will laptops one day replace desktop computers? i hope not.

euteamo

n00b
Joined
Dec 21, 2003
Messages
55
do you guys think that someday laptops will replace desktops? i really don't like that idea one bit! what do you think?
 
Originally posted by euteamo
do you guys think that someday laptops will replace desktops? i really don't like that idea one bit! what do you think?

Mine already does. My desktop has a 533MHz FSB, non-HT 2.8GHz P4 with PC1066RDRAM.

My notebook has an 800MHz FSB, HT-enabled 3.2GHz P4 with dual-channel DDR400 RAM.
 
i dont think they will anytime soon. biggest reason for that is price and cost of making the machines. i think that if the laptop maker industry gets together and starts making parts and peices that are more interchangeable than just the ram, then they will be on thier way to replacing desktops. currently a laptop costs so much becouse you and i cannot buy the parts to build one. until they get a standard and start following it, i will never take a laptop over my desktop...dont care about speed or looks.
 
Well I can not say for sure that they will but with the many improvements that keep coming out for laptops maybe it might happen.
 
i don't think so.

laptops are nice and come in convienient packages, but they don't match cost vs power of desktops, and i believe, never will. desktops have the ability to upgrade, while laptops do too, technically, its almost not worth it most of the time.

and with the prices of desktops really cheap (especially from distributors like dell and compaq) laptops can't compete in price. i mean for 400 you can get a piece of crap desktop that most families will actually not mind using...that comes w/ a cheap ass lcd and POS speakers...against a laptop that you might buy for 400 bucks, that's pretty good i think
 
Originally posted by Tekara
there's a better chance for PDA's to replace laptops then there is for a laptop to replace a Desktop. Current PDAs are just amazing, they can handle most of the minor functions of a PC and their small size makes them far more convienient for travelers.

This man has the right idea, Tablet/PDA style will replace larger laptops.

Desktops will be around long after the change takes place. But eventually I think they will change, mabey more geared towards more discrete systems that are based somewhere int he house or office which screens and input devices work off of a wireless system. Pretty much like todays lan's but with no more tower at the work station and almost zero wires. The main system would probibly sort out all traffic (screen, inputs, etc..) like a central CPU.

Its the wave of the future man, its like the year 2000:D Wheres my flying car?
 
i think laptops will replace desktops eventually but not in the current way of things. its a ways off
 
they might one day, or some type of laptop. I dont see anyone getting past the size of the screen which is a major advantage desktops have until someone makes a neural interface. Or some neat little thing that goes over the eyes, like a mini projection device type thingie mabob du flickie.
 
companies like Intel, ATI, Nvidia, and AMD do not worry too much about how much power their top of the line stuff uses, It takes a while to refine it so it uses less power, and they want to have their fastest stuff out ASAP so they can stay competetive.

there will always be something faster that uses more power and runs hotter, so it can not go in a laptop.

also 3 1/4 hard drives use more power to perform so well,

however laptops allready can replace mid range desktops, especiialy the way a lot of manufacturers cheap out with shared ram etc.
 
Laptops will most likely never replace desktops, at least not until there is a standard for the internal hardware inside them. Consumers are always going to want the expandability of desktops. You can put in them what you want, and upgrade at will. You can't exactly go to the local computer store and purchase an upgraded video card for you laptop... Laptops are limited to space as well. No room for a second hard drive or a second optical drive. Consumers will most likely ALWAYS want the expandability and size of desktops for their primary machines, i know i will.

I love my laptop, it's great and i use it all the time, but i'll never replace my desktop.
 
Originally posted by euteamo
do you guys think that someday laptops will replace desktops? i really don't like that idea one bit! what do you think?

On some applications ... it already does ... I have a friend who work for a company that only uses laptops ... but some form of the desktop will stay, specially for home and enthusiast use ..
 
Yea unless the day comes where I can build my own laptop just by ordering parts and a case I don't think laptops will takeover the desktop. Too pricey atm, I've been wanting to pickup a laptop for awhile now, but still holding out untill one fits my pricerange.
 
For that to happen, laptops would need to be upgradeable as much (or nearly so) as desktops. This would require some very big changes to the designs of lappys and the manufacturers would have to adopt form factors, similar to desktops. Alienware is on the right track, but remember that the upgradeable video is only one facet of what can be done to a desktop machine. Nowadays, the gaming community is driving much of the push towards better/faster technology, so suddenly telling this huge market that they can no longer have the fastest PC to play on/with is going to make big waves.

Also, having a laptop server is pretty pointless, so there's already one market that will need desktop-style PCs for years to come, unless, of course, servers witness a major design change.
 
other than servers, laptops probably will replace desktops..... just like people were saying cell phones would never replace land lines a few years ago, now i know people who are considering canceling their land line phones because they dont use them
 
Originally posted by Bitchnmoan
For that to happen, laptops would need to be upgradeable as much (or nearly so) as desktops. This would require some very big changes to the designs of lappys and the manufacturers would have to adopt form factors, similar to desktops. Alienware is on the right track, but remember that the upgradeable video is only one facet of what can be done to a desktop machine. Nowadays, the gaming community is driving much of the push towards better/faster technology, so suddenly telling this huge market that they can no longer have the fastest PC to play on/with is going to make big waves.

Also, having a laptop server is pretty pointless, so there's already one market that will need desktop-style PCs for years to come, unless, of course, servers witness a major design change.

On my laptop, I can upgrade the CPU, RAM, hard drive, optical drive, and motherboard (and thus, the GPU).
 
Originally posted by skritch
On my laptop, I can upgrade the CPU, RAM, hard drive, optical drive, and motherboard (and thus, the GPU).
How difficult and how expensive? Doubling the drive space on my desktop (ok, under desktop :p ) with a 2nd drive can be done in about 10 minutes and $50; I'm not certain I would like to undertake that task in my current laptop. That'll be another problem with a laptop-only world, at least until economy-of-scale kicks in. It may happen someday, but it's going to require some serious changes in how the vast majority of lappys are built.
 
Originally posted by Bitchnmoan
How difficult and how expensive? Doubling the drive space on my desktop (ok, under desktop :p ) with a 2nd drive can be done in about 10 minutes and $50; I'm not certain I would like to undertake that task in my current laptop. That'll be another problem with a laptop-only world, at least until economy-of-scale kicks in. It may happen someday, but it's going to require some serious changes in how the vast majority of lappys are built.


The CPU is an off-the-shelf P4.
The hard drive is a standard notebook hard drive.
The optical drives are standard notebook optical drives.
The motherboard and GPU upgrade is $600-700. Considering that's roughly what it costs to buy a decent desktop motherboard and top of the line desktop GPU (and that I'd be getting a decent notebook motherboard and top of the line notebook GPU), that's perfectly comparable.


As for ease, it's trivial. Then again, I'm comfortable with hardware.
 
I would suspect that your PC is not the current norm. What brand did you buy, and did you buy it with the ability to upgrade in mind, or is that just a pleasant side benefit of your purchase?
 
Originally posted by Bitchnmoan
I would suspect that your PC is not the current norm. What brand did you buy, and did you buy it with the ability to upgrade in mind, or is that just a pleasant side benefit of your purchase?

Sager 5680. And yes, one of the main reasons I bought it was its upgradeability. The other main reason is that it's equally as powerful as today's top-of-the-line P4 desktops (3.2GHz HT P4, 800MHz FSB, 1GB dual-channel DDR400, 60GB 7200RPM IDE HD, 128MB Radeon 9600Pro Turbo, GigE, 8x DVD-RW, 1600x1200 LCD, full-sized keyboard, built-in BlueTooth and 802.11a/b/g).
 
Back
Top