Where Anonymity Breeds Contempt

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
The author of this NY Times article believes that “anonymity increases unethical behavior.” What makes her an expert on internet trolls? She’s a product design manager at Facebook.

Trolling, defined as the act of posting inflammatory, derogatory or provocative messages in public forums, is a problem as old as the Internet itself, although its roots go much farther back.
 
Anybody notice this part "That mythical ring gave its owner the power of invisibility, and Plato observed that even a habitually just man who possessed such a ring would become a thief, knowing that he couldn’t be caught. Morality, Plato argues, comes from full disclosure; without accountability for our actions we would all behave unjustly." was directly to the left of "MOST POPULAR ARTICLES <mention of wikileaks after wikileaks article at #1 spot, #4 spot, etc.>".

I wonder if the author positioned that text that way on purpose or if that was just one big, huge coincidence.
 
First - people like this need to get a grasp of what trolling truly is. It is NOT "act of posting inflammatory, derogatory or provocative messages in public forums". Who says it need to be on a public message board? Who says it even has to be online? To summarize however, my definition is simply getting a rise out of somebody. You can walk up to a girl and say "Nice shirt" with a sly look on your face and then walk away laughing and I would call it trolling.

The idea is simply to get the person to think about, argue, or worry about some random opinion / statement that really has no bearing and anyone with a brain could careless about. The problem is people are too busy caring about what random people have to say instead of just ignoring it.
 
First - people like this need to get a grasp of what trolling truly is. It is NOT "act of posting inflammatory, derogatory or provocative messages in public forums". Who says it need to be on a public message board? Who says it even has to be online? To summarize however, my definition is simply getting a rise out of somebody. You can walk up to a girl and say "Nice shirt" with a sly look on your face and then walk away laughing and I would call it trolling.

The idea is simply to get the person to think about, argue, or worry about some random opinion / statement that really has no bearing and anyone with a brain could careless about. The problem is people are too busy caring about what random people have to say instead of just ignoring it.

You would be incorrect. The internet and real life are NOT interchangeable. "Trolling" is a uniquely internet behavior. There are obnoxious people everywhere both online and in the real world but, being a "Troll" is a grab for attention and nothing else.
 
What a fascist tool that bimbo is...

Anonymity is vital in a free society so that people can speak without being punished for their beliefs. Most so-called trolling is just people, perhaps insensitively, expressing unpopular opinions. More dangerous that the trolls are the fascist tools who complain about anonymity.
 
What a fascist tool that bimbo is...

Anonymity is vital in a free society so that people can speak without being punished for their beliefs. Most so-called trolling is just people, perhaps insensitively, expressing unpopular opinions. More dangerous that the trolls are the fascist tools who complain about anonymity.

No, a free society is the ability to talk about your beliefs without threat of punishment. There is no use for everyone to keep their opinions to themselves unless they feel comfortable that they will not be prosecuted for them. Being able to express your beliefs without threat of punishment is what we want.
 
No, a free society is the ability to talk about your beliefs without threat of punishment. There is no use for everyone to keep their opinions to themselves unless they feel comfortable that they will not be prosecuted for them. Being able to express your beliefs without threat of punishment is what we want.

What a surprise! I believe in a utopia with magical fairies and unicorns too! Too bad that will never exist, because while you may be able to talk about your beliefs without getting be-headed, you will have to fight a mob of legal hassles and other annoyances. This is why anonymous is the only possible way to remain as such.
 
Hmm..

first, before we enact any laws, let's have public live cameras installed everywhere in her home, her car, etcetera.

Then let's see if she writes an article about privacy being so bad.
 
No, a free society is the ability to talk about your beliefs without threat of punishment. There is no use for everyone to keep their opinions to themselves unless they feel comfortable that they will not be prosecuted for them. Being able to express your beliefs without threat of punishment is what we want.

Bingo! +1 on all fronts.
 
What a surprise! I believe in a utopia with magical fairies and unicorns too! Too bad that will never exist, because while you may be able to talk about your beliefs without getting be-headed, you will have to fight a mob of legal hassles and other annoyances. This is why anonymous is the only possible way to remain as such.

True to an extent. We have to aspire for a utopia, even though we will never achieve it. Bettering our society, leaving it better than when we joined it, is essential to all future generations.
 
I did not read article because NY Times requires a login, and I hate the NY Times so they won't get one from me. Let me get this straight though... She works for Failbook, and complains about anonymity on the internet. This is the same Failbook that doesn't ever erase anyone's personal info, yes? Why am I not surprised.

What a surprise! I believe in a utopia with magical fairies and unicorns too! Too bad that will never exist, because while you may be able to talk about your beliefs without getting be-headed, you will have to fight a mob of legal hassles and other annoyances. This is why anonymous is the only possible way to remain as such.

I'm the one and only Phoenix bird. Without anonymity, I couldn't use the internet. The fact that nobody actually believes that I'm a bird makes it nice because to all you humans I'm either just a kook or a furry or whatever. So I can interact with you without having to worry about some nutcase trying to serve me up as dinner in an attempt to gain immortality (yeah... a Persian king tried this once without quite grasping how the whole immortality part works), or put me in a zoo where they could charge people insane fees to get a look at me. I DO NOT LIKE BEING STARED AT! :mad:

Kind of nice that anonymity stuff.
 
So I've got to ask, is a thread about Trolls more irresistable for trolls than a thread that isn't about trolls? Cause there's some good ones in here! ;)
 
Back
Top