Which 120mm Fan?

Aerosparx

n00b
Joined
May 20, 2007
Messages
2
Hey there! I'm wondering which 120mm fan to stick on a Ultra-120 Extreme Heatsink seated on a new rig with a Intel C2D E2140?

I'm open to suggestions as well! However, I have it between these 2:

Akasa AK-191-BL Blue Ultra Quiet 120mm Fan - 3 Pin
http://www.overclockers.co.uk/showproduct.php?prodid=FG-036-AK

Arctic Cooling Arctic Fan 12L 120mm Fan - 3 Pin
http://www.overclockers.co.uk/showproduct.php?prodid=FG-002-AR

Exact same price, however the Akasa 'advertises' about 13 CFM more worth of Air Flow than the Arctic, and also is also 'advertised' 2 dB quieter..

Although the bearings are different, Akasa is sleeve bearing while the AC fan is fluid dynamic bearing. Now I know the Akasa is the same price as the AC and 'advertises' better specs, but I know sometimes there not truly as they are...

So which should I pick? Although I'll say again - I'm still open for any other better 120mm fans?



Thanks,
Sparx

-EDIT-
Also open to any cheaper, yet almost as effective heatsink/CPU coolers as the Ultra 120 Extreme? (with it being £47)..
 
Many people, my self included, are fond of Panoflo fans. Not sure if there are better now, but I have been using them a long time and had really good luck with them.
 
The Panaflo's are good, but I don't believe they come in 120mm x 25mm. The last I checked, they were all 120mm x 38mm. The Scythe S-Flex fans are the best, imo.

http://search.store.yahoo.com/cgi-bin/nsearch?catalog=svcompucycle&query=s-flex

I, personally, went with the SFF21E model. They run about $15USD, so around £13 (scan link | oc link).

The Akasa you linked to has similar specs to the S-Flex fan I recommended, but is sleeve bearing. Since this is for the CPU HSF, I'd spend the extra money for the peice of mind knowing that the S-FDB will last a LOT longer than any sleeve bearing fan. I'm not sure what the difference is between the AC and the Scythe's... just know that the Scythe's licensed the technology from Sony (thats what the S is for in S-FDB).
 
+1 on the Panaflo recommendation (some of them have been rebadged as Rexus)... Yate Loon is also considered a good choice. But enginurd is right... all of the Panaflos that I've seen (and used) have been 120mm x 38mm.
 
Back
Top