Why CG Sucks (Except It Doesn't)

Great video. At this point. there is absolutely no need to even have physical actors there anymore I'd say.
 
CG is easy to spot and sticks out like a sore thumb to me. They could fix a lot of this effect by not over exaggerating physics so much.
 
CG is easy to spot and sticks out like a sore thumb to me. They could fix a lot of this effect by not over exaggerating physics so much.

This. Physics are wrong, but even the best CG still looks incredibly fake. I could live with a little fakeness, but they still don't explain why movies need to place unnecessary CGI in scenes.
 
The problem with CG is that it's useful when it's used it moderation, when it's little things that are CG'd when it's a main focus of any particular scene then it's absolutely horrible.
 
I'm curious...did you guys actually watch the video?

As it points out, CGI is everywhere; that vast majority of the time, you simply don't see it, because it's good. CGI doesn't suck; bad CGI sucks.
 
There's a lot more bad CG in movies than good, unfortuntely due to budget.

Also, I still believe there are certain things computers haven't perfected yet in creating with CG that do look better practical. The key is to strike the best balance of what you CG, versus what you use as practical.

Physics is also part of CG, and is usually not handled well. When the physics feel off, there is a sense of fakery and trickery you cannot excuse.

A good example I like to use is Farscape the TV series. All the puppets were practical puppets in the TV series, not CG. To me, that did just make it feel a lot better. Farscape wouldn't have looked so unique if all the aliens were CG.
 
Physics are still really bad for the most part. As for CGI itself, if you've worked with some you can see it pretty easily. Like all special effects, most people don't see them right away because it's all they know, but like today, people will laugh 20-30 years into the future at how basic they "used to be".
 
As long as I don't spot fakery on the first watch it's fine. If I go back and watch a movie again and spot things, thats fine. Its the first time I watch a movie is what matters imo.
 
I think the fact that so many thought that Mad Max had almost no CG shows that there's plenty of good CGI. And as the guy said, if it's a good movie, bad SFX don't matter.
 
This. Physics are wrong, but even the best CG still looks incredibly fake. I could live with a little fakeness, but they still don't explain why movies need to place unnecessary CGI in scenes.

did you even watch the video? there is no way you'd spot all the CG that is used these days.
 
did you even watch the video? there is no way you'd spot all the CG that is used these days.

I did watch the video, and even in the latest Mad Max, certain things still felt off. If used in moderation, fine. But anything in the foreground feels fake most of the time. It feels too shiny and oversaturated. I have yet to see a movie where CG doesn't stand out like a sore thumb.
 
I'm curious...did you guys actually watch the video?

As it points out, CGI is everywhere; that vast majority of the time, you simply don't see it, because it's good. CGI doesn't suck; bad CGI sucks.

I'm pretty sure most of them didn't. The video is fantastic. Obviously we pick up on a lot of CG but when it's things like the canyon in Mad Max I call BS. That stuff is nowhere near obvious to them. Ya clouds explosions sure but when it's a road side scenery that stuff is near impossible to pick out unless you're trying with all your might or lying to yourself.
 
Honestly, the final Hobbit movie's CG was terrible. It looked so faded and dull compared to the actual actors or objects in the scene. They also looked very 2 dimensional. That was a movie where CGI was done to a point that it ruined an already terrible film. rofl
 
I did watch the video, and even in the latest Mad Max, certain things still felt off. If used in moderation, fine. But anything in the foreground feels fake most of the time. It feels too shiny and oversaturated. I have yet to see a movie where CG doesn't stand out like a sore thumb.
That's a massive load of B.S. and you know it. I'll bet you're the type of person that thinks they can spot retouched portions of images all day long too :rolleyes:
 
I did watch the video, and even in the latest Mad Max, certain things still felt off. If used in moderation, fine. But anything in the foreground feels fake most of the time. It feels too shiny and oversaturated. I have yet to see a movie where CG doesn't stand out like a sore thumb.

Gamma mismatch is a pet peeve of mine ... it's not that hard ...
 
Good video, pretty much sums up what I've always felt about CG. If it's a movie/TV I enjoy, say Star Trek Voyager, I simply ignore any obvious effects (like species 8472 or Janeway on a lift platform in an alien city) but if the movie/TV is bad than obvious CG just makes it that much worse. But it's been nice that the good effects have steadily increased over the years as one would hope and expect and they will continue to do so...bad for people who earned extra money as extras.

Farscape though, I hated the puppets (except Pilot was pretty good) but then I didn't like the show so I doubt good CG would have helped.
 
For me, use all the CGI cars, buildings, and scenery you want. The moment you bring a CGI actor onto the screen, that kills it. CGI aliens, creatures, those are ok sometimes, it is just the fake actors/humanoid actors that make me hate CGI. The last movie I can think of with "no CGI" was The Evil Dead from 2013.
 
For me, use all the CGI cars, buildings, and scenery you want. The moment you bring a CGI actor onto the screen, that kills it. CGI aliens, creatures, those are ok sometimes, it is just the fake actors/humanoid actors that make me hate CGI. The last movie I can think of with "no CGI" was The Evil Dead from 2013.

Eh...I didn't realize Sandra Bullock was CGI in Gravity. Good CGI is good.
 
I was already calling bs on his breakdown, then he referenced micheal bays transformers, shut it off at that point. Guy is completely wrong. It isnt just physics that cg has issue with, its light and reflection, i can always, always, spot cg in scenes and the most basic way to do so is to catch the sheen on it, everything looks like its a little bit wet, even when the texture is mat. Half of his arguments where the use of computers to blend various real and practical effects shoots into a single shot, that is not computer graphics...

And transformers is the worst blend of cg and real effects i have ever watched, all of them are practically unwatchable, the mess on screen makes it impossible to tell what is happening.

Tldr CG has a long way to go, if you know what to look for you can always spot it.
 
Gamma mismatch is a pet peeve of mine ... it's not that hard ...

Gamma mismatch is the most obvious tell for me, too. Especially egregious in early 2000's films that started to use more cgi to replace objects when combined with animatronics. The troll scene in Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone is one example that comes to mind. CGI objects are less saturated, more pale in that film.

However, recently... there's been some great strides. Captain America Winter Soldier is one example where some basic compositing (and believability) issues aside, the CGI was fantastic. I was able to stay in the story.
 
Ya I agree, CG is WAAAAAAAAAAAY overdone in all movies now. Hey its cheaper for them to lay in fake ass graphics then actually film on location.

The fast n furious movies have way too much CG and its poorly done.
 
I disagree with the author. Bad CGI sucks, 100% of the time, and there is no excuse for it. The people making the movies who fail to see it, fail at their job, 100%.
 
Honestly, the final Hobbit movie's CG was terrible.
I agree, and you'll notice many people blame bad MAKEUP, so you'd think that'd be an advantage for CG, but no, it simply sucked.
 
The problem with CG is that nowadays it's used for everything. Instead of using it for scenes where it makes sense. It gets to the point where you don't need actors, which I wouldn't complain. But movies like Short Circuit would suck if done with CG.

tumblr_m0brfhVgTD1qd1ub2o1_500.gif
 
The problem with CG is that nowadays it's used for everything. Instead of using it for scenes where it makes sense. It gets to the point where you don't need actors, which I wouldn't complain. But movies like Short Circuit would suck if done with CG.

tumblr_m0brfhVgTD1qd1ub2o1_500.gif

What's your opinion on chappie?
 
My problem is when you combine CG + shake cam + .25 second shots cut after cut. You basically see nothing, which is great way to mask bad CG.
 
My issue with CGI and movies is the director ends up using it to replace real scenes with easily done CG animation. It ends up ruining the feel of the movie, instead of developing the scene and finding the feel they just give direction to a bunch of nerds and they come up with something that looks outstanding but has zero feel to it.

I loved the way they used it in Mad Max, every scene was originally shot. Some ended up getting completely replaced by CGI but they still filmed to preserve accurate angles and actual elements of the real scene. Made it much better and awe inspiring.
 
Don't watch a lot of movies... but man, I wouldn't have realized most of that were CG.
 
The first rule of Movie Making -

1. You need a really good script.

Then -

2. Everything else.
 
sucks to be you. Glad I can watch it and enjoy it.

Yep. Gravity is one of the best Sci-Fi movies I've seen. One scene completely ignores physics, but that's not CGI's fault. The script and a the acting is at a level that won't allow a single flawed scene to ruin the whole experience.
 
I personally can't wait to see what JJ Abrams has in store for Star Wars fans. So looking forward to The Force Awakens.
 
Back
Top