Which used RAID card would YOU get?

Joined
Feb 19, 2004
Messages
3,861
I'm working on setting up an OpenFiler NAS for a VMware lab at home for learning and experimentation without breaking other people's stuff. I have very limited funds for this after I bought my two servers for the VMware Cluster.I have a spare server with a PCI-X slot and room for a stack of HDDs but no RAID card. I was wondering if you guys could give me your opinions on the following cards below. My budget is "around" $100 and this is the best I could find on eBay for around that price.


3Ware 9500s 8 port SATA RAID

SuperMicro 8 Port SATA PCI-X NAS RAID Card AOC-SAT2-MV8

ADAPTEC 21610SA 64M PCI-X 16-Port SATA RAID NEW SEALED

lsi logic SAS3041XL-S 4 PORT SAS/SATA 3GB/S PCIX



Any input would be greatly appreciated. I was leaning towards the 3Ware since I've used them before but other than that I have no real reasoning behind it. :)
 
The 3Ware

I have one of the Adaptecs in that family (though fewer ports) and it's RAID 5 speed is woeful.
 
Thanks for the input gentleman. I did some more research on that LSI board and it looks great and everything but there is no memory and it only does RAID 0/1/1E/10E. Since it's only a 4-port card that limits me considering my budget. I was planning on using the 3x 160GB Seagates I have now and picking up a couple more used ones. That would put me at at roughly 290GB usable if I went RAID 10E. I'm thinking that might not be enough shared storage.

Here's the tech brief on the card from LSI's website: http://www.lsi.com/DistributionSyst...ntation/storage/hbas/sas/lsisas3041x_r_pb.pdf

Going to do some more looking around to see if I can find another LSI PCI-X card. Just occurred to me that LSI makes all the RAID cards for HP. Thinking about seeing if I can find one of those on the eBay . . .
 
Going to do some more looking around to see if I can find another LSI PCI-X card. Just occurred to me that LSI makes all the RAID cards for HP. Thinking about seeing if I can find one of those on the eBay . . .

No, LSI does not.
HP designs and builds their own cards. They're derivative of the Compaq CISS family. The SmartArray P-series are HP designed and built. Some do use LSI for the physical drive attachment side, but the RAID and board interface logic are purely HP. That doesn't mean they won't work - I've used them in all kinds of systems. Just that they're HP. (Oh, and do require the expensive BBUs to run.)

I should have checked the card model, too. You'll need to get a proper LSI RAID card with cache and BBU. If you're going PCI-X, for a bit more money, you can find the MegaRAID 300-8X and 300-8XLP relatively cheap. They're old, they're not screamers, but they're very respectable and very reliable.
 
No, LSI does not.
HP designs and builds their own cards. They're derivative of the Compaq CISS family. The SmartArray P-series are HP designed and built. Some do use LSI for the physical drive attachment side, but the RAID and board interface logic are purely HP. That doesn't mean they won't work - I've used them in all kinds of systems. Just that they're HP. (Oh, and do require the expensive BBUs to run.)
.

Ahhh, my bad. I was thinking that LSI made some of them, swear I've seen LSI somewhere in an HP server before . . . oh wells. :D

Thanks for the info. I'm going to take a look and see what other LSI goodness I can find on eBay. I'd like to get something that does SATA II as I may use this for personal storage after I'm done with my WMware/Citrix lab stuff.
 
Okay, so after a bit of research I have narrowed my choices down to either the 3ware 9500S-8 or the LSI MegaRAID 300-8X. They both support SATAII and have the necessary PCI-X interface. They both have 128MB of ECC SDRAM. Looks like the LSI supports NCQ, can't find info on if the 3Ware does or not. I guess I'm leaning more towards the LSI at this point. Does anyone else have any input? Thanks!
 
No idea on the 3Ware. I do know that the 300-8X/300-8XLP is pretty much bulletproof in everything you can throw at it. And then some. It's based on a design going back to the AMI MegaRAID family. (Ancient history what?) Excellent driver support in absolutely everything. Simple straight forward interface.
Oh, and relatively cheap.
 
That 9550SX 3ware card in the review is anywhere from $100-300 more expensive than the LSI 300-8X on the eBays right now, though. The 3ware 9500S-8 isn't mentioned at all, which is the card that is in my price range. :D

Again, this isn't for anything mission critical, just to run OpenFiler so I can do iSCSI and NFS for my VMware lab. May end up just selling everything after I'm done and go buy something more recent, then again I may keep it, too. who knows. . . .
 
Tom couldn't review his ass if somebody else did. Well no, he wouldn't, unless somebody paid and gave him the numbers they wanted. Don't even waste our time with it. We won't mention the fact that they're not even remotely qualified to test storage from any perspective beyond "ooh, the box looks nice."

The LSI is faster in most modes of operation.

And don't run OpenFiler. Run FreeNAS, use the LSI. The LSI screams on FreeBSD, and will give you absolute trouble-free operation, guaranteed. (And if it doesn't, you let me know, and I can toss you fixes.)
 
Because frankly, OpenFiler is based on something that puts data integrity at the absolute bottom of the list. It also is based on something that has a history (which I've verified multiple times) of data corruption on both of those cards, due to people who have NO clue what they're doing messing with the drivers.
 
Get the LSI

I am personally a bigger fan of opnefiler than freenas, but I was not aware of data integrity issues so I may look into that.
 
Because frankly, OpenFiler is based on something that puts data integrity at the absolute bottom of the list. It also is based on something that has a history (which I've verified multiple times) of data corruption on both of those cards, due to people who have NO clue what they're doing messing with the drivers.

Fair enough. :eek:
 
Get the LSI

I am personally a bigger fan of opnefiler than freenas, but I was not aware of data integrity issues so I may look into that.

Google "LSI Linux data corruption" and "LSI Linux cache bug".
Linux doesn't give two shits about data integrity, and never has. You use it at your own risk, which is why I don't.

Besides, FreeNAS does iSCSI and NFS too. And bluntly, the NFS implementation on FreeBSD actually WORKS, as opposed to Linux which is just going to drive you to throwing things out the window. (If you're lucky. I have seen it literally drive people to ripping out cords and ethernet. It has yet to improve in the last 15 years.)
 
Not this again....

This time I will quote, not to be confused with paying your ridiculous game.

The absolute fastest most badass machine(s) runs Fedora Linux and I am more than sure they are interested in data integrity.... Quit posting this crap.

Sorry. I don't play ridiculous games with people who don't know enough about HPC to know that link is completely irrelevant and useless.

So why are you still here again, kid? You can go away now. We have enough zealots.
 
Sorry. I don't play ridiculous games with people who don't know enough about HPC to know that link is completely irrelevant and useless.

So why are you still here again, kid? You can go away now. We have enough zealots.

Edit:

In a temporary lapse of judgement I replied to your comment and almost stooped to your level.
 
Last edited:
I'm working on setting up an OpenFiler NAS for a VMware lab at home for learning and experimentation without breaking other people's stuff. I have very limited funds for this after I bought my two servers for the VMware Cluster.I have a spare server with a PCI-X slot and room for a stack of HDDs but no RAID card. I was wondering if you guys could give me your opinions on the following cards below. My budget is "around" $100 and this is the best I could find on eBay for around that price.


3Ware 9500s 8 port SATA RAID

SuperMicro 8 Port SATA PCI-X NAS RAID Card AOC-SAT2-MV8

ADAPTEC 21610SA 64M PCI-X 16-Port SATA RAID NEW SEALED

lsi logic SAS3041XL-S 4 PORT SAS/SATA 3GB/S PCIX



Any input would be greatly appreciated. I was leaning towards the 3Ware since I've used them before but other than that I have no real reasoning behind it. :)

+1 for the LSI, although the 3ware would be a close second. And yes, 3ware is now owned by LSI --so, unless the card is EOL, then LSI support will be handling any issues.

No, LSI does not.
HP designs and builds their own cards. They're derivative of the Compaq CISS family. The SmartArray P-series are HP designed and built. Some do use LSI for the physical drive attachment side, but the RAID and board interface logic are purely HP. That doesn't mean they won't work - I've used them in all kinds of systems. Just that they're HP. (Oh, and do require the expensive BBUs to run.)

[..Snip..]

I hate to disagree with you, but HP does NOT design and build all (probably only a small portion, if that) their own cards. But, this all varies depending on the card in question; HP, LSI, or various other vendors could have designed and built different parts or all of the card. However, many "HP" RAID cards built by LSI are 100% LSI -- excluding the firmware and/or management utilites ONLY.
 
I hate to disagree with you, but HP does NOT design and build all (probably only a small portion, if that) their own cards. But, this all varies depending on the card in question; HP, LSI, or various other vendors could have designed and built different parts or all of the card. However, many "HP" RAID cards built by LSI are 100% LSI -- excluding the firmware and/or management utilites ONLY.

You can disagree, but it just makes you wrong.
All SmartArray cards are purely HP designed. They use individual ICs from LSI and others, but that's bluntly, irrelevant. LSI doesn't even design every chip on their own stuff. The PCB, battery, and every line of firmware and ROM code is purely HP. No other company has anything to do with the design of the P400, P600, or P800. As I said, the SmartArray is derivative of the Compaq ISS (Intelligent Storage Subsystem.)
Just like the CISS, they're based around some off the shelf parts - LSI SAS HBA/PHY interface, somebody's off the shelf embedded processor, etcetera. Everything about the card's actual RAID functionality and host interface is done entirely with code originally developed at Compaq in the 80's. In fact, the code is so tight, that the same driver for the Compaq SmartArray 5300 (which is an ancient SCSI-UW card) works with the HP Smart Array P800 with virtually no differences. So much so that the 5300 can be updated to firmware that supports HP's new ADG features, the same ones you get on the P800.
We won't mention that LSI does not have anything comparable to ADG or SAN Access Port Method, or much of the advanced technology present in the SmartArrays. They exist in a class of their own. The only LSI designed HP cards are the old NetRAID.

EDIT: And yes, I would take a SmartArray over an LSI for the same dollars, any day of the week. Provided it has the BBU and cache modules.
 
Last edited:
Running Linux on 3ware here. Have had some excellent customer service from 3ware, who replaced a secondhand card that was failed and out of warranty.
 
Back
Top