this that think the Windows 2000 UI was fantastic or that still think XP was the best.
 
Does it even matter anymore?
Forcing Metro and being unable to go to desktop in 8 on launch did its damage.
Users that were frustrated beyond belief with 8 at launch didn't even bother to try 8.1, and honestly, can you blame them?
All we heard over and over is "its the future, get used to it" and now its "uhm, yeah, so we f#cked up and alienated our user base.... Sorry you weren't smart enough to get us, here's a bone."
Thank you Ubuntu and WINE for making my life better and helping to ditch these idiots.
 
Your assessment doesn't seem to be the majority view when it comes specifically to the Venue 8 Pro. I think everyone agrees that the Windows Store is well behind iOS and Android currently but it has improved significantly over the 15 months since Windows 8 went general release. The modern version of IE 11 I think compares very well to Chrome and Safari. One very nice advantage is Flash support, there's still tons on the web that's dependent on Flash and a lot of the apps for iOS and Android are often just web site replacements that work in Windows 8 though the apps are more touch friendly. Not really sure what issues you have with Windows 8's keyboard in modern apps, it's pretty good and has real time handwriting to text conversion which works well for me, got a good pen.

Well there is only one active pen at the moment that is compatible from Dell and its being redesigned due to the failures... I, on my second pen after a warranty replacement, got a decent one this time and it's actually accurate and usable, but still, how the hell do you type with a pen, that has to be god awful slow. Tablet keyboards like phone keyboards need thumbs.

I've gotten pretty quick with the split layout Windows offers, but my accuracy still isn't close to what it is on most of the android keyboards due mostly to the awkward layouts imo. The biggest thing is complete lack of customization of the keyboard, alternate keys when they actually show up are awkward, hold down for what seems like forever (at least a whole second wait) then drag to the alt key, VERY slow (not to mention most keys don't even have alt keys, seems only numbers on the full screen layout, you have to go in to a second keyboard screen, VERY SLOW for passwords). Then when and where the keyboard pops up is awkward (and completely missing on anything desktop which I almost understand due to the lack of application api support, but at the same time wish they would have tried to do something better), the input auto correction completely missing during most inputs, even in metro and metro IE (only occasionally does it seem to work and only on larger textboxes?). It seems very inconsistent when it does and does not pop up which completely eliminates any chance of the universal built-in keyboard spell check being terribly useful (hell blackberry figured this one out 5+ years ago and it worked great!). The transitions to keyboard url mode in metro IE isn't exactly elegant either, the right space bar magically turns in to a .com button ensuring you tap it unintentionally when you want a space (this bar is also used for searching so yes, you do actually use the space bar).

Not sure if this is an IE or Metro thing, but long pressing to select text to copy from a textbox especially, but occasionally just typical web pages is still somewhat buggy, sometimes not letting me select text at all. Then you just have UI oddities like long-pressing say images in metro IE instead of opening like a context menu you’d expect where you can do important things like copy the image URL or link URL or open in new tab you get the awkward black bar coming up from the bottom of the screen with two options, save picture or copy picture, that’s it. Also long-pressing links lacks the open in private tab, or copying link text which are both useful and used a lot (at least they got the copy link url in there!). Yes I'm a power user, but I want to do the things I'm used to doing and running in to oh it doesn't exist yet and who knows when it will every corner is frustrating to say the least. I’m glad the marketplace is getting better, but just because an app is in the marketplace doesn’t mean it’s half as good as the version whatever company made for android/iphone. I know devices in people’s hands will help this, but year Windows 8 is how many years old and how many devices have installed it now and it’s still like this?

I'm around Redmond (no not a msft employee), but I see the koolaid every day, and sometimes I wonder if the blue badges there even look out the many windows to see what else is out there and what actually is working... I've used a lot of devices, from my blackberry phones years ago to windows mobile, lots of android, and most of those in between (except Apple, aside from troubleshooting other peoples devices I've never owned a single Apple product and likely never will).
 
Look at all the people around even a place like this that think the Windows 2000 UI was fantastic or that still think XP was the best.

Is it really such a bad thing for someone to have a preference for a particular operating system's user interface that happens to also be old or outdated? I get it that lots of people are complaining a lot about having little squares on their screen instead of little icons or that they want a button that opens a cascading menu in the one corner they can poke/click/whatever, but who cares what someone else thinks? Yeah it gets old reading it on a forum, but its also dumbness to willingly expose yourself to it if it gets you upset or makes you wanna spend a ton of time trying to change opinions. It's like thinking that crimping is better than curling or that a friendship bracelet is better to wear than a pair of leg warmers. There's no reason at all to crusade for people you don't know and will never ever meet to stop putting on friendship bracelets and to go grab some leg warmers. It's just like mega pointless. If someone wears leg warmers because of what you said, it doesn't make even a little bit of a difference. Nothing substantial changes. The world still goes along with everyone singing, "Tra la la!" or downloading the same funny cat pics.
 
... It's because it's a clunky, disjointed, UI for those using a mouse and keyboard.

I have more tech in my home automation systems and server rack than most medium size businesses. I'm an early adopter. I'm no luddite, I just know the difference between a good user experience and a crappy one.

I actually find it very smooth, fast, and unified using a m/kb considerably more so than any previous iteration of Windows so much so I installed it on every system in the house and workshop.
 
Well there is only one active pen at the moment that is compatible from Dell and its being redesigned due to the failures... I, on my second pen after a warranty replacement, got a decent one this time and it's actually accurate and usable, but still, how the hell do you type with a pen, that has to be god awful slow. Tablet keyboards like phone keyboards need thumbs.

I don't type, I write in cursive. Been doing that on tablet PCs long before people were using thumbs on touchscreens, just something that I'm comfortable and good with, better than the average person with thumbs on a touch screen.

I've gotten pretty quick with the split layout Windows offers, but my accuracy still isn't close to what it is on most of the android keyboards due mostly to the awkward layouts imo. The biggest thing is complete lack of customization of the keyboard, alternate keys when they actually show up are awkward, hold down for what seems like forever (at least a whole second wait) then drag to the alt key, VERY slow (not to mention most keys don't even have alt keys, seems only numbers on the full screen layout, you have to go in to a second keyboard screen, VERY SLOW for passwords).

Whole second wait for the cues? That's not correct, at least it should only be about half that and then you can drag instantly in the direction of the character if you know where it is.

Then when and where the keyboard pops up is awkward (and completely missing on anything desktop which I almost understand due to the lack of application api support, but at the same time wish they would have tried to do something better), the input auto correction completely missing during most inputs, even in metro and metro IE (only occasionally does it seem to work and only on larger textboxes?).

The transitions to keyboard url mode in metro IE isn't exactly elegant either, the right space bar magically turns in to a .com button ensuring you tap it unintentionally when you want a space (this bar is also used for searching so yes, you do actually use the space bar).

True, but this is a url that's used also for entering urls .

Not sure if this is an IE or Metro thing, but long pressing to select text to copy from a textbox especially, but occasionally just typical web pages is still somewhat buggy, sometimes not letting me select text at all. Then you just have UI oddities like long-pressing say images in metro IE instead of opening like a context menu you’d expect where you can do important things like copy the image URL or link URL or open in new tab you get the awkward black bar coming up from the bottom of the screen with two options, save picture or copy picture, that’s it. Also long-pressing links lacks the open in private tab, or copying link text which are both useful and used a lot (at least they got the copy link url in there!). Yes I'm a power user, but I want to do the things I'm used to doing and running in to oh it doesn't exist yet and who knows when it will every corner is frustrating to say the least. I’m glad the marketplace is getting better, but just because an app is in the marketplace doesn’t mean it’s half as good as the version whatever company made for android/iphone. I know devices in people’s hands will help this, but year Windows 8 is how many years old and how many devices have installed it now and it’s still like this?

Don't really know what's going on here but here's a pic of what I think you're saying doesn't work but does:

Screenshot%20%2831%29%202.png


I'm around Redmond (no not a msft employee), but I see the koolaid every day, and sometimes I wonder if the blue badges there even look out the many windows to see what else is out there and what actually is working... I've used a lot of devices, from my blackberry phones years ago to windows mobile, lots of android, and most of those in between (except Apple, aside from troubleshooting other peoples devices I've never owned a single Apple product and likely never will).

Microcenter is selling the 64 GB Dell Venue 8 Pro for $250 currently. If Microsoft and it's OEMs can push a steady stream of devices at this price, quality and capability, Windows tablets may still be 3rd place, but they should sell in pretty solid numbers.
 
Is it really such a bad thing for someone to have a preference for a particular operating system's user interface that happens to also be old or outdated? I get it that lots of people are complaining a lot about having little squares on their screen instead of little icons or that they want a button that opens a cascading menu in the one corner they can poke/click/whatever, but who cares what someone else thinks?

You're bringing something into the discussion that I wasn't talking about. Right or wrong, up or down, cat or dog, there are plenty of people that have stated clearly in this Windows 8 debate that they don't want ANY change to the Windows UI and that they want to run the same old programs they've always run and that's it. Nothing else period. To say that resistance to change has nothing to do with part of Windows 8 perception problems is as tone deaf as those that accuse Microsoft of the same thing.
 
What ever happened to MS not doing service packs, and going on to the next number and charging the users a small amount for it every year?
 
You're bringing something into the discussion that I wasn't talking about. Right or wrong, up or down, cat or dog, there are plenty of people that have stated clearly in this Windows 8 debate that they don't want ANY change to the Windows UI and that they want to run the same old programs they've always run and that's it. Nothing else period. To say that resistance to change has nothing to do with part of Windows 8 perception problems is as tone deaf as those that accuse Microsoft of the same thing.

What's wrong with not wanting change? And who cares if someone else feels that way?
 
I actually find it very smooth, fast, and unified using a m/kb considerably more so than any previous iteration of Windows so much so I installed it on every system in the house and workshop.

Once you figure it can be ultra fast. I use a Microsoft touch mouse and there's gestures on that thing when used in conjunction with 8 that are incredibly efficient. Move mouse and click a Start Button for the Start Menu? Flick two fingers, Start Screen appears. Part of the problem with the perception of Windows 8 is that Windows users are entrenched in the "see and click" mentality. Mac users have for years praised track pad gestures which is something that Windows now actually has decent support for, unfortunately the hardware is still lacking. Intel and Microsoft are supposed to be working with track pad makers to solve these issues, including ones that have been long outstanding such as inadvertent touch pad clicks that screw up focus, even in Windows 7.
 
Be specific maybe? I'm just curious.

Change is simply the thing that we all deal with, one way or another. We grow older, our family situations change, our financial situations change. Laws change, political views change, social views change. Indeed if one believes in evolution, what we are changes. Existence with out change is death.
 
If Heatless was really into change, he wouldn't only be evangelizing new Microsoft products.

He would be buying and evangelizing Nexus tablets, Macs, and iPads, because that would be a change.

Instead he has THIRTY freaking thousand posts, all beating the same tired drum:

The total awesomeness of whatever Microsoft is currently doing.

We can count on him singing the Praises of Windows 8.2, 9.x, 10.x, no matter what direction they take. It will be awesome.

There is nothing more changeless than the constant Windows evangelizing from HLS, he has no shred of credibility to lecture others on their resistance to change.
 
You could at least talk about the changes in 8.1 Update 1 before going into some rant about me.
 
If Heatless was really into change, he wouldn't only be evangelizing new Microsoft products.

He would be buying and evangelizing Nexus tablets, Macs, and iPads, because that would be a change.

Instead he has THIRTY freaking thousand posts, all beating the same tired drum:

The total awesomeness of whatever Microsoft is currently doing.

We can count on him singing the Praises of Windows 8.2, 9.x, 10.x, no matter what direction they take. It will be awesome.

There is nothing more changeless than the constant Windows evangelizing from HLS, he has no shred of credibility to lecture others on their resistance to change.

Your post may make sense in your head, but it really doesn't make sense at all. You seem a bit upset also.
 
Your post may make sense in your head, but it really doesn't make sense at all. You seem a bit upset also.

I'm sure it does make sense to him, but it also had absolutely nothing to do with the changes rumored in 8.1 Update 1 in any way shape for form. What I'm finding more and more interesting about all of this 8 debate is that as time goes on, there's people that seem to use it and at least understand the point. Then there are those that seem to have nothing to offer other than yet another personal attack that adds nothing to the actual conversation.

I've never told anyone that was happy with Windows 7 that just wanted the same old desktop UI and desktop apps to upgrade as I've mentioned time and time again there's not a lot to be gained in those cases. I've said time and time again that the changes in Windows 8 were a direct response to tablets and that Windows needed to be more like those devices in order to stay relevant in the consumer space. I've said time and time again that the desktop and modern UI need to be better integrated and that Windows 8 needs to become more familiar to desktop only users.

Why do I like Windows 8? Because it will run on everything from a cheap 8" tablet to a multiple screen desktop monster. OS X, iOS and Android can't do that. That's not to say that any of those OSes don't bring a lot to the table and I've said long ago that the iPad is revolutionary. But a Dell Venue 8 Pro with 4 times the storage and twice the memory with the same DPI as the original iPad mini can be had new for $50 dollars less and the V8P can run Eclipse, Visual Studio, Photoshop, etc. While not revolutionary it's hard to believe that someone would argue against a 13 ounce cheap device being able to do things that iPads and Android tablets can't do. It's beyond hypocritical to preach to me about choice while hating it.
 
you can't be monological about this. windows isn't some silver bullet because it can be installed on many devices; what can you expect a machine with an 8-inch display "running" visual studio to really offer, for example? I'm prepping a windows VM in OS X for visual studio work, and I expect it to be far less cumbersome, honestly. :)
 
Back
Top