Why aren't there any high end AMD CPUs?

Vithar

Limp Gawd
Joined
Mar 6, 2012
Messages
269
I'm just curious why doesn't AMD make CPUs in the $300 price point like Intel does, I mean AMD's most expensive CPU is the FX 8150 and that's still at the $200 price point, why is that?
 
Because amd has nothing to compete with against the 2600k price point.
 
That's pretty much it. Intel has (again) forced them into a lower price band based on their relative performance.
 
AMD could easilly repackage their G34 processors for desktop and have something that could (in the multi-threaded realm, at least) compete with the fastest i7, but they choose not to because AMD does not find the high-end desktop market important. it has nothing to do with "can't": AMD "wont" do it.
 
For AMD to compete at the 2600K level of performance (and higher) will require a significant amount of resources and finances. Unfortunately, that is something AMD does not have, or cannot afford to divert resources to. Like I said in my other post in the other thread, Intel beats AMD's net income 8-to-1. EIGHT-TO-ONE. That's as of the last fiscal year. That's a significant amount of cash Intel has on hand. Intel can afford to research in new CPU materials and technology like tri-gate transistors, and take risks on them. AMD can't do that. They may be behind and slow to catch on, but they are trying. Steamroller looks to me as a turning point for AMD because they're implementing something Intel already had back on Sandy Bridge-- microOP cache. Who knows if it's enough to beat the fabled 2600K? But, to get there, would have required investments in technology and research and design spread over years, not months. Intel can spend money on this and do this in months and less time than AMD can.

AMD has opted, instead, now to devote a good amount of resources towards its APU and server products. From their server products, research and development comes the FX processors (and everything in-between them and Trinity) for consumers. So, what may not work as well as the 2600K or higher for gamers, may work better for mobile users, multitasking and server-related tasks. It's pretty evident where AMD is putting its money on and is betting on it. Is it a risk worth taking? Probably. We may not see the benefits now, but maybe in the future.

They bought out ATI. They bought out Sea Micro. They partnered with ARM for on-chip security processes. They started the HSA Foundation for the fusion of CPU and GPU computing. AMD is placing their bets and investing heavily in future technology that probably may not matter to us now, but most likely in the future.

If these resources were diverted for competing directly at Intel to achieve a high-end midrange and enthusiast processor on par with the 2600K and higher parts, then we would have probably seen $300, $400, $500 or even $1000 FX processors. They'd be priced as a way to get a return in that investment. But, we aren't seeing that.

Maybe they realize like with many other software development companies, that the future lies in mobile technology and server technology. Who knows? Intel is making those bets too. Microsoft as well. Everything nowadays seems to be cloud-this, mobile-this, and that. It's probably a future worth investing in now or get left behind.

Intel can afford the extra investment in new technology for its processors because they can. Not AMD. AMD is pretty much forced into this position, like Forceman said above. AMD has to decide with what little money they have and where should their money go to. I, myself, do not believe AMD has the money or the resources to spread out in different areas such as GPU, enthusiast CPU, mobile APU, and server technology all at once. That's pretty much spreading yourself too thin and could bankrupt the company itself. (Maybe, maybe not.)
 
Well said, octoberasian. Totally agree.

AMD is a smaller company, they're doing what they can.

I too think there's more growth in low power/mobile stuff than there is in high end desktops. How many phones, laptops, and tablets are sold a year compared the # of high end enthusiast desktop systems?
 
AMD could easilly repackage their G34 processors for desktop and have something that could (in the multi-threaded realm, at least) compete with the fastest i7, but they choose not to because AMD does not find the high-end desktop market important. it has nothing to do with "can't": AMD "wont" do it.

It would only compete in heavy multithreaded applications which is what the majority of desktop users don't utilize or appreciate. Sure a dual G34, 32 core system would rip a movie pretty fast... but surfing the web, checkng email, or gaming would see no benefit over whats already in the desktop space.

Though I am curious how a G34 system would benchmark on BF3....
 
It would only compete in heavy multithreaded applications which is what the majority of desktop users don't utilize or appreciate. Sure a dual G34, 32 core system would rip a movie pretty fast... but surfing the web, checkng email, or gaming would see no benefit over whats already in the desktop space.

Though I am curious how a G34 system would benchmark on BF3....

Badly. G34s are low-clocked ships, and don't do that well in single-threaded apps.
 
A lot of people misunderstand my stance on desktop G34: I'm not saying they simply take the Opteron processor and put an 'FX' sticker on it. All I'm saying is that AMD could run with the Opteron's G34 platform and release higher-clocked CPUs for desktop. Intel's Xeon chips are rarely clocked over 3.0 ghz, but the 2011 i7s are between 3.4 and 3.8ghz; yet they use lower-bin silicon. AMD could do the exact same thing and just raise the clocks on a couple of its 12 and 16 core chips and release them as desktop performance processors.
 
For AMD to compete at the 2600K level of performance (and higher) will require a significant amount of resources and finances. Unfortunately, that is something AMD does not have, or cannot afford to divert resources to. Like I said in my other post in the other thread, Intel beats AMD's net income 8-to-1. EIGHT-TO-ONE. That's as of the last fiscal year. That's a significant amount of cash Intel has on hand. Intel can afford to research in new CPU materials and technology like tri-gate transistors, and take risks on them. AMD can't do that. They may be behind and slow to catch on, but they are trying. Steamroller looks to me as a turning point for AMD because they're implementing something Intel already had back on Sandy Bridge-- microOP cache. Who knows if it's enough to beat the fabled 2600K? But, to get there, would have required investments in technology and research and design spread over years, not months. Intel can spend money on this and do this in months and less time than AMD can.

AMD has opted, instead, now to devote a good amount of resources towards its APU and server products. From their server products, research and development comes the FX processors (and everything in-between them and Trinity) for consumers. So, what may not work as well as the 2600K or higher for gamers, may work better for mobile users, multitasking and server-related tasks. It's pretty evident where AMD is putting its money on and is betting on it. Is it a risk worth taking? Probably. We may not see the benefits now, but maybe in the future.

They bought out ATI. They bought out Sea Micro. They partnered with ARM for on-chip security processes. They started the HSA Foundation for the fusion of CPU and GPU computing. AMD is placing their bets and investing heavily in future technology that probably may not matter to us now, but most likely in the future.

If these resources were diverted for competing directly at Intel to achieve a high-end midrange and enthusiast processor on par with the 2600K and higher parts, then we would have probably seen $300, $400, $500 or even $1000 FX processors. They'd be priced as a way to get a return in that investment. But, we aren't seeing that.

Maybe they realize like with many other software development companies, that the future lies in mobile technology and server technology. Who knows? Intel is making those bets too. Microsoft as well. Everything nowadays seems to be cloud-this, mobile-this, and that. It's probably a future worth investing in now or get left behind.

Intel can afford the extra investment in new technology for its processors because they can. Not AMD. AMD is pretty much forced into this position, like Forceman said above. AMD has to decide with what little money they have and where should their money go to. I, myself, do not believe AMD has the money or the resources to spread out in different areas such as GPU, enthusiast CPU, mobile APU, and server technology all at once. That's pretty much spreading yourself too thin and could bankrupt the company itself. (Maybe, maybe not.)
AMD had to do some mistakes in the past that devoted them in current position, they started not even 1 year after Intel, so I believe Intel had to have better management and organization inside the company while AMD didn't, although I was hardcore AMD fan long time, sometimes I think they are smoking crack in there, and they are buying it from the income, instead of putting resources to research. The Barcelona and Bulldozer were great examples that something is very wrong. Intel is much better in keeping market position.
 
I'm just curious why doesn't AMD make CPUs in the $300 price point like Intel does, I mean AMD's most expensive CPU is the FX 8150 and that's still at the $200 price point, why is that?

Because their mainstream desktop platform is limited to 125w TDP, and OEMs wouldn't absorb the extra cost associated with a higher TDP.

They could probably boost performance reliably by a few hundred MHz if they bumped the voltage, but increasing performance (essentially overclocking) would push power consumption way up. Without more power, they cannot increase performance...and their current performance at 125w is barely at-or-above the 2500k mark. You can't sell a lesser-performing chip for more money and expect people to take you seriously (the reason they cut prices soon after the launch of Bulldozer).
 
A lot of people misunderstand my stance on desktop G34: I'm not saying they simply take the Opteron processor and put an 'FX' sticker on it. All I'm saying is that AMD could run with the Opteron's G34 platform and release higher-clocked CPUs for desktop. Intel's Xeon chips are rarely clocked over 3.0 ghz, but the 2011 i7s are between 3.4 and 3.8ghz; yet they use lower-bin silicon. AMD could do the exact same thing and just raise the clocks on a couple of its 12 and 16 core chips and release them as desktop performance processors.

Yes they could however they would have to introduce a new socket that was designed to use more power like a 175W stock or 200W stock or even more than that. I would suspect this to be a platform with a market similar to lga2011.

I would certainly be interested in a 200W 10 or 12 core piledriver / steamroller with a > 4GHz stock. Although if this was a > $1000 CPU maybe not so much..
 
Last edited:
I'm just curious why doesn't AMD make CPUs in the $300 price point like Intel does, I mean AMD's most expensive CPU is the FX 8150 and that's still at the $200 price point, why is that?

Dude, what planet have you been living on the last five years:confused:
 
I'm just curious why doesn't AMD make CPUs in the $300 price point like Intel does, I mean AMD's most expensive CPU is the FX 8150 and that's still at the $200 price point, why is that?

because AMD has moved away from the high end market and are moving more toward the APU market which has a lot more potential in the long run then to bother spending millions of dollars trying to compete with intel in the high end market where profit margins aren't as good.
 
What has been said here is generally true - its unfortunate that AMD is basically outspent, but I too am wishing that AMD could compete at the high end. For quite some time with the Athlon64 through Phenom II chips, AMD really was doing well and offering gaming use and desktop workstation multitasking use that were really competitive. Much like their video cards after taking over ATI, they offered something 10% less powerful than Intel (sometimes, less than that!) at a huge discount! In addition, their technologies like AMD64 basically brought the possibility for 64 bit computing to the desktop in a viable and affordable way - to the point that even Intel incorporated their style of 64 bit instructions and extensions. AMD really had some great processors.

Unfortunately, they've been lagging behind for the past 3 generations and that means that Intel is just raising prices and fapping around. If AMD had a near 2600K and 3770K processor offering, I can guarantee that SB-E would be cheaper, similar to 1366's affordability and that IB-E wouldn't be waiting until NEXT FUCKING YEAR to debut; likely at a maxed out price using old technology compared to the mainstream Haswell etc.. Bulldozer just wasn't competitive; and you can't launch a product that is made for an extreme specialization in a market that isn't going to make use of that specialization for the most part. So Intel keeps prices high on procs and platforms, old tech around etc...

AMD could likely profit greatly if they were able to to provide competitive parts meant to be near the performance of top-end Intel mainstream chips in the $200-300 market, and then really do well by offering $300-500 ultra high end chips that compete with Intel's enthusiast market like the 3930K and 3960X etc... if the performance was close enough, I can guarantee lots of people would rather buy a $300 -$500 AMD enthusiast high end instead of Intel offerings costing near double that. Sadly though, since they are outspent so highly its going to be difficult for them to muster the technology to make those kinds of chips. This is one case where I feel that patents and whatnot are really keeping technology down.

I like to support AMD , especially as they fabricate in the US, make their creations as "open" as possible with response to drivers and specs etc.. but if they just can't provide chips that will allow me to game and run other high end desktop stuff smoothly, I can't justify purchasing them. Intel has some skeevy business practices though, especially with respect to grants, public funds backing patented developments and ending up as private money, fabrication in southeast asia, and their interactions in Israel; I'd like to see some of these issues dealt with to put them on a more even platform with AMD, perhaps - they're not so wealthy simply because they're just "that good" - there is a lot of ethical and political considerations with their business practices.

I'm hoping that AMD's gamble will pay off in the end, and the APUs are looking very nice in some regards, but they can't continue to make Bulldozers in the processor world; its not good for AMD and only allows Intel hegemony to rest on its laurels.
 
I don't really think the Intel sell expensive processors, only the SB-E is overpriced crap. The next thing is, although AMD is US company, the fabrication of dies is currently in EU and assembly in Malaysia, they are building new plant in NY but it's not yet complete.
 
Profit, plain and simple.

AMD can't be profitable by going for the high end, simply because they don't have the resources, research and development, to compete with Intel on this front.

If I were a betting man, I'd wager that the market for the top end CPU's is awfully small, and that AMD would be fighting for what is a rather small piece of filet mignon / lobster tails at the dinner table. It's simply not practical for them to pay a king's ransom for such a meal, no matter how tasty it may be.

Instead, it's better for them to focus on more practical solutions that give people a big bang / buck, such as the A-series APU. These chips give a nice boost to the user at a low cost, and systems that use such chips don't need much power at all, since you don't have to worry about a separate graphics card.

Think of AMD's offerings as chuck eye steaks. While they're not as tender or as magnificent as filet mignon, they're certainly quite tasty, are still nicely marbled, and tender enough for most folks that they can enjoy a good steak at a low cost.
 
never gonna give you up never gonna let you down, never gonna run around and desert you
 
keep on trolling trolling trolling. October amd will have its new cpu out... till then lets keep trolling trolling trolling
 
The FX series is their high-end. When the FX-8150 first appeared, it was more expensive than the 2600K.

The reviews across the web showed all of us what the true colors of these new processors really are amidst all the pre-release hype: higher power consumption, higher heat output, and slower performance in many applications than the processors they were meant to replace.

That's why prices have dropped so drastically and the 8150 is $170 shipped right now.

They are still very capable processors, and for Joe Shmoe the web surfer/email checker/Facebooker/light-moderate gamer, they would not be able to tell if AMD or Intel was under the hood.
 
Last edited:
Profit, plain and simple.

AMD can't be profitable by going for the high end, simply because they don't have the resources, research and development, to compete with Intel on this front.

If I were a betting man, I'd wager that the market for the top end CPU's is awfully small, and that AMD would be fighting for what is a rather small piece of filet mignon / lobster tails at the dinner table. It's simply not practical for them to pay a king's ransom for such a meal, no matter how tasty it may be.

Instead, it's better for them to focus on more practical solutions that give people a big bang / buck, such as the A-series APU. These chips give a nice boost to the user at a low cost, and systems that use such chips don't need much power at all, since you don't have to worry about a separate graphics card.

Think of AMD's offerings as chuck eye steaks. While they're not as tender or as magnificent as filet mignon, they're certainly quite tasty, are still nicely marbled, and tender enough for most folks that they can enjoy a good steak at a low cost.

I completely agree with this. AMD needs to basically ignore Intel and make products that work best for their target audience. AMD may never be the fastest and best, but all they need to do is produce products that their customers NEED, and keep it cheap. Intel is for the WANT-to-have crowd (at least in the consumer/gaming market), AMD has to position itself as the go to supplier of what people need instead of want. Show me a $4000 PC that can rip a Blu-Ray in 30 seconds and I will drool all over it and want it badly, but show me a PC for < $1000 that can play the latest games and still do editing and productivity work, but not quite as fast and I'll go for best bang for the buck. As far as I'm concerned, Bulldozer was a MASSIVE failure because AMD lost sight of who they are, they are not Intel and they should not try to be. The Deneb processors are still VERY viable after what.. 4 years? That right there is testament to what AMD is all about. I'm currently in the process of switching back to AMD.
 
I completely agree with this. AMD needs to basically ignore Intel and make products that work best for their target audience. AMD may never be the fastest and best, but all they need to do is produce products that their customers NEED, and keep it cheap. Intel is for the WANT-to-have crowd (at least in the consumer/gaming market), AMD has to position itself as the go to supplier of what people need instead of want. Show me a $4000 PC that can rip a Blu-Ray in 30 seconds and I will drool all over it and want it badly, but show me a PC for < $1000 that can play the latest games and still do editing and productivity work, but not quite as fast and I'll go for best bang for the buck. As far as I'm concerned, Bulldozer was a MASSIVE failure because AMD lost sight of who they are, they are not Intel and they should not try to be. The Deneb processors are still VERY viable after what.. 4 years? That right there is testament to what AMD is all about. I'm currently in the process of switching back to AMD.

They don't even make blu-ray drives that are any where near being able to rip a blu-ray in 30 seconds so it's pretty irrelevant if the CPU can or not.
 
OP, back in the day, AMD had a processor called the FX-60 which is equivalent to today's i7-3960X... it was the best processor at the time and was around ~$1000.
The FX series is their high-end.
It's a shame their marketing team just tossed all good history with that name when they released Bulldozer. :(
 
They don't even make blu-ray drives that are any where near being able to rip a blu-ray in 30 seconds so it's pretty irrelevant if the CPU can or not.

That was just an extreme example.. Wasn't meant to be taken literally.
 
OP, back in the day, AMD had a processor called the FX-60 which is equivalent to today's i7-3960X... it was the best processor at the time and was around ~$1000.

Having the most bad-ass processor doesn't mean crap if you can't out produce your competition. Yes the Athlon FX chips basically curb stomped the P4EE chips into the ground, but AMD couldn't make a whole lot, and didn't actually outsell the P4EE (even more so that 'high-end' OEM machines basically ignored AMD).
 
My 8120 sure plays every game out today just fine and encodes video for youtube beautifully. Lots of time I'll do both at the same time for fun. 3D gaming is fun on this processor.

So what am I missing by going Intel again? 5 fps in older games?
 
Ummm, those are the high end amd cpus :)

Its just that they are shit compared to intel atm, but as far as amd are concerned, those are their high end chips.

They still perform admirably for everything mind you, hell up until 2010 I was using a fx60 which could do everything I wanted to do, ok it struggled with newer games, but it could still play them, but that was a chip from 2006, so the ones from 2012 are going to be just fine.
 
I miss the Thuban series. I went looking for 1100t to build a rtorrent box and can't find any other than used
 
I miss the Thuban series. I went looking for 1100t to build a rtorrent box and can't find any other than used

Yeah, you'll only find used 1100Ts now. The only retail X6 Thuban is the 1045T but even then, they're selling what's currently available in stock. This will be the case for the Bulldozer-based FX 4000, 6000 and 8000 series probably by next year if anyone still wants to buy them when Piledriver-based FX processors are out.

If looking for it, you may want to try Pricewatch and see if some smaller online e-tailer has it. Of course, the last options are Craiglist and eBay.
 
I remember having the highest end AMD FX single core back in the day.. I forget which one it was but it was hella expensive at the time of release. I got it cheaper when the dual-cores came out. I didn't go for the dual then because nothing I used supported them (and in some cases ran worse on a dual). I've been bouncing between AMD and Intel ever since the AM386 DX 40Mhz. AMD was very sketchy on the first generation of Athlons and I think the socket Athlon is the only generation of AMD I never owned.. I got GREAT mileage from my overclocked Celeron 300 (the most historic milestone in overclocking ever!!!!)
 
How much longer will AMD be in business?

I believe staying out of the highest end (at least not sinking all their money into) and concentrating on mobile while removing their fab liability are measures to have long term profitability.
 
Last edited:
Having the most bad-ass processor doesn't mean crap if you can't out produce your competition. Yes the Athlon FX chips basically curb stomped the P4EE chips into the ground, but AMD couldn't make a whole lot, and didn't actually outsell the P4EE (even more so that 'high-end' OEM machines basically ignored AMD).

Back in those days, people still thought AMD sucked. I dont know how many times i heard comments, "they are unreliable, they over heat, etc etc" Even if AMD had a superior chip it would be pretty hard to convince people of it.
 
Back in those days, people still thought AMD sucked. I dont know how many times i heard comments, "they are unreliable, they over heat, etc etc" Even if AMD had a superior chip it would be pretty hard to convince people of it.

Yes this was quite true during that time:(
 
I've always built amd machines, but a huge issue was their motherboards back then. The nforce boards were finally built well enough that some people would switch over but were still pretty bad at times. Let's not forget socket 754 being almost dead upon arrival and then am2 not offering much more than 939 for almost two years. It created a lot of dead areas where they should have made more of it than they should have.
 
I believe staying out of the highest end (at least not sinking all their money into) and concentrating on mobile while removing their fab liability are measures to have long term profitability.

"Removing their fab liability"? What do you mean?

It doesn't matter if they stay out of any particular market section; they don't have the capacity to make enough chips for any top-tier vendor, so they'll never get serious contracts. They have no intellectual property, they have no capital assets, and so they're doomed.
 
"Removing their fab liability"? What do you mean?

It doesn't matter if they stay out of any particular market section; they don't have the capacity to make enough chips for any top-tier vendor, so they'll never get serious contracts. They have no intellectual property, they have no capital assets, and so they're doomed.

AMD is no longer a part of GlobalFoundries as of last year. GlobalFoundries is now like TSMC. AMD gives them the chip designs, and GloFo makes it for them.

Hence, no fab liability. AMD is free to go to whatever fabricator they'd like for their products-- TSMC or GloFo.
 
"Removing their fab liability"? What do you mean?

It doesn't matter if they stay out of any particular market section; they don't have the capacity to make enough chips for any top-tier vendor, so they'll never get serious contracts. They have no intellectual property, they have no capital assets, and so they're doomed.

Did you come in here specifically to bash AMD?

Llano was a huge success. Trinity is doing well. Their server chips are doing decently well. In fact, they're doing just fine in every market except the one market that people on [H] care about: the enthusiast market.
 
Back
Top