Which (cheap) HDD should I buy?

nullstring

n00b
Joined
Oct 1, 2011
Messages
28
I am in the market for a new HDD. 1.5TB to 3TB, likely

This will be a storage drive, and therefore I am not in the market for a WD black, etc.
It will be running torrents off of it and will likely be active a large majority of the time.
The data isn't even that important and therefore I am not interested in one of the more expensive enterprise or RAID drives.

All recent HDDs seem to have pretty bad reviews.

Right now I am waiting on a good price on a deskstar.
What do you guys think? It seems to be a crapshoot out there right now.
 
I'm a fan of the Samsung Ecogreen 2TB drives. They're decently fast for a green drive, especially compared to a WD green. Although, I have to be honest, now that the warranty is down to 1 year on the Samsung drives (thanks Seagate!), I'd probably just go with a 2-3TB WD green drive. The WD warranty is the best available right now. I've had a 1.5TB WD green for 2ish years now, no problems so far. I have 4 of the Samsung Ecogreen (F4) drives, 3 I've had for about 18 months, and 1 from post-Seagate acquisition. Those have all been great as well.
 
The samsung drives aren't made by the same factory anymore. (I don't think?), so it's hard to consider your testimony from old drives into my purchase consideration since they are no longer available. (These would've, without a doubt, been a drive of a choice back when samsung was still making these)

And the newegg reviews for WD green drives are pretty bad.

Anyone else have any feedback?.
 
And the newegg reviews for WD green drives are pretty bad.

Anyone else have any feedback?.

I see those negative reviews on the WD Greens and really wonder if a lot of them aren't the result of shoddy shipping or something... I've never had much trouble with them. *knock on wood*

I've got 3x WD Green 1TB drives from 2 different revisions (EACS and EADS), 1x WD Green of some flavor (external MyBook unit) and 1x 2TB WD Green of some flavor (external Elements unit). A few of my friends have multiple 1TB Green drives for storage on my recommendation. I think out of all of them I've handled, a single one tanked after about 2 hours during a system build, so I just sent it back to the 'zon for a replacement.

I guess I don't want to sound like a shill or anything, but I use WD drives for a lot of my own gear. Of course, you probably couldn't pay me to use WD 250GB Blue drives. Those units tank on a routine basis in the enterprise machines I work on and those boxes are far from performance oriented.

my $0.02 :)
 
How old are those drives? 1TB makes me think they are at least a few years old.
I have a 1.5TB WD green drive thats going strong. The concerning reviews are recent development in the last year or so.
 
How old are those drives? 1TB makes me think they are at least a few years old.
I have a 1.5TB WD green drive thats going strong. The concerning reviews are recent development in the last year or so.

You're right, I think one of my 1TB units is probably over 2yrs old. I checked out the 1TB units that are listed now and literally none of them matches the modeling on the drives I have. They're all 64MB cache units now and the reviews are pretty awful... Looks like my next buy won't be WD units... :eek:
 
You're right, I think one of my 1TB units is probably over 2yrs old. I checked out the 1TB units that are listed now and literally none of them matches the modeling on the drives I have. They're all 64MB cache units now and the reviews are pretty awful... Looks like my next buy won't be WD units... :eek:

Look at the other reviews though. The only ones that look decent are the Samsungs.. but those don't exist any more and were cut down to a one year warranty from a three year.

And now you'll understand why I am making this post. None of them seem like great options. =/
 
The samsung drives aren't made by the same factory anymore. (I don't think?), so it's hard to consider your testimony from old drives into my purchase consideration since they are no longer available.

Nobody knows. Some people say they're the same drives, just with a Seagate label, other people say they're a Samsung branded version of a 2TB Baraccuda green. I found an article from Nov-Dec a few months ago (can't find it now) that had an interview with some Seagate exec saying that the Samsung HDDs were still being manufactured as Samsung HDDs, and would be for about a year (Christmas 2012ish) before Seagate just kills them off. If that's true, they're the same drives. But I looked for a few minutes and couldn't find the article again.

And the newegg reviews for WD green drives are pretty bad.

WD sells a lot of drives. It's mostly people with problems that review things like hard drives, unless they're truly blown away by price, performance, or some other. I wouldn't worry about them too much.

EDIT: There's also been a lot of complaints about Newegg's packaging of hard drives, and that could have something to do with the number of failed drives. I just bought a 2TB WD black, and it came packaged okay. It was inside a box (foam holders on the ends), which was on the bottom of the main box, with that paper stuff on top of it (none underneath). Make of that what you will.
 
WD sells a lot of drives. It's mostly people with problems that review things like hard drives, unless they're truly blown away by price, performance, or some other. I wouldn't worry about them too much.

There's probably a lot of truth in this. Goes along with that old saying, something like "make 100 people happy and one will tell his friends, piss one person off and they'll tell every person they know".
 
There's probably a lot of truth in this. Goes along with that old saying, something like "make 100 people happy and one will tell his friends, piss one person off and they'll tell every person they know".

But this phenomenon isn't new.
While what you're saying is definitely true, the reviews have gotten worse. so it seems like we have 2-3x as many people getting pissed off, which is pretty significant.

EDIT: Hell, look at the reviews for the samsung drives. Their reviews are sooo much better.
 
The samsung drives aren't made by the same factory anymore. (I don't think?), so it's hard to consider your testimony from old drives into my purchase consideration since they are no longer available. (These would've, without a doubt, been a drive of a choice back when samsung was still making these)

And the newegg reviews for WD green drives are pretty bad.

Anyone else have any feedback?.

I can testify from recent purchase that the Samsung HD204UI is really a Seagate Barracuda with a samsung sticker...and when you get an RMA they will replace it with a factory refurbished Seagate Barracuda. :mad:
 
Back
Top