Why You Should Avoid Core 2 Engineering Samples

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
TechARP updated their article on why one should avoid Core 2 engineering sample (ES) CPUs. If you’re new to the ES world or are considering purchasing one of these at a discount, check the article out. All of my ES Conroe, Kentsfield, Wolfdale, and Yorkfield CPUs have had one issue or another; nothing show-stopping but they definitely aren’t as stable as retail units in certain applications. Caveat emptor.

Unfortunately, engineering samples aren't what you think they are. As far as the Core 2 engineering samples that are sold out there are concerned, they should really be considered defective goods, rather than special handpicked samples.
 
To expound on my post, I've had ES CPUs that had issues like one core is not as stable as others when overclocking, the CPU temp sensor is malfunctioning and reporting wildly different temps, and an inability to hit even mild OC numbers without stability issues. When running fully stock, these CPUs are perfect.

However, as always, YMMV as I've seen people hitting great numbers with their ES CPUs.

Here's Intel's official word about ES CPUs.
 
What about QS processors? Those should be just as good as production CPUs, right?
 
I used to play around with a few engineering samples. They were really meant to allow testing of the line of CPU's from the low to the top without having to send out multiple samples. This really helped out testers do up various configurations to help with driver development and QA in other areas not related to CPUs. As for overclocking, I've always found retail samples to be of higher quality and to an actual higher standard as ES modules are usually early runs anyways.
 
I've got a QX6700 B1(ES) cpu, It must be one of the better ones then as It has gotten as fast as 3.51GHz for months on end doing Seti 24/7, I've this cpu since the Retail QX6700 B3 cpus came out and Yes I also have a QX6700 B3 cpu too. :D
 
I had a E8400ES but i got rid of it as no matter any overclock or voltage, it was not stable. It would only run stable half the time at default clock. Was completely horrible.
 
I'm running an ES E6700 and an ES Q6700. I use to think that the E6700 was causing problems but it turned out to be a specific application. The Q6700 hasn't had any issue, now that I've got it going.

FLG FTW ;)
 
I used to work at intel`s post silicon Validation lab in for mobile CPU`s until recently

i can tell you that the beating taken by those units are extreme , they are ran for many weeks non-stop at full load @ 100-105c (using swiftech IsoTherms) and also ran for week at -5 and -10

of all of this is to check how chips work at extreme conditions , but after a project ends , those chips are given to employees (1 per employee per year)

oh , and they are NOT commercial stepping
 
I am sitting here with a ES QX9750 trying to figure out what bored to put it in. The ES E6600 I am currently running is working perfect. It replaced the ES Pentium D 830 which replace the ES Pentium 4 3.6. Even the two ES T2700s work great. Never had an issue with getting these working properly.
 
Back
Top