Which would be a better upgrade...

As long as DX10 means nothing to him - the 7900 gs by a landslide. You could also check out the x1950 pro/gt similar price/performance.
 
I would say the 7900GS simply because if the 8600 was run in DX10 it would be pointless because it would run so slowly and at such low settings it would look better in DX9
 
how long do you think it will be before the games are released without a dx9 version or capability?
 
Honestly, see if he can't buy an Evga card that also comes with Quakewars for free ;)
 
Back
Top