Which Setup for HDMI Audio and ...

ave

n00b
Joined
Oct 25, 2009
Messages
51
OK I am so confused on HDMI Audio. Everybody has different answers so I am hoping somebody could answer what I need for my 2 HTPC Computers. Here is what I want to do.

Computer 1
I want to run BLU-RAY Ripped Movies (Anydvd) to my Denon AVR3808 CI to my 63" Plasma. I prefer to use a Nvidia (Personal Preference but can change) HDMI card. I currently have a Nvidia 8500gt 1gb hooked up with component to the T.V. and use SPDIF to the Denon Receiver. I use TMT 3 with the SPDIF option and get descent sound with the on-board audio card. I get Digital 5.1 and DTS but not not True HD. Is that because my audio card doesn't support it. On TMT 3 Info screen it says DTS Mastered or True HD but on the receiver it says Dolby Digital. What would be the easiest way to send all the Ripped Blu-Rays to my Denon with Full Decoding capabilities? I can't seem to get a straight answer on which Nvidia Cards pass through the HDMI Audio to my Denon receiver.

Computer 2
I'm basically sending out a L/R signal to 8 T.V."s with a Component Matrix Switcher. 7 of the T.V.'s get sound from the T.V.'s Speakers and 1 is hooked up to a Harmon Kardon AVR-8000 Receiver. What is the best sound the AVR-8000 can get from 2 channels with L/R cables?

On both Computers I am using Windows 7 Media Center with the TMT 3 Plugin.

I appreciate any help.

Thanks.
 
1.) Your PC is decoding the HD audio formats (True HD, DTS-MA tracks) and then downsampling them to 5.1 DD/DTS level audio which is why TMT is saying one thing and you're receiver is saying something else.

2.) None of NV's support TrueHD or DTS-MA. The closes you'll get is one of NV's onboard IGPs, an 8000 series or 9000 series boards. They can pass 7.1 LPCM audio which will get the HD audio track to your receiver.

3.) SPDIF does not and can not support these HD audio formats. Not enough bandwidth.

4.) Easiest way to get your BR audio to your receiver with full abilities is to get a 5750.

5.) I'm not understanding your last question there. If you're going 2.0 audio out to a receiver then the best your going to get, clearly, is 2.0 analog audio. So, yeah. I don't understand what you're asking for.
 
4. With the 5750 I'm just hooking up the HDMI cable to the AVR and then to the T.V. and then I'll get full capabilities? I thought that it will be down-sampled. Here is a quote from someone at arcsoft :

"The only card that passes through (bitstreams) the HD codecs that currently works with TMT3 is the Asus Xonar HDAV audio card. There are various other graphic cards out there that will send audio via HDMI but with these the audio is downsampled to 48Khz/16-bit PCM. Whether you would actually be able to audibly tell the difference is open to debate."

5. Not sure what I was talking about. I think I'll use the stereo output for the T.V's and then use the Digital SPDIF to the AVR. I'll use the Media Center plugin to switch between analog and digital.

Thanks.
 
4. With the 5750 I'm just hooking up the HDMI cable to the AVR and then to the T.V. and then I'll get full capabilities? I thought that it will be down-sampled. Here is a quote from someone at arcsoft :

"The only card that passes through (bitstreams) the HD codecs that currently works with TMT3 is the Asus Xonar HDAV audio card. There are various other graphic cards out there that will send audio via HDMI but with these the audio is downsampled to 48Khz/16-bit PCM. Whether you would actually be able to audibly tell the difference is open to debate."



Thanks.

that was before the ati 5 series cards showed up. different game now.
 
That question was just asked yesterday. I beleive if you use Power DVD it will work but not TMT 3?
 
that was before the ati 5 series cards showed up. different game now.

When the 5800 series first came out it had this issue cause, obviously, they were brand new and the only product to have a feature anywhere similar was the Xonar.

That isn't the case now but TMT needs (and from what I understand it's being worked on) to be updated to take advantage of this. PowerDVD was which is why it works.
 
Will I still get True HD downsampled?

Until TMT updates, yes. Otherwise and without an Xonar or 5000 series video card you're going to get downsampled HD audio (unless you're going LPCM out).
 
But I can't get Dolby True HD with an optical using the SPDIF setting can I? I plan on buying a 5000 series card this week.
 
Will I still get True HD downsampled?

Only if you choose to use TMT. Using an open-source alternative, on the other hand...

But I can't get Dolby True HD with an optical using the SPDIF setting can I? I plan on buying a 5000 series card this week.

You can't bitstream TrueHD over S/PDIF. If you chose to decode it then downmxi it to 2 channels, 16-bit, 48KHz audio, then that would work over S/PDIF, but that's the absolute maximum you could do. (16*48*2 = 1536kbps, S/PDIF's max.)
 
But I can't get Dolby True HD with an optical using the SPDIF setting can I? I plan on buying a 5000 series card this week.

As I said earlier, SPDIF doesn't have the bandwidth for it.
 
In your post you said you are playing ripped blu rays. You don't need TMT at all. In fact you can get all the latest HD audio with anything that can send audio over HDMI.

You just have to rip things the right way. I don't know how you are ripping your blurays, maybe straight to iso? That would lock you into a player and a card that can bitstream, but there are other better ways.

I rip the video to mkv, audio to flac and merge. You get 100% of the audio over LPCM to your receiver with no need for a card that can bitstream. You install haali and madflac and they will play right in media center, no need for another player.
 
I am using AnyDVD to rip to staright to Hard Drive not an image. I then use TMT 3 for Media Center playback. do I still need the 5800 card or can I use my existing Nvidia card and use the optical out for playback or does it have to be HDMI to the Denon Receiver?
Your method seems like a lot of work for a lot of Blu-Rays. Anydvd is 1 button and then MYMovies plugin find the title.

Thanks.
 
It has to be HDMI because, as I already said, SPDIF can't send the signal. You don't need a 5800 series card either, no idea how you got on that track. If you want to pop a Blu Ray and play it straight from disc with the HD audio track then you need a 5750 right now (next year the lowerend 5000 series cards will be released which would be much better for an HTPC).
 
The problem is I get conlicting information from different people. Some people said they Nvidia cards don't send audio via HDMI and that they have a sepearte audio optical cable. Which Nvidia cards can I use?

Everybody I talked to on the Arcsoft boards say I have to use the 5800 cards to get downsampled True HD?

I don't plan on ever putting a Blu-Ray in the machine. They will be all ripped in the basement racks.
 
The problem is I get conlicting information from different people. Some people said they Nvidia cards don't send audio via HDMI and that they have a sepearte audio optical cable. Which Nvidia cards can I use?

Everybody I talked to on the Arcsoft boards say I have to use the 5800 cards to get downsampled True HD?

I don't plan on ever putting a Blu-Ray in the machine. They will be all ripped in the basement racks.

New Nvidia discrete cards have HDMI audio. The 210 and 220gt. But they won't bitstream TrueHD or DTS-HD MA.
If you rip the way I suggested you don't need to bitstream those formats to get the same audio. But you would need a card capable of HDMI audio.

The method is easy. You are already making a rip. In my method you still make the rip, audio to one format, video to another(it all happens in the same rip, set and hit go) and then merge the audio/video together in an mkv. It's very easy. Then you don't have to worry about DRM for playback. There is no DRM anymore. You won't have to use a 3rd party player. You don't have worry about all this bitstreaming stuff either. It will send the audio out as LPCM. You get 100% of the audio. No worries about downsampling.
 
Last edited:
Ok I will try it out. What are you using to make the rip? Is their any guides to this.

I appreciate your help.
 
Would I be happier with the Nvidia GT240 or the ATI 5750? I am looking for good card with reliable graphics.
 
1. I wan't the best Video without stuttering

2. I deffiently want HD Audio. I'll probally do the Power DVD or eventually get a Slim card.
 
Not sure what you mean by 'best video.' Both should produce identical results with some small variances due to how their drivers are written. Neither should give you stuttering, as that isn't a video card issue, but tearing can be. Still, tearing is as likely on ATI hardware as it is on NVIDIA hardware.

Not sure what you mean by 'HD Audio' either, but you might want to check out my post in the thread that was right below this one or search this forum for info on the current audio-over-HDMI situation.
 
I read that thread, but the GT240 had the built in HDMI Audio. Can't I take that out for True HD to my Denon AVR with TMT3? I read somehwere it will work but downsample the audio?
 
I read that thread, but the GT240 had the built in HDMI Audio. Can't I take that out for True HD to my Denon AVR with TMT3? I read somehwere it will work but downsample the audio?

No reason to get a GT240 over a GT220. But no, it won't bitstream TrueHD. Nvidia has no product that can bitstream the HD audio formats yet. Just make your rips as I suggested and you won't have to worry about it.
Otherwise get a ATI 5000 series card, or the asus hdav or that new auzentech. Those are the only 3 options for bitstreaming of HD audio. But I gave up on that and didn't want to deal with having to use this player or that one so I made my rips so I get all the audio with none of the hassle.
 
So if I get the GT220 and use the flac option I can get True HD? Can I still play the new ripped Flac file with TMT3 from WHS. My goal is to use Media Center "MyMovies" as my GUI.

Thanks.
 
I just found a Xonar Deluxe for $160 open box. I think I am going to buy that and leave everbody alone.:mad: One last question. I still need to pass HDMI from my computer to the Xonar card, right or can I just use the card to go staright to my AVR. That would be ideal because I can just keep my Nvidia 8500gt Component card.
 
So if I get the GT220 and use the flac option I can get True HD? Can I still play the new ripped Flac file with TMT3 from WHS. My goal is to use Media Center "MyMovies" as my GUI.

Thanks.
Yes, you can get the audio. That is the whole point. You get Dolby TrueHD and DTS-HD MA with no need for any of these fancy bitstreaming cards. No DRM. No need to use other players. No hassle.

You will not need to use TMT3. You still use media center and it will play without the need for another player.

Use media browser instead of mymovies. It's much better.

I just found a Xonar Deluxe for $160 open box. I think I am going to buy that and leave everbody alone.:mad: One last question. I still need to pass HDMI from my computer to the Xonar card, right or can I just use the card to go staright to my AVR. That would be ideal because I can just keep my Nvidia 8500gt Component card.

You don't need a xonar deluxe. There is a cheaper hdav slim that would work.

The video card plugs into the hdav card and then goes out to the receiver.

I wouldn't drop $160 on that card either when you could get the cheaper ATI card and get better video quality over a 8500gt.

I would ONLY worry about getting a card with bitstreaming if you were playing discs on your HTPC. Other than that there really is no point. Just make your rips properly and you get it all.
 
Last edited:
I just found a Xonar Deluxe for $160 open box. I think I am going to buy that and leave everbody alone.:mad: One last question. I still need to pass HDMI from my computer to the Xonar card, right or can I just use the card to go staright to my AVR. That would be ideal because I can just keep my Nvidia 8500gt Component card.

Why are you wasting money on that crap? Jesus. If you're spending that much just get a fucking 5750 which does the same thing but better and cheaper.
 
1. ATI Sucks and so does their drivers.
2. The 5750 can't do what I want it to do. Bit streaming only works with the garbage Power DVD.

I found another open box for Xonar Deluxe for $129 and I bought the Galaxy GT 240. It should hopefully do what I want. Installing now.
 
1. ATI Sucks and so does their drivers.
2. The 5750 can't do what I want it to do. Bit streaming only works with the garbage Power DVD.

I found another open box for Xonar Deluxe for $129 and I bought the Galaxy GT 240. It should hopefully do what I want. Installing now.

ATI drivers are fine.

You just spent $220+ to do what I showed you to do for $60. Not a smart choice. But good luck with that.
 
ATI drivers are fine.

You just spent $220+ to do what I showed you to do for $60. Not a smart choice. But good luck with that.

How would it cost $60 and do what I want? I tried your method but something happend to the video where it was all stuutered and different colored boxes.

I just paid a $100 a week ago for TMT 3 so I want to keep that method for the Media Center.
 
False pretense, nice.

Another false pretense, nice.

Why would you say it's false. I had lot's of problems with 1 machine I owned a year ago. Iv'e always had Nvidia and no problems. Just my opnion. It's true the 5750 method wouldn't work for me. I just bought TMT 3 1 week ago so I am not going to spend another $100.
 
Either way I need a HDMI card. I can always return the Asus card. I setup the GT 240 and my Denon says "MULTI CH DIRECT" does that mean I will get everything decoded by the Nvidia card or TMT 3? If it Downsamples the audio but still plays True HD I would be fine with that and return the card. This is what the receiver shows. Thanks

Surround Mode MULTI CH DIRECT
Input Signal PCM
Fs 48kHz
Format 3/3/.1
 
How would it cost $60 and do what I want? I tried your method but something happend to the video where it was all stuutered and different colored boxes.

I just paid a $100 a week ago for TMT 3 so I want to keep that method for the Media Center.

Because $60 is the cost of the 220gt. There is absolutely no need for a 240gt.

If you tried my method it would work fine. You must have screwed up somewhere. There is no reason why it would put up a bunch of colored boxes on the screen or stutter. Unless you aren't using the proper codecs or don't have them set as system default. If you needed help with it you should have just asked.

No need to use TMT3 at all. Well you can leave it installed on your ripping machine so it can decode DTS-MA HD. But I wouldn't let the cost you paid for that force you to pay more money for something you don't need.
 
Back
Top