Which is better ClockSpeed or Effinecy

Which would you rather own.


  • Total voters
    41

DeChache

Supreme [H]ardness
Joined
Oct 30, 2005
Messages
7,087
Ok I have two computers and well I want to know which one you guys think is the best. Ok First lets imagine that my 7800GT and the X-Fi are in the computer that you think is better.

Reason for this is just plain curiosity.

System 1 is a AMD Athlon 64 3200+ (Venice Core) at stock(3.4) with a Giga-Byte K8N - Pro SLi and 1 Gig Corsair DDR 400 Value Ram.

System 2 is a Intel Pentium 4 550 With H/T at stock (3.4) with a Foxconn 925XE and 1 Gig (2X512) Corsair DDR2 533 Value Ram.

They both have their charms and well I just want to know what other people think. And if the vote goes for one or the other by a large margin I might have to flip vid cards and see what I think.

Rigs are also in my sig.

Disclaimer: I have both these systems underneath my Desk right now and have been for a year or more. So no Conroe is the best why dont you have that.
And please no Flaming

Mods if this is not in the right section feel free to move or close.
 
I'd use the P4 because

1. although they're both single-core, the HT on the p4 will let it do better as things get incresingly multi-threaded.

2. The venice is a rather dead-end upgrade path, since it's 939 / DDR1
 
He wasn't asking about upgradability.

I voted for the A64, but somewhat regret doing so due to the P4's HT and the clockspeed higher than the A64's rating. Since the two come so close the fastest one will depend on what kind of apps you're using, so it's difficult.
 
Eva_Unit_0 said:
he asked for our personal opinions, and I gave it. I don't see the problem.
... but upgradeability has nothing to do with clockspeed/efficiency of the two listed cpu's.

My opinion is that it depends on what you're using the system for. I think the A64 will perform better in games, and the Intel will be better for multi-tasking. This is the result I see with my A64 3200+ and P4 2.8C (both with 2GB of DDR400).
 
Eva_Unit_0 said:
he asked for our personal opinions, and I gave it. I don't see the problem.

Your good on that. I want opinions though my updates are limited due to the fact of the 925 chipset.

I like having both computers. I like the A64 for everyday use but the P4 I love my work and multitasking and there is nothing better for encoding. The P4 is almost 3 times faster in media encoding.

But keep the opinions coming.
 
I would go for the P4.

I fucking hate single core a64's, slow as hell. My P4 feels much snappier in Windows.
 
a 3800+ single core isn't too slow.
it's just the older athlons don't work as well as the newer ones.
 
filthysanchez said:
a 3800+ single core isn't too slow.
it's just the older athlons don't work as well as the newer ones.

I dont think any A64 can be considered slow. It may lag a little in multitasking but not slow.
 
they feel pretty slow to me. The X2 was a completly different deal, but the single core a64's were slow.

it's just the older athlons don't work as well as the newer ones.
The XP's are absolute dogs due to teh FSB architechture and chipset support. the A64 is better, but not that much better.
 
My dad's got a 3800+ non dual core, and I have a socket 478 P4 3.0E w/ HT. I'll bet he stomps me in games, but in Windows doing light multi-tasking, mine has way more "pop". We both have a gig of RAM.

OP, are you gaming with said rig? You might sit down one afternoon and actually test both out and tell us, ya know?

I'd say P4, but I bet the A64 does better in games.
 
mdameron said:
My dad's got a 3800+ non dual core, and I have a socket 478 P4 3.0E w/ HT. I'll bet he stomps me in games, but in Windows doing light multi-tasking, mine has way more "pop". We both have a gig of RAM.

OP, are you gaming with said rig? You might sit down one afternoon and actually test both out and tell us, ya know?

I'd say P4, but I bet the A64 does better in games.

Im gaming right now with the A64. Ive been meaning to do that but first I have to get a hard drive for the P4. It gave me the click of death this afternoon and Im wonder if the powersupply has the grunt to power a Prescott and a 7800GT.

I have noticed if I do something CPU intensive with the A64 it will take a few minutes to recover before its really usable again but that maybe the harddrives.

Dead Even on the Poll thats interesting.
 
I'd certainly pick the venice....but why the hell is it still at stock speeds?!
 
lithium726 said:
they feel pretty slow to me. The X2 was a completly different deal, but the single core a64's were slow.


The XP's are absolute dogs due to teh FSB architechture and chipset support. the A64 is better, but not that much better.

all of the above cpu are perfectly capable. to call an A64 slow is ludicrous, to call an XP slow is goofy. they all run the apps of their day just fine, often it is the carbon based processors that are slow.
 
to call an XP capable is goofy, IMO. Yeah, they were alright 4 years ago with an NF2U and a beta set of drivers (in my experience) but nowhere near a P4HT. Same deal with the A64, though to a lesser extent. The X2 is a completly different deal, those things are fast. Really fast. I sold mine though, didn't feel it was worth the $ I paid for it. Got the P4 system for a rediculously low price.

XP's are freaking slow. Mine has been retired to the file server, my laptop and desktop kill it in responsiveness and overall smoothness.

"quickness" is a subjective thing. I gave my opinion as was mandated by the OP. It is not less valid than yours.

BTW: I have owned and operated every chip I am talking about.
 
quadnad said:
I'd certainly pick the venice....but why the hell is it still at stock speeds?!

Giga-byte mobo and Value Ram. This was a cheap system. Put together when I needed a computer last fall when the P4 Fried its self and the mobo. and I used it as a excuse to try AMD. (My first since a Orignal Athlon 800 in a HP.)

My P4 is good for atleast 3.8 is just that on stock cooler it gets a little toatsy. The AMD I havent really played with the AMD.

Im toying with getting a Scythe Ninja and overclocking the hell out of the P4 and using it as a gaming rig and the AMD as everyday use.
 
I ran a 2.2 ghz athlon XP with 512 megs of ram, windows ran just as well on that as it does on my 2.8 ghz opteron with 1.5 gigs of ram. I have no idea what any of you are talking about with "windows snappiness" or whatever. Obviously doing things like video encoding there is a difference, but with general multitasking and web browsing, I haven't noticed one bit of difference.

That aside, I'd pick the 3200+ any day. I've used a P4 3.0 ghz w/ht and a gig of ram, it was very sluggish. Also, a 3200+ should be able to overclock quite a bit, easily.
 
DeChache said:
Giga-byte mobo and Value Ram. This was a cheap system. Put together when I needed a computer last fall when the P4 Fried its self and the mobo. and I used it as a excuse to try AMD. (My first since a Orignal Athlon 800 in a HP.)

Then run a divider! A64s don't need the bandwidth anyway, and that motherboard has to be good for at least 250HTT which puts it at 2.5ghz. All I'm saying is you've got a shitload of potential in there, value ram or not. Read up on eclipse's oc guide, get a decent hsf for ~$30, and I'm sure you'll be able to get at least 25% out of it.
 
quadnad said:
Then run a divider! A64s don't need the bandwidth anyway, and that motherboard has to be good for at least 250HTT which puts it at 2.5ghz. All I'm saying is you've got a shitload of potential in there, value ram or not. Read up on eclipse's oc guide, get a decent hsf for ~$30, and I'm sure you'll be able to get at least 25% out of it.


Very true I just need to stop being a wuss and do it.

lithium726 said:
"quickness" is a subjective thing. I gave my opinion as was mandated by the OP. It is not less valid than yours.

Quickness is subjective because I think that my P3 800 is more than enough for windows and internet surfing. Even office work.

Ok keep the opinions coming.
 
lithium726 said:
to call an XP capable is goofy, IMO. Yeah, they were alright 4 years ago with an NF2U and a beta set of drivers (in my experience) but nowhere near a P4HT. Same deal with the A64, though to a lesser extent. The X2 is a completly different deal, those things are fast. Really fast. I sold mine though, didn't feel it was worth the $ I paid for it. Got the P4 system for a rediculously low price.

XP's are freaking slow. Mine has been retired to the file server, my laptop and desktop kill it in responsiveness and overall smoothness.

"quickness" is a subjective thing. I gave my opinion as was mandated by the OP. It is not less valid than yours.

BTW: I have owned and operated every chip I am talking about.

yes you are entitled to your opinion. the more people debate and the more they demand fast cpu, the more I realize how little they know abut the actual cpu itself. how other parts of the computer affect over all speed. to blame a cpu for the computer being slow is simply not right.

there are two reasons to squeeze the most from an older cpu. one, to appreciate anything about computers you should respect some of the earlier cpu, and two because they are awesome in and of themselves. a bunch of work went into the engineering, and they run just the same as they did when they came out. your P4HT someday will be a 486, will you take a hammer to it ? what thanks and respect is that ?
 
compulsivephreek said:
yes you are entitled to your opinion. the more people debate and the more they demand fast cpu, the more I realize how little they know abut the actual cpu itself. how other parts of the computer affect over all speed. to blame a cpu for the computer being slow is simply not right.
Excuse me, but are you implying that I am ignorant about how a computer system works? I am fully aware of the intracacies of these systems, in fact, if you will reread my last post i explained that the largest bottleneck to the Athlon XP (especially the later models) was the chipsets that supported it. They had slow memory controllers, and while the NF2U was alright when properly optimized with drivers, the rest of them absoutly sucked. I went through 5 years of the Socket A platform, I know what Im talking about. Hell, I still have a few of them sitting in my closet. Even my mother felt like her XP2700 was too slow, and you wanna know why? The KT400 running the processor. The system was sluggish as all hell for anything beside something *purely* singlethreaded which was given 100% of the CPU time. Proof of this lies within the Athlon 64 - basically the same chip, some added cache (in the earlier models), a few reworked internals, and a bitchin new memory controller and system interface. Much snapper, although still lagging behind a P4HT or (although they were not out at the time) the Dual Core chips (and SMP systems, but that is a different market)

there are two reasons to squeeze the most from an older cpu. one, to appreciate anything about computers you should respect some of the earlier cpu, and two because they are awesome in and of themselves. a bunch of work went into the engineering, and they run just the same as they did when they came out. your P4HT someday will be a 486, will you take a hammer to it ? what thanks and respect is that ?
I am an engineer. An electrical engineer, at that. I am fully aware of the R&D and engineering that goes into these chips. Respect for something created and saying something is still a viable contender in a market in which it obvoiusly does not contend in is something compleltly different. Would you say that a 486 is fast? Hell no. The market has changed. Who cares if it could run 3.1 fast as hell? That OS is now defuct and no one can run it for anything productive. The software of 3 years ago (AXP) is differant than the software today, and the software today demands a beefier processor and subsystem. Yes, the Processor does not determine performance, but when was the last time you saw a new, high performance chipset running a processor that was 3 years old which used a less than stellar technology for communications with the northbridge?

You assume I will take a Hammer to my P4. Wrong assumption. It'll either get sold or sit in my closet. I dont destroy things unless they piss me off beyond belief, and something has to be really poorly engineered to do that (read: boards based around the KT133/266 chipsets. Poorly designed AGP/PCI implementation, dying IDE channels, etc..)

Quickness is subjective because I think that my P3 800 is more than enough for windows and internet surfing. Even office work.
Right. maybe if you boot up Word and just use that, but when you start surfing large flash movies, high res images, and doing other intensive things that computers see on a daily basis these days I doubt you can tell me that thing isnt sluggish. I have quite a few p3's, I love the P3, and the only one I could stand to use on a daily basis is my Dual P3 1.4ghz system. It might not be the fastest encoder in the world, but Windows sure is snappy and nothing can slow down the responsiveness of that system.

The P4 is the better system choice.
 
lithium, thanks for the reply. not trying to be a troll, but there are so many folks who say a computer is slow and blame this and that when it is usually the system itself that is at fault. you can have a fast motherboard / chipset/ cpu but a slow drive will make people scream that the computer is slow. they say, oh its a P II so it HAS to be slow. Not. Too many generalizations. Why people want a faster computer when they already have one is beyond me. You and I both know that 95 percent of what people use a pc for can be done on a very simple computer. That XP2700 should have done fine for your mother, this 1600 runs great so I am not sure why the 2700 would seem slow. My son uses a 1700 OC to run EQ II and it does fine. Yeah software gets more bloated thus we need faster machines. But not as fast like some people say. Why waste money ? PC World said it would take all this and that to run Vista. Not, total BS. Wait and see. MS even said it scales to match the hardware.

I like these forums, but most on here are spoiled and buy new stuff for no good reason at all.
 
Well, according to the C2D review, there's no need to take one over the other because they both perform the same. Logically, you should take the P4 because it's just as fast as the A64, and it has HT.
 
compulsivephreek said:
lithium, thanks for the reply.
Sure thing.
not trying to be a troll, but there are so many folks who say a computer is slow and blame this and that when it is usually the system itself that is at fault.
Yes, but processors still can be slow. A 1.7ghz P4 on the i875p will still be slow.
you can have a fast motherboard / chipset/ cpu but a slow drive will make people scream that the computer is slow. they say, oh its a P II so it HAS to be slow.
and they would be right...
Not. Too many generalizations.
Not necessarily. Computers are sold as a package, and even if you add new components (RAM, HDD, optical, video card) things like the chipset can limit these too. The 815 will not get the throughput of the i875, which makes the platform slow.
Why people want a faster computer when they already have one is beyond me.
Because they feel that it is slow? Computers are cheap these days, why shouldnt you have something reasonably fast? Now, Im not saying you should give up something a year old for something brand new, but yeah, something like a P3, P3, or early Athlon is definatly due for an upgrade, especially with Vista on the horizon.
You and I both know that 95 percent of what people use a pc for can be done on a very simple computer.
Not necessarily. you been catching all the Apple commercials recently? They all focus on media. Media encoding and photography stuff can be very intensive. Fast computers are needed to keep one from ripping their hair out. Again, this is the software pallet - This was not a huge thing three years ago. It is now.
That XP2700 should have done fine for your mother, this 1600 runs great so I am not sure why the 2700 would seem slow.
Its not htat it was particulary slow, it was very sluggish though. When she set it to do the photography work she does, it would get done in a reasonable amount of time, but she couldnt do ANYTHING else while it was working. This was unacceptable. (Yes, i know SMP is the best solution for this (which is why she got the HT P4, it was cheap) but even my laptop is more responsive than that system was.)
My son uses a 1700 OC to run EQ II and it does fine.
Computers arent only for gaming..
Yeah software gets more bloated thus we need faster machines.
Not just bloat, they do more things and are more powerful. This takes horsepower.
But not as fast like some people say. Why waste money ? PC World said it would take all this and that to run Vista. Not, total BS. Wait and see. MS even said it scales to match the hardware.
Course it does, its still sluggish on a p3 1ghz (tried it) and it sucks without a DX9 card. It boots slow on a 7k2 HDD, and its still slower than XP is on a 10k disk.

I like these forums, but most on here are spoiled and buy new stuff for no good reason at all.
100% agree. Shit, 200% agree. I was caught up in it for a while, wasted more money than I would like. Sold it, got a nearly free computer from my buddy (the GT and RAM was mine) and im pretty happy. Nearly always on my laptop anyhow, which i got for $700 from IBM.
 
Back
Top