which would you rather have: AA or AF?

Hobbit89 said:
Could someone tell me what the differance is in the two, i have read the previos posts and it tells me that AF has to deal with the draw distance (cleaner textures from further away)? and AA? what exactly do they do? sorry to sound like such a noob, but time to learn this stuff. like i said, all i really know is it makes the game look better. Thanks.

The way games are coded, there are certain sized textures on surfaces, and the closer you are to them, the bigger and more detailed textures the engine is supposed to use. But to conserve texture memory, further away areas used lower detailed textures. The problem is, you get an ugly "stepping effect" where the engine changes over to different texture sizes. AF basically takes samples of each textures near the border of the two textures and mixes them so they are blended together. That way the gradient is much smoother and nicer looking.

AA basically is a jaggie smoother Instead of having a binary change inbetween pixels of the image, a graident is applied to "smooth" the jaggies.

AF is important at all times, esp in games with long corridors or large outside enviroments. You can get away without using AA so much if you use a higher resolution, since each pixel is smaller.
 
AA is much more important to me.Most of the time i have AA on full and AF on bilinear. Nice performace and games look great. IMO.

To me, AF isn't worth the performace decrease. Whilst AA is becuase makes more of a difference.
 
Definately AF, I can still remember Half Life on an old old old machine with a Radeon 7200. Can anyone say fuzz? Can anyone say fuzz only a few 'metres' away?

Gimme higher AF any day.
 
I'd also have to say AF is more important to me than AA. I definitely want both however.

Anytime you can visually fake an effect (such as AA) by borrowing your little brothers 17/20 prescription glasses, or by using a substandard ramdac - can't rank that high up on the list.

Edit: I often wonder if it would be worthwhile to create a constructive - refined interference in a Ramdac (instead of the destructive - chaotic interference that you normally get with cheap quality VGA cables) to give *free* AA
 
It's AF for me, as others have said- the textures in the distance add to the overall experience a lot more than jaggies take away in my book. Plus to see things spontaneously clear up as you get closer really knocks you out of the flow.

To me, it boils down to AA is really needed if you are standing still, looking around at something. That's when you see the most jaggies. AF is really needed the most when you're moving-that's when the textures and objects in the distance are emphasized. Which one happens more in your average game?
 
I´ve always wondered why some engines seem to have drastically jaggier engines than others. I´ve yet to have to use AA on any D3 engine games, but source at the same res without 2 hits of AA is a totally different matter, and F.E.A.R. is even worse! Right now I´m playing, BG&E, console port, no AA. But next to another console port at the same res (GTA:SA) the IQ is great without AA. What gives?

On another note, bumping up the AF to 8 doesn´t seem to affect my performance much, so I keep most games at that. However, 4 hits of AA is a WAY different story....

-wil
 
I like anisotrisoptic filtering better or whatever that is. Better textures at a distance. It sux when u have it disabled and you're walking, looking at the ground, you can see teh textures in front of you getting clearer when you travel along. So I always have that on. AA, it doesn't matter in action packed games like CoD2 where you're not paying attention to the performance but the stuff around you. But in something like CS:S, I have it at 6x AA and 16x ANISO, max settings, 1280x1024. (and i still get 70+ fps :))
 
Blurry textures I can live with; they don't make a huge difference, but AA I have to have. I can't stand to look at anything that doesnt have at least 2x AA.
 
I turn AF to 16, then turn up AA as I can.

With my Dual Core system and 2 7800GTX in SLI, I get to run pretty much every game as high as I wish (I only game at 1600x1200).

EQ2 is the only game where I still have to really juggle graphics. I wish they would let you have settings profiles in that damn game so I can set different graphics levels quickly for when single group and raiding.
 
This is a question that is kind of obsolete nowadays you know? It´s for pre 9700 era when you really had to choose. Because the performance hit of each was so large...

9700 PRO was the first that really allowed you to apply both. Have done so ever since. Can´t choose because can´t live without any of it...
 
Brent_Justice said:
Here's a pic from Quake4 on my computer as well, that's what the gun should look like

click on the advanced video options in the game and make sure everything is turned on
everything is on
vsync is off
ScHpAnKy said:
seems your drivers IQ settings is not set to a Quality/High Quality setting

If you want to know how to change it, you must specify whether you're running nV or ATI
where can i find iq settings?
 
I agree that it varies from game to game. FEAR and HL2 look terrible at almost any resolution without AA, but Doom 3 looks just fine. Most modern cards allow you to really crank AF without dramatic performance drops, though, and I just put AA as high as I can manage.
 
As many have said, it largely would depend on the game. BF2's jaggies bother the crap out of me. Games such as Farcry doesnt have as many, and doesnt bother me as much.

With my res of 1920x1200, jaggies are not as big of a problem as they are in say, 1280x1024. So if I *had* to pick, I would rather have 16xAF. And ATi's Quality AF at that. Unless its BF2, then AA...
 
oqvist said:
This is a question that is kind of obsolete nowadays you know? It´s for pre 9700 era when you really had to choose. Because the performance hit of each was so large...

9700 PRO was the first that really allowed you to apply both. Have done so ever since. Can´t choose because can´t live without any of it...

I would love to see you apply that theory to Doom 3, Far Cry, HL2, Fear and see if you get playable framerates :rolleyes:
 
Phantron said:
I would love to see you apply that theory to Doom 3, Far Cry, HL2, Fear and see if you get playable framerates :rolleyes:

Looking at oqvist's sig, I am sure his 6800 Ultra can do at least 2xAA, 4xAF in all of those games - except maybe FEAR. I guess it depends on what you consider "playable," though.
 
name said:
Looking at oqvist's sig, I am sure his 6800 Ultra can do at least 2xAA, 4xAF in all of those games - except maybe FEAR. I guess it depends on what you consider "playable," though.

I meant on a 9700pro
 
AF for sure! The appearance of jaggies can be reduced by upping the resolution and pushing the screen a little further away. Even the best textures look disgusting with no AF and there is no work around that can change this.
 
karl76 said:
AF for sure! The appearance of jaggies can be reduced by upping the resolution and pushing the screen a little further away. Even the best textures look disgusting with no AF and there is no work around that can change that.

When your running a Dell 2405 at 1900x1200. Jaggies are not a problem.
 
well since my post disappeared or it just didnt go through

AF>AA in all case IMO injsut about everygame on my computer, havin AA on anything but max makes the game look uncolorfull... it seems washed out or something, and in newer games thats a performance hit im not willing to make. and blurry textures drie me insane so i have AF on no matter what :p
 
I run everything 4x8 at 1280x960 on a 21' monitor with my 7800gt looks great and fast as a mofo.
 
Real gamers dont need fancy graphics while playing FPS shooters. Whats the point when your busy fragging someone? 1280 for me with none of this on. Even when I upgrade from a 6600 to a 7800gt i will not put this stuff on.
 
Is there a noticable difference between AF x8 and x16?

While playing CS:S I really can't tell between 8 and 16.

Anyway, while playing CS:S I use 1280x1024 (19" LCD) and AAx4 AFx8. FEAR 1280x9xx with AAx2 and AFx8. CoD2 AAx2 AF on.

Back to topic, I think I put more importance on AA as I really hate seeing the jaggies. And AAx2 really decreases the amount of jaggies so you don't need more than that.
 
ServerKing said:
Real gamers dont need fancy graphics while playing FPS shooters. Whats the point when your busy fragging someone? 1280 for me with none of this on. Even when I upgrade from a 6600 to a 7800gt i will not put this stuff on.

Hehe yea all my settings are set to minimum when I play online :).
 
I prefer AF always being at 16x, it makes a HUGE difference in texture quality, and it makes things like your gun look totally different. (just look at those Doom 3 photos earlier in the thread)

And I'm pretty sure it has almost no effect at all on the frame rate. I've done frame rate checks for two games, HL2 and UT2004, and my frame rate change was either nothing, or 1 FPS or less going from no AF to 16x AF. I ran a UT2004 benchmark utility which does identical run-throughs of maps while pre-scripted bots run around and attack eachother. First I did no AF and recorded the average frame rate. Then I cranked AF to 16x and recorded the frame rate again. I sware to god there was a 1 FPS difference AT MOST. And this is on a 6800 GT.

AA on the other hand impacts frame rate A LOT, but it does look nice, just not as much of a visual difference as AF, at least not while the game is in motion. Who pays attention to jaggies when they are twitching the mouse around in UT2004 and the background is scrolling at 100 inches/sec? ;)
 
I always try to find a balance of both, but if I have to pick which one to set higher or use exclusively, then it is AF.
 
grifter said:
i see some people set their af higher than aa but i personally like trading off more aa for af


I have discovered there is a fundamental difference between brands of cards which may sway peoples opinions:

If you have an ATi card, AF makes very little difference as long as you run in high quality mode and all images look crystal clear sharp. If you ahve an nVidia card, the textures look washed out blurry if you don't have AF cranked way up, and even then 16xAF still looks washed out compared to ATi's 2x AF.

It's kind of making me doubt if I will be happy with my purchase of the 512 MB 7800 GTX.
 
2 things if you are going to take comparison screen shots

1. Take them from the same spot / angle
2. save the images as original BMP files to show the true image, not compress jpeg.


for me

1, High res (1600 x 1200)
2. AF
3. AA

but now with only my laptop and a 64mb 9700 mobility, i aint using AA or AF on much of anything :(
 
AF hands down. Without it, textures look fucking UGLY! But I could be biased by the 1920x1200 resolution of my screen. :p Though, I can only imagine what the 3007FPW will bring to the table... :eek:
 
If you notice (and I just glanced through a few posts here), most people with sig's here who said AF needs to be cranked up are the ones with nVidia cards. Most people with ATi cards have no idea why anyone needs AF. This is because the ATi really does have better LOD on textures.

Now that I have gone with nVidia again, I am starting to remember when I first switched to ATi a few years back that I was surprised how much better the ATi iq was, but I wrote it off as to being a 9700 Pro compared to a 4200 TI. Now that I have gone from an X800 to a 6800/7800, I am back to realizing nVidia needs to pull some tricks out of their asses to come up on iq.
 
Back
Top