Windows 10 Is Broken: Fix It, Microsoft!

I have to stick with MS in this case. For the corporate environment its easily controlled and not an issue.

For the private user its a tad harder. But again, lets be honest, year after year the attempt to make people update their PCs so they dont suffer from old exploits have failed. Mandatory type updates is simply required. And I dont have an issue with it on the home front. The only PC at home I modified in that regard is the HTPC.
 
YAWN....

Seriously, I have no issues and I am on WIndows 10. I guess that this isn't "cool" for a tech site where a lot of ALT OS nerds gather to talk about their OS like annoying hipsters like to talk about shitty bands that no one cares about as being better, but cést la vie. Because I know just like those hipsters, if their OS ever "got big", they'd ditch it and then say it sucked, just so they can find some new obscure OS to put on a pedestal.

Not saying WIndows is the be all end all - far from it. But most of the bitching I read about it makes people sound like some baby boomer giving a "when I was your age" spiel...

Linux hipsters huh?

Windows 10 is Microsoft's attempt to collect info the way Android and iOS do. Only a fool would laugh at people who want to control their own machines. I've seen you around and think you're prone projecting a lot.

Windows is still better when it comes to GUI and not all games have Linux ports. But they will come.
 
The more I read on win10 the more I wonder how the hell are people actually switching to it and saying it's "fine"? If my computer is self rebooting without my consent I would be so pissed off. Especially if there is no way to change it. It is *MY* computer, not Microsoft's. They should not have the right to take it over like that. Sadly, they do, because it's probably embedded deep within the EULA that they do. But why do people allow this.

As the author of that article said, a computer is a tool. When a tool starts to stop you from using it, it is a bad tool.

Imagine a world where self driving cars are now widespread. Imagine you're on your way to work, suddenly the car hits a certain mileage, and then does a U turn and goes to the dealership for a tuneup because it's due, without your consent. You're now stuck in the car while robots are doing the tune up, your cell phone is disabled for your safety so you can't call in to work to explain that you're late. You eventually get fired. That is basically what windows 10 is doing with your computer. It's taking it over and doing whatever the hell it wants. Spying on you, rebooting at will, not allowing you to customize it at all. You have to submit to it.

Where I work, this different IT department basically took over years back, nobody really knows who they are, but they're in some office somewhere in a tower and call the shots and do all the GPO stuff. They tend to do forced reboots at the worse times, basically you get a message and have 20 minutes to reboot or it does it on it's own. We've all fought this and lost. Even high up management. Even *THE* main sysadmin has no say. I can't fathom the idea of my own personal computer at home doing this to me and having zero say. Complete insanity.
 
It hasn't caused me any problems. In fact 10 has been the smoothest OS I've used since I started on Win 3.1.

Just relax and go with the flow. Life is too short to have a stroke over it all.
 
years out of date

i've got to love this "you're out of date there for sky is falling" straw-man. I've ran many a system 24/7 *and* connected to the internet *gasp* - and sky's ever fell. From Win95, Win98, Win2k, WinXP, Win7 for up to 5 years even.

Just because a software developer wants you to update because the hax0rz, doesn't really mean your system will burn down the moment a new version number comes out and the sky falls because oh no you don't have the latest telemtry update patch!
 
This was a problem I've said before Windows 10 was released. To this day I'm afraid my PC will shutdown when MS feels like doing it, cause it has rebooted my machine while I'm using it. But this is why I only have 1 Windows PC, which is mainly for gaming.

They'll never fix that because no one is leaving Windows in droves. Until they start feeling it in their wallet they won't care. And, there is no viable option to Windows. No matter how much you want it to be, Linux is not a viable option.
Says the person who never uses Linux. The only reason I haven't replaced my one Windows machine is because the games haven't been ported over to Linux. Wine is unable to emulate most of my games as well. Even Skyrim can be a problem.
 
This isn't the case, I know of many people who are in the middle of doing work, and the sytem restarts to install an update, not giving the user a chance to save their work. I understand your point, if that was the case. But mid stream of doing something and a reboot happens for an update is wrong period.

I was in the middle of a game.

BAM. Minimized out.

"You need some updates."

No. There is no planet on which this is acceptable.

"Active hours" can only be 12 hours consecutively--and only defined on a very simple schedule (say 8AM to 8PM). Heaven forbid someone play games at 8:01PM. Outside that, Microsoft views it as fair game to do whatever the hell it wants with update shenanigans.
 
The only reason I haven't replaced my one Windows machine is because the games haven't been ported over to Linux.
Thank you for making my point for me.

it will never be unfortunately.
You cannot make a viable OS that can marketed to the masses with the fragmentation of Linux. They MUST make one version that has serious corporate backing to compete. If they want to have a billion other versions that's fine, but until they have ONE version backed and supported it doesn't matter how negative my thinking is, it won't be a viable option.

Tell that to the people who ditched Windows long ago... for Linux.
What, all 12 of them?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
There's a KB fix for this that came out last December.

Yes and it takes 12 hours to install. I just went through this on 3 different laptops on Friday. Always fun when you have to move an employee to another desk to accommodate Microsoft's crap.
 
This is pure clickbait. C'mon. You can tell Windows 10 to never reset the PC to finish an update within certain "active hours". You don't lose any work, nor download time as the post suggests (what service is this guy using that can't resume a download???).

Seriously, you gotta be kidding me. I've used Windows 10 for the past 2 years and I have never, ever had the system just reset because it felt like it. I set my hours from 7AM-7PM and set update time at 3AM: if my PC happens to be on all night, it'll restart at 3AM, otherwise, the update will finalize whenever I turn it off.

Then, after saying that Windows Update is the worst because it restarts whenever it wants (untrue) the article provides its own solution of 12h active hours and says that's also bad. If you can't reset your PC at any point in 12 hour you have problems. If you need to not reset your PC in a day, then you're likely a business and should be using the non-consumer-focused Pro version of Windows (legally speaking) and use Windows Update for Business which lets you defer updates. Problem gone.

Active hours are not long enough in some situations. Needing to have a system active for more than a 12 hour period is not a problem. There are programs that can take days to process. Not everyone can switch to enterprise. So no this isn't clickbait. Just because something works for you doesn't mean it works for everyone else.
 
The KB in question has taken 5 minutes to install, including Googling/downloading time, on every system I've ever run it on.

Your experience does not invalidate my own. Each machine was started at 8am and didn't finish until the evening when I RDP'd in to check on them.
 
Your experience does not invalidate my own. Each machine was started at 8am and didn't finish until the evening when I RDP'd in to check on them.

My experience certainly means yours is not the authoritative, final version as your posts imply. And it certainly betrays a lack of preparation on your part. Install the KB on your stock system image and push it out to your computers when you know there's an issue, not when it's time to update them and you have an enormous update glut pending. This goes double if you're relying on Windows Update direct from Microsoft and not an enterprise WSUS deployment, or an alternative like KACE.
 
My experience certainly means yours is not the authoritative, final version as your posts imply. And it certainly betrays a lack of preparation on your part. Install the KB on your stock system image and push it out to your computers when you know there's an issue, not when it's time to update them and you have an enormous update glut pending. This goes double if you're relying on Windows Update direct from Microsoft and not an enterprise WSUS deployment, or an alternative like KACE.

We use WSUS but when the systems refuse to take their updates due to a missing KB it's not much help. We do not have a stock image because we don't have a stock platform (waiting on management, forever.) The fact that you interpret my posts as authoritative is your problem, not mine.
 
We use WSUS but when the systems refuse to take their updates due to a missing KB it's not much help. We do not have a stock image because we don't have a stock platform (waiting on management, forever.) The fact that you interpret my posts as authoritative is your problem, not mine.

You don't need a stock platform to have a stock image. Use Windows PE to create a stock image and install them locally through USB when devices cross your desk. Use GPO or even a batch script to push out the KB to already deployed devices.

The fact that you hinder yourself by creating excuses is your problem, not mine. Enjoy your 12 hour waits.
 
If you don't know how to set Active Hours, or set to a Metered connection, you shouldn't be on [H] whining about those "problems."
 
My favorite is how you see people talking about how they are trying their hardest to NOT update their PC.

When updates are known to break and brick shit? Can you HONESTLY blame them?
 
  • Like
Reactions: DPI
like this
Anecdotal evidence I know, but I've been running Win10 on 2 laptops and my main desktop since it was released and I haven't had a single major problem. One or two minor issues, but it's not like Win7/8/8.1 didn't also have a few minor issues as well.
 
I agree. They need to fix it. Is it broken? Not really. It's working as intended. But, there are TONS and TONS of complaints. Like Windows 8.1 Start Screen, when there is that many people complaining about a "feature", there is a problem.
 
They'll never fix that because no one is leaving Windows in droves. Until they start feeling it in their wallet they won't care. And, there is no viable option to Windows. No matter how much you want it to be, Linux is not a viable option.

It is for me. I've been migrating my systems to Mint Linux and have been very happy with it. All the applications I use (jEdit, Firefox, Thunderbird, Libre Office, Octave, g++, etc) are available under Linux so the transition has been painless. Brother actually provides a Linux driver for the 2 multifunction printers we have. I'm currently in the process of migrating my wifey's machines to Linux too.
 
I agree. They need to fix it. Is it broken? Not really. It's working as intended. But, there are TONS and TONS of complaints. Like Windows 8.1 Start Screen, when there is that many people complaining about a "feature", there is a problem.

I agree with you, they need to reconsider how they implement this feature.

Where I work, I'm not bound by desktop management (yet), and I was able to move to win 10. I'm still tracking, but it's looking like it will cost my employer about 1 hour a week on average of lost productivity. For having to shut everything down and get back to the context I last had before the weekly update. At my effective hourly rate, that isn't cheap over the course of a year. For managed desktops, we still run windows 7.

The biggest, most universally problematic issue with windows updates is less the OS patches, and more the feeding you 3rd party drives via MS. They get that wrong often enough to be a problem, and when it's wrong, it's a giant PITA.

Then of course there is the fact that while making the security argument, they ignore lots of things like browsers that are a primary vector of attack.
 
You cannot make a viable OS that can marketed to the masses with the fragmentation of Linux. They MUST make one version that has serious corporate backing to compete. If they want to have a billion other versions that's fine, but until they have ONE version backed and supported it doesn't matter how negative my thinking is, it won't be a viable option.

Part of me agrees, part of me knows that once you get over the prejudice and use a preinstalled linux (side stepping the fact that the install is easier than Windows install) 9 out of 10 general consumers use it just happily. I personally haven't found even one non-gamer who wouldn't use linux fluently. It's actually more familiar to most than Windows 8 for example.
 
I agree. They need to fix it. Is it broken? Not really. It's working as intended. But, there are TONS and TONS of complaints. Like Windows 8.1 Start Screen, when there is that many people complaining about a "feature", there is a problem.


Unfortunately, we now live in a childlike age whereby everyone appears to think they have a god given right to piss their pants like a baby in outrage at any little hassle life throws at them. The tiniest little issue then gets blown out of all proportion as these sheep like idiots band together to moan and whine about something that really isn't that big an issue.

Pussies.
 
If you don't know how to set Active Hours, or set to a Metered connection, you shouldn't be on [H] whining about those "problems."

Except when Active Hours are ignored. They're ignored on my wife's computer on a regular basis. To the point where she's scared to death of using the computer when working on her grad school work. She never knows when that stupid piece of shit operating system is going to reboot. The first time it happened I thought I had screwed something up so of course I apologized profusely to the wife as I was getting yelled at and double checked everything. All was set properly. I thought...well maybe it was a fluke. Nope, as it happened again and then again. It might be a bug but that's one pretty fucking inexcusable bug.

As soon as my wife is done with grad school (next semester thankfully) and she no longer needs MS Office, I'm blowing away that shit operating system and moving her onto Linux and then onto a simple Chromebook when the laptop dies.
 
I seem to have an issue where joining any windows 10 PC to a domain disables all built in apps including the start menu. Have not been able to locate a fix yet, rather aggravating.


With Windows 10 you have to be careful with changes to your GPO in the section Configuration->Policies->Administrative Templates->Start Menu and Taskbar because it can break the Windows 10 Start Menu in some way, so you will need to ask yourself if you need those settings for legacy devices, and if so you may need to make a WMI filter, so it just applies to them.
 
If you're leaving unsaved work up when leaving your PC for long periods of time... you deserve whatever you get. Windows update, power surge, or Jimmy the janitor knocking the plug out of the wall / the cat walking across the keyboard. Nothing wrong with the update system, something wrong with the user.
It's not just about saving. When working on art, losing your undos can be as crippling as losing the current project.
Similar to this is losing all your "backs" in your browser when you've been browsing for references or textures.

Also, a lot of the work is done by the computer itself. You can easily leave the computer rendering for 30 or 40 hours after each project. If you come back after 30 hours to check if the rendering is done and find that the computer rebooted, you don't only lose whatever amount of time the computer has been idle since the reboot. Video files can't be continued from where you left off. You have to start the render all over again.

And there's also the fact that just opening a project file will usually take upwards of 7 hours. When you come back to a rebooted computer, you know that you'll be useless for the next 7 hours while you reload the project.

And what about the files that the studio only offers in streaming formats? Sometimes you have to download 8 or 10 4K reference videos. So you leave them buffering and come back 5 hours later to see if they're done and the computer has rebooted and you've lost all the buffering and have to start all over again.

But the main issue is that even something as low-level and critical as the video drivers can now be updated without rebooting. Just a few years ago, I would have voted for video drivers as the least likely component to be able to be updated without rebooting. If Windows updated can't do the same it's because they are not trying hard enough.

And that's not even considering the moral issue of someone else deciding for me when to reboot (or when to do anything, really) to -MY- computer.

This is why I don't have a cat. This is why only I am allowed to do the cleaning in the computer room. This is why I have a 30-minute UPS. This is why I have a diesel generator for longer outages.
 
Unfortunately, we now live in a childlike age whereby everyone appears to think they have a god given right to piss their pants like a baby in outrage at any little hassle life throws at them. The tiniest little issue then gets blown out of all proportion as these sheep like idiots band together to moan and whine about something that really isn't that big an issue.

Pussies.

It's not that big of an issue (I restart when needed and haven't had a problem at all with forced restarts). People bitch because the internet is a perfect platform for it. Instant, seen my millions, you start to get the mob with their torches and pitchforks, and open to anyone.

If it can make the OS better, then great. Listen to the customers. For some, it's solid and good feedback. For others, it's just whining and bitching. Take the constructive criticism and leave the bitching and moaning...
 
I really hate when I'm playing a game and it decides that it wants to bump me out of said game to schedule updates. Like seriously leave me the fuck alone i'll do that when i want, not when you want.
 
More updates delivered faster, now with less QA! Would could possibly go wrong.
 
Just kill windows update, then restart it when you want to update. Looks like the best solution. And if that doesn't work one day then a 3rd party program will make it happen.
 
My main issue is the pop up that blocks the entire screen. I use the PC's as a static display for dispatching at the FD. This stupid thing comes up and I dont know until I get a phone call from someone stating it needs an update or it just stays there till my next shift. Just let me pick when I want to update. Kiosk mode would be nice for this if it wasnt tied to a windows app.
 
Yet even with the patch installed, it can still take hours for Windows 7 updates to run.

Not in my experience. I've installed the KB and then updated Windows 7 SP1 fresh installs directly over Windows Update. Took about an hour for the 120-odd updates to download, took another hour to install and reboot. Alternatively, I could have used the Windows 7 Convenience Rollup, which would likely have been quicker, but I didn't have it on hand and didn't see a benefit to downloading it at that time over letting Windows Update process normally.
 
Windows 10 is Microsoft's attempt to collect info the way Android and iOS do.

Microsoft did telemetry before Windows 10, and then backported Windows 10's telemetry to Windows 7 and 8.1. Additionally, iOS' data collection is opt-in and anonymized, so it doesn't fit in your analogy.
 
Your experience does not invalidate my own. Each machine was started at 8am and didn't finish until the evening when I RDP'd in to check on them.

It feels like you two are talking past each other. Is it taking 5 hours for the KB fix to apply from WSUS, or is it taking 5 hours to install the msu manually from a download?
 
It's exactly the reason I had to resort to blocking Windows Updates completely.

I've said this in a few other threads. But I've had numerous occasions where WU fails to update in "non active hours" because an app (like Photoshop) prevents it from rebooting. There's no option to tell it to force the reboot, so it fails.

Next day I get back to work and occasionally will need a reboot (driver crash, etc.), now my options are "Shutdown/Reboot and Update" .. or to hard reset (pull power).

Often, when I select Reboot and Update, it'll take 5minutes and do its thing. But sometimes, an update is corrupted (or needs a secondary patch to install) and it has to revert changes and reboot a couple more times (now it's been between 10-15min since I wanted to simply reboot).

Worst part, the damn WU will reflag itself in an hour, so you'll get the "Shutdown/Reboot and Update" options and do it all over again (even though it failed, it'll endlessly do this loop). To fix it, you have to then search for why that update is failing, clear caches, install hotfixes, and do everything else but work.

The fix I suggest:
- Add an option to force reboots during non active hours. This doesn't fix the fail-to-install updates.

- Readd (it was removed) the option to Shutdown/Reboot without updating. I shouldn't have to resort to pulling the plug

TLDr;
Article is right. WU currently sucks for trying to get work done on Enterprise (what I have) versions.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top