HardOCP News
[H] News
- Joined
- Dec 31, 1969
- Messages
- 0
You guys really should watch this video. I think this guy makes some great points about the use of CG in movies.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
CG is easy to spot and sticks out like a sore thumb to me. They could fix a lot of this effect by not over exaggerating physics so much.
PeakR said:CG is easy to spot and sticks out like a sore thumb to me.
Nytegard said:This. Physics are wrong, but even the best CG still looks incredibly fake.
Sound like a no!I'm curious...did you guys actually watch the video?
This. Physics are wrong, but even the best CG still looks incredibly fake. I could live with a little fakeness, but they still don't explain why movies need to place unnecessary CGI in scenes.
did you even watch the video? there is no way you'd spot all the CG that is used these days.
did you even watch the video? there is no way you'd spot all the CG that is used these days.
I'm curious...did you guys actually watch the video?
As it points out, CGI is everywhere; that vast majority of the time, you simply don't see it, because it's good. CGI doesn't suck; bad CGI sucks.
did you even watch the video? there is no way you'd spot all the CG that is used these days.
That's a massive load of B.S. and you know it. I'll bet you're the type of person that thinks they can spot retouched portions of images all day long tooI did watch the video, and even in the latest Mad Max, certain things still felt off. If used in moderation, fine. But anything in the foreground feels fake most of the time. It feels too shiny and oversaturated. I have yet to see a movie where CG doesn't stand out like a sore thumb.
Yeah that snow at 1:02 is so fake omg."God dammit the physics in that rock outcropping were totally off /points finger CRAPPY FAKE CG!!"
I did watch the video, and even in the latest Mad Max, certain things still felt off. If used in moderation, fine. But anything in the foreground feels fake most of the time. It feels too shiny and oversaturated. I have yet to see a movie where CG doesn't stand out like a sore thumb.
For me, use all the CGI cars, buildings, and scenery you want. The moment you bring a CGI actor onto the screen, that kills it. CGI aliens, creatures, those are ok sometimes, it is just the fake actors/humanoid actors that make me hate CGI. The last movie I can think of with "no CGI" was The Evil Dead from 2013.
Eh...I didn't realize Sandra Bullock was CGI in Gravity. Good CGI is good.
I thought she looked like a bobble-head most of the time.
Gamma mismatch is a pet peeve of mine ... it's not that hard ...
I agree, and you'll notice many people blame bad MAKEUP, so you'd think that'd be an advantage for CG, but no, it simply sucked.Honestly, the final Hobbit movie's CG was terrible.
The problem with CG is that nowadays it's used for everything. Instead of using it for scenes where it makes sense. It gets to the point where you don't need actors, which I wouldn't complain. But movies like Short Circuit would suck if done with CG.
![]()
sucks to be you. Glad I can watch it and enjoy it.