Which 8800gt should I get?

Nosenuggets45

Limp Gawd
Joined
Jun 6, 2008
Messages
492
Hi, I'm new here and am hoping someone can help me out with this problem. I currently have a nvidia 7800gt and am looking into buying an 8800gt. I've read that they have some heat issues, so that led me to widen my search. I've narrowed it down to this, what should I go with?

A) EVGA 8800gt then separately buy a fan/heatsink for it
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814130318

B) MSI 8800gt
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814127329&Tpk=msi+880gt

The MSI seems to have a very good cooling solution and is already pre-overclocked. Though, I've heard nothing but good reviews about the EVGA one. By the way, I have to keep it at $200 max (not including tax, shipping, ect.)

Thanks
 
Get the MSI, I hear it has quiet cooling and the pre-overclock is convenient.
 
I'd get the EVGA considering the price difference. You can get an Accelero S1 which would bring it up to the same price and you'd have better cooling.

Also, the cooler on the MSI does not cool the ram chips.
 
I'd get the EVGA considering the price difference. You can get an Accelero S1 which would bring it up to the same price and you'd have better cooling.

Also, the cooler on the MSI does not cool the ram chips.
I was reading about the fact that the ram chips are bare, and it said that the temps bare with airflow over them vs. a heatsink on them are just about the same.
 
I was reading about the fact that the ram chips are bare, and it said that the temps bare with airflow over them vs. a heatsink on them are just about the same.

That's assuming you will keep the stock cooler on the EVGA, which you're not. ;)
 
I was reading about the fact that the ram chips are bare, and it said that the temps bare with airflow over them vs. a heatsink on them are just about the same.

bumping the memory speed gives you way more performance return then OCing the core. Something with good memory cooling is a good idea if you plan to OC it.
 
bumping the memory speed gives you way more performance return then OCing the core. Something with good memory cooling is a good idea if you plan to OC it.
So if I get the EVGA with the Accelero S1 and overclock the memory and ram to be equal or greater than the MSI, will I still have good temps? It is really all about the temps in my case. If I have to sacrifice not oc'ing it just to have good temps, that is fine by me. One thing I'm afraid of is that the EVGA with the Accelero S2 may not fit in my case.
 
I've got TWO of the MSI cards, and they're phenomenal.. No issues whatsoever with heat.. Plus, the factory OC can be OC'd even more without a hassle..
 
I've got TWO of the MSI cards, and they're phenomenal.. No issues whatsoever with heat.. Plus, the factory OC can be OC'd even more without a hassle..
Just out of curiosity, what have you oc'ed it to and what are your idle/load temps?
 
The MSI cards come with a program (MSI Dual Core Center) that can control overclocking by selecting what you intend to do with it.. "Gaming" mode will push the card to 693MHz and 1900MHz, but I've had BOTH of my cards as high as 720/2020 stable.. I never really bothered trying to go higher than that..

Honestly, if you intend to overclock, RivaTuner or nTune work just fine and are a little more intuitive..
 
I currently have a nvidia 7800gt and am looking into buying an 8800gt.

If you decide to go with an 8800 GT, the MSI card is good. However, the next generation of video cards are being released in just a couple of weeks... nVidia's cards on June 18th, and ATI's card the week after. While the nVidia cards won't be inexpensive, the ATI HD 4850 is expected to come in under $200 and perform better than an 8800 GTS 512MB. So you might want to wait.
 
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814134035 Ya i guess I could of paid big $$ for the new junk that is comming out. But it works very nice. I having it setting right above my 360 rad, it stays very cool. My 8800 ultma had 13000 3d stock and this one runs almost 12000. (have it in my second computer). I guess you have to say.. hmm do I really need to get a 600$ card that will be top dog for 5 months or so. Or say hmm I got to pay 55$ to fill up my car now. :mad:
 
hmm do I really need to get a 600$ card that will be top dog for 5 months or so. Or say hmm I got to pay 55$ to fill up my car now. :mad:

That's what people said about the 8800GTX/Ultra but they were top dog for 2 years and sometimes still are today.
 
Back
Top