Why do cards still have DVI ports?

hedron

Limp Gawd
Joined
Apr 24, 2008
Messages
495
Doesn't everyone have HDMI ports on their monitors by now? I hardly ever upgrade my PC and I have them. I basically only upgrade when something breaks or some game/program won't run.

But, I was nosing around the video card section of Newegg and noticed that only 'budget' video cards have dual HDMI. If I was in the market to buy a video card I would flat out refuse to buy one that doesn't have dual HDMI ports as I can't use my PC without two monitors.

I would think that it would be the opposite way around. The super-expensive cards would have dual HDMI, but no DVI. Or is DVI considered superior to HDMI? If so, then why'd they even bother making the standard to begin with?
 
HDMI ports only come standard on mid-upper range monitors and not everybody wants to blow $400+ for that feature when DVI can easily do HD if that is all you need.
Unless you are a hardcore gamer it does not apply to the majority of those who just browse the web.
 
Cheaper video cards are generally used in HTPC machines where HDMI is appreciated.

DVI to HDMI is an easy conversion, but HDMI to Dual-Link DVI isn't trivial. Furthermore, most people still have monitors with DVI.

For now, having the DVI connector offers the most flexibility.
 
1) not everyone is using new monitors.
2) DVI is superior to HDMI in most cases. 2560x1600 and 2560x1440 are impossible via HDMI without custom timings.
 
2) DVI is superior to HDMI in most cases. 2560x1600 and 2560x1440 are impossible via HDMI without custom timings.

So, then I should be thinking in terms of getting a card with display port, then. I just hate those stupid huge adapters. They're so clunky and awkward. Especially if your PC acts up and you have to swap out parts and disconnecting/reconnecting DVIs ports is terribly annoying.
 
It'll take a long time for manufacturers to drop DVI with the vast amounts of hardware out there.

I would much rather the royalty-free VESA standard DisplayPort take over from DVI, instead of paying a licencing fee to HDMI Licensing LLC which just inflates the price. But the companies which make up the HDMI consortium (Hitachi, Panasonic, Philips, Silicon Image, Sony, and Toshiba) would rather make more profit off the consumer and put up a lot of marketing effort to keep collecting royalties.

Here is a pretty good article on the subject :

http://www.pcworld.com/article/2030669/hdmi-vs-displayport-which-display-interface-reigns-supreme-.html
 
Dual Link DVI is superior to HDMI. But DisplayPort is where it's at! I'll never get a non-DP monitor.
 
The real question is why do they still ship monitors with VGA ports?

Trying to share one / two displays across three machines is a real PITA.
 
The question itself wasn't stupid, it was the assumption behind that question (that HDMI has replaced the need for DVI) that was stupid. The ideal video card has at least 1 each of Dual-Link DVI, HDMI, and DisplayPort. In reality the HDMI in that lineup is superfluous, but is nice for people like the OP who don't want to bother with DVI cables or HMDI adapters.

When I bought a GTX 750 Ti for my secondary PC, I bought the one with the ports I listed above for the flexibility; most of the other models were missing one of them and thus were eliminated from contention for my dollars. I do not regret my pickiness.

Edit: Holy crap there's an edit feature here.
 
Last edited:
1) not everyone is using new monitors.
2) DVI is superior to HDMI in most cases. 2560x1600 and 2560x1440 are impossible via HDMI without custom timings.

My 7 year old 24" 1920x1200 monitors only had HDMI/VGA/Component/Composite inputs. No DVI on them, which I though was strange at the time.

I personally prefer DVI since they can be locked down.
 
My 7 year old 24" 1920x1200 monitors only had HDMI/VGA/Component/Composite inputs. No DVI on them, which I though was strange at the time.

And my 2 year old ZR2740's have only dual link DVI & DP.

That doesn't change the fact that bunch of companies are still using their old 17-22" Samsung monitors with VGA & DVI only.
 
HDMI has replaced the need for DVI

Most monitors sold have many different inputs to accept anything you can throw at it. If I'm buying a new video card, I would want the latest and greatest. Why would anyone want some old outdated video card? Part of the upgrade is to get new features, like HDMI and Displayport, not just better FPS/3d effects.

In other words, there is less a need for DVI on a video card because monitors accept most anything. Plus, there are adapters. Making DVI superfluous in most cases.
 
It'll take a long time for manufacturers to drop DVI with the vast amounts of hardware out there.

I would much rather the royalty-free VESA standard DisplayPort take over from DVI, instead of paying a licencing fee to HDMI Licensing LLC which just inflates the price. But the companies which make up the HDMI consortium (Hitachi, Panasonic, Philips, Silicon Image, Sony, and Toshiba) would rather make more profit off the consumer and put up a lot of marketing effort to keep collecting royalties.

Here is a pretty good article on the subject :

http://www.pcworld.com/article/2030669/hdmi-vs-displayport-which-display-interface-reigns-supreme-.html

Actually...by 2015 AMD, Intel and a bunch of big hardware industry players have agreed to drop VGA and DVI in favor of HDMI and DP.

That agreements was made back in 2010
 
And my 2 year old ZR2740's have only dual link DVI & DP.

That doesn't change the fact that bunch of companies are still using their old 17-22" Samsung monitors with VGA & DVI only.

My HP 23" is only digital, DVI, DP, HDMI. got a deal on that, $125 from HP a few years ago, price mistake that they honored.
Rep was trying to push a cheaper model on me and I insisted on that model since I required the DP.
all the other monitors with DP were more than double that price at the time.
main drawbacks of this monitor are glossy screen and not VESA mountable since there is a large HP logo on the back that lights up.
 
HDMI 2.0 supports 3840x2160 (4k).

And so far we have no news of any new unreleased video card supporting hdmi 2.0.

dvi is still on cards because it is still needed. How long did it take to phase out ps2, parallel, and serial ports? quite a while, manufacturers would rather add the few cents it takes to add dvi to a board then lose out on all the sales of people who want dvi and don't buy their card but go with a different company that has dvi on their card.
 
And so far we have no news of any new unreleased video card supporting hdmi 2.0.

dvi is still on cards because it is still needed. How long did it take to phase out ps2, parallel, and serial ports? quite a while, manufacturers would rather add the few cents it takes to add dvi to a board then lose out on all the sales of people who want dvi and don't buy their card but go with a different company that has dvi on their card.

The problem. No one has been putting any effort to maintaining or updating the DVI standard in over a decade. DVI is going to go away much sooner than it took PS/2 and parallel/serial to go away.
 
HDMI is only up to 1080p is most computers. DVI can go up to 2560xXXXX resolution with dual link. 2.0 HDMI isn't even supported i think yet by most companies. DisplayPort is superior i think to all at least right now but no one is supporting it much at all. A lot of standards mostly unused ;)
 
HDMI is only up to 1080p is most computers. DVI can go up to 2560xXXXX resolution with dual link. 2.0 HDMI isn't even supported i think yet by most companies. DisplayPort is superior i think to all at least right now but no one is supporting it much at all. A lot of standards mostly unused ;)

And when you say "no one" you mean "no one" besides NVidia, AMD...HP, Dell, and other monitor makers that have been selling panels with DP for 4 years?
 
The real question is why do they still ship monitors with VGA ports?

Trying to share one / two displays across three machines is a real PITA.

Why share? Just log into the other machines on the main machine, done.
 
So, then I should be thinking in terms of getting a card with display port, then. I just hate those stupid huge adapters. They're so clunky and awkward. Especially if your PC acts up and you have to swap out parts and disconnecting/reconnecting DVIs ports is terribly annoying.

So with DP/hdmi they magically connect and reconnect themselves?. /sarcasm

They work like DP, hdmi and vga. I have not had any problems with any of them and have used them all. Plug them in, plug them out. Pretty simple.
 
The problem. No one has been putting any effort to maintaining or updating the DVI standard in over a decade. DVI is going to go away much sooner than it took PS/2 and parallel/serial to go away.

That's because displayport was meant to replace it. What I don't get is why relatively few monitors have it. Hdmi has to be licensed and from what I can read ranges from 4 cents to 15 cents per device, display port is free or at least wikipedia says it is. I have a 30" dell and I need displayport or dl-dvi.
 
So, then I should be thinking in terms of getting a card with display port, then. I just hate those stupid huge adapters. They're so clunky and awkward. Especially if your PC acts up and you have to swap out parts and disconnecting/reconnecting DVIs ports is terribly annoying.

I only use DP on my vidcards/monitors now, but I hate displayport connectors. The button is absurdly hard to depress if you dont have the space to get your fingers in there (like when your monitors port is mounted in reverse so the latch side is up against the backplate of the monitor...:mad:)

Back when I had my AW2310 (120hz) I had to use DVI. Actually wasnt that bad
 
I use to DVI with my old Dell 24 monitor years ago to the desktop. VGA was there for emergencies when something didn't work right. Hadn't used the old Dell 24 monitor for a long time since moving over to laptops and I decided to one day. The old Dell 24 monitors had all the ports, DVI, VGA and HDMI even.

First thing that came to mind was DVI, and with much difficulty I finally found one and then realised my laptop didn't have the port. Same thing with the VGA port. Had to finally just use HDMI. Wasn't very happy with that because the HDMI ports are always iffy. If there's a slight movement to it, the connection cuts out for a few seconds. Applies to everything that uses a HDMI cable, etc.

Only use display port if there's no other options (like the new Dell/tablet machines). Display port to HDMI for certain things I need doing (like being in a non Roku 3 environment) LOL
 
Actually...by 2015 AMD, Intel and a bunch of big hardware industry players have agreed to drop VGA and DVI in favor of HDMI and DP.

That agreements was made back in 2010

They estimated back in 2010 how long it would take before they could think about moving on the standard to DisplayPort. AMD is serious about DP, even jumped ahead and pulled off Eyefinty Surround using DP years ago.

I'd say the market will guide if/when manufacturers drop dvi. Or mysteriously a few AIB cards will have those plugs on them, even if reference models do not have them to satisfy the market demand.
 
Manufacturers are in a hard place. Businesses will use tech until it falls apart. They buy the cheapest products then they spend the cost of the unit again on the longest onsite warranty that's offered. Some full repair onsite warranties las 10 years. The company I currently do onsite repairs for (a major world-wide OEM) is encountering a HUGE problem with modern main boards ditching the VGA output in favour of a DVI-I port and two DP outputs. If a customer wants to use dual-screens, they either use a cheap, off-brand adapter or they have to update their 5+ year old screens. What to the clients do? Use the cheapest adapters they can find and call up the OEM when things don't work PERFECTLY. We are talking a warranty call is made when the second display flickers for less than a second ONCE A DAY.

So you could imgine what OEMs do to avoid these situations: include ALL THE PORTS. Even ones that are 15+ years old. And because those ports are still around, monitor manufacturers think 'hey, people are still using these outputs, if we stop including them on our models, the clients will just go to a competing brand that still provides them."

So really, we're screwed.
 
I thought the whole point of HDMI was to force copy protection / DRM on consumers? So there's going to be a tremendous amount of pressure to make this the preferred standard.
 
And when you say "no one" you mean "no one" besides NVidia, AMD...HP, Dell, and other monitor makers that have been selling panels with DP for 4 years?

Most ordinary people with regular computers from mainstream manufacturers are using DVI still and VGA. Trust me not that many are using DP even today. You see it on high end videocards but most onboard and low end setups use DVI and VGA still in the real world general population. I work at a shop so i know what everyones buying and using these days. DisplayPort stuff almost never comes in out of the hundreds of computers i've touched. Like over 95% of the computers don't even use dedicated graphics cards that come in. Next to almost everyone uses onboard video. Computers sold from Dell brand new desktops have DVI and HDMI only usually sometimes with VGA. DP is pretty rare. You only see DisplayPort when people get a graphics card thats pretty high end thats recent also. Almost all average joes use DVI and VGA still. Almost everyone out there uses VGA and DVI on desktops. Its different with smart phones and tablets. But in general for desktops most still use the big 2. HDMI is 3rd. 4th is DP. I don't see anyone using those DP to DVI adapters either.
 
Last edited:
A lot of the monitors in the $150-250 range don't have DP, only DVI and HDMI--or worse, HDMI and VGA (I've seen that a few times).
 
A lot of the monitors in the $150-250 range don't have DP, only DVI and HDMI--or worse, HDMI and VGA (I've seen that a few times).

Yea...and Kia still sells cars without power windows or mirrors.

El cheapo will always be that.
 
I thought the whole point of HDMI was to force copy protection / DRM on consumers? So there's going to be a tremendous amount of pressure to make this the preferred standard.

HDCP is supported over DVI.
 
1) not everyone is using new monitors.
2) DVI is superior to HDMI in most cases. 2560x1600 and 2560x1440 are impossible via HDMI without custom timings.

2560x1600 has been supported in HDMI 1.6 since 2006.

Let's also note that HDMI and DVI are electrically compatible, so you could replace a DVI connector with an HDMI connector in literally all cases.

In terms of unencrypted video transmission, the protocols are essentially identical. All the extra HDMI features are transmitted in the "data island" window (coinciding with the vertical blanking period).
 
HDMI supports digital audio over the same cable.

DVI needs an adapter and in AMD's case a special one.

Yeah I know DP can as well but nobody implements it, blah, blah, blah

/thread done
 
I use VGA with my Dell UltraSharp display. I find VGA is more common than DVI. That's why I use it. My display doesn't have HDMI or DisplayPort. I also suspect that analog is slightly less of a security hazard than digital, but I could be wrong.
 
Back
Top