Widescreen TV and Widescreen DVDs

Robizzle01

Limp Gawd
Joined
Sep 30, 2005
Messages
159
So I have been trying to read up on this without much luck. I've talked to some friends that should be in the know, but alas, I am here asking.

I just recently bought a new widescreen lcd tv (1080p.) I am using my xbox with the hd component cables as my dvd player and noticed peculiar behaviour with the screen size/shape. Sometimes a dvd will fill almost the entire screen, other times the black bars on the top and bottom are fairly tall. This occurs not only on dvds but also in downloaded stuff that I play back in xbox media center.

It was my understanding when I bought the TV that the black bars on movies may not dissapear compleatly, however they should be very thin since any difference in screen ratio would be minor. Are dvds marked as "widescreen" really just 4:3 video with black bars included in each frame, or is it true 16:9ish where none of the frame is a black bar? This is counterintuitive, but if I have a widescreen tv maybe I should be buying non-widescreen dvds?

I guess what I really need is a test dvd that has a chapter for each of the common ratios where the picture shows me a ruler so I can go up to my tv and check if any skewing or clipping is occuring. I can't figure out if my tv is working as intended, if xbox media center is working as inteded, and/or if dvd manufacturers are just bastards without some standards. Anyone know of a dvd like this or be able to whip one up fairly easily?

I wouldn't bother asking about this except that the black bars are pretty damn big sometimes but yet the picture goes all the way from the left edge to the right edge of the screen. XBMC allows me to streatch the image but its hard to tell if i'm skewing the image or correcting it. Worst part is, its different for every dvd I try then on top of that we have widescreen and regular versions of all of those ... bleh.
 
If the TV is marked as a 16:9 TV, then a 16:9 widescreen DVD will fill up the entire screen. There are other widescreen formats, such as 16:10, however, or anamorphic:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anamorphic

The same thing goes with the downloaded video. If it isn't the proper aspect ratio, the black bars will appear.
 
Robizzle01 said:
So I have been trying to read up on this without much luck. I've talked to some friends that should be in the know, but alas, I am here asking.

I just recently bought a new widescreen lcd tv (1080p.) I am using my xbox with the hd component cables as my dvd player and noticed peculiar behaviour with the screen size/shape. Sometimes a dvd will fill almost the entire screen, other times the black bars on the top and bottom are fairly tall. This occurs not only on dvds but also in downloaded stuff that I play back in xbox media center.

It was my understanding when I bought the TV that the black bars on movies may not dissapear compleatly, however they should be very thin since any difference in screen ratio would be minor. Are dvds marked as "widescreen" really just 4:3 video with black bars included in each frame, or is it true 16:9ish where none of the frame is a black bar? This is counterintuitive, but if I have a widescreen tv maybe I should be buying non-widescreen dvds?

I guess what I really need is a test dvd that has a chapter for each of the common ratios where the picture shows me a ruler so I can go up to my tv and check if any skewing or clipping is occuring. I can't figure out if my tv is working as intended, if xbox media center is working as inteded, and/or if dvd manufacturers are just bastards without some standards. Anyone know of a dvd like this or be able to whip one up fairly easily?

I wouldn't bother asking about this except that the black bars are pretty damn big sometimes but yet the picture goes all the way from the left edge to the right edge of the screen. XBMC allows me to streatch the image but its hard to tell if i'm skewing the image or correcting it. Worst part is, its different for every dvd I try then on top of that we have widescreen and regular versions of all of those ... bleh.


well, there are three standards, 1.3333:1 (4:3), 1.7777:1 (16:9), and 2.35:1 (don't know the whole number ratio).

2.35:1 is cinema widescreen, most movies are made in this format. when played on 16:9 televisions, you get black bars on the top and bottom.


buying 'full-screen' dvd's will actually make things look worse, since everything will be stretched and look bloated.
 
rayman2k2 said:
well, there are three standards, 1.3333:1 (4:3), 1.7777:1 (16:9), and 2.35:1 (don't know the whole number ratio).


Doing a little math: its 47:20 :)
 
full screen dvd's also do not show everything that was meant to be seen as they crop out the most important part onto the screen and fail to show what the director wanted you to see. this is my number one reason for buying the widescreen version of the movie.
 
soooooooome dvds that I have say widescreen, but it does have the black bars at the bottom and top. It reaches both the left and right side of my screen, but not a full picture. I dont think its really a problem, just some movies have it.

what im really wondering is my widescreen LCD tv was showing cable television in widescreen. every single channel looked completely fine in widescreen. none of the logos like cnn or mtv were out of the picture (like when you zoom-in). I was amazed that regular cable could do that. Then I tried this one option out "Dnie demo" and the widescreen was gone!. could never get it back. Some channels even look like they support widescreen, but When I try it out in widescreen. it doesnt look right, it wants a zoomed in view.. but then the logos are out of the screen.
 
One thing that gets alot of people just getting into HDTV's with DVDs is the failure to set monitor type on the source device. The xbox has the tv settings section which allows you to choose resolution and screen type. Make sure it is set for 16x9 or you will have a really screwed up output of video, which will result in abnormally large black bars and you will never have the correct video displayed on screen.
 
Back
Top