Why All The Hate For Wikipedia?

My favorite is when someone edits their own wikipedia page, only to have their work redacted because it's not popular.
 
"Capital of Namibia? I'll just head to the library that's open about 5 hours a day."
 
If you read up on WWII in Europe, the Russians sided with the Nazis at first. They started expanding their empire the minute Hitler did; Poland circa 1939.

WWII was the best thing that happened to Russia. They should have taken down by the Allied powers in 1945. Russia gained a lot territory from WWII. They betrayed the Poles, the Finns, the Japanese, the Allies, and everyone else who they could.
 
It's accurate more often than it is not. I don't get why you guys are so bitter.

Because proper academic research is done through primary sources. Wikipedia is not a primary source. Wikipedia is good for what it is, but it is not nor should it ever be relied upon as a primary or one's only source.
 
Not sure how many Russians at least at the time saw it that way. Actually the US benefited the most from WW II.


Stalin was good with it. He didn't care how many Russians died, as long as the ones left feared him.

How much land did the US gain from WWII?
 
Stalin did some really crappy things. If Russia was a "victim" it was just karma.
 
Note: The US GNP doubled from 1939-1946.
So did the USSR.

The US wasn't afraid of Russia simply because Stalin was a dick. We had legitimate concerns that they were going to take over the world after WWII.
 
How much land did the US gain from WWII?

And how developed the bomb four years before the Soviets? And where is the Soviet Empire today?

My Dad grew up in the Great Depression and joined the Army as soon as he could in early 1942. If you think the economy is bad now, it was REALLY bad prior to WW II. There's so much that we accomplished during WW II. Just think about the military power that we projected across two oceans, no one had ever done that. The development of the bomb, getting ourselves out of the doldrums of the Depression and ramping up our factories, factories that built much more than just weapons. Plus we were the only great power spared the destruction of the war, I don't think people realize just how deadly and destructive that conflict was, everything pales in comparison to the size and scope of all other wars to this day. Yes, other economies grew quickly because they had been pulverized. The US was wholly intact.
 
Apparently some people here believe that authors of books and encyclopedia entries are incapable of bias.
 
Wikipedia is absolutely not a reasonably reliable source of information on anything. Sure it has a lot of good information but the inconsistency makes it impossible for someone who does not already know the answers to the questions they are asking to trust it.

Google tried this with Knol, and, oops, all the articles came from biased professionals. That sunk Knol quite fast.

I dislike Wikipedia as Jimmy Wales makes his biases well known. Someone in his position needs to stfu and just evangelize in the name of Wikipedia, not, his political party.
 
I dislike Wikipedia as Jimmy Wales makes his biases well known. Someone in his position needs to stfu and just evangelize in the name of Wikipedia, not, his political party.

So, we're to believe you're not biased in any way?

Usually, such statements expose one's own bias to the party that feels slighted by what one could consider one's ideological foe.

Nice try!
 
Wikipedia needs to be taken with a grain of salt, you can get citations for anything. For example this article makes it seem like there is serious scientific traction behind an idea that has basically been totally defeated in the mainstream: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Altaic_languages It's in an area that very few people would care enough to mod down and the people involved have essentially bet their careers on a sinking ship so they have a lot of motivation to keep it up.

Just one example of many, I'm not saying Wikipedia isn't interesting or entertaining. What I am saying is that even for technical or scientific information you have to be very careful.
 
Wikipedia needs to be taken with a grain of salt, you can get citations for anything. For example this article makes it seem like there is serious scientific traction behind an idea that has basically been totally defeated in the mainstream: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Altaic_languages It's in an area that very few people would care enough to mod down and the people involved have essentially bet their careers on a sinking ship so they have a lot of motivation to keep it up.

Just one example of many, I'm not saying Wikipedia isn't interesting or entertaining. What I am saying is that even for technical or scientific information you have to be very careful.

Jeepers, I dont think I have seen a more boring wiki page lol.
You'd have to be pretty hard up for fun to make a career from this.
 
Wikipedia is good for simple and mostly widespread knowledge that isn't subject to bias. Basically like any encyclopedia.

If you're going to spend copious hours researching something, wikipedia probably isn't your best bet. If it's very obscure knowledge, wikipedia probably isn't your best bet. If it's something that's subject to bias, treat wikipedia as one of many potential sources just like you would any other source of potentially biased information.

I mostly find myself at wikipedia when I'm looking up a formula or relationship that I can't remember off the top of my head and it's quicker to google it than look up a text book. Usually when I see it, it comes back to my memory so I'm not overly worried about potential inaccuracies.

The other time I find myself at wikipedia is just looking for random information that might be otherwise hard to find. Like, recently, what year did Battletoads come out? Google, first link is wikipedia, bang, there's your release date.
 
Whenever I think about Wiki's potential to be inaccurate I think about Neil deGrasse Tyson saying how he tried to correct his own Wiki page and it would get reverted back to incorrect information...lol.

Still a great source of temporary information.
 
I think it's stupid people condemn Wikipedia because it's not a perfect source of information. There is no perfect source of information, and there won't be as long as humans are compiling it. Wikipedia is a vast collection of information that is generally more reliable than the vast majority of websites out there, and therefore is useful as a reference to compare other sources. Only idiots rely on a single source of information. Seems to me anyone complaining Wikipedia is not perfect is expecting to have a single source of information to rely on.
 
I use Wikipedia pretty much daily, but one thing I hate about the site are the "hardcore" editors who keep changing the article by removing useful information or anything that doesn't "comply" with them is what gets on my nerves.

But sometimes Wikipedia cannot be trusted because people tend to edit false information.
 
Back
Top