Why All The Hate For Wikipedia?

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Why all the hate for Wikipedia? I don't know, the term "self inflicted wounds" comes to mind. -citation needed

Much hay has been made over the unevenness of coverage across different topic areas, but the fact remains that on a broad spectrum of subjects – from science to literature to history – a student or novice reader can get the basics on almost any topic he or she might want, and can usually get a list of references for where to find more information.
 
1290599035621.jpg
 
If I have no integrity, an agenda, and time on my hands, I can make wikipedia spin my way. What's the problem?
 
Wikipedia is absolutely not a reasonably reliable source of information on anything. Sure it has a lot of good information but the inconsistency makes it impossible for someone who does not already know the answers to the questions they are asking to trust it.
 
Wikipedia is really useful as long as you dont go researching politicians :p
I dont have a problem with it, nor have I heard of it being hated by real people (as opposed to internetees).
 
Wikipedia is absolutely not a reasonably reliable source of information on anything. Sure it has a lot of good information but the inconsistency makes it impossible for someone who does not already know the answers to the questions they are asking to trust it.

That was true 7-8 years ago. Now, most articles have proper citations. It gets a little hairy when it comes to politics, but it's very good for technical information.
 
That was true 7-8 years ago. Now, most articles have proper citations. It gets a little hairy when it comes to politics, but it's very good for technical information.

I'd say it's a good start to acquire information, but the problem is too many people take it as gospel. And I'm not even talking bias articles here (politics, religion, etc.). There have been several topics I've seen blatantly wrong information on. Modifying pages to correct them can sometimes be tricky.
 
I'd say it's a good start to acquire information, but the problem is too many people take it as gospel. And I'm not even talking bias articles here (politics, religion, etc.). There have been several topics I've seen blatantly wrong information on. Modifying pages to correct them can sometimes be tricky.

Agreed, for what it is it is still an excellent tool but yeah, I hate the actual editing technology. I use it to get general ideas about things that I am unfamiliar with, looking up bio info on celebs, etc. For important or academic use, of course major pieces of information should independently verified.
 
I'm usually not disappointed whenever i look up stuff related to science or technology; history too. And you know what? There's all these little links at the bottom to check facts.

Granted, most people don't check facts--but that's their fault, not wikipedia's.
 
I love Wikipedia. It's great for getting up to speed on a topic real quick or learning something new. To validate anything or if you're doing real research - use the sources at the bottom. From those sources, you can verify the information (or debunk it).
 
Wikipedia is absolutely not a reasonably reliable source of information on anything.

Wikipedia said:
This article is about the term used in rhetoric. For the mathematical term, see Hyperbola.

Hyperbole (/haɪˈpɜrbəliː/ hy-PUR-bə-lee;[1] Greek: ὑπερβολή hyperbolē, "exaggeration") is the use of exaggeration as a rhetorical device or figure of speech. It may be used to evoke strong feelings or to create a strong impression, but is not meant to be taken literally.[2]

Hyperboles are exaggerations to create emphasis or effect. As a literary device, hyperbole is often used in poetry, and is frequently encountered in casual speech. An example of hyperbole is: "The bag weighed a ton."[3] Hyperbole makes the point that the bag was very heavy, though it probably does not weigh a ton

In rhetoric, some opposites of hyperbole are meiosis, litotes, understatement, and bathos (the 'letdown' after a hyperbole in a phrase).
They seem to have got this one right.
 
I'm usually not disappointed whenever i look up stuff related to science or technology; history too. And you know what? There's all these little links at the bottom to check facts.

Granted, most people don't check facts--but that's their fault, not wikipedia's.

Exactly... many people are using it wrong.
 
For everything they are a questionable source of information, entirely dependent on the bias and writing ability of the author. Some articles are just outright poorly written, and all necessary information is left to the references.

Anything to do with politics, political figures, political movements, etc...are utterly awful. Senior editors change an article to sound the way they like, and then lock it. That "lock" mechanism is quickly destroying the concept of an "open" encyclopedia, considering the increased frequency of usage.
 
The true value of wiki is the resources. Get a good understanding of the material but get what you need through the links.

You no longer need to hunt for sources of material is already in one package for you.
 
I saw this study a few years ago:
http://bpastudio.csudh.edu/fac/lpress/wikieval/

The sample size was only 50, so it is not fully credible from the get go, but I still thought it was interesting.


It asked experts in various fields to take a look at some wikipedia pages related to their study, and then look at equivalent Encyclopedia Britannica pages.

It seems that the majority found that wikipedia was actually more accurate/complete compared to Encyclopedia Britannica.


But again, a 50 person sample size is hardly enough to draw any serious conclusions. I am sure there are some other "issues" with the study as well. I just proffer it up as I found it interesting, and relevant here.
 
That was true 7-8 years ago. Now, most articles have proper citations. It gets a little hairy when it comes to politics, but it's very good for technical information.

That is simply put not truth. Words mean things and unless the meaning of reliable has changed Wikipedia does not meet any reasonable definition of reliable. Errors in normal technical information are common and forget trusting anything remotely involving politics or history. Wikipedia can only be used as a starting point anything and everything there is suspect until verified... that hardly meets the requirement of "reliable".
 
"basics" yep.

Many of the cited sources are garbage*, making a whole lot of topics slanted and in some cases plain wrong. Plus there are OCD egomaniacal editors and previous contributors who revert edits because it goes against their pet theories or other thoughts about how the topic should be covered.

* the only standard seems to be that someone at sometime wrote it on a web page, regardless of the accuracy
 
adding...

Wikipedia is great for trivia-type knowledge (caution: inaccuracies), and can be used as a basis to search for primary sources of information after relevant terms are extracted and used.
 
I'm usually not disappointed whenever i look up stuff related to science or technology; history too. And you know what? There's all these little links at the bottom to check facts.

Granted, most people don't check facts--but that's their fault, not wikipedia's.
Doesn't help one bit if biased spin is accomplished by omitting or blocking content
 
Use Wikipedia to get a 1000 mile view of something. Dig into the sources for the real deal (while also vetting those sources).
 
Because they won't take bitcoin donations

The Foundation does not currently accept Bitcoin or other currencies not backed by the full faith and credit of an issuing government.
 
That is simply put not truth. Words mean things and unless the meaning of reliable has changed Wikipedia does not meet any reasonable definition of reliable. Errors in normal technical information are common and forget trusting anything remotely involving politics or history. Wikipedia can only be used as a starting point anything and everything there is suspect until verified... that hardly meets the requirement of "reliable".

More reliable than any other encyclopedia, with more information to boot. Obviously you should check citations, but you should do that even with peer reviewed journals. Most of the information is accurate.
 
I guess. Point me to something better, then.

Depends on the topic, but primary source material is ideal. Try google scholar for journal articles for research etc. For historical information, maybe a book? Wikipedia is a tertiary source at best. Go to a primary or secondary source.
 
Depends on the topic, but primary source material is ideal. Try google scholar for journal articles for research etc. For historical information, maybe a book? Wikipedia is a tertiary source at best. Go to a primary or secondary source.

So, you're saying there is no better aggregate source of information that exists in this world today.
 
So, you're saying there is no better aggregate source of information that exists in this world today.

No, I'm saying there is no GOOD, RELIABLE aggregated source of information in the world today.
 
It's accurate more often than it is not. I don't get why you guys are so bitter.
 
More reliable than any other encyclopedia
[citation required] :p

I've looked at wikipedia's own article on its accuracy and lol'd @ the most recent source (2013 "study"): 86% of the wiki article sources were considered "suspicious" to "extremely suspicious" and only 5% of the sources got a "confident" or "very confident" rating (the 2 lowest confidence levels).

The image accompanying the article explains how wikipedia is better, in the sense a case of dog food is better than a good restaurant meal (because more dog food):

hJ5gi4K.jpg
 
No, I'm saying there is no GOOD, RELIABLE aggregated source of information in the world today.

Which means if I don't have a couple hours to dig up menial details that are fairly common. (ie capitals of different countries, or different product lines of GM) I need to go to the library or dig out primary sources?

I'm with the others. Its a good start, but you don't go there to write a thesis or anything.
 
It's accurate more often than it is not. I don't get why you guys are so bitter.

Personally, I taught a Biology class when I was a grad student, and I told the students that they were NEVER to cite to wikipedia. I told them it's fine as a jumping off point to familiarize themselves with some basic subject matter, but anything that was ever turned in as part of a paper, report etc should never cite to it.
There are VERY good reasons why it is not accepted by professionals, and I would never allow my students to apply to any standard other than that.

Invariably someone would cite to wikipedia and wonder why they lost 25% of their grade (or more) on the assignment.

Drove me nuts.
 
Personally, I taught a Biology class when I was a grad student, and I told the students that they were NEVER to cite to wikipedia. I told them it's fine as a jumping off point to familiarize themselves with some basic subject matter, but anything that was ever turned in as part of a paper, report etc should never cite to it.
There are VERY good reasons why it is not accepted by professionals, and I would never allow my students to apply to any standard other than that.

Invariably someone would cite to wikipedia and wonder why they lost 25% of their grade (or more) on the assignment.

Drove me nuts.

Nobody here is saying it is OK to cite Wikipedia, as it isn't a primary source for any information. Not because it isn't accurate (sometimes it isn't), but because academically, you can't cite something that isn't a primary source. Those aren't just your rules. Student's can't cite Encyclopedia Brittanica either. We know this.

That's not the argument I'm making. What I am saying is that it is the most useful website in the world, hands down. Nothing comes close to being as useful. If people can't use a tool properly, they are probably not going very far in the world anyway.
 
Many of the cited sources are garbage*,

* the only standard seems to be that someone at sometime wrote it on a web page, regardless of the accuracy

Trust, but verify. If there is any doubt, or it sounds biased, find other sources. Wikipedia is far from unbiased or created by ego maniacs. Fact check.
 
How reliable of a source Wikipedia is often depends on what you are looking for and who you ask. I find it especially invaluable for introductions to certain scientific or mathematical topics. On the other hand history teachers absolutely hate it.

I think a lot of us take Wikipedia for granted, especially the amount of work its editors put into it. Granted I have only made a few edits myself, mostly correcting minor mistakes in some equations, but you should really click the talk page, especially on articles that look controversial to you. It gives you a very good idea of what actually goes on in each edit "behind the scenes".
 
Wikipedia is pretty damn useful. If you don't think it's useful, try not using it at all, and see how difficult it is to find basic information on a lot of topics. Wikipedia has all kinds of obscure gaming info that is hard to find or not available in one place. For instance, all the Rock Band songs ever released are in a nice convenient list by date and band. I can go find all the games ever released for the Dreamcast by date, region, title, etc. Want to find some info about some old obscure pinball machine or video game, probably with a nice picture to go along with it? Wikipedia. I can find info on movies and bands and other projects related to them very easily. I can look up some weird bird or snake I saw in my backyard and find out something about it.

Now, would I use it for hard science facts? No. Would I believe, even remotely, that political information on Wikipedia, or anywhere on the web, is accurate? No. Would I bet my career or reputation on it? No. Sometimes, even with everything handed to you on a plate, you still have to use your brain.

Also, there's no advertising on Wikipedia. That's worth a lot to me, not having to sift through that crap.
 
Back
Top