Why 2012 Was Firefox’s Year

I am among the ranks of those who feel Firefox's quality has declined of late.

One thing I've always disliked about Firefox is that it uses a ton of antiquated code, and that the developers insist on using an outdated build system that makes it difficult for anyone else to join the project, contribute code, or test patches.

Also, the memory leaks are worst on Windows, but Firefox was always a pleasure to use on Linux, so I tended to stick with it when I ran Windows out of familiarity.

Now Firefox no longer has a supported Flash plugin on Linux, and Chrome has the ability to share my bookmarks/themes/plugins/etc between profiles on several different computers (or between reinstalls) without work on my part. Also, the memory leaks in Windows seem to be as bad as ever, and it's now married to a stream of pointless, frustrating major version updates that constantly break my plugins.

I was with Firefox back when it was still called Phoenix, and I stayed with them up to this year. But all of the above is why I now use Chrome, and it would take quite a bit for me to ever go back to Mozilla for anything. The only thing I miss about Firefox is the ability to customize the UI a bit more, and that's really it.
 
Flash content is in a separate process entirely and has been since 3.6.4 so if you're seeing browser crashes specifically when dealing with Flash it's far more likely to be something going on with the add-ons you're using rather than Firefox itself.
I'm not an expert on what makes a browser unstable, but my Firefox at work has no add ons and is the latest ESR version and often slows to a crawl or freezes completely which usually aligns with me opening something which was flash related. It doesn't happen ALL the time, but it happens often enough to be annoying. At home my Firefox only has a couple of add ons and if it weren't for the couple of add ons I use then there'd really be no point using Firefox at all. On of my old computer, having hardware acceleration on caused crashes once every few hours, and leaving it off meant text quality was shit.

Those have been my recent gripes with Firefox. For me, and I don't pretend to be an expert (I work on computers, but I'm not an IT person and did engineering in university, not any computer related degree), Firefox has been the most problematic of the major browsers. I did also have some issues with Opera, but I don't use that much.
 
The argument that browsers need to be 64 bit is ridiculous because the only real benefit for an app like that WOULD be memory allocation and like said before if you need more memory for your browser something is wrong.

Why does everyone keep forgetting that 64bit offers additional security features? :confused:
 
I'm not an expert on what makes a browser unstable, but my Firefox at work has no add ons and is the latest ESR version and often slows to a crawl or freezes completely which usually aligns with me opening something which was flash related. It doesn't happen ALL the time, but it happens often enough to be annoying. At home my Firefox only has a couple of add ons and if it weren't for the couple of add ons I use then there'd really be no point using Firefox at all. On of my old computer, having hardware acceleration on caused crashes once every few hours, and leaving it off meant text quality was shit.

Those have been my recent gripes with Firefox. For me, and I don't pretend to be an expert (I work on computers, but I'm not an IT person and did engineering in university, not any computer related degree), Firefox has been the most problematic of the major browsers. I did also have some issues with Opera, but I don't use that much.

Must be your problem, I have zero issues with Firefox. I, like you also get freezes, but because I know it's not Firefox but actually Flash, understand that I just have to kill the plugin-container.exe which restarts Flash. Firefox itself hasn't given me any issues whatsoever.
 
Must be your problem, I have zero issues with Firefox.
Perhaps, but it's not like I'm talking about 1 install of Firefox on some crusty old box, it's caused me issues on multiple installs and multiple systems, some of which are pretty close to fresh installs of the OS. I know that just because one person has issues doesn't mean the program is a problem, but also just because one person doesn't have issues doesn't mean the program isn't a problem.
I, like you also get freezes, but because I know it's not Firefox but actually Flash, understand that I just have to kill the plugin-container.exe which restarts Flash. Firefox itself hasn't given me any issues whatsoever.
I'll keep that in mind, I know many of my issues are Flash related (though it doesn't seem all of them). Even if Flash is the issue and I know flash is shit, but other browsers don't have nearly the same number of issues.

For me, Firefox went from bulletproof to shaky after 3.6, most other browsers these days remain bulletproof.
 
For me, Firefox went from bulletproof to shaky after 3.6, most other browsers these days remain bulletproof.

So it wasn't just me. I also had the same problem. I had FF installed on 5 different machines, 5 different installations, varying different plugins. All had the same crash or slow to a crawl problem. That or it became so slow compared to Chrome or IE even. I actually do some things that require me to change pages on the browser a lot so when FF took 2-3 seconds to load and Chrome took less than .5sec, I instantly switched. Didn't actually miss many of the plug ins I had.
 
I and most of the other IT people I know, have switched to Chrome. I downloaded FF the other day onto a new computer, used it for about an hour and went right back to Chrome. Unless Google does something totally stupid, I don't see ever needing another browser.
 
I'm a great supporter of Firefox (and Mozilla) and I encourage everyone, especially those technically inclined, to realize that using Firefox (or a handful of other open source browsers, less known) is one of the best things you can do on a daily basis to "vote" for the importance of your privacy and the "health" of the Internet.

It is important to note that Firefox has done, and continues to do what has sadly become an increasingly limited trend: Providing innovative, user-focused software (free and open source, at that) designed to serve your needs, protect your privacy, modify as you like it etc... Even more impressive is that Mozilla has designed Firefox to be not only usable, but useful, to be both the near tech-illiterate and script/addon writing gurus and developers! Doing all this while avoiding the pitfalls of pandering to some corporate money somewhere to trade user choice, transparency, or privacy for advertising, SEO and, data mining dollars is exceedingly rare. Firefox empowers the user and allows them to make their own choices, without handcuffing their ability to see information necessary to make those choices in an informed manner, or having to look for new puppet strings being tied surreptitiously by various puppeteers, always watching for the latest thing you need to "opt out" of.

Firefox, and projects like it are absolutely critical to support these days. I've used all the competitors and I've seen the overblown criticisms that are levied against Firefox, but no matter what I keep coming back to the browser that lets me do what I wish. I can theme the UI as I like, I can deny ALL forms of cookies, I can install addons that actually block ads, scripts, all the other privacy-invading bugs out there, I can sync my parameters and data as I wish in a way that protects my privacy perfectly, I can output/input using an assortment of open formats without fear, I can sandbox when and how I wish, I can customize to my liking without even having to know how to code, and much much more...

Using Firefox is voting for your privacy and for a vision of the Web where users are both protected and informed, capable of altering and understanding, and that the user is paramount for that software to serve before any other external interest.
 
I'm a great supporter of Firefox (and Mozilla) and I encourage everyone, especially those technically inclined, to realize that using Firefox (or a handful of other open source browsers, less known) is one of the best things you can do on a daily basis to "vote" for the importance of your privacy and the "health" of the Internet.

It is important to note that Firefox has done, and continues to do what has sadly become an increasingly limited trend: Providing innovative, user-focused software (free and open source, at that) designed to serve your needs, protect your privacy, modify as you like it etc... Even more impressive is that Mozilla has designed Firefox to be not only usable, but useful, to be both the near tech-illiterate and script/addon writing gurus and developers! Doing all this while avoiding the pitfalls of pandering to some corporate money somewhere to trade user choice, transparency, or privacy for advertising, SEO and, data mining dollars is exceedingly rare. Firefox empowers the user and allows them to make their own choices, without handcuffing their ability to see information necessary to make those choices in an informed manner, or having to look for new puppet strings being tied surreptitiously by various puppeteers, always watching for the latest thing you need to "opt out" of.

Firefox, and projects like it are absolutely critical to support these days. I've used all the competitors and I've seen the overblown criticisms that are levied against Firefox, but no matter what I keep coming back to the browser that lets me do what I wish. I can theme the UI as I like, I can deny ALL forms of cookies, I can install addons that actually block ads, scripts, all the other privacy-invading bugs out there, I can sync my parameters and data as I wish in a way that protects my privacy perfectly, I can output/input using an assortment of open formats without fear, I can sandbox when and how I wish, I can customize to my liking without even having to know how to code, and much much more...

Using Firefox is voting for your privacy and for a vision of the Web where users are both protected and informed, capable of altering and understanding, and that the user is paramount for that software to serve before any other external interest.
<rant>
Thank you very much for this post, as it limits how much I have to rant on the topic. As I have to mention in every Firefox hate thread, I have been a user of Firefox back before it was even called Firefox, so I am a wee bit biased. I am also a web developer and Open Source Software programmer, so even more bias there. With that aside I'll take Firefox any day over any competing browser (with the slight exception of Opera and links). Firefox works on a plethora of platforms and has stayed true to Mozilla's initial promises to promote and maintain a free and open browser and Internet.

Firefox makes it a pleasure to present a variety of content over the Internet, with full support for XML/HTML/Audio/Video/Plugins and an ever extendable framework that tailors that experience to the user. The new rapid development cycle, while I disliked it at first, pushed Firefox beyond other browsers in supporting web standards and new features. If there is an update to a W3C spec, you can bet it was between Firefox and Chromium that pushed that standard. And while Chromium is advanced in terms of raw horsepower it is a child's toy in comparison to the tool-set Firefox offers up.

Also I am guessing that a lot of the frustration comes from the Windows ported version. I've been using 64bit Firefox since I got an AMD64 CPU. Currently only using 280MB of RAM with 7 tabs open though. I've even had the pleasure of running a 32bit jail just to make horrible plug-ins like flash run. When you have the source, you are free to do what you want. And the Mozilla Developer Network provides in depth knowledge on web standards and how to program towards them.
</rant>
 
You should look those features up and do a little research. It has nothing to do with this discussion.

Could you provide value to the discussion by explaining why he's wrong rather than a vague dismissal? Please cite a reference explaining why HE-ASLR is not beneficial to a web browser, which is what he and others are saying, which I'd argue is very much part of this discussion.

Here's a recent article on Ars Technica discussing this exact point:
Why 64-bit Firefox should be prioritized
 
Back
Top