Which Cell Phone?

ZoSo

Limp Gawd
Joined
Jun 5, 2004
Messages
236
Wasn't sure what forum to put this in but figured this one was the closest thing ;)

I'm looking to get a new cell phone, my LG C1300 just don't cut it, poor reception, etc.
So, I think I narrowed my choices to the Motorola V551 or the Nokia 6230.
If anyone uses one of these I would appreciate your opinions on them, and any suggestions.

Thanks,
 
To tell the truth, I don't have either, but I have a V505. I like the Moto's icon-based interface a lot more than the Nokia, but that's just me. A neat thing about the v551 is that you can modify the firmware and flex so that it runs faster and leaner. The Moto, AFAIK, has a pretty big community of modders and experts, too.
 
who cares about the provider? get an unbranded phone off ebay so you can put it on whatever provider you want, dont let the providers communist ways affect your better judgement. buying a branded phone is selling your soul to the devil. BTW dhim off ebay sells the 6230 for 300 cdn unbranded, and brand new, i recommend that phone, it comes with everything and looks really cool, i wanted that phone originally but it was way over 700 dollars at the time, i got the z600 instead, sony blows chunks, never get anything from them.
 
The 6230 is a good, solid phone with a nice amount of features. It's basically your standard Nokia brick with a camera, bluetooth, memory expansion, etc. Overall, its a much nicer phone than the V551. I'd go with the Nokia.
 
klowngoblin said:
who cares about the provider? get an unbranded phone off ebay so you can put it on whatever provider you want, dont let the providers communist ways affect your better judgement. buying a branded phone is selling your soul to the devil. BTW dhim off ebay sells the 6230 for 300 cdn unbranded, and brand new, i recommend that phone, it comes with everything and looks really cool, i wanted that phone originally but it was way over 700 dollars at the time, i got the z600 instead, sony blows chunks, never get anything from them.

Oi... The providers are SOCIALIST in nature not communist. Communism is GOOD, but has never existed in the world and never will... Only SOCIALISM.

Now that thats cleared up, I think Verizon has by far the best cell phone network, but their phones are so old... I have an LG VX7000... Its a bit big, but it definetly serves its purpose. You can pick up an old Motorola V60i off eBay for $40ish... The V60's were Motorola's biggest hits.
 
Thanks for the input so far, everyone.
I'm kind of leaning towards the Motorola V551, mainly because it's a flip phone, need the buttons and screen protected due to work environment, plus I looked into what Snore mentioned, and you can mod it up pretty good. I do like the Nokia alot too, just wish they where coming out with there flip line sooner.
Sometimes I hate trying to make my mind up :eek:
 
i just ordered the v551 for at&t, a bluetooth headset, and a bluetooth usb receiver for my pc. i hope i am happy with it :)
 
compslckr said:
i just ordered the v551 for at&t, a bluetooth headset, and a bluetooth usb receiver for my pc. i hope i am happy with it :)
compslckr, let me know how you like it.

Thanks,
 
klowngoblin said:
who cares about the provider?

people who currently have a contract with a provider and wish to get a phone that works on thier network care about the provider.
 
The V551 is a great phone and has gotten some pretty good reviews... Both phones have similar feature sets, though from what I hear the 6230b has the best EDGE speeds around. I think both phones are great and you probably can't go wrong with either. Personally, I'd get the moto because it's a flip unless I was planning on tethering the phone to a laptop or PDA. In such case, I'd go with the Nokia.
 
i have the motorola v551 and the nokia 6620 and by far i prefer the nokia series 60 phones. i have had the v600 as well and they are awesome flip phones but the quality pales in compairason. i would stick to the series 60 nokia phones
 
Loki008, In what ways does the quality differ?

Thanks everyone for the input so far, I really appreciate it :)
 
i got my v551 today and it is sweet. the bluetooth works flawlessly with my epox usb adapterThe menu is easy to use, and the phone overall is very small. the camera works good, the sound quality is great for both ringtones, speaker phone and normal conversations.

the screen is nice and bright, the white keypad is nice, the themes are sweet and easy to customize and the video capture works well and includes sound :)


overall, it is an awesome phone. the build quailty feels very sturdy.

iwould recomend it
 
Thanks everyone, I decided to go with the Moto V551.
I went and checked out the phones, in hand, and I didn't like the buttons on the Nokia too small, the screen is a little smaller also. That combined with, a flip phone would better suit the needs of protection for me, won the V551 over the Nokia.
But, I'm sure the Nokia is a good phone, going by what I have read in reviews and by what users of it have said about it.

Thanks again,
 
I just got the V551 and it's really nice. Hooked up my laptop and surf the net with no problem. I have that problem with the work environment too. Paint. Really nasty marine primers and paints that melt any plastic other than polyethylene/polypropalene. Thinking about wrapping Saran wrap around the phone because the boss always wants to call me when my hand are covered in epoxy. Had the Nok 6200 and that worked good as an edge modem and was pretty rugged.
 
i have the bluetooth link and i am connected to the phone. how do i set it up so i can access the internet with it? it says enter username, password and phone number. is this provided my by service provider (at&t) or by an isp (ie. netzero etc.)
 
If you have a data plan through AT&T you can set it up through Dialup networking
or use a connection manager. What provider and what phone?
 
i have at&t with an unlocked v551. i can use the browser on my phone to get show times etc, but it would be nice to beable to use the internet wirelessly on my laptop through my phone
 
compslckr said:
i just ordered the v551 for at&t, a bluetooth headset, and a bluetooth usb receiver for my pc. i hope i am happy with it :)
Sorry I missed your post. Don't use AT&T for Data. $80 for unlimited. Cingular is 25 for unlimited. Send it back and switch to Cingular.
 
OOps! They want to charge you per Kb for attachment to laptop!!!!! Those fuckers!!!! AT&T are the very worst.
 
i dont reallly see why they would charge more for at&t since the att/cingular merger since yyou can use both networks and it does not charge you to use the other one, for example while i am at shool i am usually on the cingular network, and while at home on the att network. i guess i dont really need the ability to access the net with my laptop from anywhere, but it woul dbe kind of nice.
 
Believe me, I just received a sill for $150 because I went to Michigan and was roaming. Get out of AT&T immediately. You will get robbed.
 
gigaxtreme1 said:
Believe me, I just received a sill for $150 because I went to Michigan and was roaming. Get out of AT&T immediately. You will get robbed.
i have had really good luck with at&t actually. i travel alot with my family all over the place, including europe, egypt, mexico, costa rica, canada, and around the states, and i have never noticed a big unexpected jump in my bill. i used my phone quite a bit last time we were in mexico and each call averaged out to about $0.40 a minute which i thought was quite reasonable since the resort wanted to charge 99 cents a minute to call the states.

I have had at&t for 2 years now and it has been good to me so i am sticking with it.
 
Good luck. You may want to change the data plan though. Just trying to help. Talk to your provider and see what the current rates are
 
Well, I got the V551 yesterday and I'm very happy with it, even put a new custom Flex in it which upped my space from 5MB to 7.5MB and extends the battery charge time by a few days(which will be tested this week ;))

ZoSo
 
ZoSo said:
Well, I got the V551 yesterday and I'm very happy with it, even put a new custom Flex in it which upped my space from 5MB to 7.5MB and extends the battery charge time by a few days(which will be tested this week ;))

ZoSo
can you explain what exatly that is> my battery life is not very good and my phone is filling up pretty fast.
 
Just got off the phone with tech support. It seems that Cingular is falsely advertising a $24.99 unlimited internet service. It seems that the real fee for unlimited internet when your laptop is hooked up to your phone to use the data services is actually $79.99 or more per month. I got two numbers near 80 bucks, both different. Could not find this information on any of the pages on Cingular's site. I'm going to the Better Business Bureau today to file a complaint. I may back out of this contract before the day is over. Might go with another provider before the day is over too.
 
Back
Top