Why CG Sucks (Except It Doesn't)

What's your opinion on chappie?
I liked chappie but not as much as other movies with robots and AI. Chappie went from plausible to way out in left field. The inventor wasn't your typical white guy, which is a good start. The robot looks like what you'd expect from a police robot. But then we're transferring minds over to other robots and people that look like from mad max, and don't forget the ED-209 copy cat from RoboCop. Oh and movies with AI need to stop with the solo inventor guy, cause that will never happen. The guy was having a problem compiling the software for the robots AI?

Story is not as good as Short Circuit and the CG wasn't what hurt the movie. Despite lighting hitting a robot and making it self aware being very unlikely, the rest of the movie was plausible. Chappie went from likely to very unlikely the rest of the movie. But consider that the big difference is that the robot from Short Circuit is real and was a technological wonder. That robot was something like 90% of the movies budget. Today they could take that robot and bring it to school around the world to influence children. Chappie is 100% CG so you can't do that.

Despite CG, most of Chappie's life was in a run down building with people he calls mommy and daddy. Ex Machina took place entirely in a building as well. It makes sense from the story but the real wonder was seeing AI interact with the human world. Not much of what happens in Chappie that's real world, unless you live in a war zone. So it makes it hard for the audience to relate. This goes for Ex Machina as well.

Remember they did this with a real robot and they used parts from Radio Shack to fix him as part of the films script. I know Radio Shack is dead but nearly everyone has been there at least once right?

gif-johnny-5-Short-Circuit-sandbox-719509.gif
 
My problem is when you combine CG + shake cam + .25 second shots cut after cut. You basically see nothing, which is great way to mask bad CG.

I think fast cuts are used more to mask stunts (or lack thereof). First place I remember seeing it was in Gladiator.
 
There's a car chase scene in Bad Boys 2 that is entirely cgi. You know the one, across the bridge with the cars being dropped from the transport carrier. BB2 is a good movie, the CGI was very average. Then you have Fast Five, a very average movie, with little to no CGI that I am aware of. Absolutely spectacular car wrecks, especially the grand finale with bank safe being dragged through the city. I've watched that scene a dozen times. Practical fx certainly have their purpose and they definitely add a lot to the movie.
 
All I'm reading here is a bunch of spoiled brats complaining about their entertainment. Hate CGI so much? How about we take away computers completely. Remember what the world was like before that? No, you don't. I do. Stop whining already.
 
There's a car chase scene in Bad Boys 2 that is entirely cgi. You know the one, across the bridge with the cars being dropped from the transport carrier. BB2 is a good movie, the CGI was very average. Then you have Fast Five, a very average movie, with little to no CGI that I am aware of. Absolutely spectacular car wrecks, especially the grand finale with bank safe being dragged through the city. I've watched that scene a dozen times. Practical fx certainly have their purpose and they definitely add a lot to the movie.

F5 had a ton of CG but you didn't notice it because it was good CG mixed with practical fx. The CG is not always where you expect it to be.
 
All I'm reading here is a bunch of spoiled brats complaining about their entertainment. Hate CGI so much? How about we take away computers completely. Remember what the world was like before that? No, you don't. I do. Stop whining already.

You'd have a point if they were giving these movies away for free. They're not, so you don't.
 
You'd have a point if they were giving these movies away for free. They're not, so you don't.

You'd have a point if you were forced to go to movies. You're not, so you don't.

Besides, most people don't care. Most of us go to movies and enjoy them. I'm sure all of you bitched about the CGI in Avatar. Everyone I know loved the F/X.
 
Pointing out bad CGI is not bitching, it's merely an observation. It makes sense that hardcore pc gamers would not be as wow'ed about it, too. It takes a shit ton of fuck all to impress a lot of us old cranky folks here :D
 
F5 had a ton of CG but you didn't notice it because it was good CG mixed with practical fx. The CG is not always where you expect it to be.

Well sure, but what I mean is full cgi, not augmented cgi. Replacing a backdrop with mountains instead of the city is fine. Inserting fake bystanders near a car explosion is fine. Using cgi to render a fireball and complete car is not ok, the entire scene is completely fake.
 
Freddie Wong rocks the socks. If this is the first you've come across him you should really check out his early work. He's turned out some truly amazing VFX that puts studio work to shame for several years now.
 
Well sure, but what I mean is full cgi, not augmented cgi. Replacing a backdrop with mountains instead of the city is fine. Inserting fake bystanders near a car explosion is fine. Using cgi to render a fireball and complete car is not ok, the entire scene is completely fake.

What you just described is exactly what the video addressed and what it called "Good CGI"
 
I'm glad he makes the point that even movies which are talked about as if the director hates cg and did everything practically typically feature hundreds of vfx shots. He used Mad Max as an example, Christopher Nolan is another one where a huge deal is made of a handful of practical effects, ignoring the absolute shit-ton of cg he uses. But it's no accident; it's a carefully calculated tactic to appeal to the industry dinosaurs that vote for the Oscars. Interstellar beating Planet of the Apes was an absolute joke, but it happened because Nolan's PR team know what buttons to press, while Weta aren't as canny at selling their (far superior) work.

the use of computers to blend various real and practical effects shoots into a single shot, that is not computer graphics...

Sure. Tell that to the thousands of compositors working in the industry.
 
The problem with CG is the over-use and reliance on it when you can achieve the same effect with a practical effect.

Cg has its place, and when used correctly you won't even notice it (IE background, objects not in the foreground).

However when it comes to actual characters , rather it be monsters, people, etc? It sticks out like a sore thumb. It's easy to notice CGI characters, and this is an area where practical effects beats out CGI, because the practical effect actually physically exists in the real world and our mind doesn't notice it as easily "sticking" out because things like lighting/shadows, etc don't look "off." It's generally only when it "moves" that something may appear off.

You can have good/bad in both, there are some terrible practical effects just as there are bad CG effects.

To me the point of making a movie shouldn't be a focus on one or the other, but a focus on making people forget that what they are seeing isn't "real." You should pick the one that achieves that the best and don't be afraid of using either.

Movies like Jurassic Park 1, Terminator 2, The Crow, all understood this very well and they used both CG and practical effects but knew when/where best to use them.

That's why all three films hold up so well vs most of films of that time that resorted to heavy CGI overuse.

I mean:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KkUk1QRwlDk

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v5Co3A3fLBo

Where's the CGi and practical effects?

In The Crow it's the background buildings and cityscape, in JP it's the T-rex when you see his legs move, otherwise it's a giant animatronic.

also couldn't finda good clip of T2, but this behind the scenes special effects explains it good:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EYQMfT6nsQs

Also Stan Winston did both JP/T2, he was a master of effects and responsible for so many great effects in many movies, from Alien to JP, T2, etc.

You probably didn't even realize they used a lot of practical effects for the T1000 .
 
Yes, while technically it is often done on the computer, compositing is not the same as "CG". At least, not in 99% of conversations.
 
^ Um, that is about the easiest "CG" to pull off for humans, they could've used a still photo painted in photoshop for all we know...
 
The problem with CG is the over-use and reliance on it when you can achieve the same effect with a practical effect.

Cg has its place, and when used correctly you won't even notice it (IE background, objects not in the foreground).

However when it comes to actual characters , rather it be monsters, people, etc? It sticks out like a sore thumb. It's easy to notice CGI characters, and this is an area where practical effects beats out CGI, because the practical effect actually physically exists in the real world and our mind doesn't notice it as easily "sticking" out because things like lighting/shadows, etc don't look "off." It's generally only when it "moves" that something may appear off.

So Planet of the Apes would have worked better if the main apes were men in Ape costumes?
 
So Planet of the Apes would have worked better if the main apes were men in Ape costumes?

Nope.

Animal-practical effects are good for single shots or when in small numbers with no/limited movement.

Having apes like in Rise/Planet of the apes CGI works better because you're doing a lot of shots with "movement" and things (Where practical effects for animals usually are weak). Lots of shots with the chimps/apes doing very ape like things that a human can't do well, so CGI works better when it comes to that.

On the other hand, when you have "human" like creatures practical effects work better in many cases.

Take Lord of the rings vs the hobbit.

In Lord of the rings the orcs were real people with makeup/prosthetics, whereas in the Hobbit it was CGI, which one look more "fake" to you?

Lord of the rings:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iSKtx2A1X80

The Hobbit:
https://youtu.be/WFE6E9qAtuw?t=23s
 
Nope.

Animal-practical effects are good for single shots or when in small numbers with no/limited movement.

Having apes like in Rise/Planet of the apes CGI works better because you're doing a lot of shots with "movement" and things (Where practical effects for animals usually are weak). Lots of shots with the chimps/apes doing very ape like things that a human can't do well, so CGI works better when it comes to that.

On the other hand, when you have "human" like creatures practical effects work better in many cases.

Take Lord of the rings vs the hobbit.

In Lord of the rings the orcs were real people with makeup/prosthetics, whereas in the Hobbit it was CGI, which one look more "fake" to you?

Lord of the rings:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iSKtx2A1X80

The Hobbit:
https://youtu.be/WFE6E9qAtuw?t=23s

The Hobbit looks awful, but I don't know if it looked bad in theaters or not, especially given how horrible that video is (even at 1080), but my gut says on this one you're right...but to me that's a case of bad CGI. If you can make a chimp look good, you can make an imaginary creature look good.

I have no idea what happened in here. Maybe budgets got cut. It certainly looks like it's incomplete.
 
You're right abotu the quality, here's a better quality video I could find showing the main orc:
https://youtu.be/olVsFS8Ajtk?t=1m54s

There is absolutely no reason they couldn't have used makeup+prosthetics on an actual person to get that "look."
 
You're right abotu the quality, here's a better quality video I could find showing the main orc:
https://youtu.be/olVsFS8Ajtk?t=1m54s

There is absolutely no reason they couldn't have used makeup+prosthetics on an actual person to get that "look."

In that particular clip, it's not the orc that sticks out to me but the swirly camera motions towards the end before it gets cut off... My eye instantly caught the "impossible to do in camera" physics of it. While I rewatched the Harry Potter films, even in scenes with a mostly unnoticeable (or barely noticeable) gamma mismatch... they're really not that distracting as long as the physics make sense. Sudden switch from animatronics to CGI with wonky physics are the worst cases, usually.
 
I think some directors have just lost perspective on things.

Take for instance the scene in 2001 where the guy is asleep on the shuttle and his pen is floating and spinning in zero-g.

Looks great, works perfectly.

The cost of that special effect?

Probably less than a dollar.

They used a clear sheet of laminate and some 'newly invented' household product called double sided stickytape.

Took maybe a couple of hours to setup.

Now a modern director would sub contract that shot out to some digital effects warehouse where they would spend 2 months creating it at a cost of $750,000+

"We'll sort that in post!"
 
I think some directors have just lost perspective on things.

Take for instance the scene in 2001 where the guy is asleep on the shuttle and his pen is floating and spinning in zero-g.

Looks great, works perfectly.

The cost of that special effect?

Probably less than a dollar.

They used a clear sheet of laminate and some 'newly invented' household product called double sided stickytape.

Took maybe a couple of hours to setup.

Now a modern director would sub contract that shot out to some digital effects warehouse where they would spend 2 months creating it at a cost of $750,000+

"We'll sort that in post!"

You're contracting to the wrong digital effects warehouses most could do that for less than $10,000 with a 24 hour turn around.
 
You're right abotu the quality, here's a better quality video I could find showing the main orc:
https://youtu.be/olVsFS8Ajtk?t=1m54s

There is absolutely no reason they couldn't have used makeup+prosthetics on an actual person to get that "look."

I'd still like to see it on a bigger screen, but I don't love it...but to be honest, I don't think the dwarf looks good either. The lighting is really odd, but it may not be if I see it within the context of the movie.
 
If it looks bad on youtube or smaller resolution, then it'll almost always look much worse bigger in more clarity. The Hobbit series just looks bad overall, and it's not really about the framerate... Jackson just lost his ability to discern good from bad effects in general (CG, makeup, lighting, etc...) but of course will say it's merely an aesthetic "stylistic" choice. Like how lots of kids nowadays prefer the over-autotuned vocals over untouched realistic stuff. It's not so much about what is real as it is what looks new and fantastic, and those things change over time. I'm sure lots of Black/White film folks thought color didn't look good at first either, and they would correct in some cases such as sharpness and contrast levels. Similarly, newer effects simply need time to adapt. We keep pushing higher and higher resolutions and frame-rates, and that take a toll on render times. People still have mouths to feed.
 
I'm pretty sure most of them didn't. The video is fantastic. Obviously we pick up on a lot of CG but when it's things like the canyon in Mad Max I call BS. That stuff is nowhere near obvious to them. Ya clouds explosions sure but when it's a road side scenery that stuff is near impossible to pick out unless you're trying with all your might or lying to yourself.

Yep. CG has mastered adding more dusty rock, to a a dusty desert.

But creature stuff if galling bad. Case in point:

On the other hand, when you have "human" like creatures practical effects work better in many cases.

Take Lord of the rings vs the hobbit.

In Lord of the rings the orcs were real people with makeup/prosthetics, whereas in the Hobbit it was CGI, which one look more "fake" to you?

Lord of the rings:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iSKtx2A1X80

The Hobbit:
https://youtu.be/WFE6E9qAtuw?t=23s

Yep, perfect example of movies cheaping out and ruining things with CGI.
 
If it looks bad on youtube or smaller resolution, then it'll almost always look much worse bigger in more clarity. The Hobbit series just looks bad overall, and it's not really about the framerate... Jackson just lost his ability to discern good from bad effects in general (CG, makeup, lighting, etc...) but of course will say it's merely an aesthetic "stylistic" choice. Like how lots of kids nowadays prefer the over-autotuned vocals over untouched realistic stuff. It's not so much about what is real as it is what looks new and fantastic, and those things change over time. I'm sure lots of Black/White film folks thought color didn't look good at first either, and they would correct in some cases such as sharpness and contrast levels. Similarly, newer effects simply need time to adapt. We keep pushing higher and higher resolutions and frame-rates, and that take a toll on render times. People still have mouths to feed.

TI like Auto tuned voices are a stlylistic choice. The guy has great pipes (see his tiny desk concert if you have any doubts).

As for Big screen vs youtube, I can only go by things like old SW films. I never saw the obvious boxes around tie fighters in the theater, but it was always visible on TV (even in the VHS days). Hell, even when they did the SE versions in the late 90s, I didn't see them in the theater, but again they were there on VHS and later on DVD.

Still, it doesn't look great in that clip. One of these days I'll probably buy/rent the trilogy Extended versions and see what I think....just depends how much they cost.
 
Yep. CG has mastered adding more dusty rock, to a a dusty desert.

But creature stuff if galling bad. Case in point:



Yep, perfect example of movies cheaping out and ruining things with CGI.

the 3 movies cost 3/4 of a billion dollars. May have failed, but it was cheap.
 
Back
Top