Which mobo/proc combo would be better?

Geshtar

Limp Gawd
Joined
Apr 15, 2004
Messages
227
First a little background on what I am aiming for with this system and how I will use it:
1)Must be able to be a good setup for 2-2.5 years
2)Low Noise/Heat would be nice but is not critical
3)Best Value for my money
4)Gaming is not my number 1 priority(although I do game some)
5)Day to Day stuff would be primary use(5-6 apps at once); some encoding.

All other components in these two systems would be the same so I will leave that out. RAM would be 512MB and probably some more later, when the wallet permits.

Setup 1:
ABIT "AN7" nForce2 Ultra 400 $99
AMD Mobile Athlon XP 2500+, 266 FSB, 512K Cache, OEM $88
Total: $187 +HSF

Setup 2:
ABIT "IS7" i865PE
Intel Pentium 4/ 2.8C GHz 800MHz FSB, 512K Cache, Hyper Threading, Retail
Total: $271

Now I don't know to much about which Intel chipsets are the good ones, so if there is a better chipset choice for not too much more I would consider that.

The AMD motherboard has Soundstorm according to the website, which I have heard is very nice and I do listen to lots of music. So that may be something to consider

I figure with the cost of the HSF factored in for #1, Setup 2 will end being about $50-60 more than setup 1.

Which would you choose and would it last for the time-frame I am hoping for?

Thanks in advance.
 
I did some quick looking and found one more setup of interest:

Setup 3
MSI "K8T NEO-FSR" K8T800 $92
AMD Athlon 64 2800+, 512KB L2 Cache, Retail $187
Total: $279

$8 more expensive than setup 2 and probably $60-70 more than setup 1. Would setup 2 and 3 be worth the extra money?
 
The P4 will have better multi-tasking for sure! i865PE and i875P are good choices are far as chipset. The 875 is a slightly better performer and can be found on the abit IC7 or IC7-G (if you need built in LAN)

I got an nforce system because of soundstorm (for my sony DTS system, and so I didn't have to get a soundcard) but was not all that impressed with its "EAX" performance in games. It sounds pretty damn good for music though.

The only way you can use soundstorm is if you have a dolby digital capable reciever with an spdif input.

I am now using a soundblaster live 5.1 value and it blows the soundstorm away for games. Kinda wish I went for the p4...

Good luck!
 
My suggestion, due to the fact that you're planning on doing alot of multitasking, is the P4 setup. The 865PE chipset is good plus allows for dual channel support for when you get more RAM, or if you get a 512 dual channel kit.
 
Back
Top