which fanless video card?

damasko

n00b
Joined
Aug 30, 2007
Messages
24
Hello all, I'm looking for a passive cooled vga, for SFF Silverstone sg01.
I found these ones:
hd2400pro
hd2600pro
x1650pro
7600gs
8400gs
8500gt
how do you put them in order by performance?
 
my guess would be:

2600pro
1650pro
7600gs
8500gt
8400gs
2400pro

if you want performance, im pretty sure there are passively cooled 8600s out there too, which would outperform all these card, there might also be some fanless 7900GSs out there for truely excellent performance
 
there are several passive cooled 8600s, I have read about fanless 7900 cards but I'm not sure they ever shipped.

14-121-077-10.jpg
14-125-063-08.jpg
14-150-238-11.jpg
14-127-287-09.jpg
14-125-061-08.jpg


asus / gigabyte / xfx / msi / gigabyte (single slot)
 
thanks, but I don't need high performance, only cool and silence
Even if I play a little, I want discover which vga has the best cost/performance ratio ;)
2600pro 86€
1650pro 80€
7600gs 75€
8500gt 84€
8400gs 56€
2400pro 43€

At the first look, 7600gs appears more convenient than 8500gt.
 
They even have fanless 8600gts. I was surprised because 8600gts gets rather hot.
 
I've got an Asus fanless 8500 GT (512 MB version) and while it's not that bad, the heatsink still gets rather hot to the touch. An 8600 has to be even worse. You can look at the TDP ratings of those GPUs to get an idea of how hot they'll run passively.

Alternatively you can get a regular fan-cooled GPU and replace it with a passive cooler. Those latter generally give you a lot more surface area the heat can be dispersed with. Just make sure there's always sufficient airflow in the case or whatever solution you'll go with won't matter a bit ;)
 
I've got an Asus fanless 8500 GT (512 MB version) and while it's not that bad, the heatsink still gets rather hot to the touch. An 8600 has to be even worse. You can look at the TDP ratings of those GPUs to get an idea of how hot they'll run passively.

Alternatively you can get a regular fan-cooled GPU and replace it with a passive cooler. Those latter generally give you a lot more surface area the heat can be dispersed with. Just make sure there's always sufficient airflow in the case or whatever solution you'll go with won't matter a bit ;)

where did you find the gpu tdp? because the only one I found is hd2400, with 30w tdp.
should be better to buy an ati gpu, because of their 65micron construction process, right?
 
http://www.hardocp.com/article.html?art=MTM2MCwxMCwsaGVudGh1c2lhc3Q=

From the data, we can conclude that the ATI Radeon HD 2600 XT uses 37 watts of power when idle. That is certainly respectable. However, that is also 15 watts more power than the XFX GeForce 8600 GT XXX video card used while idling.

At full load (in Oblivion), the tables are turned, at least a little. Our measurements showed that the XFX GeForce 8600 GT XXX used 3 watts more power under full-load conditions than its rival, the ATI Radeon HD 2600 XT. However, when we overclocked the Radeon, even that small advantage disappeared, and to no avail (see Overclocking section below).

:)
 
thanks to all! :)
I think will buy 7600 or 8500 because of their idle tdp (will go in sff sg01)
unfortunatly ati doesn't distinct 2d/3d while running idle, so it's always hot.
 
with ati tools, can I underclock also low-end cards? like non XT versions? like 2400pro/2600pro?
 
Back
Top