Which P4 Mobo?

Chez

Weaksauce
Joined
Oct 10, 2002
Messages
76
I've got a P4 3.0C CPU and 1x 512Mb Corsair XMS3500 CAS2 RAM and plan on adding a second stick of RAM at a later date.

I plan to run the CPU/RAM 1:1 at or around 217fsb (so I can keep decent RAM timings)

What I want to know is which board will be best out of the following -

Abit AI7
Abit IC7-G
Abit IC7-Max3
Asus P4P800
Asus P4P800 Deluxe
Asus P4C800
Asus P4C800 Deluxe
Asus P4C800-E Deluxe

The reason I have listed so many is that I would rather spend as little as possible if I'm not going to be pushing for stupid fsb's.

I want the system to be as stable as possible.

I've never had an asus board before and have always like my abit one's, but have heard bad things about the latest abit boards.

One major factor which does make me look at the abit boards is that they have spdif audio in AND out (asus only seem to have inputs). This would be useful for recording my minidiscs to CD.

I'm not too worried about LAN speed, as I will only be using it if/when I get an ethernet broadband router.

In terms of HDD compatability, I currently have an SATA WD Raptor as C: and an ATA133 Maxtor as D: although I may move to all SATA in the future.

Thanks in advance
Chez
 
Since you're overclocking and those are your choices and you're leaning that way anyway, get the Abit IC7-Max3. I can't believe I actually said that, hehe. This is because I would never buy an Abit board, but for other reasons I'd rather not get into right now.

Anyway, if you have problems, there are plenty of people here with that same MB that can help you. One thing I always say though before buying a MB is compare the specs and get the one that has the stuff you want.
 
Even though you didn't mention it as a candidate, I shall still take the time to suggest you shy away from the Intel D875PBZ till we hear from Kyle or Keith which version of the BIOS has been used for benchmarking purposes. Very likely, he's been using P05 or an earlier BIOS. Later BIOSes (we're now on P21) have PAT disabled and would show appreciable declines in performance possibly. Needless to say, most people who buy Intel motherboards aren't disappointed with minor performance shortfalls here and there, but I happen to be fuming. Intel seem unwilling to address the issue or even to admit it. It'd be great of HardOCP would shed some light on it if they could!
 
i'd get the Max-3 simply because it is the fastest board avaiable right now. but beware if you have an old printer, this board doesn't have the parrallel port that older model printers use.
 
Hmm I am also in the process of ordering a mother board.

But I will not be overclocking and I will be running the same setup. p4 3.0c and 1 gig ddr ram.

I am considering these:
ABIT IC7-G MAX2
ASUS P4C800-E DELUXE
INTEL D875PBZLK FMB 1.5

The Intel card is the cheapest out of the bunch. $140 from NewEgg. Would I have any problems with that board? Or is it a pretty solid board.
 
It's a great board, but PAT is disabled permanently. Intel have not so far resolved the issue and chances are they won't. It's been disabled since BIOS P06, which was released six months ago. I think they know they've disabled it and refuse to admit it and refuse to fix it. They're happier with the slightly increased stability that disabling PAT has achieved, I suppose. But yes it's a solid board, otherwise. But the Intel CPU heat monitoring software for Windows is really quite crappy, crashes often on the two Intel boards I've used it on.

By the way, nobody in the HardOCP review staff has indicated which Intel BIOS they use, so don't trust the HardOCP benchmarks to indicate the performance level you will get with a new D875PBZ.
 
Originally posted by Chez
I've got a P4 3.0C CPU and 1x 512Mb Corsair XMS3500 CAS2 RAM and plan on adding a second stick of RAM at a later date.

I plan to run the CPU/RAM 1:1 at or around 217fsb (so I can keep decent RAM timings)

What I want to know is which board will be best out of the following -

Abit AI7
Abit IC7-G
Abit IC7-Max3
Asus P4P800
Asus P4P800 Deluxe
Asus P4C800
Asus P4C800 Deluxe
Asus P4C800-E Deluxe

The reason I have listed so many is that I would rather spend as little as possible if I'm not going to be pushing for stupid fsb's.

I want the system to be as stable as possible.

I've never had an asus board before and have always like my abit one's, but have heard bad things about the latest abit boards.

One major factor which does make me look at the abit boards is that they have spdif audio in AND out (asus only seem to have inputs). This would be useful for recording my minidiscs to CD.

I'm not too worried about LAN speed, as I will only be using it if/when I get an ethernet broadband router.

In terms of HDD compatability, I currently have an SATA WD Raptor as C: and an ATA133 Maxtor as D: although I may move to all SATA in the future.

Thanks in advance
Chez
Best: IC7 MAX 3
Best Value: AI7 (97% of the performance for 60% of the price)

Originally posted by genodive
Hmm I am also in the process of ordering a mother board.

But I will not be overclocking and I will be running the same setup. p4 3.0c and 1 gig ddr ram.

I am considering these:
ABIT IC7-G MAX2
ASUS P4C800-E DELUXE
INTEL D875PBZLK FMB 1.5

The Intel card is the cheapest out of the bunch. $140 from NewEgg. Would I have any problems with that board? Or is it a pretty solid board.
I have it (D875PBZ) and it works great.
 
that is good to know. i need to read up a little more on it. but for me i think it would be sufficient. i mainly use my pc for work (accounting) and gaming.
 
I would have to go with the IC7-Max3 myself. I have that board and I'm running a P4 2.8c (SL6Z5) at nearly 3.6ghz watercooled. Awesome board and rock stable.

Originally posted by Chez
I've got a P4 3.0C CPU and 1x 512Mb Corsair XMS3500 CAS2 RAM and plan on adding a second stick of RAM at a later date.

I plan to run the CPU/RAM 1:1 at or around 217fsb (so I can keep decent RAM timings)

What I want to know is which board will be best out of the following -

Abit AI7
Abit IC7-G
Abit IC7-Max3
Asus P4P800
Asus P4P800 Deluxe
Asus P4C800
Asus P4C800 Deluxe
Asus P4C800-E Deluxe

The reason I have listed so many is that I would rather spend as little as possible if I'm not going to be pushing for stupid fsb's.

I want the system to be as stable as possible.

I've never had an asus board before and have always like my abit one's, but have heard bad things about the latest abit boards.

One major factor which does make me look at the abit boards is that they have spdif audio in AND out (asus only seem to have inputs). This would be useful for recording my minidiscs to CD.

I'm not too worried about LAN speed, as I will only be using it if/when I get an ethernet broadband router.

In terms of HDD compatability, I currently have an SATA WD Raptor as C: and an ATA133 Maxtor as D: although I may move to all SATA in the future.

Thanks in advance
Chez
 
Is there any reason that you don't have the p4s800d-e? For the performance, and well... you said you wanted as cheap as possible; I really dont see how you could beat it, unless you have something against SiS chipsets...
 
If you want the best performance for what you get, I think the standard IC7 board (of which I currently run) is the king of that cash crop.

You can achieve great overclockability just like its bigger complements and it's at a real great price of only $113.00 at Newegg.com.

I've just heard a lot more problems associated with the IS7 compared to the simplistic yet complex IC7. That's just my opinion though.

Dark Assassin
 
Abit AI7 is the performance king!

2.4C @ 3.416 284x12=1138 FSB 1.7v (watercooled)
Corsair 3200LLPT set at 5/4 3,3,3,7
9700Pro 406/337 (6.14.10.6414 driver version)

10,400 MIPS (SISandra)
6013 Memory (SISandra)
19,897 3DMark2001 SE
6,197 3DMark03

Nuf Said!
 
Back
Top