Windows 7 vs Windows Server vs Ubuntu for a File Server

af22

Gawd
Joined
Jun 21, 2010
Messages
610
Hello,

Currently i am using my HTPC (windows 7) to serve double duty as my file/media server. Are there any benefits of switching to an server class operating system in terms of file server / network performance?

My only purpose is to see if i could get any better performance, and in addition add more data integrity by raiding some of the drives.

Thanks.
 
What performance problem(s) are you having? Is all your network gear gigabit? What hardware is in the HTPC currently?
 
Are you equally comfortable with Linux as Windows. If not then I would not advise switching to it. The network performance is the same in both OS's and is going to be limited by your hardware/network.
 
Well Linux/BSD would allow you to team several cheap gigabit NICs together and allow a multigigabit link, if gigabit if not enough. On Windows that would only work with the proprietary drivers from dualport NICs like Intel's.

But yeah it's not like Windows can't saturate gigabit; though SMB/CIFS protocol sucks but you can't get around that.
 
to be perfectly honest, i dont have any problems with my current system. my ssd recently fried which made me rethink my data integrity across my desktop and laptop (since i have ssd in both computers).

my primary question is whether windows 7 file serving capability is as good as windows server.

my HTPC is the follow:

AMD Phenom 710 (tri core)
6GB RAM
1TB OS / Music / Photo Drive
1TB DVR for Windows Media Center Drive
2TB Storage Drive
60GB Thrash Drive for Sabnzbd / uTorrent

Since everything runs off individual drives, I rarely notice any performance hit except only when the CPU maxes out. The only limitation I have is my nforce chipset network card does not support jumbo frames. =( And my WD Green drives are slow =(. I have all gigabit switches that support jumbo frames and cat6e wiring.
 
my primary question is whether windows 7 file serving capability is as good as windows server.

nice thing about WHS is the backup feature for win7 systems (typical htpc). I enjoy the 'set it and forget it' approach to my home network.

the performance ideally comes from your drives/controller/network.

AMD Phenom 710 (tri core)
6GB RAM
1TB OS / Music / Photo Drive
1TB DVR for Windows Media Center Drive
2TB Storage Drive
60GB Thrash Drive for Sabnzbd / uTorrent

if you are doing all of that on your HTPC, god help you! :p
 
I've ran WHS and Ubuntu Server on my MSI Wind Nettop. I first ran Ubuntu, which took some time to setup. Had quite a few problems with the Ethernet not coming back up to 1000 Mbps when suspended. Everything else was simple to setup and I enjoyed knowing what the system was setup to do. No overhead to, which is great for a system this week. Running WHS now and its definitely a lot easier than linux. My desktop (Win7) found it no problem and I have regularly scheduled backups. Problem is, its really slow when try to make changes. Sometimes WHS has to "organize" the drives and that means no writing or reading to them. This can take a while with my system. If your looking for simplicity, WHS, if you want something that does EXACTLY what you want, Ubuntu server.
 
Back
Top