Why Intel Picking Up AMD Might Make Sense

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
Several years ago people wouldn't have given much thought to Intel buying up AMD simply because both were the major competitors in the same market and it would have been considered a monopoly for Intel. Times have changed along with the chip market and now the once far flung idea is looking more like a good move for Intel.

With ARM staying the dominant instruction set in the phone and tablet space, Intel is facing a serious issue as Apple, Samsung, Qualcomm and Nvidia are all making money on ARM chips.
 
F9CJSDn.jpg
 
Imagine how much we will be paying for a CPU if Intel has no desktop competitors.
 
Probably about as much as you do now.

The market is utterly saturated. The only way Intel makes money are on replacements, and if the upgrades don't come fast enough and at a reasonable price, there is little to no reason to buy a cpu.
 
Sure wish you could edit in this forum. "The only way... are". Wow. My brain is not working.
 
Probably about as much as you do now.

The market is utterly saturated. The only way Intel makes money are on replacements, and if the upgrades don't come fast enough and at a reasonable price, there is little to no reason to buy a cpu.

/fail comment. You understand nothing of economics.
 
/fail comment. You understand nothing of economics.
Uh, last I checked, there isn't a huge demand in the consumer market to buy AMD, so what makes you think them being out of the picture will change pricing at all? Intel typically doesn't market their prices to compare to AMD because lately AMD isn't even competing.
 
/fail comment. You understand nothing of economics.

Devices based on ARM and lower power x86 options are encroaching on the desktop space. If desktops cannot compete on price, they offer few perceived advantages to mainstream customers these days. Intel needs to keep prices lower if they want to keep their desktop offerings relevant.

Naturally, I would prefer to have both AMD and Intel in the desktop space. But Intel having a monopoly in this market segment is no longer the big concern that it used to be.
 
This talk comes back every so often like an itch that won't go away.
 
Probably about as much as you do now.

Um, no.
I remember when AMD was on top back in 2005.

A single-core 3700+ was $360, and the lowest-end non-OEM dual-core X2 3800+ was around $650.

That would be like an i3 costing $300-400 and an i5 costing around $600-800.
Remember the 386/486 era?

Believe me, the prices would most certainly not stay the same.
 
Devices based on ARM and lower power x86 options are encroaching on the desktop space. If desktops cannot compete on price, they offer few perceived advantages to mainstream customers these days. Intel needs to keep prices lower if they want to keep their desktop offerings relevant.

Naturally, I would prefer to have both AMD and Intel in the desktop space. But Intel having a monopoly in this market segment is no longer the big concern that it used to be.
ARM isn't ready for the desktop yet. And it also doesn't run desktop Windows. So, your stacking up ARM Linux or something against Wintel?

And yes I remember the days when there were actually competing architectures that weren't on the same OS. Motorola for instance. Intel prices were pretty much astronomical at the time.
 
Imagine how much we will be paying for a CPU if Intel has no desktop competitors.

/fail comment. You understand nothing of economics.

Neither do you. Intel already has no competition for i5 S1155 CPU, not even talking about i7, S2011 or server Xeons. Yet you still see pretty much the same ~200 euro price for C2Q/Core i5 S1156/Core i5 S1155 CPU, you still see the ~300 euro price for CPU one level above, ~500 euro price for 2nd best consumer CPU, ~1000 for best consumer CPU.

So no, AMD leaving x86 market won't affect the pricing of Core i5/i7/Xeons at all. Where pricing could change is the ultimate lowend (Celerons and Pentiums), but that would happen probably like killing of the Celeron line and leaving only the Pentium line, thus increasing the minimum CPU price to 60-80 euros instead of the current 40e "floor".

Intel already found out the "sweet spots" for their pricing where demand doesn't drop dramatically, yet Intel makes enough money. You can check this pricing back to Core 2 Duo Extreme CPUs, you will find the same segmentation over and over again.
 
Neither do you. Intel already has no competition for i5 S1155 CPU, not even talking about i7, S2011 or server Xeons. Yet you still see pretty much the same ~200 euro price for C2Q/Core i5 S1156/Core i5 S1155 CPU, you still see the ~300 euro price for CPU one level above, ~500 euro price for 2nd best consumer CPU, ~1000 for best consumer CPU.
:facepalm:

They don't have to make an identical competitor for each product. They just have to be relatively capable of it. And if Intel's prices became ridiculously high, AMD would be able to compete and enter the space. Just the fact they can enter that space keeps Intel somewhat in line.

I blame Rush and other wallstreet centric capitalists for this de-education of America. Without competition, capitalism is as much a fail as Communism or anything else.
 
It is funny how the people who are pointing out *why* Intel can't just elevate prices for more profit give actual reasons.

The people who don't seem to understand this do not appear to be able to form coherent arguments, but sure are good at slinging insults around. Usually, this is a pretty good indicator of a lack of strength of position.

The simple fact is, CPUs last ages, and do not increase in capability nearly as quickly as they did in the past. The doom and gloom scenarios seem to think that the volume of purchases of x86 processors must remain the same, and in the absence of cheap CPUs, people will be willing to pay any price. This ignores the obvious fact that with the massive lifespan, there are far more capable CPUs in existence than we actually need. The reason we keep buying new ones for such minor improvements is because they are dirt cheap relative to any other time in the history of x86.

However, I am sure that there are a few people who will so eloquently reply to me with such gems as how little I know, facepalm, or the like, but won't be able to refute any claims.

You sirs, are the epitome of intellect.
 
My shares doubled in value in the last 2 weeks thanks to this news.
 
Uh, last I checked, there isn't a huge demand in the consumer market to buy AMD, so what makes you think them being out of the picture will change pricing at all? Intel typically doesn't market their prices to compare to AMD because lately AMD isn't even competing.

Cause the desktop market is different then that of tablets and smart phones. As it is, x86 chips are far beyond the performance capabilities of ARM. Who's to say that Intel won't charge a boat load of money for high end stuff anyway? That's what they did in the past, before AMD became relevant. Low and mid range products probably won't cost much more, but high end stuff will likely be unreasonable. Low and mid range products will likely get a bigger gapping difference between the higher end stuff. Unlike now where that extra performance increase doesn't give enough reason to buy it, unless you must have the fastest fast.

Devices based on ARM and lower power x86 options are encroaching on the desktop space. If desktops cannot compete on price, they offer few perceived advantages to mainstream customers these days. Intel needs to keep prices lower if they want to keep their desktop offerings relevant.
People who believe that ARM devices are eroding the PC market, probably also believe in Santa. Tablets aren't doing spreadsheets, word processing, or even Email on ARM based devices. Yes Email, I said it. Everyone maybe looking to buy a tablet, but everyone already has a PC. It's already plenty fast for those tasks.

Anyone who's smart enough to know the difference, will likely continue to buy PC's. People who thought a tablet could take the place of a PC, are now finding out that it can't, and will upgrade.

It's like saying the microwave oven is going to replace the traditional gas based ovens. Suddenly gas based ovens are dropping in sales, while everyone is buying microwave ovens. Turns out, people still use gas based ovens, and don't buy new ones unless the old one breaks, or just isn't performing like you'd want it too. The microwaves turned out to be useful, for warming up frozen foods and meals already cooked in gas ovens. But nothing beats cooking in a real oven.
Naturally, I would prefer to have both AMD and Intel in the desktop space. But Intel having a monopoly in this market segment is no longer the big concern that it used to be.
The only reason Intel would be buying AMD is because suddenly AMD is moving forward fast. If you consider both Xbox 720 and PS4 will use AMD, including the Wii U which uses AMD graphics, then it's not hard to see Intel is losing ground. Though not enough to concern Intel for the immediate future.

That means developers are going to concern themselves with AMD hardware, more so then Intel. Which means Intel will likely lose market share, and will have to lower prices to compete against AMD. AMD's Jaguar is sounding like the Bulldozer we've been expecting. We already know it'll be using GDDR thanks to hUMA. AMD finally has a jump on Intel, and Intel is shitting themselves.

But thanks to the "ARM threat", it's OK to let Intel buy them up and become a monopoly in the x86 market? Not like it matters, cause the EU and US government will probably stop them in their tracks faster then Intels fastest chips.

37554606.jpg
 
I would welcome an Intel purchase of AMD. Intel knows CPU, AMD knows GPU, it's the perfect match. As far as the antitrust concerns you could always set a stipulation that Intel gives out another x86 license. That license could go to Nvidia, they were looking to make CPUs years ago but never got a license. I think this arrangement would create better products for users and keep the market balanced.
 
ARM isn't ready for the desktop yet. And it also doesn't run desktop Windows. So, your stacking up ARM Linux or something against Wintel?

Strawman argument. You changed the topic so that you could argue something different. Reply to something relevant to my post, and you'll get a proper reply to me. I'll start you off with a hint: I never claimed that ARM was ready for the desktop (your point, not mine).

People who believe that ARM devices are eroding the PC market, probably also believe in Santa. Tablets aren't doing spreadsheets, word processing, or even Email on ARM based devices. Yes Email, I said it. Everyone maybe looking to buy a tablet, but everyone already has a PC. It's already plenty fast for those tasks.

Anyone who's smart enough to know the difference, will likely continue to buy PC's. People who thought a tablet could take the place of a PC, are now finding out that it can't, and will upgrade.

It's like saying the microwave oven is going to replace the traditional gas based ovens. Suddenly gas based ovens are dropping in sales, while everyone is buying microwave ovens. Turns out, people still use gas based ovens, and don't buy new ones unless the old one breaks, or just isn't performing like you'd want it too. The microwaves turned out to be useful, for warming up frozen foods and meals already cooked in gas ovens. But nothing beats cooking in a real oven.

PC shipments are down. Tablets and convertible shipments are up. Mainstream consumers are purchasing these devices in favor of desktops. If Intel wants to help keep the desktop relevant, jacking the prices won't help. So even though Intel is not in direct competition with ARM on the desktop side, they are competing with them for relevance.

I like your Microwave analogy, but it doesn't apply here. Overs do something that a microwave cannot. Desktops currently do things that tablets can do...but just better. As ARM's CPUs evolve, tablets docked with keyboards/mice/monitors will continue to serve the needs of former desktop users.
 
I can see AMD selling off the graphics division to Intel thats about it though..... I think there's too much political involvement to let this happen now.
 
It is nice that we have people like Fuad Abazovic , when you have serious lack of insight and knowledge on what you been writing about and just say something for the sake of saying something then this happens.

Intel already crushed AMD badly, the market share is so tiny and even if it kept doubling each year Intel could go on and on doing what they are doing already for several years maybe several decades.

Why would Intel buy something that has no value and is not killing them, ARM is killing them , buying anything there would make sense since everything is happening there

With this in mind, this would be the main reason for Intel to pick up AMD. AMD would not cost them that much, as Intel still has billions in bank, but with AMD, Intel would gain great graphics, something that the company has been struggling to crack for many years. It would make Intel slightly more competitive, but it would not solve all of its problems.

Yes because Intel is losing badly and why not buy graphics because AMD has them, Nvidia would be easier since they don't hold a license for X86.

Now Intel has been bridging the gap on their gpu but sales wise it doesn't matter for them the whole argument is made up by some person with a brain of a 5 year old.

Hang on didn't Intel do the X86 android thing as well to battle ARM , yes they did , story time is over but there some many people who don't kniow what there talking about and can't see it either (even if it was standing in front of them).
 
I'm a strong believer in laissez faire economics.

But there are a few things the government needs to interfere with, and that is to ensure businesses abide by laws, protect workers and the environment from industry, and prevent monopolies.

I would hope that any such merger would be stopped, but more likely some money will politicians will be bought off.
 
Although the risk of an Intel monopoly is not very high, the governments would never permit the purchase ... if Intel wanted to risk the wrath of government anti-trust they would be better served by trying to buy Qualcomm or NVidia ... either of those sources would be much more strategic buys with at least some chance of government approval

The other merger that would make sense (but it would never happen because it is too complex) would be a two way merger with Intel/Microsoft or a three way merger with Intel/Microsoft/NVidia ... neither of those combos would happen because of the economics and the egos ;)
 
/fail comment. You understand nothing of economics.

Lol, uhm, economics can work this way.

It is funny how the people who are pointing out *why* Intel can't just elevate prices for more profit give actual reasons.

Rates of optimization. Large companies do these calculations. Will prices rise? Sure. Will they rise so astronomically that equal revenues will require only 60-50% of the level of purchases seen now? No. Because frankly, if the prices rise too much, many consumers (especially OEM consumer) will drop demand drastically.

Once something enters the race to zero (a term used in many electronics industries) manufacturers can't turn tail too easily. There needs to be *very* compelling reasons to price chips 25-50% higher than current prices.
 
Exactly, x86 cpu demand, with all factors considered, is *extremely* elastic now.

I'm not even sure there is room for any price increase. I actually predict that the effect would be smaller improvements per generation instead of this imagined gigantic price increase that some posters here predict. However, I am not sure how much of Intel R&D is on CPU architecture and how much is on process development. They need to maintain their process edge (and grow it as much as possible), and I don't think spending would decrease there. On the architecture side though, they could slack. We already see this somewhat anyway. Performance improvements have taken a back seat to efficiency improvements. And, as a hint to some posters here, that has absolutely nothing to do with AMD.

The gain for Intel would really be in defensively securing the x86 IP that AMD has. If someone with no interest in manufacturing x86 processors were to secure AMD's IP, I'm not sure what the ramifications for Intel would be (as they'd lose the leverage of their own x86 IP in a cross licensing agreement). They may have something in the AMD agreement to protect themselves though.
 
PC shipments are down. Tablets and convertible shipments are up. Mainstream consumers are purchasing these devices in favor of desktops. If Intel wants to help keep the desktop relevant, jacking the prices won't help. So even though Intel is not in direct competition with ARM on the desktop side, they are competing with them for relevance.
That's not the point. Like I said, you have low end, mid, and high end products. The low and mid range of products will likely not change in price, but in performance. For example, lets say Intel creates a new chip called AI, which is the combined effort of AMD and Intel engineers. The AI3's and AI5's will likely be affordable, cause consumers aren't interested in buying things out of a certain price range. The AI7's though will likely be extremely expensive, but also much faster. Unlike now where an i7 isn't really worth it. Even gamers can be comfortable with an i5.

That's because the only people interested in i7's are gamers, artists, or work intensive tasks. Even as of now, the i7 extreme processors are ridiculous, and only because AMD has nothing close to that in performance. Where as the highest end i7 is half as much, and AMD's highest end is even less then half as much.

Lets say AMD's new Jaguar turns out to be an i7 killer. Knowing AMD's pricing, I doubt anyone would buy an i7 Extreme or regular. This would force Intel to drop prices to compete.
I like your Microwave analogy, but it doesn't apply here. Overs do something that a microwave cannot. Desktops currently do things that tablets can do...but just better. As ARM's CPUs evolve, tablets docked with keyboards/mice/monitors will continue to serve the needs of former desktop users.
A. ARM CPUs are likely not to evolve as much as people believe. Due to the fact that they're limited by heat and power, which a desktop PC doesn't deal with. Unless someone plans to make a desktop based ARM chip, ARM will hit a brick wall.

B.
There's no real limitations on what can be done on the ARM chip. It's just that the OS's typically used on them is Android and iOS. Both of which I would imagine doesn't have the capabilities of Windows or Mac OS X. Not unless you install Ubuntu on them, in which case we're assuming Linux can take the place of Windows.

C.
The performance difference between an ARM chip and a x86 is massive. Unless the fastest Atom processor is like the epiphany of x86 performance to you. While ARM chips are fast for their power consumption, they couldn't run Crysis. Xbox 360 and PS3 can barely run it, and I doubt the Tegra 4 can match them in performance.
 
A. ARM CPUs are likely not to evolve as much as people believe. Due to the fact that they're limited by heat and power, which a desktop PC doesn't deal with. Unless someone plans to make a desktop based ARM chip, ARM will hit a brick wall.

Nvidia said they were going to make a desktop ARM chip at one point. Who knows what happened to that since they haven't announced anything. That's why I think Intel should be permitted to buy AMD, but also be required to give Nvidia a x86 license. Nvidia originally wanted to make a x86 desktop CPU but had to stick to ARM because they couldn't get the x86 license from Intel. If Nvidia did get a x86 license that would create two companies capable to producing a proper APU, while ensuring competition and better products for consumers.
 
I wouldn't want Intel to buy out AMD even if they had to give Nvidia a x86 license. To my uneducated mind, Intel & Nvidia = $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
AMD = $
:D
 
I wouldn't want Intel to buy out AMD even if they had to give Nvidia a x86 license. To my uneducated mind, Intel & Nvidia = $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
AMD = $
:D

AMD, when it has processors that are as fast as Intel's charges just as much.

When they had the fastest consumer cpus, they too charged $1,000 each for them.

Your perception is flawed. You get what you pay for.
 
That's not the point. Like I said, you have low end, mid, and high end products. The low and mid range of products will likely not change in price, but in performance. For example, lets say Intel creates a new chip called AI, which is the combined effort of AMD and Intel engineers. The AI3's and AI5's will likely be affordable, cause consumers aren't interested in buying things out of a certain price range. The AI7's though will likely be extremely expensive, but also much faster. Unlike now where an i7 isn't really worth it. Even gamers can be comfortable with an i5.

That's because the only people interested in i7's are gamers, artists, or work intensive tasks. Even as of now, the i7 extreme processors are ridiculous, and only because AMD has nothing close to that in performance. Where as the highest end i7 is half as much, and AMD's highest end is even less then half as much.

Lets say AMD's new Jaguar turns out to be an i7 killer. Knowing AMD's pricing, I doubt anyone would buy an i7 Extreme or regular. This would force Intel to drop prices to compete.

A. ARM CPUs are likely not to evolve as much as people believe. Due to the fact that they're limited by heat and power, which a desktop PC doesn't deal with. Unless someone plans to make a desktop based ARM chip, ARM will hit a brick wall.

B.
There's no real limitations on what can be done on the ARM chip. It's just that the OS's typically used on them is Android and iOS. Both of which I would imagine doesn't have the capabilities of Windows or Mac OS X. Not unless you install Ubuntu on them, in which case we're assuming Linux can take the place of Windows.

C.
The performance difference between an ARM chip and a x86 is massive. Unless the fastest Atom processor is like the epiphany of x86 performance to you. While ARM chips are fast for their power consumption, they couldn't run Crysis. Xbox 360 and PS3 can barely run it, and I doubt the Tegra 4 can match them in performance.

See, the flaw in your argument is that you think performance matters to normal people now. It dosn't and it hasn't for a long time. Why? Because they aren't doing anything that needs more performance. Yes there will always be a market for creators that will always need more performance but if tablets have proven anything is that the majority of people are consumers. As long as it plays their video or loads their webpage at an acceptable speed they are good. Gaming will eventually fall under the same category.

I want to draw your attention to three things.

1. https://brendaneich.com/2013/05/today-i-saw-the-future/ 1080p video powered by WebGL and Javascript.

2. http://www.joystiq.com/2013/03/29/mozilla-unveils-browser-based-unreal-engine-3-using-javascript/ Unreal Engine 3 powered by WebGL and Javascript.

3. hUMA system architectures where workloads can be split to the device that's best for the job which nowadays will be more towards the video card.

All of these can be accelerated by the video card, or by specialized chips that nowadays are included or can be included in cellphones and tablets. So other than say a better quality design what's the incentive for the average family to pay $1200 for a Ai7 when the $400 ARM is adequate for what they do?

Cost isn't the problem, its the fact that their older systems or cheap companion devices is good enough. If Intel and AMD wants people to upgrade their 2008 desktop they need to develop software that normal people would want to use that justify the upgrade. Problem is no one knows what that is.
 
Never was much of an AMD fan. Would enjoy seeing Intel acquire them and use the GPU tech.

It would not be as big of a monopoly as people think. Quite frankly intel is trying to figure out how to stay alive right now with the trend towards low cost machines. People expect a desktop to cost like $300 and a Laptop to be around $500. The enterprise market can only provide so much support as their price point is still far below enthusiast/performance levels for the mass buys. Servers are still high dollar, but relatively low volume in the entire scheme of things.

Not saying I agree with only cheap machines, but that is what the mass consumer demands these days as can be seen if you pickup an electronics store ad or what regular consumers are buying.
 
If anything we need another competitor for Intel or AMD really needs to actually be competitive. Look at the price of CPUs latetly? Holy crap! Intel already technically has a monopoly. Would definitely be worse if they bought AMD.

I can just see it now. The Bulldozium 2, now with hyperthreading!
 
If anything we need another competitor for Intel or AMD really needs to actually be competitive. Look at the price of CPUs latetly? Holy crap! Intel already technically has a monopoly. Would definitely be worse if they bought AMD.

I can just see it now. The Bulldozium 2, now with hyperthreading!

Honestly the price of CPUs seems dirt cheap to me right now for the performance you can get.

Even the measly ~$45 G540 can kick compete with high range CPUs from previous generations. For less than $200 you can pickup the i5-3750 which is more power than most need and crazy powerful for that price point.
 
Never was much of an AMD fan. Would enjoy seeing Intel acquire them and use the GPU tech.

It would not be as big of a monopoly as people think. Quite frankly intel is trying to figure out how to stay alive right now with the trend towards low cost machines. People expect a desktop to cost like $300 and a Laptop to be around $500. The enterprise market can only provide so much support as their price point is still far below enthusiast/performance levels for the mass buys. Servers are still high dollar, but relatively low volume in the entire scheme of things.

Not saying I agree with only cheap machines, but that is what the mass consumer demands these days as can be seen if you pickup an electronics store ad or what regular consumers are buying.

I am not sure I would phrase it that Intel is trying to stay alive, it is more like trying to stay relevant ... right now they get about 70% of their revenue from pc related products (desktop chips, mobile chips, wireless, graphics, etc) ... ARM is unlikely to completely kill the PC market but ARM could shrink it dramatically (down to the server market size perhaps) ... in that situation Intel would become a smaller company but they are nowhere near the survival risks of AMD

Unless a more dangerous competitor tried to buy AMD (Samsung or Qualcomm) I don't think Intel cares about them at all ... the only element that AMD has that is worth anything at all to Intel is the graphics technology ... even the Nextgen technology that originally made AMD competitive for a while is not that useful now

Although Intel has denied wanting to become a foundry, they will shortly have a new CEO who was the COO. The market will be looking for him to do something dramatic. A license of ARM technology, a merger with a graphics company like NVidia, or offering their excess capacity out as a foundry might all fit that bill (much more so than an attempted merger with AMD that the government would shoot down) :cool:
 
Nvidia said they were going to make a desktop ARM chip at one point. Who knows what happened to that since they haven't announced anything.
That I would really like to see, as the more competition the better. Also, the only OS that would work is Linux based OS's.

See, the flaw in your argument is that you think performance matters to normal people now. It dosn't and it hasn't for a long time. Why? Because they aren't doing anything that needs more performance. Yes there will always be a market for creators that will always need more performance but if tablets have proven anything is that the majority of people are consumers. As long as it plays their video or loads their webpage at an acceptable speed they are good. Gaming will eventually fall under the same category.
When a Pentium 200 MMX was out, people said the same thing. When a 1 Ghz Athlon was released, people said the same thing. Now we're at like 4+ Ghz Quad core CPUs and people still say the same thing.


All of these can be accelerated by the video card, or by specialized chips that nowadays are included or can be included in cellphones and tablets. So other than say a better quality design what's the incentive for the average family to pay $1200 for a Ai7 when the $400 ARM is adequate for what they do?
None, and that's the fault of software developers. Specifically game developers, as you've never needed something faster to do word processing and email. Nowadays you can include Facebook, and even then you don't need anything past 1+Ghz for this. And don't give me this gamez don't matter business, cause people are buying tablets and smartphones just to play Angry Birds. It's like the #1 driving reason why people buy these things. You know, besides acting cool and pretending you're up to speed in technology.

Since the 360 and PS3's launch, developers have taken a different stance on PC games, and instead focus on developing games on those consoles, and then port the games to PC with some minor improvements. So long as your PC has equivalent specs to a mid range PC of 2006, then you can pretty much play any game made today. And tablets are quickly approaching the speed of a 360 and PS3, but that's because it's been like 6 years since they were released.
Cost isn't the problem, its the fact that their older systems or cheap companion devices is good enough. If Intel and AMD wants people to upgrade their 2008 desktop they need to develop software that normal people would want to use that justify the upgrade. Problem is no one knows what that is.
Like I said, you don't need anything past 1+Ghz CPU if you do basic tasks. Last I checked, people kept upgrading their machines. Why? For the games, and that's about to change really soon.

Since the Xbox 720 and PS4 are gonna be out soon, developers will change the way they develop their games. Suddenly they're making games with tessellation and more polygons and what not. Not only that, but developers wanna focus on making games on the PC first, and then port them over to consoles. Which will again drive the demand for PC hardware.

It's going to be a slow uphill battle, cause even when the PS4 and 720 are released, developers will still make games 360 and PS3 friendly. I expect that when Valve releases their Steam Box, and has enough developers behind it, that the demand for faster PC's will be there. All it takes is one killer game that requires a Quad core CPU and DirectX 11 GPU as a minimum requirement, and the demand for PCs will skyrocket. A game like Half Life 3 would do it.

I'm basing this on history. Doom drove people to buy faster PCs, and from what I understand it even outsold Windows 95 at that time. That game caused chaos in work places and offices. Quake 3 had the same effect on PCs being sold at that time. If PCs came with a 3D accelerator, it was to play Quake 3. That's why the ATI Rage chip was included in so many PCs. Remember when Doom 3 was leaked and people got to try it? So many people ran out and bought hardware just to be able to play it.
 
AMD, when it has processors that are as fast as Intel's charges just as much.

When they had the fastest consumer cpus, they too charged $1,000 each for them.

Your perception is flawed. You get what you pay for.

Yea I assumed that was the reality. But I still like my view. :rolleyes:
 
That I would really like to see, as the more competition the better. Also, the only OS that would work is Linux based OS's.

When a Pentium 200 MMX was out, people said the same thing. When a 1 Ghz Athlon was released, people said the same thing. Now we're at like 4+ Ghz Quad core CPUs and people still say the same thing.

None, and that's the fault of software developers. Specifically game developers, as you've never needed something faster to do word processing and email. Nowadays you can include Facebook, and even then you don't need anything past 1+Ghz for this. And don't give me this gamez don't matter business, cause people are buying tablets and smartphones just to play Angry Birds. It's like the #1 driving reason why people buy these things. You know, besides acting cool and pretending you're up to speed in technology.

Since the 360 and PS3's launch, developers have taken a different stance on PC games, and instead focus on developing games on those consoles, and then port the games to PC with some minor improvements. So long as your PC has equivalent specs to a mid range PC of 2006, then you can pretty much play any game made today. And tablets are quickly approaching the speed of a 360 and PS3, but that's because it's been like 6 years since they were released.

Like I said, you don't need anything past 1+Ghz CPU if you do basic tasks. Last I checked, people kept upgrading their machines. Why? For the games, and that's about to change really soon.

Since the Xbox 720 and PS4 are gonna be out soon, developers will change the way they develop their games. Suddenly they're making games with tessellation and more polygons and what not. Not only that, but developers wanna focus on making games on the PC first, and then port them over to consoles. Which will again drive the demand for PC hardware.

It's going to be a slow uphill battle, cause even when the PS4 and 720 are released, developers will still make games 360 and PS3 friendly. I expect that when Valve releases their Steam Box, and has enough developers behind it, that the demand for faster PC's will be there. All it takes is one killer game that requires a Quad core CPU and DirectX 11 GPU as a minimum requirement, and the demand for PCs will skyrocket. A game like Half Life 3 would do it.

I'm basing this on history. Doom drove people to buy faster PCs, and from what I understand it even outsold Windows 95 at that time. That game caused chaos in work places and offices. Quake 3 had the same effect on PCs being sold at that time. If PCs came with a 3D accelerator, it was to play Quake 3. That's why the ATI Rage chip was included in so many PCs. Remember when Doom 3 was leaked and people got to try it? So many people ran out and bought hardware just to be able to play it.

You are looking at it from the eyes of an enthusiast. Why do most of us upgrade? Games. We may do some work too but it’s really is for a game. I’m talking about consumers that say they are gamers, but as soon as you mention spending more than $500 on a desktop to play a game at max settings they decide to buy an Xbox instead.
To these people, the upgrade from 200 MHz was because the newer system had a CDRW drive and they didn’t know you could just buy one to replace their standard drive. Some may have been for games but I’m not going to assume that all of them game like you did. The average consumer upgrades when they think the computer is dead, or something comes along that they are sure their system can’t handle, like Photoshop, video editing, watching HD video, etc. If gaming was almost always the reason people upgrade, then why is most systems running solely on Intel graphics?
The point I was making was that you don’t even need 1 GHz machines nowadays to do the tasks that people want nowadays because of acceleration. And chances are their 4 year old system did have some basic acceleration support that still gets those jobs done. The fact that those things are being stripped down to running on JavaScript should show you that for everyday tasks less power is needed, contrary to the increases in the past.
Are you really trying to say that “oh the 720 is going to get the PC market going again!” Let’s say it does, so what happens in 2017 when those graphics are old hat, but we still have 7 years to go before they are upgraded? What happens when more apps are web based and just require a browser with great JavaScript support and a high speed connection? Sure we’ll still be upgrading as it’s our hobby but normal consumer will still only pay $500 (or hell what am I kidding probably $400 at that point) max for a system?
 
Back
Top