Why A High-Quality PSU Is Essential

haha that was brilliant... im a Corsair customer for life, love their power supplies. and their customer service is second to none.
 
To Corsair and company: Awesome job on a good laugh. Its nice to see someone having fun on the job for once.

As for everything else? Wow...some of the posts in here have proven to me that just because you're on [H] doesn't mean you do much reading around here.

Marketing? Duh. Who is Corsair supposed to give a plug to when its hosted on THEIR site, done in THEIR labs, using THEIR equipment? What, you wanted them to plug OCZ or Thermaltake instead? PC&C? If any of you seriously say yes to any of those, or even think of it, please log out of the forums now and please don't return. Your inability to think past your keyboard rage and be reasonable is unsettling.

Seriously, do you honestly think Corsair was being very subtle about this as a marketing thing? I mean, really, was there ANY kind of effort to conceal this as their doing? "ZOMG, THEY'RE MARKETING THEIR PSU'S TO ME! DON'T YOU DARE PEDDLE YOUR CANDY TO ME!" No shit, Sherlock, what was your first fucking clue? The web URL, the webpage itself, or the Corsair name being mentioned in the video? What, did you think you were going to get Rick-rolled instead by clicking on the link?

Of -course- they're going to advertise the stability their units have. Besides, the reviews here at [H] and jonnyGURU and elsewhere only confirm that. And you have a complete oveview of their methodology to know that it isn't some bullshit setup some kid did in their basement. (I.e. "I plugged it in, turned it on, and my computer lived! A+++++!! Bobzilla_t3h_Gr8 recommended!") So really, what is there to be all pissy about when a company decides its going to, oh I don't know, advertise its awesome product on its own website? Honestly, were any of you getting your panties in a knot over this SINFUL ACT OF MARKETING really thinking when you posted that? In your world, does Coca Cola give shameless plugs for Pepsi products? Because if it does, I'd like to know what you've smoking, so I can make sure that if I ever decide to take up drugs, I'll have one to avoid.

But like all companies everyone puts out a dud or something that doesn't work so great once in a while. Maybe even an entire batch is bad. Nvidia 6 series chipset anyone? Exploding laptop batteries? Bueller? Bueller?

Maybe it was mishandled between leaving the factory and ending up in your hands. Trust me, I work in retail, its possible. Ever see someone drive a forklift through a skid of floorstanding speakers? How about a thoroughly crushed LCD TV? Or like today we had crushed car amps. I've most certainly seen the end results of that work, and still wonder how a vendor or the freight company thinks we'd accept something that fucked up. But sure as can be, its shown up on my dock before and been refused just the same. An extreme example yes, but that doesn't mean that every little jarring and dropping of a box doesn't leave its mark. Ever consider that? And if you say "But I don't shop at B&M's!" Hey pal, we all have horror stories involving UPS or FedEx or DHL, myself included. About half my boxes for DVDs come in looking like they were used to hold up the truck while a tire got changed. Shit happens before you get a product in your hands, and not every manufacturer builds their product box or their shipping packaging to take that kind of abuse..

Anyway, marketing aspect of it aside, it still brings up a very valid point and that is to be more considerate of what you buy for your computer in terms of a power supply. Yes, some budget PSUs work great. But the more likely case for many of us is that the majority of them need to be blacklisted unless the hardest hitting system you're throwing it in is a K6-2 rig. In my experience? Budget PSU's work as much as you paid for them - not very fucking much.

I had a PowMax unit rated for 400W only outputting 200 watts that was tripping my T-bird rig everytime I tried to play a game until it finally died with a deafening POP and a literal gout of sparks shooting out the back of my case. The guys I bought it from had no idea they were that horrible, and immediately returned their entire stock of it based on my experience. They hooked me up with a Sparkle unit for free for my trouble. That one blew after I moved out of state about a year after. Don't know why, but I blame the PowMax for doing the damage in the first place, because my system never ran right after that incident anyhow. I don't think even a good power supply would've saved it.

I had an Allied 500W unit that came with a Dynex case from Best Buy. That thing ate my A64 rig after a couple years of running on that, but in the weirdest way - I had the front USB ports hooked up and plugged in something to test them. A literal spark and a sharp pop noise and my board is dead, processor's dead, nothing boots.

I'm now running on a Silverstone 500W that cost me a fair amount of bones over some other units in its power range, at least the "budget" ones anyway and this thing has been rock solid for me. If I ever needed proof that a quality PSU is needed, this is it right here in the Silverstone I'm using. It was jonnyGURU recommended and evaluated by the man himself: http://www.jonnyguru.com/modules.php?name=NDReviews&op=Story&reid=13

I have a friend who's using a Corsair 620 for his rig and he is running rock solid running a Q6600 and a 9600GT with an Asus Xonar PCI-E soundcard. He's also got two DDR2 Corsair sticks and there's nothing wrong with his rig whatsoever.

A co-worker of mine is running the 750 and he's also running solid on his, and he -abuses- the PC its in.

When I get some extra cash set aside I'm getting the HX1000 whether I need it or not and will build a quad-core rig based around it. The reason being is because I can find that cheaper than the Thermaltake Toughpower 1000W (W0132RU). If the Toughpower was closer to the HX1000's price, or I could find it for the HX1000's price, I'd jump on that instead.

I trust Corsair products over most anyone else. I'm not particularly fond of their price premiums for some of their RAM modules, but last I checked they weren't the most expensive on the market, so they can't be all that bad price wise. Everything I have ever purchased from their product lines has worked rock solid out of the box and I am confident that the trend will continue for me in the future. However, the day they start cutting corners and start showing up with Deer units or something equally as shitty, trust me, I will blacklist them just as quick as any other.
 
It was becasue the primary switching transistors were undersized for the unit.

The whole PSU is junk but only three things caused it, the combination of all 3 actually, if any of the following were improved it would have a better result.

Undersized transistors
Thin heatsink
Cover off allowed this combination to overheat more, and more rapidly.

A shorted capacitor could do it, but you wouldn't generally find that happening with the PSU so new else it wouldn't have turned on (actually I mean stayed on more than ms) at all if it were defect rather than degraded caps over time.



Ahhh! Makes sense... I've only had one PSU die on me (yes, it was a cheap one) and it just started smoking. It's never fun when you're indoors, you hit the power button and you smell burning electronics!
 
Loved the video, and have been using corsair exclusively since they released the HX620 <3.

I've had the same psu for almost a year now and have had no problem.

To Corsair and company: Awesome job on a good laugh. Its nice to see someone having fun on the job for once.

As for everything else? Wow...some of the posts in here have proven to me that just because you're on [H] doesn't mean you do much reading around here.

Marketing? Duh. Who is Corsair supposed to give a plug to when its hosted on THEIR site, done in THEIR labs, using THEIR equipment? What, you wanted them to plug OCZ or Thermaltake instead? PC&C? If any of you seriously say yes to any of those, or even think of it, please log out of the forums now and please don't return. Your inability to think past your keyboard rage and be reasonable is unsettling.

Seriously, do you honestly think Corsair was being very subtle about this as a marketing thing? I mean, really, was there ANY kind of effort to conceal this as their doing? "ZOMG, THEY'RE MARKETING THEIR PSU'S TO ME! DON'T YOU DARE PEDDLE YOUR CANDY TO ME!" No shit, Sherlock, what was your first fucking clue? The web URL, the webpage itself, or the Corsair name being mentioned in the video? What, did you think you were going to get Rick-rolled instead by clicking on the link?

Of -course- they're going to advertise the stability their units have. Besides, the reviews here at [H] and jonnyGURU and elsewhere only confirm that. And you have a complete oveview of their methodology to know that it isn't some bullshit setup some kid did in their basement. (I.e. "I plugged it in, turned it on, and my computer lived! A+++++!! Bobzilla_t3h_Gr8 recommended!") So really, what is there to be all pissy about when a company decides its going to, oh I don't know, advertise its awesome product on its own website? Honestly, were any of you getting your panties in a knot over this SINFUL ACT OF MARKETING really thinking when you posted that? In your world, does Coca Cola give shameless plugs for Pepsi products? Because if it does, I'd like to know what you've smoking, so I can make sure that if I ever decide to take up drugs, I'll have one to avoid.

But like all companies everyone puts out a dud or something that doesn't work so great once in a while. Maybe even an entire batch is bad. Nvidia 6 series chipset anyone? Exploding laptop batteries? Bueller? Bueller?

Great post dude and I agree. Corsair sell good psu's and are doing a bit of advertising. Don't see anything wrong with that.
 
Well, I don't have time to read every post in a 5 page (and probably counting) thread. But I'll post my take on what I have seen here:

1) Yes, it's marketing. So what? Doesn't mean this didn't happen. Okay, they only show 3 PSU's that appear to be the same blowing up, but I'll go ahead and take their word for it that 3 more also blew up.

2) Okay, yes the cover was off. But they did put a fan up to help compensate for that. And well, if they are going to film what happens inside of the PSU's isn't it a lot easier with the covers off? They can always lower the temprature in their lab to compensate too if having the cover off is THAT big of an issue. I think in some of the posts I did read, someone pointed out that the Corsair lab is kept pretty cold anyway.

3) I do trust that the Coolermaster box was an accident. My first thought was just "Oh, case box..well Corsair doesn't make cases, guess I know now what brand they buy to build complete systems". If anything Coolermaster got a free advert out of this unintentionally, since that is obviously a case box, not a PSU box.

4) No, I am not a Corsair fanboi. I've used their memory before. May do so again. But I've used OCZ, GeiL, Mushkin and a couple other brands and liked them also. I am just pointing out my opinions here.

5) Finally...cute video. Marketing or not, neat to see. As an aside, I assume/hope that room was pretty well ventalated. The one and only time I had a PSU fail in such an epic manner, it really let out some acrid smoke too. And that was just one unit, not six in a row.
 
I had some fun like that too, if I may be permitted a cheap plug: http://www.jonnyguru.com/modules.php?name=NDReviews&op=Story&reid=71

Nice article. Rather predictable results on most of them. I've seen a couple cheap-o PSUs go when building computers, rather fun to watch until you see that they fried your mobo in the process of getting the magic smoke out. I have to be honest and say I never actually visited the site before. That article and a couple others have officially made me a fan. I like the humor.
 
Sorry, dude, but YOU need to STFU. Who cares what exact brand it is? There are shit-tons of cheap-ass PSU's out there. No reason to single any one out when you know your product is good, you just show why someone should consider yours.


Some are a lot worse than others. Many questionable brands that score low on psu, website ranking lists, would not have failed so soon if at all for very short term tests, though this is not an argument to skimp rather than buying enough PSU to last the life of the system.
 
This first paragraph goes to the people that think having the cover off made the PSU's fail quicker or whatever:

Correct me if I'm wrong, but my thinking is that by leaving the cover off that would be better cooling, since the heat generated can more easily dissapate into the air, espically with the 2 fans which I assume are working as they should.

No, by leaving the cover off you are no longer channeling the rear fan flow (rear in this case meaning internal, towards the front of the system case), and the exhaust fan on the back of the PSU is mostly moving air drawn from lowest impedance areas - outside the PSU instead of pulling that air through the heatsink area. It makes a large difference, similar to how you couldn't expect a CPU heatsink to do nearly as well if you mount the fan somewhere else instead of forcing air through the heatsink fins.

Leaving the cover on would only act as an enclosure to trap heat.....which is why the fans are there to direct air over the PSU components to get the hot air out of the PSU case. Leaving the cover off, at ROOM TEMP no less, which is of course generally COOLER then IN A COMPUTER CASE this would actually be the better environment giving the PSU's a better chance to succeed, but instead they fail horribly.

No, cheaper PSU absolutely depend on airflow channeled over their small heatsinks. Having a room air temp of a few, maybe 5C cooler (we cannot expect a system that could run from such a low capacity PSU to generate much more heat, the only reasonable way to assume PSU would be much hotter is if there were terrible case ventilation which there might be in a really cheaply built system, but not for the purpose of the test that blew them out), is less of a factor than a large decrease in air volume flowing past those very hot heatsinks.


I imagine pick any PSU that sells for under 40 bucks would probably fail like this video showed, especially those cheap junkers that sell for 14.99 for a 400 watt one LOL....it's like those cheap Chinese computer speaker systems that say 600 Watt P.M.P.O, which is Peak Momentary Power Output, as in, lightning will have to strike to achieve those results LOL!

No, it takes a fairly large amount of cost-cutting to make this happen. No offense intended to OCZ, but they hand-picked the candidate expecting this result. There are many other low cost generic PSU that would fail before their time, which is also completely unacceptible, but would not fail so soon and that at as low a %/rated-capacity load. It would be a gamble though, to run even a very good PSU for an extended period of time without the cover on unless it was specifically engineered to allow, or ignore this state. The entire PSU case is factored into cooling specs and it is almost never the case that a fan-cooled PSU would do as well without the case cover on it. Especially today with PSU tailored to the low-noise crowd, they make the most they can of low RPM quiet fans by trying to optimize the heatsinks for the airflow present.

These R***m**x et al rebrands on the other hand, place no concern over much of anything except how cheaply it can be made.

Channeling airflow is very important, consider the typical OEM Dell system that can cool itself without even having a CPU fan by just channeling airflow well over the CPU heatsink.
 
I meant no offense intended to Corsair, not OCZ. Most get... more sleep... someday... soon.
 
No it doesn't happen very often lol. Scared the shit out of me and stank up my house for a few hours. Exploding electronics smells.


I think the smell of one's pants may have masked the electronic smell tbh :p
 
Funny video, I like Corsairs strategy of viral marketing.
First thing was the "4GB vs. 2GB RAM" document with a "research" kind of approach, while this video is more drastic but funny at the same time ;)

Really good contrast to the usual "3D-rendered-boobs-with-stupid-gaming-performance-quote"-strategies.
 
The power supply they used isn't a Coolermaster. The box is strictly an accident.

I can't find anything in the current or past Coolermaster lineups that had those specs that were previously mentioned.

Anyone serious about his gaming rig isn't going to be buying a 30 dollar power supply, unless it were a quality unit that had a rebate on it.

As for the video, it's good entertainment.

People who are yelling at the Corsair folks about the video should relax. If you don't think that the video is entertaining, then simply discard it. The fact that some of you are taking time to bash Corsair and their methods, proves that the video did what it was intended to do, and that was to get your attention.
 
The box just showed up in the video because I ran away from an exploding power supply like a frightened schoolgirl.

Best thing I"ve ever read.

Havn't had a chance to watch the Video (damn work filters), but I don't see any thing at all with a company showing a video of thier competitors products exploding under thier rated conditions. Especially when it is one of the few companies I do respect.
 
RedBeard, Corsair's official HardOCP rep, was a HardOCP'er before he went to work for Corsair. In fact, he landed the job through HardOCP.
Read the thread he started before Kyle added it to the front page and started this thread.
If you see my post on RedBeard's thread, I believe I correctly identified the psu they used. It may be from CompUSA but I'm betting it was produced by Raidmax.
 
Up until about a year ago, I was one of those (ignorant) people who was of the mindset of, "Why should I spend a lot of money on a power supply when I can get one with the same wattage rating for a lot cheaper? Power's power, right? What difference does it make?" At that point, the most recent in my long chain of cheap-ass power supplies (power supplies are supposed to randomly go bad every couple of years, right? durrr) was a Chiefmax 550 watt unit (this made reading that Jonnyguru article linked in this thread hilarious and a bit scary, btw, to think of what an absolute piece of garbage I'd had in my PC back then).

Then it came time for me to upgrade my system with a new mobo, CPU, GPU and RAM, and I decided to try my hand at overclocking for the first time. I put a little bit of an overclock on my CPU, and everything seemed to be working fine. Then I cranked up my GPU clock, ran it through a benchmark to stress-test it, and *POP* -- my screen went dark, sparks flew out the back of my computer, followed by the smell of burnt electronics. I jumped up faster than I think I've ever moved before and hit the power switch on my PSU and yanked out the power cord. Thankfully, the PSU was the only thing that went, and it didn't hurt anything else in my system (which, after reading that Jonnyguru article, it turns out that that was an absolute miracle).

After that incident, I did a lot of research into power supplies, and came to the full realization of just how ignorant I'd been about them. After a lot of research and reading a lot of power supply reviews at various websites (including [H], Jonnyguru, and Anand), I decided on a Corsair HX620, which performs marvelously.

I've noticed a funny thing since I put that Corsair unit in my system: My computer is stable now. I'd always thought that computers were just generally unstable machines that occasionally lock up, crash, suffer from slowdowns and generally behave strangely for unknown reasons, regardless of what hardware or software you have in them. After I got my Corsair PSU, nearly all of my stability problems and strange quirks with my PC vanished, and that thing's been rock solid ever since. If those issues were caused by dirty, badly-regulated power, I can only imagine what my poor PC's hardware was being put through to make that happen.

With my own personal experiences dealing with power supplies, I've become a strong proponent of a high-quality PSU being one of the most important pieces (if not THE most important piece) of equipment in a PC, and I cringe whenever I see someone skimping on their power supply when putting together a new system now.
 
Back
Top